- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Yercaud Coffee Curing Works Ltd. v. The State Of Tamil Nadu
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
T.C. Nos. 298 to 300 and 314 of 1971 concerned assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66, and T.C. No. 305 of 1971 concerned assessment year 1966-67. The common assessee (dealers in fertilisers, manure mixtures and rock phosphate) purchased chemical fertilisers locally and from outside the State and produced mixture manures (e.g., "tea manure", "coffee manure") by mixing organic chemicals.
Under item 21 of the First Schedule to the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, specified chemical fertilisers are taxable at the point of first sale in the State; the entry also included mixtures of those articles with organic manures. For assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66 the assessee claimed exemption for mixture manures as "second sales" on the ground that the mixing did not involve a manufacturing process or chemical change, and thus the mixtures were not commercially different goods.
The assessing authority found significant purchases from outside the State and treated sales of those items as first sales within the State (taxable). Because the assessee did not keep separate accounts for first and subsequent sales, the assessing officer estimated the first-sale portion by a formula (local purchases x local sales / total purchases) and taxed the apportioned turnover. For 1966-67, the assessing officer assessed the entire turnover relating to manure mixtures, concluding there was no evidence of proportions to warrant any exemption. Proceedings under Section 16 were initiated for 1962-63 to 1965-66 on the ground that previously exempted turnover had escaped assessment.
The assessee appealed against the reassessments under Section 16 and the assessment under Section 12 for 1966-67. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Tribunal confirmed the assessing authority's orders (subject to a small portion not relevant to these revisions). The assessee then filed the present revision petitions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether manure mixtures produced by mixing listed chemical fertilisers with organic manures are "commercially different goods" such that their sale constitutes a first sale in the State (and therefore is taxable under item 21), or whether they are the same as their component organic chemicals so as to qualify as second sales (and be exempt).
- Whether the assessing authority had jurisdiction under Section 16 to reassess turnover for assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66 where turnover had previously been considered and exempted at the original assessment (i.e., whether the turnover "escaped assessment" so as to permit reassessment).
Arguments of the Parties
Assessee's Arguments
- The manufacture of manure mixtures did not involve a manufacturing process or any chemical change to the organic ingredients; the mixtures were not commercially different from their component organic chemicals and hence sales of the mixtures were second sales (exempt under item 21) where based on locally purchased inputs.
- With respect to assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66, there was no escapement of turnover from assessment; the assessing authority had considered the turnover at the original assessment and deliberately exempted it, and therefore could not reopen the matter under Section 16 merely by a change of opinion in the absence of fresh materials.
Revenue / Assessing Authority's Position
- The assessing authority concluded that sales of mixture manures (especially where inputs were purchased from outside the State) constituted first sales in the State and were taxable under item 21. The officer also found that the assessee failed to keep separate accounts for first and subsequent sales and therefore estimated the taxable portion by reference to a formula (local purchases x local sales / total purchases).
- For assessment year 1966-67, because there was no evidence as to proportions of organic chemicals used in manufacture, the assessing officer assessed the entire turnover of manure mixtures as taxable.
- The assessing officer invoked Section 16 for assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66 on the ground that earlier exempted turnover had escaped assessment; the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Tribunal affirmed these actions.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Imperial Fertiliser and Company v. State of Madras [1973] 31 S.T.C. 390 | The proposition that to obtain exemption as a second or subsequent sale the assessee must establish identity between the product sold and the product purchased; if there is no identity between the product sold and that purchased, the later sale cannot be treated as a second sale. | The court treated this authority as directly covering the question of mixture manures and relied on it to hold that the mixture manures were different articles and therefore taxable as first sales. |
| State of Tamil Nadu v. Rallis India Ltd. [1974] 34 S.T.C. 532 | Although mixing may not involve a manufacturing process, the components of mixtures have different chemical properties and uses; therefore a mixture cannot be treated as the same article as its components for the purpose of treating a sale as a second sale. | The court followed this decision to support the conclusion that the chemical properties and uses of the mixture differ from those of the components, so mixtures are different articles and the turnover is taxable. |
| State of Madras v. Louis Dreyfus & Co. Ltd. [1955] 6 S.T.C. 318 (F.B.) | The word "escape" in the context of reopening an assessment refers to "turnover" that was not noticed by the officer (due to inadvertence, omission, concealment, or want of care) rather than to an "assessment" per se. | The court cited this Full Bench decision for the natural and normal meaning of "turnover which has escaped" but acknowledged later authorities that refine or change aspects of that view. |
| Maharajadhiraj Sir Kameshwar Singh v. State Of Bihar [1959] 37 I.T.R. 388 (S.C.) | With materially similar wording ("for any reason"), the Supreme Court held that reassessment proceedings may assess an item earlier included in the return but treated as exempt — indicating that the phrase removes conventional fetters and limitations on reassessment of escaped turnover. | The court relied on this Supreme Court authority to support the proposition that Section 16 can cover cases where an item earlier considered exempt may nevertheless be reopened and assessed. |
| F.K. Hasheeb & Co. v. State of Madras [1966] 17 S.T.C. 38 | This court held that many observations in Louis Dreyfus are no longer good law and that a turnover which was considered and exempted could still be brought to reassessment under Section 16. | The opinion treats this decision as supporting reassessment even where the turnover had been previously considered and excluded from tax. |
| East India Corporation Ltd. v. State of Madras [1973] 31 S.T.C. 330 | Section 16 covers cases where the assessing authority has considered a turnover and wrongly excluded it from tax, whether due to erroneous view of the nature of the transaction or wrong understanding of the Act. | The court relied on this Division Bench decision to hold that Section 16 applies to turnovers previously considered and excluded and thus reassessment was permissible. |
| Narayana Shenoi v. State of Kerala [1961] 12 S.T.C. 665 | A Kerala High Court decision taking a similar view that reassessment provisions can apply where a turnover previously considered may still be reopened. | Referenced as corroborative support for the proposition that reassessment may cover previously considered/exempted turnovers. |
| Deputy Commissioner v. Dhanalakshmi Vilas Cashew Co. [1969] 24 S.T.C. 491 (S.C.) | The Supreme Court, dealing with powers of a single authority that has both revisional and escaped-turnover powers, restricted the scope of "escaped turnover" when the revisional power was also available to that authority; held that in cases falling under revisional jurisdiction those do not fall under escaped turnover jurisdiction and vice versa. | The court analysed this decision and distinguished it on the ground that in the present statute the powers are vested in different authorities (Section 16 for assessing authority and Section 32 for Deputy Commissioner), so the restriction articulated by the Supreme Court in that specific context does not apply generally here. |
| State of Kerala v. K.E. Nainan [1970] 26 S.T.C. 251 (S.C.) | A similar Supreme Court decision to Dhanalakshmi Vilas Cashew Co., limiting the interplay between revisional powers and escaped-turnover powers when vested in the same authority. | The court considered this authority and concluded it did not mandate a restricted meaning of "escaped turnover" in the present statutory scheme because the respective powers are vested in different authorities under the Act at issue. |
| State Of Kerala v. M. Appukutty [1963] 14 S.T.C. 242 (S.C.) | Addressed the relation between revisional powers and power to assess escaped turnover where both powers are vested in the same authority; used by later Supreme Court decisions to limit scope of escaped-turnover power in such contexts. | Referenced by the court in discussing the line of Supreme Court authorities that confine the meaning of "escaped turnover" when the same authority possesses both revisional and escaped-turnover powers; the court distinguished that context from the present Act's scheme. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in two principal analytical strands corresponding to the main issues.
First, on whether manure mixtures are commercially different goods, the court treated the issue as covered by previous decisions. The court accepted the reasoning of Imperial Fertiliser and State of Tamil Nadu v. Rallis India Ltd. that identity between the product sold and the product purchased is essential to treat a sale as a second sale; where there is no identity, the later sale cannot be treated as a second sale. Even though the mixtures were produced by manual mixing rather than a chemical manufacturing process, the court noted (following the cited authorities) that the mixtures possess different chemical properties and different intended uses. On that basis the court concluded the mixtures are different articles and therefore the turnover relating to their sales is taxable as first sales under item 21.
Second, on the validity of reassessment proceedings under Section 16 for assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66, the court examined the statutory language of Section 16 and the authorities interpreting similar provisions. The court acknowledged the Full Bench decision in State of Madras v. Louis Dreyfus, which construed "escape" as referring to turnover not noticed by the officer. It then considered subsequent Supreme Court authority (Maharajadhiraj Sir Kameshwar Singh) and this court's decisions (F.K. Hasheeb & Co. and East India Corporation Ltd.) which support the proposition that Section 16 may be invoked even where a turnover had earlier been considered and wrongly excluded from tax.
The court also analysed the line of Supreme Court cases (Deputy Commissioner v. Dhanalakshmi Vilas Cashew Co., State of Kerala v. K.E. Nainan and State Of Kerala v. M. Appukutty) that limited the scope of "escaped turnover" in contexts where the same authority possessed both revisional powers and powers to assess escaped turnover. Observing that the statutory scheme before it vests the assessing authority's jurisdiction to assess escaped turnover under Section 16 and the Deputy Commissioner's revisional power under Section 32 in different authorities, the court held that those Supreme Court limitations do not compel a restricted meaning of "escaped turnover" in the present Act. The court thus concluded that the reassessment proceedings initiated by the assessing officer under Section 16 were valid.
Having resolved both points in favour of the assessing authority (mixtures are different, and reassessment under Section 16 was valid), the court found no other issues remained for consideration.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revision petitions are dismissed.
More specifically:
- The court held that the manure mixtures sold by the assessee are commercially different articles from the component organic chemicals; consequently, turnover relating to sales of these manure mixtures is liable to be taxed as first sales under item 21.
- The court held that the reassessment proceedings initiated by the assessing officer under Section 16 for assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66 were validly initiated and could proceed; therefore the reassessments were not vitiated for want of jurisdiction.
Implications:
- Direct consequence for the parties: the assessee's challenge to the taxation of mixture manures and to the reassessment under Section 16 failed; the revision petitions were dismissed with costs and counsel's fee fixed at Rs. 150 in each petition.
- Broader precedent note: the court applied and followed existing decisions (both of this court and the Supreme Court) as described in the body of the opinion; the opinion does not assert that it sets a new legal principle beyond applying those authorities and distinguishing certain Supreme Court decisions on the basis of differences in statutory scheme (i.e., separation of powers between assessing authority and revisional authority under the present Act).
No other points survived for consideration in these tax revision petitions.
1. T. C. Nos. 298 to 300 and 314 of 1971 relate to the assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66 and T. C. No. 305 of 1971 relates to the assessment year 1966-67. The assessee in all these cases is the same. The assessees are dealers in fertilisers, manure mixtures and rock phosphate, etc. They purchased number of items of chemical fertilisers both locally and also from outside the State. In some cases, they mixed organic chemicals in various proportions and manufactured different types of mixture manures called "tea manure", "coffee manure", etc. Under item 21 of the First Schedule to the Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, the chemical fertilisers enumerated in that item are to be taxed at single point on the point of first sale in the State. After enumerating 15 items of chemical fertilisers, the entry further provided that any mixture of one or more of the articles mentioned therein with one or more of the organic manures would also come within that entry. In the assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66, the assessee claimed exemption in respect of the mixture manures on the ground that the manufacture of manure mixtures does not involve any manufacturing process and does not also involve any chemical change of the organic ingredients and that, therefore, they are not commercially different goods. On that basis, the assessee claimed that the sale of manure mixture is a second sale in the State as it was made of the organic chemicals purchased by them. The assessing authority found from a check of the records that the assessee had not only purchased organic chemical fertilisers within the State but also a good portion of the turnover related to purchase from outside the State. In respect of the chemicals purchased by the assessee from outside the State, the assessing officer considered that the sale of the same by the assessee would be the first sale within the State and that, therefore, under entry 21 that turnover is liable to be taxed. He also found that the assessee had not been keeping separate accounts for the first and subsequent sales and he accordingly proposed to estimate the first sales with reference to a formula. The formula determined by him was "local purchases x local sales"./total purchases On this basis, he determined the turnover relating to the second sales and exempted only that portion and subjected to tax the remaining portion. When the question was again considered for the assessment year 1966-67, the assessing authority thought that in the absence of any evidence to show what was the proportion of the organic chemical which was used in the manufacture of manure mixture, no portion of the sales turnover of manure mixture could be exempted as second sales. In that view, he assessed the entire turnover relating to manure mixture for the assessment year 1966-67. He also initiated proceedings under Section 16 in respect of the assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66 on the ground that that portion of the turnover relating to sales of manure mixture exempted on the earlier occasion had escaped assessment. The assessee preferred appeals both against the reassessment orders made under Section 16 and the assessment order made under Section 12 in respect of the assessment year 1966-67. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner confirmed the order of the assessing authority. The Tribunal also confirmed the decision except in regard to a small portion, which is not the subject-matter of revision in these proceedings. Before the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Appellate Tribunal, the assessee contended that in so far as the assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66 are concerned, the assessing authority has no jurisdiction to invoke his power under Section 16 as the assessing authority on the earlier occasion had considered that question and deliberately exempted the turnover as second sales. In those circumstances, the turnover could not be said to have escaped assessment giving jurisdiction to the assessing authority to invoke his power under Section 16. He also contended that in respect of the assessment years including 1966-67, the manure mixtures, which he sold are not commercially different goods from that of the organic chemicals which he has purchased and that, therefore, in so far as the purchases made by him locally the turnover of manure mixture is a second sale and not liable to be taxed. Both these contentions were not accepted by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Tribunal. Hence these revision petitions.
2. The question whether the manure mixture is commercially a different commodity and that, therefore, the sale of the same is to be treated as first sale in the State is covered by the authority and against the assessee. In Imperial Fertiliser and Company v. State of Madras [1973] 31 S.T.C. 390, a Division Bench of this Court, to which one of us was a party, considered almost an identical question. In that case also, the assessee purchased various items of chemical manure referred to in item 21 of the First Schedule and by mixing one or more of the said articles with one or more of any organic manure he produced certain manure mixtures. The question for consideration was whether the turnovers relating to the mixture were liable to be taxed. It was held that for getting an exemption on the ground that it is a second or subsequent sale, the assessee had to establish that there has been a sale of the same goods at an anterior point of time and if there was no identity between the product sold and that which was purchased by the assessee, it was not possible to treat the sale by the assessee as a second sale. This view was followed by a subsequent decision reported in State of Tamil Nadu v. Rallis India Ltd. [1974] 34 S.T.C. 532, which also related to mixture manures coming under item 21 of the First Schedule. It was pointed out that though no manufacturing process is involved in the mixing of such mixture the components of the mixture have different chemical properties of their own and their use also is different and that, therefore, it is not possible to treat the manure mixture as the same article as the components themselves. These decisions clearly cover the merits of the contention of the learned counsel. Though tea manure and coffee manure and the other mixtures sold by the assessee are manufactured by the mixing of the organic fertilisers by human labour, since the chemical properties of the mixture are different from organic properties which formed the components, they are different articles and intended for different purposes. We are accordingly of the view that the turnover relating to the sales of these manure mixtures are liable to be taxed.
3. It was then contended by the learned counsel for the assessee that in respect of the assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66, there was no escapement of the turnover from assessment to tax and that, therefore, the assessing authority had no jurisdiction to reassess the turnover under Section 16. According to the learned counsel, if a turnover had been considered by the assessing authority at the stage of original assessment and either by reason of the mistake of fact or mistake of law or for any other reason it deliberately omitted to assess the same, it would not be open to the assessing authority, on a mere change of opinion without any fresh materials, to invoke his power under Section 16. Section 16(1) of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1959, which is the relevant provision, reads as follows :
Assessment of escaped turnover.-(I) (a) Where, for any reason, the whole or any part of the turnover of business of a dealer has escaped assessment to tax, the assessing authority may, subject to the provisions of Sub-section (2), at any time within a period of five years from the expiry of the year to which the tax relates, determine to the best of its judgment the turnover which has escaped assessment and assess the tax payable on such turnover after making such enquiry as it may consider necessary and after giving the dealer a reasonable opportunity to show cause against such assessment.
(b) Where, for any reason, the whole or any part of the turnover of business of a dealer has been assessed at a rate lower than the rate at which it is assessable, the assessing authority may, at any time within a period of five years from the expiry of the year to which the tax relates, reassess the tax due after making such enquiry as it may consider necessary and after giving the dealer a reasonable opportunity to show cause against such reassessment.
4. In one of the earliest cases in State of Madras v. Louis Dreyfus and Company Ltd. [1955] 6 S.T.C. 318 (F.B.), which considered a corresponding provision in Rule 17 of the Madras General Sales Tax Rules, a Full Bench of this Court observed:
The 'escape' that serves as the foundation of the jurisdiction to reopen an assessment is that of 'turnover' and not, be it noted, an assessment. 'Turnover' escapes when it is not noticed by the officer either because it is not before him by reason of an inadvertence, omission or deliberate concealment on the part of the assessee, or because of want of care on the part of the officer the turnover though in the books has not been taken notice of. This would be the natural and normal meaning of the expression turnover which has escaped' in Rule 17(1).
5. But, in a subsequent case arising under the Bihar Agricultural Income-tax Act, 1938, the Supreme Court in the decision reported in Maharajadhiraj Sir Kameshwar Singh v. State Of Bihar . [1959] 37 I.T.R. 388 (S.C.), held with reference to a provision which is almost identical with Section 16, that by the use of the words "for any reason" all those fetters and limitations which are normally associated with the assessment of escaped turnovers have been removed and that it was competent in a reassessment proceeding to assess an item of income which had been omitted to tax earlier even though in the return that income was included and the Agricultural Income-tax Officer then thought that it was exempt. In the light of this decision, this court again considered the scope of Section 16 in the decision reported in F.K. Hasheeb & Co. v. State of Madras [1966] 17 S.T.C. 38. This court was of the view that many of the observations contained in the judgment of the Full Bench in State of Madras v. Louis Dreyfus and Company Ltd. [1955] 6 S.T.C. 318 (F.B.) are no longer good law and that even a turnover which was considered and exempted by the assessing authority could be brought to reassessment as a turnover which has escaped assessment under Section 16. Again in East India Corporation Ltd. v. State of Madras [1973] 31 S.T.C. 330, a Division Bench, to which one of us was a party, held :
Section 16 covers within its ambit even cases where in respect of a turnover the assessing authority has considered the liability to tax and wrongly excluded it from tax, whether on the ground of erroneous view of the nature of the transaction or on a wrong understanding of the provisions of the Act or for any other reason.
6. A similar view was taken also by the Kerala High Court with respect to a corresponding provision in the decision reported in Narayana Shenoi v. State of Kerala [1961] 12 S.T.C. 665. But the learned counsel laid strong reliance on the two decisions of the Supreme Court reported in Deputy Commissioner v. Dhanalakshmi Vilas Cashew Co. [1969] 24 S.T.C. 491 (S.C.) and State of Kerala v. K.E. Nainan [1970] 26 S.T.C. 251 (S.C). In the first case, the facts were these: In the original assessment order made in respect of the assessment year 1958-59, the assessing authority, though the turnover was before him, did not include it in the taxable turnover on the ground that it was not liable to tax. Subsequently, by a notice dated 29th October, 1963, the Deputy Commissioner of Agricultural Income-tax and Sales Tax, who is the revising authority, proposed to revise the assessment under Section 15(1) of the Travancore-Cochin General Sales Tax Act, 1125 M.E. Under Section 15(1), the Deputy Commissioner may suo motu call for and examine the record of any order passed or proceeding recorded under the provisions of the Act by any officer subordinate to him, for the purpose of satisfying himself as to the legality or propriety of such order or as to the regularity of such proceeding and may pass such order with respect thereto as he thinks fit. This power could be exercised by the Deputy Commissioner within a period of four years from the date on which the assessment order was communicated to the assessee. Under Rule 33(5) read with Rule 33(1) of the Travancore General Sales Tax Rules, 1950, framed under the Travancore-Cochin General Sales Tax Act, if for any reason the whole or part of the turnover of business of a dealer has escaped assessment to the tax in any year, the Deputy Commissioner may also at any time within a period of three years next succeeding that to which the tax relates determine to the best of his judgment the turnover which has escaped assessment and assess the tax payable after making such enquiry as he considers necessary. The assessee contended that the Deputy Commissioner could have proceeded only under Rule 33(5) and assess the turnover as one that has escaped assessment and since the notice dated 29th October, 1963, was beyond the period of three years, he had no jurisdiction to proceed under that provision. The notice purported to have been issued under Section 15, which gave him a larger period of limitation, was therefore not valid. The Supreme Court, relying on the decision in State Of Kerala v. M. Appukutty . [1963] 14 S.T.C. 242 (S.C.), held that in the context of the powers under Section 15 and Rule 33(5) vested in the same authority only in cases where Rule 33(5) is not applicable, the Deputy Commissioner could invoke his power under Section 15 and the case before them was one falling under section 15(1) and not under Rule 33(5). In that view, the Supreme Court upheld the proceedings initiated under Section 15. This decision was followed in State of Kerala v. K.E. Nainan [1970] 26 S.T.C. 251 (S.C.) in almost on identical facts. It may be seen from the decision that the Supreme Court was concerned with the power of one authority, namely, the Deputy Commissioner, who had both the power to assess an escaped turnover and also the power to revise an assessment on the ground of illegality or impropriety. In the context of both the powers found in two different provisions on the same authority, the Supreme Court held that if it is a case of escaped turnover it will not fall under the revisional jurisdiction and if it is a case falling under the revisional jurisdiction, it could not fall under the jurisdiction to assess escaped turnover. The decision in State Of Kerala v. M. Appukutty . [1963] 14 S.T.C. 242 (S.C.), which was relied on by the Supreme Court is also to the same effect. That decision was concerned with the powers of the Deputy Commissioner under Section 12 of the Madras General Sales Tax Act, 1939 and Rule 17(3-A) of the Madras General Sales Tax Rules, 1939. Since both conferred power on the Deputy Commissioner, the Supreme Court held that without exercising the power to assess escaped turnover, under Rule 17(3-A), the Deputy Commissioner could rely, while revising an order of the assessing authority, on Section 12(2). But the scheme of the present Act is different. While the assessing authority's jurisdiction is dealt with under Section 16, the Deputy Commissioner's power to revise is found under Section 32. Therefore, the words "escaped turnover" in Section 16 and the words "illegality, impropriety or irregularity" in Section 32, in our opinion, have to be understood in the context in which it is now found in the Act. The Supreme Court in State Of Kerala v. M. Appukutty . [1963] 14 S.T.C. 242 (S.C.), Deputy Commissioner v. Dhanalakshmi Vilas Cashew Co. [1969] 24 S.T.C. 491 (S.C.) and State of Kerala v. K.E. Nainan [1970] 26 S.T.C. 251 (S.C.) considered the words "escaped turnover" in the context of the power given to the same authority to revise an assessment on the ground of illegality and impropriety and, therefore, their Lordships have restricted the scope of these words "escaped turnover". In the absence of such different provisions vesting the power on the same authority, we are of the view that a restricted meaning either for the words "escaped turnover" or for the words "illegality, impropriety or irregularity" is not warranted. But as pointed out by this court in East India Corporation Ltd. v. State of Madras [1973] 31 S.T.C. 330, the conditions or limitations on which each could invoke their powers are different and had to be found only in the respective provisions of Sections 16 and 32. We are therefore, of the opinion that the decisions in F. K. Hasheeb & Co. v. State of Madras [1966] 17 S.T.C. 38 and East India Corporation Ltd. v. State of Madras [1973] 31 S.T.C. 330 do not require any reconsideration even after the decisions in Deputy Commissioner v. Dhanalakshmi Vilas Cashew Co. [1969] 24 S.T.C. 491 (S.C.) and State of Kerala v. K.E. Nainan [1970] 26 S.T.C. 251 (S.C.). We, accordingly, hold that the reassessment proceedings were validly initiated by the assessing officer in respect of the assessment years 1962-63 to 1965-66. No other points survive for consideration in these tax revision petitions. The petitions, accordingly, fail and they are dismissed with costs. Counsel's fee Rs. 150 in each.
Alert