Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The State Of Madras v. Mohamed Mustafa.

Madras High Court
Mar 25, 1970
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary (Ramaprasada Rao, J.) — Heard 20 March 1970

Factual and Procedural Background

By a notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act (Act I of 1894), dated 7 March 1962, an extent of 7 grounds 75 sq. ft. in Survey No. 34/3 at Puliyur near Kodambakkam was acquired for construction of a sewage pumping station. The Land Acquisition Officer (LAO) awarded compensation at Rs. 4,587 per ground for the land and Rs. 5 per tree for 39 trees. The respondent claimed additional compensation for injurious affection to the remaining (unacquired) land, which the LAO rejected. On a reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, the City Civil Court (Fourth Assistant Judge, Madras) confirmed the LAO's market-value award, increased tree-compensation by Rs. 2 per tree, granted Rs. 3,000 as damages for injurious affection, and added solatium at 15% (apparently on that damage award). The State (appellant) challenged the grant of solatium on damages and also objected to the enhanced tree compensation. The respondent filed cross-objections contending that the true market value was higher and sought compensation at Rs. 5,000 per ground.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether solatium under Section 23(2) of the Land Acquisition Act can be awarded as an annexure to damages granted for "injurious affection" under Clause (iv) of Section 23(1).
  2. Whether the additional compensation awarded by the lower court for palmyrah trees (increase of Rs. 2 per tree) is maintainable.
  3. Whether the market value of the acquired land was correctly determined by the court below (specifically, whether the respondent's cross-objection seeking Rs. 5,000 per ground should succeed).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State)

  • Contended that the grant of 15% solatium as an annexure to damages awarded for injurious affection is contrary to law and not permissible under Section 23.
  • Also objected (in the Memorandum of Grounds of Appeal) to the additional compensation awarded by the lower court for trees.

Respondent

  • Contended that the court below failed to appreciate the true market value and sought compensation at Rs. 5,000 per ground (cross-objections).
  • Relied on a post-notification sale (Ex. C-1) as support for a higher valuation; respondent's witnesses admitted the acquired land was lower in level than the roadside land.
  • Invited the court's attention to two precedents (Bombay High Court decision and a decision of the Madras High Court) which, the respondent's counsel argued, supported the grant of solatium in this context.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vakratunda Chintaman Deo v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, Poona Held that compensation reckoned as substitute for benefits (i.e., valuation of benefits arising from the land) can amount to a determination of market value; where so determined, solatium may be awarded. The court noted the precedent but explained it did not apply: that case involved valuation of benefits amounting to market-value determination, unlike the present case where damages for injurious affection are not a market-value determination.
State of Madras v. Balaji Chettiar Considered the separability of market value under Section 23(1) and solatium under Section 23(2) and addressed the vires of Act 37 of 1950 which abolished solatium. The court held the ratio was not applicable to the present issue; while Balaji Chettiar discussed separability of market value and solatium, it did not address whether solatium must be awarded on damages for injurious affection under Clause (iv) of Section 23(1).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis turned primarily on statutory interpretation of Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act.

  1. Textual construction of Section 23:
    • The court observed that "market value" appears specifically in Clause (i) of sub-section (1) of Section 23 and that sub-section (2) expressly awards solatium (15%) "on such market value". The demonstrative word "such" connects the solatium to the market value determined under Clause (i).
    • Other heads in sub-section (1) (for example Clause (iv) which deals with damages for injurious affection, Clause (v) for change of residence/business expenses, and Clauses (iii) and (vi) regarding consequential damages) are conceptually and legally distinct from the market-value determination in Clause (i).
  2. Consequence for awarding solatium:
    • Because solatium in sub-section (2) is meant to be annexed to the market value determined under Clause (i), it cannot, by the statute's language, be annexed to awards that are purely damages under Clause (iv) or other clauses not dealing with market value.
    • Therefore, where a court awards damages as such for injurious affection (Clause (iv)), those amounts do not attract the statutory solatium under sub-section (2).
  3. Treatment of precedents:
    • The court considered the cited precedents. In Vakratunda the compensation was regarded as a substitute for benefits and thus tantamount to market-value determination, permitting solatium. The present case did not involve valuation of benefits in that sense.
    • In State of Madras v. Balaji Chettiar the Division Bench discussed the separability of market value and solatium in the context of a different legislative change (Act 37 of 1950); the court found that decision did not govern the discrete question whether solatium is payable on damages for injurious affection under Clause (iv).
  4. Specific factual valuation analysis:
    • The court rejected reliance solely on Ex. C-1 (a small, post-notification corner plot sale at Rs. 7,777 per ground) because it was a corner plot abutting two roads, post-notification, and only about 1200 sq. ft., so not sufficiently comparable.
    • The court treated Ex. R-16 (sale of 1-5/8 grounds at Rs. 4,923 per ground, about three months before notification, abutting Choolaimedu Road in a developed area nearer the acquired land) as the more comparable datum.
    • From Ex. R-16 the court deducted Rs. 336 per ground to account for the expense of raising (leveling) the acquired land, a factual deduction the court found reasonable and supported by respondent's witness admission that the acquired land was at a lower level than the roadside land. On that basis the court upheld the lower court's market-value determination of Rs. 4,587 per ground.
  5. Final legal application:
    • The court allowed the appeal in part by holding that solatium could not be awarded on damages given for injurious affection; it rejected the lower court's addition of solatium to such damages.
    • The court rejected the appellant's challenge to the enhanced tree compensation only insofar as it was not seriously pressed and found no basis to disturb the finding.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Appeal allowed in part; cross-objections dismissed.

Direct Effects on the Parties

  • The grant of 15% solatium as an annexure to damages awarded for injurious affection was held to be contrary to the statutory scheme and therefore could not stand.
  • The higher compensation for palmyrah trees (increase by Rs. 2 per tree, as awarded by the lower court) was not disturbed by this court (the appeal in respect of that issue was rejected as not pressed and unsupported by evidence to disturb it).
  • The court confirmed the market value at Rs. 4,587 per ground (after a deduction of Rs. 336 per ground for raising the lower level acquired land) as a fair market value for the acquired land.
  • Cross-objections by the respondent seeking Rs. 5,000 per ground were dismissed.
  • There was no order as to costs for either party.

Broader Legal Implication

The court clarified the statutory relationship between Section 23(1)(i) (market value) and Section 23(2) (solatium): solatium is statutorily attached to the market-value determination and does not extend to amounts awarded purely as damages for injurious affection under Clause (iv) of Section 23(1). The opinion did not purport to lay down any novel precedent beyond this textual construction, and it limited its use of earlier decisions to distinguish their factual or legal scope from the present issue.


This summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion text and does not add information beyond that source.

Show all summary ...

This Appeal and Memorandum of Cross Objections coming on for hearing on Friday the 20th March 1970 and this day, the Court delivered the following:

JUDGMENT

(delivered by Ramaprasada Rao, J.)

In this appeal which is against the judgment and decree of the learned Fourth Assistant Judge of the City Civil Court, Madras the question relates to the sufficiency of compensation granted to the respondent as and towards the market value of the lands acquired under the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act (Act I of 1894). By a notification under Section 4(1) of the Act, dated March 7, 1962, an extent of 7 Grounds 75 sq. ft. in S. No. 34/3 in the village of Puliyur near Kodambakkam, was acquired for the construction of a sewage pumping station. The Land Acquisition Officer, after due notice to parties, granted a compensation at the rate of Rs. 4,587/- per ground. He also awarded a compensation at the rate of Rs. 5 per tree and there were 39 such trees. In addition thereto, a claim was made before the Land Acquisition Officer on the ground that the unacquired portion of Land has been injuriously affected by reason of the acquisition of the acquired land which is a roadside land. The case of the respondent before the Land Acquisition Officer was that the road side lands were acquired and the balance of his holding has been left out practically as hinterland and it has access only through a passage 50 feet in width and about 200 feet in length, which passage leads on to the interior lands. The Land Acquisition Officer negatived the claim for such injurious affection. On a reference under S. 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, the Court confirmed the award of the Land Acquisition Officer in so far as it related to the market value of the acquired land. The Court, however, increased the compensation by Rs. 2 per tree and granted damages under the head of injurious affection, to the tune of Rs. 3000. Whilst granting such damages, the Court also awarded solatium thereon at 15 per cent, evidently under the view that solatium has to be given even in cases where the interested person is granted compensation as and towards damages for injurious affection. The State is the appellant before us and it questions the grant of the solatium in the manner stated above, but has also added in the Memorandum of Grounds of Appeal, an objection to the grant of the additional compensation for trees. The respondent has filed Cross-Objections and he claims that the Court failed to appreciate the real market value of the acquired land and that it sought to have granted a compensation at the rate of Rs. 5,000 per ground.

We may at the outset reject the appeal in so far as it relates to the additional grant made by the Court below for Palmyrah trees as it is not even seriously pressed and there is no evidence to disturb this finding.

The next and the most formidable objection raised by the appellant is that the grant of 15 per cent solatium as an annexure to the damages awarded to the interested person under the head “injurious affection” is opposed to law. Under the Land Acquisition Act the Court, while, determining the amount of compensation to be awarded for lands acquired under the Act, shall take into consideration the market value of the land at the date of the publication of the notification under S. 4 and in addition thereto, the Court shall in every case award a sum of Rs. 15/- per centum on such market value in consideration of the compulsory nature of the acquisition. The word “market value” appears in clause (i) of sub-section (1) of S. 23. It again re-appears is sub-section (2) of S. 23. In sub-section (2) of S. 23, the solatium, as it is commonly called, is awardable on such market value. The word “such” in sub-section (2) of S. 23 has to be given its full weight as it has a special significance. It has reference to the market value determined by the Court under Cl. (i) of sub-section (1) of S. 23. The other clauses appearing sub-section (1) of S. 23 relate to various heads totally unconnected with the market value of the land. For example, Cl. (iv) of sub-section (i) of S. 23 provides the head of damage which an interested person my sustain at the time of the acquisition and by reason thereof resulting in his other property, moveable or immoveable, being injuriously affected. The Section and Cls. Nos. (iii) and (vi) specifically speak of and provide for, damages resulting from and consequential upon compulsory acquisition. Even Cl. (v) is an item which is very much akin to damage, for it provides for the payment of such reasonable expenses to the interested person if he compelled to change his residence or place of business in consequence of the acquisition. Here again, there is no question of any market value of the land being assessed or touched upon. It therefore follows that it is only in the first clause in sub-section (i) of S. 23, that the words “market value” of the land appear, and it is to this phrase is interlaced the solatium which is expressly provided for in sub-section (2) of S. 23. It therefore follows that if any damage is awarded by Court under the head of injurious affection within the meaning of Cl. (iv) of subsection (i) of S. 23, then such amount or such damage granted has no relation to the market value of the land and the solatium which is awardable only as a necessary annexure to market value cannot he awarded and annexed to such damage as well. This is what the lower Court has dose in the instant case. The learned Counsel for the respondent, however, invited our attention to two decisions, one of the Bombay High Court and the other of our Court, and contends that such grant of solatium, is sustainable. In Vakratunda Chintaman Deo v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, Poona(1) the Court was concerned with the evaluation of certain benefits which arose from the land, but which belonged to the interested person. While doing so, they emphatically observed that the compensation so, reckoned as a substitute for the benefits acquired, tantamounts to the determination of the market value of the property. In that view, solatium also was granted. That is not the case here. The ratio in State of Madras v. Balaji Chettiar has no application at all, because there the Court was primarily concerned with the vires of Act 37 of 1950, where under the grant of solatium was abolished. Incidentally, the question which arose before the Division Bench in that case was whether the market value within the meaning of S. 23(1) was intagrated with the solatium awardable under S. 23(2). Their Lordships expressed the view that the two are separable. But the ratio in that case, however, does not touch upon the issue before us as to whether the solatium has to be necessarily granted in a case where damages for injurious affection under Cl. (iv) of S. 23(1) are granted and whether such a grant is a necessary attribute even in the case of grant of damages we have already expressed the view that in cases where damages qua damages are awarded, the question of the interested person gaining solatium as if it is a statutory right, does not at all arise. It is only in cases where the Court determines the market value of the land or the benefits or rights arising thereunder, which in fact is only a substitute for the reckoning of market value of the land, then and in only such circumstances solatium gets integrated with it and can be granted under S. 23(2).

The appeal, therefore, has to be allowed in part.

As regards the memorandum of cross-objections, the learned Counsel for the objector states that the Court below ought to have railed upon Ex. C-1 and granted an increased compensation and ought not to have mechanically confirmed the compensation awarded by the Land Acquisition Officer. In this case, only two sale deeds were noticed and they were only pressed before us by either side in support of their respective contentions. Where as the Learned. Government Pleader would rely upon Ex. R. 16, the cross-objector would place considerable reliance on Ex. C-1. Both are sale deeds relating to sales of developed lands abutting Choolaimedu Road, which in turn abuts the acquired land as well. Under Ex. C-1, a small extent of about half a ground of land was sold and the ultimate price retched thereunder was Rs. 7,777 per ground. Under Ex. R-16, an extent of 1-5/8 grounds of land was sold at the rate of Rs. 4,923 per ground. Ex. R-16 relates to a sale which took place about three months before the date of the notification whereas Ex. C-1.(1) relates to a sale a few days after the notification under S. 4(1). It is no doubt well-settled that a post-notification sale ought not to be lightly brushed aside particularly when the time factor is negligable. It is this aspect that is pressed into service by the learned Counsel for the respondent. But, the land sold under Ex. C-1 abuts not only the Choolaimedu Road, but also another road to its east, viz., the Ganga Amman Koil Street. It is a corner plot. Further, the extent conveyed under Ex. C-1, was only about 1200 sq. ft. All these factors taken into consideration, do Act prompt us to place sole reliance on Ex. C-1, as it cannot be said to be comparable data for fixation of the just compensation in the instant case. The land covered by Ex. R-16 is a land which abuts Choolaimedu Road and is in a developed locality nearer the acquired land and it fetched a price of Rs. 4,923. It may be noticed that the respondent himself has limited his claim in this appeal to Rs. 5,000 per ground. The Court below, after accepting the oral evidence let in before it, had to deduct a sum of Rs. 336 per ground as and towards the expenses or charges which are to be incurred for purposes of raising the acquired lands, which were admitted by the respondent's witnesses to be lower in level than the road-side land. The contention of the learned Counsel for the respondent is that there is no clinching evidence regarding such low level of the acquired land. We do Act agree R.W I. who was examined on the aide of the respondent, himself admitted that the acquired land is in a lower level than the Choolaimedu Road. In contrast thereto, the land covered by Ex. R-16 is said to be on a level with the Choolaimeda Road. This being the factual position, the deduction of Rs. 336 per ground from the totality of the price secured under Ex. R-16, appears to us to be reasonable. The market value as determined by the Court below at Rs. 4,587 per ground represents the fair market value per ground of the land acquired. The cross-objections, therefore, fail and they are dismissed.

In the result, the appeal is allowed in part and the cross-objections are dismissed. But, there will be no order as to costs in either.

V.C.S