Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Annamalai Goundan v. Venkatasami Naidu And Others.

Madras High Court
Jan 30, 1959
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute arises from lands originally owned by the petitioner, which had been sold to the first respondent and subsequently let back to the petitioner by a lease deed dated 19 November 1952 for a term of two years (expiring 18 November 1954) at an annual rent of Rs. 166. On 2 July 1957 the first respondent (landlord) applied to the Assistant Collector, Hosur, for eviction, alleging rent arrears dating from November 1954. Some payments by the petitioner were admitted up to 25 September 1956, but arrears remained on the date of the eviction application.

The petitioner (tenant) pleaded that after the lease expired he and the landlord executed a registered agreement of sale (said by the court to have been in May 1955; the Assistant Collector's order had incorrectly recorded 24 May 1958). The agreement provided for sale of the leased properties to the petitioner for Rs. 800 to be paid by a fixed date. Consideration passed; the petitioner tendered the balance within the fixed time but the landlord refused to accept it and execute a sale deed. It is admitted that the limitation period for specific performance had not expired when the eviction application was made or when it was ordered.

The Assistant Collector rejected the petitioner's defence that the sale agreement removed his status as tenant, holding that the registered agreement did not create an interest entitling the petitioner to remain in possession and that the petitioner continued to be a tenant liable to eviction under the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act. Shortly after the Assistant Collector's order a suit for specific performance was instituted by the petitioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a person against whom eviction proceedings have been instituted under the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act can resist the eviction by raising a plea based on S.53-A of the Transfer of Property Act (i.e., rely on part-performance of a contract to transfer to claim or retain possession).
  2. Whether the specific conditions required by S.53-A were fulfilled in this case so as to permit the petitioner to rely upon the doctrine of part-performance to resist eviction.
  3. Whether a mere agreement to sell (as opposed to a completed instrument of transfer) can, under S.53-A, give the transferee a right to possession that defeats an application for eviction filed by the vendor under the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented by Mr. T.V. Balakrishnan)

  • S.53-A of the Transfer of Property Act applies and entitles the petitioner to remain in possession and to resist the eviction application — if S.53-A can be relied on in a civil suit for eviction, it should also be available in proceedings under the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act.
  • After the registered agreement for sale, the petitioner's capacity in occupation was not that of a tenant but of an owner holding under an inchoate title; consequently the eviction application under the Madras Act was misconceived because the landlord-tenant relationship had ceased.

First Respondent / Assistant Collector's Position

  • The Assistant Collector held that the registered agreement for conveyance did not create an interest in the land entitling the petitioner to remain in possession and that the petitioner continued to be a tenant even after the lease term expired; therefore the petitioner could not resist eviction under the Madras Act on the basis of the agreement to sell.
  • The first respondent's counsel raised a point (cited in the opinion) that S.53-A might not apply where the instrument relied upon is only an agreement to transfer and not a completed deed of transfer; authorities and S.54 of the Transfer of Property Act were referred to in support of the proposition that a mere contract or even a decree for specific performance does not by itself create title.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ariff v. Jadunath Majumdar (Privy Council) Held, under the pre-1929 law, that a defendant in an ejectment action could not resist eviction merely on the ground that he had a contract for sale of the property. The court noted this decision as a statement of law prior to the introduction of S.53-A and contrasted it with the post-1929 position; Ariff was relied on to show the earlier rule that was changed by the 1929 amendment.
Mian Pir Bux v. Sardar Mahomed Tahar (Privy Council) Reaffirmed the principle (existing before S.53-A) that a contract for sale was not a defence to an ejectment action. The court observed that Mian Pir Bux reaffirmed the pre-amendment position; it was used to illustrate how S.53-A altered the law introduced by the Transfer of Property Amendment Act, 1929.
Enayat Ullah v. Khalil Ullah Cited for the contention that a mere contract to transfer and even a decree for specific performance do not create a right or title in immovable property. The court recorded that this decision was relied on by the first respondent's counsel, but proceeded to explain that the critical inquiry under S.53-A is whether the conditions for part-performance and possession were satisfied so as to give the transferee a right to possession that could resist ejectment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed its analysis around whether the statutory conditions of S.53-A of the Transfer of Property Act were satisfied so that the petitioner could avail himself of the doctrine of part-performance to resist eviction.

The court noted the historical background: prior to the Transfer of Property Amendment Act, 1929, decisions of the Privy Council (Ariff; Mian Pir Bux) denied a defence of contractual sale in ejectment suits. The 1929 amendment, however, introduced S.53-A which, if its conditions are met, allows a transferee to rely upon part-performance to defeat a claim to possession by the transferor.

The text of S.53-A was set out and the court examined each statutory requirement against the facts:

  • The existence of a written contract signed by the transferor from which the terms necessary to constitute the transfer can be ascertained with reasonable certainty — satisfied by the registered agreement for conveyance between the parties.
  • Part performance by the transferee — the petitioner had paid consideration (part performance) and had tendered the balance of the price within the fixed time; the landlord had improperly refused to accept and execute the sale deed.
  • Possession or continued possession in part-performance — at the time of the agreement the lease term had expired and the petitioner remained in possession; the court treated this continuation of possession under the contract as possession in part-performance.
  • Willingness/ability to perform the transferee's part — the petitioner had performed in part and tendered the remainder of the price, demonstrating willingness to perform.

The court rejected the argument that S.53-A could be invoked only where an instrument of transfer (deed) had been executed. It emphasized the statutory language of S.53-A that expressly contemplates contracts to transfer and part-performance, and observed that no authority had been cited to require a deed of transfer prior to invoking S.53-A.

Crucially, the court reasoned that once possession is taken or continued under a contract of sale, the original landlord-tenant relationship ceases to exist. Because the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act permits eviction proceedings only where the landlord-tenant relationship subsists both when the cause of action arises and when the application is made, a person who has part-performance and possession under a contract of sale is no longer a tenant for purposes of a Madras Act eviction application.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court concluded that the conditions of S.53-A were fulfilled and therefore the Assistant Collector's conclusion that the petitioner remained a tenant liable to eviction under the Madras Act was erroneous.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court set aside the Assistant Collector's order and dismissed the eviction application filed by the first respondent. The court expressly held that the conditions laid down in S.53-A of the Transfer of Property Act were satisfied in this case and that, therefore, the petitioner could resist the eviction application.

Core Ruling: The order of the Assistant Collector is set aside and the eviction application is dismissed.

Direct implications and consequences:

  • The petitioner remains in possession as against the eviction application and is entitled to costs; the court directed that the petitioner receive costs from the first respondent.
  • The Assistant Collector's finding that the petitioner continued to be a tenant for the purposes of the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act was overturned because the court found the landlord-tenant relationship had ceased upon part-performance and possession under the contract of sale.

The opinion focuses on the statutory application of S.53-A and its effect on the factual landlord-tenant relationship; it does not purport to lay down broader, novel precedents beyond applying S.53-A to the circumstances of this case.

V.C.S
Show all summary ...

This civil revision petition raises an interesting question of law, namely, whether it is open to a person, against whom proceedings have been instituted for eviction under the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act, to raise a plea based upon S. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, for resisting the application.

The first respondent herein is the owner of lands which were let to the petitioner by a lease deed dated 19th November 1952. The term in the lease deed was for a period of two years and it expired on 18th November 1954. The annual rent agreed upon was a sum of Rs. 166. The Assistant Collector, Hosur, against whose order this revision petition is filed, entertained an application for eviction at the instance of the first respondent on 2nd July 1957. The allegation made in the petition by the landlord-first respondent was that the petitioner had f alien into arrears in the matter of payment of rent since November 1954. Some amounts had been admittedly paid upto 25th September 1956; but it was not disputed that on the date of the application for eviction there were arrears of rent payable by the petitioner.

The defence set up by the tenant-first petitioner was that some time after the expiry of the lease period, that is to say, in May 1955 (the date 24th May 1958 given by the Assistant Collector in his order being incorrect), a registered agreement was entered into between the parties, namely, the first respondent to the application for eviction and the landlord the petitioner therein whereby the landlord agreed to sell leased properties to the petitioner herein for a sum of Rs. 800 to be paid within an agreed date. It is not disputed that consideration passed for this agreement and the landlord did not dispute the execntion of this agreement. It is further admitted that, within the date fixed for execution of the sale deed, the petitioner, in whose favour the agreement of sale was executed, had tendered the balance of price due to the landlord, who improperly refused to accept the amount and execute the sale deed. It is also common ground that the period of limitation for enforcing the contract by specific performance had not expired either on the date when the application for eviction was preferred or on the date when it was ordered.

The contention put forward before the Assistant Collector was that, after the execution of the registered agreement for conveyance of the property, the petitioner no longer remained in possession as tenant and therefore the application for eviction was not maintainable. The Assistant Collector rejected this argument on the ground that the registered agreement for conveyance did not create an interest in the lands which entitled the petitioner to remain in possession. He further held that he continued to be tenant of the property, even though the term of the lease had expired and it was not competent for him to resist the application for eviction on the ground that he had acquired a new right for possession of the property under the agreement for conveyance.

It may be mentioned that the lands which are the subject of dispute originally belonged to the petitioner, who had sold them to the landlord sometime before, or almost contemporaneously with, the datejwhen the lease deed in favour of the petitioners was executed. Shortly after the order for eviction was passed by the Assistant Collector a suit for specific performance had been instituted by the first petitioner for getting a conveyance of the suit lands from the first respondent.

Mr. T.V Balakrishnan, learned Counsel for the petitioner, raised two points. First, he argued that S. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act would apply to the facts of this case and would clothe the petitioner with the light to remain in possession and to resist the application for eviction brought at the instance of the landlord. According to him, if a civil suit for eviction had been brought against the petitioner and he could resist such a suit relying upon S. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, a fortiori such a plea must be open to a tenant in a proceeding for eviction instituted under the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act. The second point was that the application for eviction under the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act was misconceived, because, after the date of the agreement for sale, the capacity in which the petitioner occupied the land was not that of a tenant, but of an owner under an inchoate title.

The first question for determination is whether the conditions laid down in S. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act have been fulfilled to enable the petitioner to rely upon the doctrine of part-performance. It is true that before S. 53-A was introduced by the Transfer of Property Amendment Act of 1929, the law in this country did not enable the defendant in an action for ejectment to resist the action merely on the ground that he had obtained a contract for sale of the property. The decision of the Privy Council in Ariff v. Jadunath Majumdar (1), which laid down this proposition, has been re-affiirmed by the Privy Council in Mian Pir Bux v. Sardar Mahomed Tahar (2). But both these decisions dealt with the law as it stood before the Amendment of 1929. After the amendment of the Transfer of Property Act in 1929, which introduced S. 53-A a defendant in a suit for ejectment is entitled to rely upon his contract for transfer, provided the conditions mentioned in that section are fulfilled. A point was raised by the learned Counsel for the first respondent whether S. 53-A would apply to a case where the instrument in question relied upon by the defendant was only an agreement or contract to transfer and not an inchoate deed of transfer. S. 53-A so far as it is relevant reads as follows:

“Where any person contracts to transfer for consideration any immoveable property by writing signed by him or on his behalf from which the terms necessary to constitute the transfer can be ascertained with reasonable certainty,

and the transferee has, in part performance of the contract, taken possession of the property or any part thereof, or the transferee being already in possession, continues in possession in part-performance of the contract and has done some act in furtherance of the contract,

and the transferee has performed or is willing to perform his part of the contract.

then, notwithstanding that the contract, though required to be registered, has not been registered, or, where there is an instrument of trans or, that the transfer has not been completed in the manner prescribed therefor by the law for the time being in force, the transferor, or any person claiming under him shall be debarred from enforcing against the transferee and persons claiming under him any right in respect of the property of which the transferee has taken or continued in poseession, other than a right expressly provided by the terms of the contract;”

Learned Counsel for the first respondent contended that a mere contract to transfer immoveable property and eyen a decree for specific performance of such a contract would not create any right or title in the property and he referred to S. 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, and to the decision in Enayat Ullah v. Khalil Ullah (3), as authorities for this contention. The point for decision is not whether the agreement to sell obtained by the petitioner in this case creates an interest in the immoveable property, but whether it creates a right in him to possession of the property for resisting the claim for ejectment made by the landlord first respondent. If the conditions stipulated in S. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act are fulfilled, it cannot be denied that the landlord woujd fee helpless in a civil Court if herresorted to that Court for evicting the petitioners. There is no dispute that the contract for sale had beenperformed in part in this case aad that it is supported by consideration. The other requirement whether the petitioner was allowed to continue in possesssion of the property in part-performance of the contract is not also in doubt, because, at the time when the contract of sale was entered into, the term of the lease has expired and the landlord was free to enforce his claim for possession, subject of course, to the provisions of the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act. It is obvious that, till the contract of sale was entered into, the petitioner only occupied the position of lessee. But, after the date of the contract and after it was performed in part by consideration being paid for the contract and the landlord allowing the tenant to remain in possession by reason of the new status created under the contract, it was no longer open to the landlord to contend that the right of possession claimed by the petitioner was referable to the contract of lease. There can be no doubt in this case that the conditions laid down in S. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act are fulfilled even though a contract to sell alone was obtained. No authority was cited for the contention that a deed of transfer should have been obtained by petitioners before they could invoke S. 53-A. Indeed the very language of the section is against such a contention. The question whether this defence would be open in a proceeding f or eviction under the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act is really beside the point, because, the moment possession is taken or continued under the contract of sale, the original relationship of landlord and tenant ceases to exist and the landlord cannot take advantage of the provisions of the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act to file an application for eviction. The Assistant Collector was therefore wrong when he held that the petitioner was a tenant of the first respondent liable to be evicted under the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act. It is manifest that, before any proceeding for eviction could be taken under the Madras Cultivating Tenants Protection Act, the relationship of landlord and tenant must subsist both on the date when the cause of action arose and when the application was made. On the plea raised by the petitioner in this case, I hold that the relationship of landlord and tenant ceased to exist when the contract of sale was entered into and was performed in part.

The order of the Assistant Collector, Hosur, is therefore set aside, and the application for eviction filed by the first respondent is dismissed. The petitioner will get his costs from the first respondent.

V.C.S