- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
B.E Kaliyaperumal Nattar v. The Authorised Officer (Land Reforms) Tiruchirapalli.
JUDGMENT
(Delivered by The Chief Justice)
1. This appeal raises the question as to the validity of a sale of an extent of 2 acres and 32 cents comprised in S. No. 40/5 and made on 14th May 1964 in favour of the appellant. The vendor filed a return under Madras Act 58 of 1961 on 15th July 1963, disclosing an extent of 3 acres and 91 cents as surplus out of 4 acres and 94 cents covered by survey field No. 40/5 in Bishandarkoil village, Lalgudi Taluk. A draft statement was published, as required by S. 10 on 29th January 1964, and the final statement under S. 12 followed on 28th January 1965. A notice of the final statement was served on the vendor 29th November 1965. An appeal arising from it failed on 10th June 1966. On 5 th October 1966 notification under S. 18(1) was made and on 13th October 1966, the vesting of the surplus was proclaimed under S. 18(2). We may mention that, on 9th March 1964, the Supreme Court struck down the Act itself as violative of the fundamental rights relating to property. Then came, with effect from 20th June 1964, 17th Amendment of the Constitution which gives deemed validity to the Act from the date of its original commencement, namely, 6th April 1960;
2. The purchaser who impugned the validity of the vesting of the land covered by the sale deed in his favour, failed in his petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution, Alagiriswami, I. taking the view that the intendment of the Act was to invalidate such a sale deed as well With respect, we are unable to share this view.
3. Madras Act 58 of 1969 provides for fixation of ceiling on agricultural land holding and for certain other matters connected there with. It gives effect to the objectives underlying Cls. (b) and (c) of Art. 39 of the Constitution of India. While fixing a ceiling at the extent mentioned in the Act on holding agricultural land, the Act contains provisions for vesting in Government of surplus land and distribution thereof by it to the landless. We have already mentioned that the Act commenced to operate with effect from 6th April 1960. S. 7 says that, on and from the date of the commencement of the Act, no person shall, except as otherwise provided in the Act, but subject to the provisions of Ch. VIII, be entitled to hold in excess of the ceiling area. We are not, at the moment concerned with the proviso to the Section. S. 8 provides for furnishing of return by person holding land in excess of the ceiling. That section itself fixes ceiling at 30 standard acres, a term which is defined. The liability to make a return is within 90 days from such date as may be specified in the Notification issued by the Government. The term ‘notified date’ is defined by S. 3 as the date specified in the notification issued by the Government under S. 8(1). S. 9 relates to collection of information detailed therein. When a return is furnished on the basis of the information under Sub-S. (1) of S. 8 as well as the representation and evidence under the proviso Explanation III to Sub-Sec. (1) of Sec. 8 the representation and evidence under the proviso or on the basis of the information under Sub-S. (1) of S. 9 and the additional particulars, if any, or on the basis of the information obtained by the authorised officer, he shall prepare a draft statement in respect of each person holding or deemed to have held land in excess of the ceiling area. Such statement should contain particulars detailed in Sub-S. (1) of S. 10 which precludes also particulars of the land proposed to be declared as surplus land. Before proceeding further, the authorised officer is given jurisdiction to decide, in certain circumstances, questions of title. After disposal of objections, if any, preferred under S. 10(5) to the draft statement published, the Authorised Officer, under S. 12, makes necessary alterations in the draft statement and declares surplus land as held by each person. This is regarded as the final statement to be published. Then follows the provision for acquisition of surplus land which is provided for by S. 18. After publication of the final statement under S. 12, the Government shall publish a notification to the effect that surplus land is required for a public purpose. Once that is done, and due publicity thereof has been given as provided by Sub-S. (2) of S. 18 the land specified in the notification, together with the trees standing on such land and buildings, shall vest in the Government free from all encumbrances from the date of publication and all right, title and interest of all persons in such land, with effect from the said date, shall be deemed to have been extinguished. In order to effectuate the scheme of the ceiling, Ch. III of the Act contains provisions for ceiling of future acquisition and restrictions on certain transfers. S. 19 enjoins that, when a transfer is made in his favour of agricultural lands, the transferee should declare the extent of land held by him. In the absence of such declaration, no document of transfer could be registered. The penalty for future acquisition in contravention of S. 7 fixing the ceiling is that the transfer effected shall be deemed to have been in favour of the Government with effect from the date of transfer. S. 22 deals with transfers between the date of the Act and the notified date. In such a case of transfer, the Authorised officer may declare, after following the prescribed procedure, the transfer to be void, but only if he finds that it defeats any of the provisions of the Act. Then comes S. 23:
“Subject to the provisions of S. 20, for the purpose of fixing, for the first time, the ceiling area of any person holding land, on the date of the commencement of this Act, in excess of 30 standard acres, the authorised officer shall not take into consideration:—
(a) any transfer, whether by sale (including sale in execution of a decree or order of a civil court or of an award or order of any other lawful authority), or by gift (other than gift made in contemplation of death), exchange, surrender, settlement or otherwise: or
(b) any subdivision (including sub-division by a decree or order of a civil court or any other lawful authority) whether by partition or otherwise, effected on or after the notified date and before the date of the publication of the final statement under S. 12 or 14.”
4. The direction in the Section is to the authorised officer which is that, for the purpose of fixing, for the first time, the ceiling area of any person holding land on the date of the commencement of the Act in excess of 30 standard acres, he shall ignore any transfer, whether by sale or by gift, etc., effected on or after the notified date and before the date of the publication of the final statement under S. 12 or 14. In sharp contrast to S. 22, the authorised officer, while acting under S. 23, has not been given any power to declare such sale deed to be void. The section also does not say that the transfer is not rendered void either expressly or by any statement in the section. The Section does not deal with the transferee's rights.
5. It is true the several possibilities may be contemplated with reference to S. 24. One of them, to take an extreme case, may be of a person holding agricultural land in excess of 30 standard acres at the commencement of the Act. After filing a return but before the vesting of surplus land, he has transferred the entirety of the land in his holding. The question may arise what should be done in such a case. If the Authorised Officer is to ignore the transfer made by the transferor, the transferee's rights will come is the way of actually taking the land, and be it noted that the State's right to take the land, will arise from the date of vesting on notification under S. 18(3). Sec. 23 cannot be read or understood as conferring power upon the Authorised Officer to take land which has not vested in the Government as provided under the provisions of the Act, particularly S. 18(3), and then distribute such land. Yet, another instance may be examined. Instead of transferring the entire land, the transferor conveys just an extent in excess of the ceiling limit. In that case, the effect of ignoring the transfer would be that the Authorised officer may be entitled to take over what could have been regarded as excess before the transfer out of the lands still in the hands of the transferor; but be it noted that this, he can do only when the land which he proposes to take has, by a notification under S. 18(3), vested in the Government. As we think the approach to S. 23 should also be from the stand point of the main objective of the Legislation, namely, fixing a ceiling too much emphasis cannot be given to distribution. We are aware that the position under S. 23, as it is worded for the moment, may be anomalous and may even lead to difficult situations. But that, in our view, should not stand in the way of finding the true scope of S. 23 and the court is not entitled to fill up gaps in S. 23 by visualising strange situations in providing for them.
6. As we read S. 23, we are unable to hold that the sale in favour of the appellant is by any means invalid. It follows, therefore, that his title or possession cannot be interfered with. The appeal is allowed with costs. Counsel's fee Rs. 200.
V.C.S
Alert