Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Murugesan And Others Petitioners-Accused v. Kothandam -Complainant.

Madras High Court
Nov 6, 1969
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent filed a private complaint against the three petitioners under Sections 355 and 341 of the Indian Penal Code (I.P.C.) in respect of an occurrence alleged to have taken place in Tindivanam at about 8:30 p.m. on 3-10-1968. The complaint was filed on 4-10-1968. The Sub-Magistrate noted that the petition disclosed cognisable offences under Ss. 341 and 355, I.P.C., and forwarded the complaint to the Sub-Inspector of Police, Tindivanam, for investigation under Section 156(3), Criminal Procedure Code (Cr.P.C.), and for a report under Section 173(2), Cr.P.C., to be submitted on or before 18-10-1963.

The Sub-Inspector investigated the matter under Chapter 14, Cr.P.C., but did not submit a final report under Section 173, Cr.P.C., to the Sub-Magistrate. The police sent a notice to the respondent on 8-11-1968 stating there was no material to proceed. On the same date (8-11-1968) the respondent filed a second complaint repeating the same allegations. The Sub-Magistrate made various endorsements and returned the complaints with directions that they be re-presented after specified dates (for example, after 18-11-1968 and again after 23-11-1968). The respondent re-presented the complaint on 20-11-1968 and again on 30-11 (dates in the record include 30-11-1963 and 30-11-1988 as recorded in the opinion). On 30-11-1988 the Sub-Magistrate took a sworn statement from the respondent, took the case on file under S.355, I.P.C. against Accused No.1 and under S.341, I.P.C. against Accused Nos.2 and 3, and posted the case for appearance of the petitioners on 10-12-1968.

On summons, the petitioners appeared through their advocate and filed objections on 4-1-1969, contending that the process was not in order because the police report in respect of the first complaint had not been received and the court should not proceed without the police report. The Sub-Magistrate recorded that the Station House Officer had not sent his report but that a refer notice had been served on the complainant and that the issue of summons was in order. Against that order the present petition (filed by the accused/petitioners) seeking quashing of the proceedings was instituted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Magistrate was correct in taking cognisance of the second complaint founded on the same facts without calling for or insisting upon the police report to be submitted under Section 173, Cr.P.C., after having earlier directed investigation under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C.?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Sub-Magistrate's order taking cognisance of the second complaint on the same facts before finally disposing of the first complaint was contrary to law and without jurisdiction.
  • After directing an investigation under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C., the Magistrate was obliged to obtain the police report and apply his mind to the materials disclosed in that investigation before taking further action; instead the Magistrate unlawfully proceeded on the second complaint.
  • The Magistrate should have followed the procedure under Chapter 14 and Section 173, Cr.P.C., and taken appropriate action on the police report in respect of the first complaint.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed the decisive question as whether the Magistrate properly took cognisance of the second complaint without calling for the police report under Section 173, Cr.P.C., given that he had earlier ordered an investigation under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C.

The court stated that, although it was not called upon to decide whether the Magistrate had the power to order investigation before taking cognisance, once the Magistrate exercised his power under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C., and directed the police to submit a report under Section 173, Cr.P.C., he was required to insist upon the submission of that report before taking further action in the matter. The opinion quoted Section 173(1) Cr.P.C. and highlighted the statutory obligation on the officer in charge of the police station to complete the investigation without unnecessary delay and to forward a report to the Magistrate empowered to take cognisance of the offence.

The court explained the elementary purpose of a Section 156(3) inquiry: the Magistrate directs the police to conduct a fuller investigation so that the Magistrate will have sufficient material collected by the investigating officer before taking cognisance. If the Magistrate accepts investigation under Section 156(3) but then proceeds on a second complaint concerning the same facts without first obtaining and considering the Section 173 report, the original direction for investigation would be rendered ineffective.

Relying on these statutory provisions and the logic of the investigative process under Chapter 14, Cr.P.C., the court concluded that the Sub-Magistrate failed to take steps to insist on the police report and that entertaining the second complaint under those circumstances amounted to an abuse of process. The court held that the proper course was for the Magistrate to call for the report under Section 173, Cr.P.C., consider the materials disclosed in that investigation, and then take such action as appropriate — including accepting the police view or differing from it and taking action accordingly.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court quashed the proceedings in C.C. No. 3792 of 1968 pending on the file of the Sub-Magistrate, Tindivanam, and allowed the revision petition.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The proceedings before the Sub-Magistrate in C.C. 3792 of 1968 are set aside. The Sub-Magistrate is directed to call for the report from the police officer who was originally directed to investigate the case and to dispose of the matter according to law after considering that report.
  • The court found that taking cognisance of a second complaint on the same facts without first obtaining and considering the police report under Section 173, Cr.P.C., after directing an investigation under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C., constitutes an abuse of process in the circumstances presented.
  • No broader precedent or new legal principle beyond the application of the statutory scheme (Sections 156(3) and 173 and Chapter 14, Cr.P.C.) is stated in the opinion; the decision resolves the matter between the parties and directs the Sub-Magistrate to follow the statutory procedure.

Disposition: Revision petition allowed; petition allowed. The Sub-Magistrate must call for and consider the police report under Section 173, Cr.P.C., and dispose of the matter according to law.

Show all summary ...

1. This petition has been filed by Accused 1 to 3 in C.C No. 3792 of 1938 on the file of the Sub-Magistrate of Tindivanam, to quash the proceedings before the said Magistrate against them on the ground that the second complaint on which the learned Magistrate had taken cognizance of the case, is not maintainable.

2. The brief facts of the case are these: The respondent filed a private complaint against the three petitioners under Ss. 355 and 341, I.P.C, in respect of an occurrence which took place in Tindivanam at about 8-30 p.m on 3-10-1968. The complaint was filed on 4-10-1968. The learned Sub-Magistrate on the same day noted in the petition of the complainant itself that it disclosed the commission of the offence under Ss. 341 and 355, I.P which were cognisable. He, therefore, forwarded the complaint to the Sub-Inspector of Police, Tindivanam for investigation under S. 156(3), Criminal P.C, and report under S. 173(2), Criminal P.C, on or before 18-10-1963. The-Sub-Inspector, Tindivanam, investigated the case but had not submitted his report under S. 173, Criminal P.C, to the Sub-Magistrate. It appears that the police had sent a notice to the respondent on 8-11-1968 informing him that there was no material to proceed further in the matter. On receipt of this notice, the respondent filed a second complaint making the same allegations found in the earlier complaint on 8-11-1968. The learned Sub-Magistrate asked the Head clerk to put up the R.C.S (referred charge sheet) on the same day. A note was put up that no report was received from the police on the first complaint, on the same day. The learned Sub-Magistrate returned the complaint to the respondent on the ground that no final report from the Sub-Inspector was received in respect of his earlier complaint and directed him to re-present the complaint after 18-11-1968. It appears that no steps were taken to remind the Sub Inspector of Police to send the report. On 20-11-1968, the respondent represented the complaint and again it was returned to the respondent with an endorsement that the final report was not received from the police and the complaint might again be re-presented after 23-11-1968. Even after this, there was no reminder to the police, nor the police had submitted the report. The respondent re-presented again the complaint on 30-11-1963. On 30-11-1988. The Sub-Magistrate took a sworn statement from the respondent and took the case on file under S. 355, I.P.C, against the first petitioner and under S. 341, I.P.C, against petitioners 2 and 3 and posted the case on 10-12-1968 for the appearance of the petitioners. On the summons issued to the petitioners, they appeared through their advocate and filed an objection on 4-1-1969 stating that the process issued to the petitioners was not in order as the report from the police officer was not received in respect of the same complaint and requested the Court not to proceed with the hearing of the case without taking action on the police report to be submitted by them. The sub-Magistrate, on the objection petitions, made the following note:

“The S.H.O (Station House Officer) concerned has not sent in his report so far. The complainant has been served with refer notice and he has filed it with his present complaint. Hence issue of summons to the accused is in order.”

3. Against this order, this petition has been filed.

4. The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the order of the lower Court taking cognisance of the second complaint on the same facts before finally passing an order on the first complaint was contrary to law and without jurisdiction and further submitted that the lower Court should have obtained the report from the police and applied its mind to the materials disclosed in the investigation and taken appropriate action on such a report in respect of the first complaint itself. It was further contended that after having directed the police to investigate the case under S. 156(3), Criminal P.C, the Magistrate must have followed the procedure of taking action under Chap. 14 and as provided under S. 173, Criminal P.C

5. The undisputed facts for the purpose of appreciating the contentions of the learned counsel for the petitioners are these: In respect of the complaint filed by the respondent on 4-10-1968, the Magistrate had directed the Sub-Inspector of Police, Tindivanam, to investigate under S. 156(3), Criminal P.C, and submit a report under S. 173, Criminal P.C The investigation was accordingly done by the Police officer under Chap. 14. Criminal Procedure Code. No final report was submitted under S. 173, Criminal P.C to the Sub-Magistrate. In the meanwhile, a second complaint was filed by the respondent in respect of the same facts alleged in the first complaint and the Magistrate took cognisance of the case after taking sworn statement from the respondent and issued process to the petitioners. The Sub Magistrate had not taken steps to insist upon the report by the police before he took cognisance of the case under the second complaint. Till now, the police have not filed a report under S. 173, Criminal P.C

6. The question, therefore, now is whether the Magistrate was right in taking cognisance of the second complaint on the same facts without calling for the report from the police to be submitted by them under S. 173, Criminal P.C and applying his mind to it to take further action in the matter.

7. We are not concerned with the question whether the Magistrate had power before cognisance of the complaint to direct the police officer to investigate under S. 156(3), Criminal P.C Once the Magistrate exercised his powers under S. 156(3), Criminal P.C, and directed the police to submit a report under S. 173, Criminal P.C the Magistrate should insist upon the police officer for submitting the report under S. 173, Criminal P.C, before taking further action in this matter. The investigation was done by the police under Chap. 14, Criminal P.C, which should ultimately result in the submission of a report under S. 173, Criminal P.C The relevant provision of S. 173, Criminal P.C reads thus:

“(1) Every investigation under this Chapter shall be completed without unnecessary delay, and as soon as it is completed, the officer in charge of the police station shall (a) forward to a Magistrate empowered to take cognisance of the offence, on a police report, a report in the form prescribed by the State Government setting forth the names of the parties, the nature of the information and the names of the persons who appear to be acquainted with the circumstances of the case, and stating whether the accused (if arrested) has been forwarded in the custody, or has been released on his bond, and, if so, whether with or without sureties and (b) communicate, in such manner as may be prescribed by the State Government, the action taken by him to the person, if any, by whom the information relating to the commission of the offence was first given.”

8. It is, therefore, clear that in an investigation done under Chap. 14 of the Criminal P.C as soon as such investigation is completed, the officer in charge of the police station shall submit a report with the particulars mentioned in S. 173(1)(a) to the Magistrate empowered to take cognisance of the offence on a police report under S. 190(b), Criminal P.C The very object of the Magistrate having directed the police officer to investigate the complaint presented to him was to have full details in respect of the allegations made in the complaint to examine the witnesses in the course of such investigation and to do all other things that the Investigating officer is empowered to do, so that the Magistrate before taking cognisance of the case, will have sufficient materials collected in the course of the investigation. Otherwise, the order made by the Magistrate for investigation by the police will have practically no effect at all. The Magistrate must have insisted upon getting a report under S. 173, Criminal P.C, from the police.

9. It is clear from the records that the Magistrate has not at all taken steps to insist upon the Police officer to submit the report. I am of the view that, before the report was submitted, the entertainment of a second complaint in respect of the lame facts which was the subject matter of the investigation by the police, will amount to abuse of process. What the magistrate should have done in this case is that before taking cognisance of the second complaint, he should have insisted upon the police officer for submitting his report under S. 173, Criminal P.C and after obtaining the report, considered the facts disclosed in the investigation and taken necessary action on that report itself. The Magistrate has got discretion, after obtaining the report from the police officer under S. 173, Criminal P.C either to accept the report or if he differs from the report of the police officer, to take appropriate action. It is true, that a notice was served on the complainant by the police officer who was in charge of the investigation and that there was no material to proceed further in the matter and on that the complainant filed the second complaint. So far as the Magistrate is concerned, when he thought fit at the first instance when the first complaint was filed that it should be investigated by the police officer under S. 156(3), Criminal P.C, there is no justification for him to change his mind without calling for a report and looking into it, and take cognisance of the second complaint on the same materials. I, therefore, hold that the cognisance of the second complaint and the issue of process to the revision petitioners, in the circumstances of this case, will amount to abuse of process. I, therefore, quash the proceedings in C.C, 3792 of 1968 pending on the file of the Sub-Magistrate, Tindivanam. The Sub-Magistrate is directed to call for the report from the police officer who was directed to investigate the case and dispose it of according to law.

10. The revision petition is allowed with the above observations.

11. Petition allowed.