Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ramaswami Jadaya Goundar (Died) And Another v. V.T Elaiya Pillai And Another.

Madras High Court
Nov 1, 1971
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision petition challenges an order of the lower Court which held that the burden of proof that a document was not properly executed lay on the defendant. According to the petitioner (described in the opinion as "the petitioner defendant"), the first respondent entered into an agreement on 9-10-1952 which adjusted the parties' rights under a compromise decree. The first respondent pleaded that he only knows how to sign his name, does not know the contents of the documents to which his signature was affixed, and that the documents were not read over or explained to him. The lower Court found that the first respondent's case was not that his signatures were taken on blank sheets but that he signed completed documents, and therefore placed the burden of proof on the first respondent to begin. The present Court reviewed that ruling on revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. When a person who is illiterate or does not understand the language of a document has signed or marked a document, which party bears the onus of proving that the document was properly explained and that the signature amounts to execution of the document?
  2. Whether the lower Court correctly placed the burden of proof on the signatory (first respondent) where the signatory pleads illiteracy and non-explanation of the document, as opposed to placing the onus on the party relying on the document.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (described in the opinion as "the petitioner defendant")

  • Asserts that the first respondent entered into an agreement dated 9-10-1952, adjusting rights under a compromise decree.
  • Contends (in the memorandum of grounds to the revision petition) that the petitioner executed a blank sheet of paper—an allegation the Court notes is inconsistent with the trial pleadings.

First Respondent (plea as recorded in the trial court)

  • Pleads that he only knows to sign his name and cannot read or write.
  • Asserts that he had no knowledge of the contents of the documents to which his signatures are attributed, and that the documents were not read over or explained to him.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Natesa Gounder v. Ramayya Gounder, (1966) 79 Mad LW (SN) p. 16 An admission of putting one's name on a blank sheet cannot amount to an acknowledgment or token of execution of a document; if a plaintiff makes out a prima facie case that the signature to a completed document is that of the defendant, it is for the defendant to establish the circumstances in which his signature appears on the completed document. The lower Court relied on this decision to hold that the burden of proof was on the signatory (first respondent) to show how his signature came to be on the completed document. The revision Court recorded this reliance but evaluated it in light of the other precedent cited.
Omanhene Kwamin Bassayin v. Omanhene Bendenty II, AIR 1937 PC 274 Where a person not knowing the language of the document affixes his mark, the onus to prove that the document was properly explained and interpreted so as to make him understand its true import lies on the party which relies on the document. The Court held this authority applicable to the facts before it (an executant pleaded illiteracy and non-explanation) and applied the principle that the party relying on the document must prove it was properly explained. On that basis the Court directed that the defendant (party relying on the document) must begin and prove his case that the document was executed by the plaintiff.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the pleadings as they stood before the lower Court. It observed that the lower Court had decided the matter on the basis that the first respondent did not plead that his signatures were affixed on blank sheets but had signed completed documents, and accordingly placed the onus on the first respondent to begin.

The Court considered two lines of authority. It noted the Natesa Gounder decision, which supports the proposition that a mere admission of putting one's name on a blank sheet is not equivalent to acknowledging the contents of a completed document and that, once a plaintiff makes out a prima facie case of signature, the defendant must explain the circumstances of the signature.

The Court then considered the Privy Council decision in Omanhene (AIR 1937 PC 274), which is authority for the proposition that where an executant does not understand the language of the document or is illiterate, the onus is on the party who relies on the document to prove that it was properly explained and interpreted to the executant so as to make him understand its true import.

Applying the Omanhene principle to the present pleadings — which included the defendant's (as presented to the lower Court) submission of illiteracy and non-explanation — the Court held that the burden of proof lies on the party relying on the document to prove that it was properly explained and, accordingly, that the defendant must begin to prove that the plaintiff executed the compromise agreement. The Court acknowledged a discrepancy in the revision petition's memorandum of grounds (an assertion that the petitioner executed a blank sheet) but confined its decision to the pleadings that the lower Court was addressing.

Holding and Implications

The petition is allowed; the defendant is directed to begin and prove his case that the document (the compromise agreement) was executed by the plaintiff.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The defendant (party relying on the document) must open and prove the case of execution by the plaintiff.
  • The Court ordered that there shall be no costs.

The opinion does not elaborate on broader jurisprudential consequences beyond the direct effect on the parties or state that it establishes a new precedent.

Show all summary ...

1. This revision petition is filed by the plaintiff against the order of the lower Court holding that the burden of proof that the document was not properly executed is on the defendant. According to the petitioner defendant, the first respondent entered into an agreement on 9-10-1952 according to which the parties adjusted their rights inter se under the compromise decree. The plea of the first respondent is that he only knows to sign his name and he had no knowledge of the contents of the documents to which his signatures are taken; and he was not informed of the contents of the documents as the documents were not read over or explained to him. The lower court, holding that it was not the first respondent's case that his signatures were taken in blank sheets and that he had signed the completed documents, held that the burden of proof is on the first respondent and he had to begin. Reliance was placed for this view on Natesa Gounder v. Ramayya gounder, (1966) 79 Mad LW (SN) p. 16, where it was held by this Court that an admission by putting one's name on blank sheet cannot amount to an acknowledgment or token of the execution of a document. It was also held that if the plaintiff made out a prima facie case by showing that the signature to a completed document is that of the defendant, it will be for the defendant to establish in what circumstances his signature is found on the completed document. The effect of this decision is that an admission of putting one's name to a blank sheet cannot amount to an acknowledgment of its contents. If the signature was put on a completed document, it is a for the defendant to establish under what circumstances his signature is found in the completed document.

2. In Omanhene Kwamin Bassayin v. Omanhene Bendenty II, AIR 1937 PC 274, their Lordships of the Privy council in dealing with a case in which a person not knowing the English language had affixed his mark to a document written in English language, held that the onus to prove that the document was properly explained and interpreted to the person affixing his mark so as to make him to understand its true import is on the party relying on the document. The plea taken by the plaintiff in that case was that the document in question is not binding on him Omanhene of Aowin, because it was in the English language and had not been properly explained and interpreted to the Omanhene of Aowin when he affixed his mark to it; in other words, that it had not been explained and interpreted to him so as to make him understand its true import. Under the circumstances, it was held that the onus lies upon the defendant to establish that the document had in fact been properly explained and interpreted so as to make the plaintiff understand its real import. This decision is an authority for the proposition that if the executant did not know the contents of the document or when it is a language not known to the executant it cannot be said that the executant had really executed the document.

3. In this case, the plea of the plaintiff is that he is illiterate and that apart from putting his signature he does not know how to read or write. In the circumstances, the burden is on the plaintiff to prove that the defendant had executed the document. The learned counsel for the respondents submitted that in the memorandum of grounds to the revision petition, the plea taken was that the petitioner executed the blank sheet of paper and this is contrary to the plea taken in the trial. The learned counsel is right, but the lower Court was passing the order on the pleadings before it where the defendant submitted that he was illiterate and that the contents of the document were not read over or explained to him. In the circumstances, the decision in AIR 1937 PC 274 is applicable and it has to be held that the burden is on the defendant to prove that the plaintiff had executed the compromise agreement. The petition is allowed and the defendant will be directed to begin and prove his case of execution of the document by the plaintiff. No costs.