Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ponnuswami Udayar And Another v. Santhappa Udayar And Others.

Madras High Court
Apr 6, 1962
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter arises out of O.S. No. 459 of 1944 filed in the District Munsif Court, Sankaridrug, which was a suit for partition and separate possession in respect of properties described in the plaint. During the suit the second plaintiff died. The trial court granted a decree in favour of plaintiffs 1 and 3 for a 3/16ths share in item I of the suit properties and dismissed the suit as to the other items. On appeal (A. S. No. 33 of 1947) the Subordinate Judge, Salem, granted a preliminary decree for partition of a one-tenth share in all the suit items in favour of plaintiffs 1 and 3. This preliminary decree was affirmed by this Court in S. A. No. 1985 of 1958. There were several defendants, some of whom were alienees of portions of the suit properties.

Plaintiffs 1 and 3 then filed I. A. No. 783 of 1954 in the District Munsif Court under Order 20 Rules 12 and 18, Civil Procedure Code, seeking an enquiry and determination of the mesne profits payable to them by the defendants from the date of institution of the suit until delivery of possession and for a final decree after such assessment. Defendants (notably defendants 1, 4, 6 and 7) opposed the application as not maintainable. The District Munsif dismissed the application as not maintainable. The plaintiffs appealed (A. S. No. 59 of 1959) to the Subordinate Judge, who held the application maintainable and remanded for ascertainment of mesne profits. Defendants 1 and 4 challenged that remand order in the present appeal.

It is recorded in the plaint that there was no specific claim for recovery of future mesne profits accruing after the institution of the suit until delivery of possession; that claim was first made in the application (I. A. No. 783 of 1954) which is the subject of the controversy. It is also common ground that the preliminary decree does not contain any direction for an enquiry under Order 20 Rules 12 and 18 regarding future mesne profits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the application filed by the plaintiffs under Order 20 Rules 12 and 18, Civil Procedure Code, for ascertainment of mesne profits (profits accruing from the date of institution of the suit until delivery of possession) is maintainable in a partition suit where the plaint does not specifically pray for such future mesne profits and the preliminary decree is silent on the matter.
  2. Whether, more generally, a court may direct an enquiry into future mesne profits in a partition (or other) suit during the pendency of that suit even when there was no specific prayer for such relief in the plaint and the preliminary decree does not make such a direction.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
B. Basavayya v. B. Guravayya (Full Bench) Establishes that a partition suit remains pending after a preliminary decree; the court may give directions (including for distribution of profits accruing during the suit) suo motu or on application; Order 20 Rule 18 does not prohibit such directions after a preliminary decree; the claim to a share of profits accruing during the pendency of a partition suit is not strictly a "mesne profits" claim to which Order 20 Rule 12 would apply. The Court held that this Full Bench decision governs the present case and strongly supports the proposition that an application for ascertainment of future mesne profits in a partition suit is maintainable while the suit is pending and before final decree.
Md. Amin v. Vakil Ahmed (Supreme Court) The Supreme Court, in that case, affirmed a preliminary decree for partition but deleted an award of mesne profits because there was no demand for mesne profits in the plaint; the Court held the claim for mesne profits could not be included within the expression "awarding possession and occupation ... together with all the rights appertaining thereto". The present Court noted that this Supreme Court decision cast doubts upon the Full Bench view but observed that it is not clear whether the Supreme Court was referring to past or future mesne profits and that the Supreme Court did not refer to the Full Bench decision; therefore the Court declined to treat the Supreme Court decision as necessarily laying down a rule contrary to the Full Bench.
Arunachala Mudali v. Maragathammal (Madras) In an ejectment (recovery of possession) action the Court held an application under Order 20 Rule 12 filed after final decree was misconceived because Order 20 Rule 12 cannot be invoked to revive a suit which had ended; the absence of a specific prayer for future mesne profits in the plaint was indicated as fatal (that observation was obiter). The present Court regarded that decision as inapplicable to the current facts because Arunachala Mudali dealt with a post-termination application in a possession suit (not a partition suit pending before final decree), and the remark about absence of a prayer was obiter in any event.
Rachepalli Achamma v. Yerragunta Rami Reddi (AIR 1958 Andhra Pr.) Held that where a decree awarding possession is silent about enquiry into future mesne profits and the decree did not completely dispose of the suit (i.e., suit remained pending for some purpose), the decree-holder may apply during the pendency of the suit for enquiry into future mesne profits. The present Court cites this Andhra High Court decision as supportive of the proposition that an enquiry for future mesne profits may be permissible while a suit remains pending and before final disposition.
K. Satyanarayana Sastrulu v. K. Mallikarjuna Sastrulu (AIR 1960 Andhra Pr.) Considered an application under Order 20 Rules 12 and 18 in a partition suit and held that the Full Bench decision (B. Basavayya v. B. Guravayya) was unaffected by the Supreme Court decision in Md. Amin; the application for ascertainment of profits since suit could be considered on merits and not rejected merely because the plaint did not pray for such profits. The present Court refers to this authority as confirmatory and persuasive support for treating the Full Bench decision as still good law and for considering applications for future mesne profits in pending partition suits.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds through several interconnected steps, each grounded in authorities and statutory provisions cited in the opinion:

  1. Primary reliance on the Full Bench decision (B. Basavayya v. B. Guravayya): The Court begins by stating that the Full Bench governs the present case. The Full Bench reasoned that a partition suit remains pending after a preliminary decree and that equitable matters (including realisation of common outstandings, discharge of common liabilities and distribution of profits accrued during the suit) must be dealt with before an equitable final partition is effected. The Full Bench also held that Order 20 Rule 18 does not prohibit the Court from issuing directions after a preliminary decree and that a plaintiff's claim to profits accruing during the suit is inherent in the right to obtain the property (and is not strictly a 'mesne profits' claim within the scope of Order 20 Rule 12).
  2. Consideration of the Supreme Court decision (Md. Amin v. Vakil Ahmed): The Court acknowledges that the Supreme Court denied mesne profits where there was no demand in the plaint, thereby casting doubts on the Full Bench's correctness. The present Court carefully examines Md. Amin and notes that the Supreme Court did not refer to the Full Bench and that it is not clear whether the Supreme Court was addressing past mesne profits or future mesne profits. Consequently, the Court declines to construe Md. Amin as necessarily overruling or contradicting the Full Bench.
  3. Distinction from cases dealing with possession suits or post-termination applications: The opinion analyses Arunachala Mudali v. Maragathammal, where an application for mesne profits after final decree in a possession suit was held misconceived. The Court distinguishes that case because it concerned a suit that had ended; in contrast, the present case involves an application made after the preliminary decree but before the final decree in a partition suit, i.e., while the suit remains pending. The Court further notes that observations in Arunachala Mudali about the absence of a specific prayer being fatal were obiter and thus not binding here.
  4. Statutory and equitable considerations about Order 20 Rules 12 and 18: The Court examines the language of Order 20 Rule 12 (which prescribes procedure for suits for recovery of possession and for rents or mesne profits) and acknowledges that a literal reading might exclude recovery of past mesne profits where there is no prayer. However, the Court draws a distinction for future profits: it would be unjust to deprive a successful plaintiff of profits accruing after the date of suit merely because the plaintiff omitted a specific prayer. The Court recognizes judicial discretion to deny such relief where appropriate but holds that the court is not powerless to award future profits in the suit, particularly where plaintiffs have obtained a right to possession.
  5. Reliance on supporting High Court authority: The Court cites decisions of the Andhra High Court (Rachepalli Achamma and K. Satyanarayana Sastrulu) which support the Full Bench position that applications for ascertainment of profits during the pendency of a suit (including partition suits) may be considered even if the plaint did not expressly pray for those profits, so long as the suit has not been finally disposed of.
  6. Synthesis and equity-based conclusion: The Court reasons that in a partition suit the mesne profits accruing from the properties form part of the corpus to be divided and that it would be inequitable and contrary to the policy against multiplicity of proceedings to compel the plaintiff to institute a separate suit for future mesne profits. On these combined legal and equitable grounds, and consistent with the Full Bench and supporting authorities, the Court finds the plaintiffs' application to be maintainable while the partition suit remains pending and before final decree.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed; the application for ascertainment of future mesne profits in the partition suit is maintainable while the suit remains pending and before a final decree, even though the plaint did not specifically pray for such future mesne profits and the preliminary decree is silent on the matter.

Direct consequences and implications stated in the opinion:

  • The specific appeal brought by defendants 1 and 4 fails and is dismissed with costs (i.e., the remand to the trial Court to ascertain mesne profits stands).
  • Practically, plaintiffs' application (I. A. No. 783 of 1954) should be proceeded with in the trial Court for ascertainment of the proper quantum of mesne profits accruing from the date of institution of the suit until delivery of possession.
  • The Court articulates a legal principle (consistent with the Full Bench view and supportive High Court decisions) that in partition suits the courts have jurisdiction to entertain enquiries into profits accruing during the pendency of the suit and to include those profits in the final adjustment, so as to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and to treat such profits as part of the corpus to be divided.

Note on precedent: The opinion recognises conflicting authorities (notably a Supreme Court decision that raised doubts) but concludes that the Full Bench decision remains applicable to the facts of this case and that supporting High Court decisions align with that position. The Court therefore applies the Full Bench principle rather than treating the Supreme Court decision as necessarily inconsistent in this context.


Summary prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion. No information was inferred beyond what appears in the opinion.

Show all summary ...

1. O. S. No. 459 of 1944 on the file of the Court of the District Munsif of Sankaridrug at Salem, was a suit for partition and separate possession of a share in the plaint mentioned properties. The second plaintiff died during the pendency of the suit. The trial court granted a decree in favour of plaintiffs 1 and 3 for 3/16ths share in item I of the suit properties, but dismissed the suit in regard to the other items. On appeal from the said decree in A. S. No. 33 of 1947, on the file of the Court of the Subordinate Judge, Salem, plaintiffs 1 and 3 were granted a preliminary decree for partition of one-tenth share in all the suit items of properties. In S. A. No. 1985 of 1958 this Court affirmed that decree. There were several defendants in the suit, some of whom were alienees of portions of the suit properties.

2. Plaintiffs 1 and 3 filed an application I. A. No. 783 of 1954 in the District Munsif Court, Sankaridrug under Order 20 Rules 12 and 18 Civil Procedure .Code, for an enquiry and determination of the mesne profits payable to them by the defendants from the date of the institution of the suit till the delivery of possession, and to give a final decree after such assessment of mesne profits. This was opposed by defendants 1, 4, 6 and 7 in the suit. The fourth defendant was an alienee from defendants 1 to 3. Defendants 6 and 7 claim to have purchased 3/4th share of the suit properties from the first and the fourth defendants in survey No. 107/3 and 108 of Koneripatti village. These defendants contested the application for ascertainment of mesne profits and for the passing of a final decree for recovery of such profits on the ground that the application was not maintainable. The learned District Munsif upheld the defendants' plea and dismissed the application. The aggrieved plaintiff challenged the correctness of that decision before the Sub Court, Salem in A. S. No. 59 of 1959. The learned Subordinate Judge held that the application was maintainable and remanded the proceedings to the trial Court for ascertainment of the proper quantum of mesne profits due to the plaintiffs. This order of remand is called in question in this appeal by defendants 1 and 4.

3. It must be stated that in the plaint there is no claim for recovery of future mesne profits accruing due after the institution of the suit till the date of delivery of possession of the properties allotted to the share of the plaintiffs under the final decree. The claim is made for the first time in the application, out of which this appeal arises which is essentially an application for the passing of a final decree in a partition suit. In this application, the plaintiff estimates that their share of the net income of the properties would be not less than Rs. 100/- per annum. It is also common ground that no direction for an enquiry under Order 20 Rules 12 and 18 Civil Procedure Code regarding future mesne profits is contained in the preliminary decree in the suit. On these facts the question that arises for consideration is whether the application filed by the plaintiffs in the trial Court is maintainable in law.

4. The Full Bench of this Court in B. Basavayya v. B. Guravayya, (FB) governs the present case. In the Full Bench case, the applications for the passing of a final decree after ascertaining the future mesne profits was filed though there was no specific prayer in the plaint asking for such a relief and though the preliminary decree itself did not expressly provide for it. The objection regarding the maintainability of such an application was overruled by the Full Bench. The view taken was that a suit for a partition does not get terminated by the passing of a preliminary decree but continues and subsists till the final decree is passed and that the equities between the parties should be adjusted and provided for only in the final decree, and that the claim for future mesne profits, namely, the profits arising and accruing after the date of the institution of the suit till the sharer is put in possession of the properties allotted to him or her is inherent on the very right to obtain the properties. The head-note in the Mad LJ report sets out the ratio of the decision as follows :-

"A partition suit in which a preliminary decree has been passed is still a pending suit and the rights of the parties have to be adjusted as on the date of the final decree. The preliminary decree determines only the moieties of the respective parties and there are other matters like the realisation of the common outstandings, the discharge of common liabilities, the distribution of the profits of the properties realised pending the suit etc., which have to be considered and decided before an equitable final partition can be effected. Even after the passing of the preliminary decree it is open to the Court to give appropriate directions regarding all or any of these matters suo motus or on the application of the parties. Order 20 Rule 18 Civil Procedure Code does not prohibit the Court from issuing such directions after the stage of a preliminary decree.

The claim of a plaintiff suing for partition and his share of the profits accruing from the lands pending suit is not, properly speaking, a claim for 'mesne profits' and Order 20 Rule 12 Civil Procedure Code has no application to such a case."

5. The Full Bench summed up the legal position in these terms : -

the Legislature has expressly empowered the court to grant relief for future mesne profits, that is to say, in respect of a cause of action arising subsequent to the suit, there is no reason to circumscribe this power by importing a qualification that there must have been a specific prayer in the plaint for the recovery of such unascertainable and unpredictable profits. Future mesne profits could, we think, well be awarded as part of the general relief to which a plaintiff is entitled."

After this clear and emphatic pronouncement by the Full Bench of this Court that an application for ascertainment of future mesne profits can be filed and maintained so long as the partition suit has not ended in a final decree, there cannot be any doubt that the application, out of which this appeal arises, is one which is completely laid. But in view of a subsequent decision of the Supreme Court in Md. Amin v. Vakil Ahmed, doubts have been cast on the correctness of the decision of the Full Bench of this Court.

6. I shall now refer to the decision of the Supreme Court. In that case, the suit was for partition and separate possession by certain Mohamedan co-sharers. The plaintiffs impugned a settlement deed and claimed a share. The trial court dismissed the suit, but on appeal the Allahabad High Court granted a preliminary decree for partition. The appeal before the Supreme Court was against the preliminary decree. The Supreme Court held that the plaintiffs were entitled to a preliminary decree declaring their shares in the plaint mentioned estate, but denied the plaintiffs' rights to claim mesne profits. The contention on behalf of the appellants before the Supreme Court, taking exception to the award of mesne profits was dealt with as follows at page 1144 (of SCR ) : (at p. 362 of AIR):

"It was however pointed out by Sri S. P. Sinha that the High Court erred in awarding to the plaintiffs mesne profits even though there was no demand for the same in the plaint. The learned Solicitor General appearing for the plaintiffs conceded that there was no demand for mesne profits as such but urged that the claim for mesne profits would be included within the expression 'awarding possession and occupation of the property aforesaid together with all the rights appertaining thereto'. We are afraid that the claim for mesne profits cannot be included within this expression and the High Court was in error in awarding to the plaintiffs mesne profits though they had not been claimed in the plaint. The provision in regard to the mesne profits will therefore have to be deleted from the decree."

7. It is not clear from this passage whether the claim for mesne profits in that case was for past profits prior to the institution of the suit or one for future profits accruing after the suit. The Full Bench decision of this Court has not been referred to by the Supreme Court, and I cannot say that the necessary implication of the view of the Supreme Court is to lay down a rule of law contrary to that decided by the Full Bench.

8. In Arunachala Mudali v. Maragathammal, Rajagopala Aiyangar, J., seems to be inclined to take the view that the principle laid down by the Supreme Court regarding the ascertainment of mesne profits without a specific prayer for it in the plaint is opposed to the Full Bench decision of this Court and that to that extent the value of the Full Bench decision as precedent is undermined. Rajagopala Aiyangar, J., considered the maintainbility of an application for ascertainment of mesne profits in an action, which was pure and simple, one for recovery of possession and not for partition and separate possession. The suit ended in a decree and it was only thereafter that the successful plaintiffs moved the trial Court to hold an enquiry under Order 20 Rule 12 Civil Procedure Code. The learned Judge held that such an application was misconceived and not maintainable as Order 20 Rule 12 Civil Procedure Code cannot be invoked to revive and continue a suit, which had ended. The basis of the decision is that the final termination of the suit without a provision in the decree directing enquiry into future mesne profits from the date of filing of the suit giving the quietus to the lis, so far as that suit is concerned and that the successful party can only execute the decree passed and he cannot have a supplemental decree in recognition of rights, however implicit and intertwined they may be in relation to the decree already obtained by him. The observation of the learned Judge that the absence of a specific prayer in the plaint claiming future mesne profits would be fatal to the maintainability of an application under Order 20 Rule 12 Civil Procedure Code was obiter. The learned Judge observed at page 701 (of Mad LJ) : (at p. 531 of AIR) :

"But in the present case it is unnecessary to pursue the point because the decree in the suit did not award to the plaintiff a relief for future profits."

I do not think that this decision applies to the present case, which is concerned with the maintainability of an application preferred after the proceedings for the preliminary decree, but before the final decree, in a partition action.

9. Can the Court direct an inquiry into future mesne profits under Order 20 Rule 12 Civil Procedure Code in a simple suit for recovery of possession of immoveable properties without a proper prayer in the plaint is a question which is not free from difficulty. The language of Order 20 Rule 12 describes the suit as one for recovery of possession of immovable property and for rent or mesne profits. In referred to already Rajagopala Aiyangar, J., has laid considerable stress on the words of this provision. A strict and literal interpretation of this provision would exclude a suit for recovery of possession alone from its ambit. The plaintiff in a suit for ejectment would be disentitled to claim past mesne profits prior to the institution of the suit if he does not pray for such a relief. It is just possible that he has waived that relief. But the question of future profits wears a different aspect. When the plaintiff succeeds in the action and obtains a decree for recovery of possession, he should not be deprived of the profits accruing from the property after the date of the suit, as he is not to be blamed or held responsible for the duration or pendency of the suit. It seems to me that the words in Order 20 Rule 12 Civil Procedure Code are not so rigid as to prohibit the Court from awarding future profits to the successful plaintiff by the accident of an omission of a specific prayer to that effect in the plaint. Undoubtedly, the Court has got discretion in the matter to negative such a relief to the plaintiff and may direct him to file a separate suit to obtain the relief. But, I am unable to say that the Court is powerless or has no jurisdiction in the matter to award future profits in his suit in which the very prayer of the plaintiff is for recovery of possession. It cannot be said that the defendants will be prejudiced by allowing the plaintiff to recover future profits. The very fact that the plaintiff is held entitled to recover possession only emphasises the wrongful possession of the contesting defendants. The revenue is n6t deprived of court-fee and the plaintiff will be compelled to pay the court-fee at the ad valorem rate after the ascertainment of the quantum of mesne profits.

10. The Andhra High Court has discussed the question of the maintainability of an application for future profits in a case where the relief was not prayed for expressly in the plaint. That is the decision reported in Rachepalli Achamma v. Yerragunta Rami Reddi, AIR 1958 Andh Pra 517. The application under Order 20 Rule 12 was filed in that Court after the passing of the decree for recovery of possession. One of the grounds on which the maintainability of the application was challenged was that there was no provision in the decree directing an enquiry into future mesne profits. A Division Bench consisting of Subba Rao, C. J., as he then was, and Jaganmohan Reddy, J., held that where a decree awarding possession is silent with regard to an enquiry into future mesne profits and the decree did not completely dispose of the suit, which, for one reason or another, was pending, the Civil Procedure Code does not prohibit the decree-holder from applying to the Court during the pendency of such suit for such an enquiry. The Andhra High Court referred also to the decision of Rajagopala Aiyangar, J., in and agreed with that decision holding that no application can be filed after the termination of the suit in a final decree.

11. There is also a recent decision of the Andhra High Court reported in K. Satyanarayana Sastrulu v. K. Mallikarjuna Sastrulu, AIR 1960 Andh Pra 45 dealing with an application under Order 20 Rules 12 and 18 Civil Procedure Code in a partition suit. It is significant to note that the Andhra High Court was of the opinion that the Full Bench decision of this Court cited above has not in any way been shaken or impaired by the decision of the Supreme Court in . The learned Judge observed thus at page 49 :

"From the above observations contained in the decision of the Full Bench in which two Bench decisions of this Court have affirmed to be good law and unaffected by anything contained in the decision of the Supreme Court in Md. Amin's case, , we are of opinion that the application filed by the plaintiffs is entitled to be considered on merits and not to be rejected on the ground that ascertainment of profits since suit has not been asked for in the plaint."

12. I am clearly of opinion that in a partition suit, an application for ascertainment of future mesne profits can be filed so long as the suit is pending and so long as no final decree has been passed even though the plaint does not specifically pray for the granting of such relief and the preliminary decree does not provide for it. The mesne profits accruing from the properties forming the subject-matter of the division and referable to the properties which are eventually allotted to the share of the successful plaintiff, form part and parcel of the corpus itself and are as much in the hotchpot as the lands themselves. It would be most inequitable and unjust to compel the plaintiff to sue separately for future mesne profits, and it is certainly not the policy of the law to encourage multiplicity of proceedings.

13 In the result the appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.