- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramaswami Goundar v. Muthuvel Goundar And Another.
Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal was brought by Ramaswami Goundar, a judgment-debtor in O.S. No. 244 of 1949 before the District Munsif, Dindigul, against the judgment and decree of the Subordinate Judge, Dindigul, in C.M.A. No. 6 of 1953. The Subordinate Judge had reversed the District Munsif's order in E.A. No. 222 of 1952 (in E.P. No. 381 of 1951 arising out of O.S. No. 244 of 1949), which had allowed an application by the appellant under Order 21, Rule 90 and Section 47, Civil Procedure Code, and had set aside a sale held on 2 January 1952 of two kulis and odd of the appellant's land that had been charged with maintenance of Rs. 60 per year in favour of his step-mother, Savadammal (the decree-holder).
Background facts as stated in the opinion:
- In O.S. No. 244 of 1949, Savadammal obtained a maintenance decree for Rs. 5 per month against the appellant, with the amount charged on a house site and two kulis and odd of land (valued in the plaint at Rs. 350 but said to be worth much more). She was permitted to put up a shed on the charged site and reside there.
- The appellant did not pay the maintenance; execution proceedings (E.P. No. 381 of 1951) were instituted to recover arrears (Rs. 137-6-0 by that time). The land was brought to sale.
- The appellant alleged that the sale notice under Order 21, Rule 66 was not served on him, that a false endorsement of refusal was procured with the process-server's aid, and that the tom-tom proclamation was not done; consequently he did not know of the sale. Only one bidder (Muthuvel, a relative of Savadammal and the eventual auction-purchaser) bid at the court sale. The court's amin valued the land at Rs. 950 and Muthuvel bid just one rupee above the upset price; the appellant contended the true market value was around Rs. 3,500–4,000.
- The sale was confirmed and delivery was ordered to Muthuvel. The appellant discovered the sale at the time of delivery on 1 April 1952 and filed an application under Order 21, Rule 90 and Section 47, Civil Procedure Code, to set aside the sale on grounds of fraud in publishing and conducting the sale.
- The District Munsif set aside the sale on findings of false return of service, lack of tom-toming, conspiracy between the decree-holder and the auction-purchaser, and material irregularity causing substantial injury (also holding the petition was within thirty days of discovery of fraud). The Subordinate Judge on appeal reversed that order, finding insufficiency of proof of material irregularity or substantial injury and treating the sale price (Rs. 951) as not unduly low given prior purchase for Rs. 900 and the existence of the maintenance charge.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the sale conducted under Order 21, Rule 66, Civil Procedure Code, should be set aside on the grounds of fraud, defective service of the sale notice and lack of tom-toming, pursuant to Order 21, Rule 90 and Section 47, Civil Procedure Code.
- Whether a Second Appeal lies in a case where the petition to set aside a sale alleges defect in service under Order 21, Rule 66 and invokes Section 47, Civil Procedure Code.
- Whether the alleged procedural irregularities caused material irregularity and substantial injury sufficient to set aside the sale.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (Ramaswami Goundar)
- The notice of sale under Order 21, Rule 66 was not served on him; a false endorsement of refusal was procured by the decree-holder and auction-purchaser with the aid of the process-server.
- The tom-tom prosecution/proclamation (public announcement) was not done, so he was unaware the property was being sold; therefore the sale was conducted by fraud.
- The amin's valuation (Rs. 950) was artificially low and the property was actually worth around Rs. 3,500 to Rs. 4,000, so the sale was for a very low price and caused substantial loss.
- He filed the petition promptly upon discovering the sale at the time of delivery (1 April 1952), and limitation should not bar his application because it was within thirty days of discovery.
Auction-Purchaser / Respondent's Position (Muthuvel Goundar and supporting counsel)
- The sufficiency of service of the sale notice was not proved by the appellant, and the process-server may have gone to the village (the Subordinate Judge entertained that possibility).
- The sale price (Rs. 951) could not be said to be unduly low or to have caused substantial injury, especially given that the land had previously been bought by the appellant for Rs. 900 and that the sale was subject to a maintenance charge which, when capitalized, reduced the effective loss to the purchaser.
- A preliminary objection was raised that no Second Appeal lay, but that objection was not pressed after the High Court's review of the authorities.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Venkataswami v. Nagayya, A.I.R. 1925 Mad. 1142 | Held that where there is a defect in service of a sale notice under Order 21, Rule 66 and the petition to set aside the sale relies on it and invokes Section 47, Civil Procedure Code, a Second Appeal will lie. | The court relied on this authority to conclude that a Second Appeal was maintainable in the present kind of case; after reference to this ruling the preliminary objection as to jurisdiction was not persisted in by counsel for the auction-purchaser. |
| Viswanatha v. Murugappan, A.I.R. 1935 Mad. 438 | Same principle: recognition that Second Appeal lies when defective service under Order 21, Rule 66 is relied upon together with Section 47. | The court cited this authority alongside others to support its conclusion on the availability of a Second Appeal. |
| Meyyappan v. Sellappa, A.I.R. 1930 Mad. 489 | Bench decision affirming that a Second Appeal will lie in cases where the petition relies on defect in service of sale notice under Order 21, Rule 66 together with Section 47. | Used by the court to reinforce the proposition that a Second Appeal was properly entertained in the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court reviewed the record and the evidence, and then summarized the positions and findings of the two lower courts before giving its own analysis:
- Jurisdictional preliminary issue: The court considered the objection that no Second Appeal lay. It examined the cited authorities (Venkataswami v. Nagayya; Viswanatha v. Murugappan; Meyyappan v. Sellappa) and held that a Second Appeal would lie in cases where a petition to set aside a sale relies on defect in service under Order 21, Rule 66 together with Section 47. After this consideration the respondent's counsel did not persist in his jurisdictional objection.
- Assessment of evidence on service and tom-toming: The court noted the conflicting evidence. The District Munsif had found that the return of service indicating refusal was false and that tom-toming (public proclamation) had not been effectively done, relying in part on admissions and the prevaricating evidence of the process-server and attestor. The Subordinate Judge, on appeal, accepted some parts of the process-server's evidence and concluded there had been tom-toming and was not prepared to say the process-server had not gone to the village at all.
- Credibility and contradictions: The High Court observed that the contradictory evidence could sustain either view, but explicitly found "there is little doubt" that the appellant was not shown the sale notice and did not refuse it, and that he remained unaware of the sale until delivery on 1 April 1952. The court commented on the contradictory testimony of Suppan Madari (P.W. 3), who supported aspects of both sides' accounts in different portions of his evidence.
- Valuation and effective price: The court took account of market appreciation and the maintenance charge attached to the land (Rs. 60 per year). It capitalized that maintenance charge at Rs. 1,200 and treated it as reducing the effective consideration paid by the auction-purchaser. Thus, although the cash bid was Rs. 951 (and appellant had previously paid Rs. 900), the court computed the auction-purchaser's real price as Rs. 2,151 (i.e., Rs. 951 plus the capitalized maintenance charge of Rs. 1,200), which diminished the force of the argument that the sale was for a mere song.
- Equitable intervention: Despite noting that aspects of the lower appellate court's conclusion could be supported on portions of the evidence, the High Court found there were sufficient circumstances to warrant interference and to pass an equitable order balancing both parties' interests rather than wholly affirming the lower appellate judgment.
- Directions and conditions for setting aside the sale: The High Court outlined a conditional, equitable remedy. It directed the appellant to deposit specified sums into the District Munsif's Court, Dindigul, by 3 p.m. on 15 July 1958 — consolidated costs of Rs. 75 to be paid to the auction-purchaser, Rs. 20 as maintenance due before 1 April 1952, and applicable sale-warrant/bid amounts (with qualifications depending on whether such amounts had already been withdrawn). Upon deposit of those sums by the date fixed, the court directed that the sale be set aside and the land delivered back to the appellant, subject to a maintenance charge of Rs. 60 per year from 15 July 1958 onwards, and with no claim for past mesne profits up to that date.
- Contingent confirmation of lower appellate order: The court made clear that if the appellant failed to comply with the deposit directions by the stipulated date, the Subordinate Judge's order (which had allowed the appeal and set aside the District Munsif's order) would stand confirmed and the present C.M.S.A. would be dismissed without costs.
- Ancillary factual matters noted: The court observed uncertainty in the record as to whether the appellant or others had withdrawn the sale-warrant amount deposited by Muthuvel or whether the appellant had withdrawn any sale-warrant deposit he had made when presenting his petition. The court also indicated that income from the lands could be offset against maintenance due, obviating an immediate mesne profits enquiry until re-delivery under the decree.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court set aside the sale conditional upon the appellant depositing specified sums in the District Munsif's Court, Dindigul, by 3 p.m. on 15 July 1958; otherwise the appeal would be dismissed and the lower appellate order confirmed.
Specific orders and immediate effects:
- If the appellant deposited by the stipulated date: the sale (held on 2 January 1952 and delivered to Muthuvel on 1 April 1952) would be set aside and the land delivered back to the appellant, but charged with Savadammal's maintenance of Rs. 60 per year from 15 July 1958 onwards.
- No mesne profits would be recoverable up to 15 July 1958 (i.e., no enquiry or award of past mesne profits up to that date), and the income from the lands could be set off against maintenance accruing from 1 April 1952.
- If the appellant failed to deposit the amounts by 15 July 1958: the Subordinate Judge's order allowing the auction-purchaser's appeal would be confirmed and this C.M.S.A. would be dismissed without costs.
- Administrative detail: If the sale-warrant/bid amounts of the auction-purchaser were still lying in the lower Court, the appellant need not deposit those amounts and the parties who had a right to withdraw them could do so; similarly, the court left open whether certain deposits already made had been withdrawn (noting that the record did not make this clear).
Broader implications:
The court applied and affirmed the existing authorities that a Second Appeal lies in cases where defect in service under Order 21, Rule 66 is alleged together with reliance on Section 47, Civil Procedure Code. Beyond providing an equitable remedy in the circumstances of this case, the opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent altering substantive law; it modifies the lower courts' outcomes in light of its findings on service, discovery of fraud, valuation adjustments for the maintenance charge, and the equities between the parties.
1. This is an appeal by one Ramaswami Goundar, a judgment-debtor in O.S. No. 244 of 1949 on the file of the District Munsif, Dindigul, against the judgment and decree of the Subordinate Judge, Dindigul, in C.M.A. No. 6 of 1953 re versing the order of the District Munsif, Dindigul, in E.A. No. 222 of 1952, in E.P. No. 381 of 1951, in O.S. No. 244 of 1949, allowing an application of this appellant under Order 21, Rule 90 and Section 47, Civil Procedure Code and setting aside the sale held on 2nd January, 1952, of two kulis and odd of land belonging to the appellant, and charged with a maintenance of Rs. 60 per year, in favour of his setp-mother Savadammal, the decree-holder. The facts were briefly these.
2. In O.S. No. 244 of 1949, Savadammal got a maintenance decree for Rs. 5 per month against this appellant, and that amount was charged on a house site and two kulis and odd of land valued in the plaint at Rs. 350, but really worth much more. Savadammal was also allowed to put up a shed on the vacant site and reside therein. That is the house site charged -'with the maintenance. She was also allowed to recover Rs. 70-13-0 as the consolidated costs from an amount in Court. The appellant did not pay the maintenance amount. So Savadammal, aided by her relative, the present auction-purchaser Muthuvel Goundar, took steps, and E.P. No. 381 of 1951 was filed for recovering the arrears of Rs. 137-6-0 due by then. The two kulis and odd of lands were brought to sale. The notice under Order 21, Rule 66, Civil Procedure Code, was, according to the appellant, not served on him and a false endorsement that he refused the notice was procured by Savadammal and Muthuvel with the aid of the process-server. The tom-tom too was not done. The result was that the appellant did not know that his properties were being brought to sale and actually only one bidder bid at the Courtsale, namely, Muthuvel, the relative of Savadammal, and the man who had attested the false endorsement of refusal of the notice under Order 21, Rule 66. I may mention here that the appellant's contention was that the property brought to sale was worth Rs. 4,000 and was got by Savadammal and Muthuvel falsely valued at - Rs. 950 by an amin sent by Court. Muthuvel was the only bidder, and he bid for just a rupee above the upset price fixed by the Court on the amin's valuation. The sale was knocked down in Muthuvel's name, and Muthuvel obtained an order for delivery. It is at this stage of delivery, on 1st April, 1952, to Muthuvel, that the appellant says he came to know of the sale of his land. He therefore filed an application under Order 21, Rule 90 and Section 47, Civil Procedure Code, for setting aside the sale on the ground of fraud in publishing and conducting the sale.
3. The learned District Munsif, Dindigul, after discussing the prevaricatory evidence of the process-server and the attestor, of the alleged refusal of sale notice by the appellant, held that the alleged refusal was false," and that the notice was not really tendered to, or refused by, the appellant. Discussing the contradictory evidence regarding the tom-toming, and acting on the admission of Suppan Madari,. P.W. 3, that he did not really do any tom-toming, he held that there was no proclamation of sale by tom-tom also. He also held that the auction-purchaser Muthuvel and the plaintiff Savadammal had conspired together with the process-server and others and procured false return of the refusal of the sale notice, and effectively kept the appellant from knowledge of the sale. He held further that the lands sold for Rs. 951 would be worth at least Rs. 3,500, as stated by the karnam, and possibly Rs. 4,000 as stated by the village munsif and the appellant himself. So, he held that there were material irregularities resulting in substantial injury, and set aside the sale. He held that limitation would not operate, as the petition had been made within thirty days of the date of the discovery of the fraud. So he allowed the petition with costs.
4. The auction-purchaser Muthuvel took the matter on Appeal. The Subordinate Judge, Dindigul, held after once again discussing the evidence; that the sufficiency of the service of the sale notice on the appellant was not proved, though he was not prepared to say that the process-server had not gone to the village at all. Discussing again the contradictory evidence of Suppan Madari, P.W. 3, regarding the tom-tom, he considered that there was tom-toming believing one portion of that man's evidence. He was also of opinion that as the land sold had been bought by the appellant himself for Rs. 900, its sale for Rs. 951 to the auction-purchaser Muthuvel could not be said to be for a low price or to have caused any substantial injury. Finally, he held that there was no adequate proof of material irregularity or substantial injury consequent on it, and allowed the appeal with costs throughout, setting aside the orders of the learned District Munsif. Hence this C.M.S.A.
5. I have perused the records, and heard the learned Counsel on both sides. Mr. K.S. Naidu, for the appellant, and Mr. V.C. Veeraraghavan for the auction-purchaser, argued the case fully and fairly. It is obvious that, in the light of the contradictory evidence, the conclusions of both the District Munsif, one way, and of the Subordinate Judge, the opposite way, can be supported on portions of the evidence. Suppan Madari, P.W. 3, supports the appellant's case in chief-examination, and the auction-purchaser's case in parts of the cross-examination. The fact also remains that, though the lands were sold, for Rs. 951 and had been bought for Rs. 900, there had been great appreciation of land values since the purchase. Against that must be set the fact that the sale to the auction-purchaser was subject to the maintenance charge of Rs. 60 per year in favour of Savadammal. That maintenance charge must be held to amount to a capitalised sum of Rs. 1,200. So the real price paid by the auction-purchaser Muthuvel was Rs. 2,151. This will take away much of the force of the argument of Mr. Naidu that the land was sold for a song. Still, there are circumstances enough to enable me to interfere with the judgment and decree of the lower appellate Court., and pass in its stead an order equitable to both sides.
6. Before doing that, I shall deal with the preliminary objection of Mr. V. C. Veeraraghavan that no Second, Appeal would lie in this case. The argument cannot be sustained. As Mr. K. S. Naidu rightly pointed out, wherever there is a defect in the service of a sale notice under Order 21, Rule 66, Civil Procedure Code and the petition for setting aside the sale relies on it also and puts in Section 47, Civil Procedure Code, a Second Appeal will lie, as held by single Judges of this Court in Venkataswami v. Nagayya A.I.R. 1925 Mad. 1142 and Viswanatha v. Murugappan A.I.R. 1935 Mad. 438, and by a Bench of this Court in Meyyappan v. Sellappa A.I.R. 1930 Mad. 489.. It is clear to me that a Second Appeal would lie in cases like these, and, after seeing the above rulings, Mr. Veeraraghavan also does not persist in his contentions.
7. Now we come to the merits of the case. In my opinion the appellant was not willing to pay any maintenance to the respondent till the Execution Petition was filed, despite repeated requests and demands. He thought he could twist his fingers at the widow, Savadammal and forget that Savadammal had a formidable ally in the auction-purchaser Muthuvel. Muthuvel was more than a match for the appellant. There is little doubt in my mind that the appellant was not really shown the sale notice under Order 21, Rule 66, Civil Procedure Code and did not refuse it, and was not aware of the sale of his lands till 1st April, 1952, when the lands were delivered to Muthuvel. Then he rushed with the petition under Order 21, rule go, Civil Procedure Code, depositing the sale warrant amount in Court in lieu of security. It is not known whether he has withdrawn the sale warrant amount so deposited. Mr. Naidu was not able to give me definite information about this, nor is it known whether the Rs. 951 put into Court by Muthuvel has been with- ' drawn by the appellant or others. It is also clear that besides the sale warrant amount, the appellant had to pay Rs. 20 more to Savadammal for maintenance at Rs. 5 per month, till 1st April, 1952, the date of delivery. I think that the income from the lands can be easily set off against the maintenance amount of Rs. 60 due to Savadammal every year from 1st April, 1952. So there is no need for any mesne profits enquiry till the date of re-delivery to the appellant by me under this decree. I direct the appellant to deposit into the District Munsifs Court, Dindigul, by 3 p.m., on 15th July, 1958, Rs. 75 as consolidated costs in all the Courts to be paid to the auction-purchaser, Muthuvel, another Rs. 20 as maintenance due to Savadammal before 1st April, 1952 and not covered by the sale warrant amount, and the sale warrant amount, if withdrawn by the appellant, and the Rs. 951 deposited by Muthuvel towards his bid, if withdrawn by, the appellant. On all these sums 'being deposited by the said date, I direct the sale to be set aside, and the land delivered back to the appellant, charged with Savadammal's maintenance amount of Rs. 60 from 15th July, 1958, onwards and with no right for past mense profits till 15th July, 1958. If the sale warrant amounts of the bid amount of Muthuvel are still lying in the lower Court, the appellant need not deposit those amounts, and Savadammal and Muthuvel can draw back those amounts. If the appellant fails to deposit the amount as directed above, by 15th July, 1958, the order of the lower appellate Court will stand confirmed, and this C.M.S.A. will stand dismissed without costs. The appellant is free to deposit the above amounts less amounts in Court earlier than 15th July, 1958, as requested by Mr. Naidu, in which case the lands will be delivered back to him earlier, but the maintenance charge will also attach to the lands from the date of the earlier delivery.
Section 47, Civil Procedure Code,Alert