Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kelloth Ibrahim Haji, In Re.

Madras High Court
Sep 13, 1956
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit in question is for partition and separate possession of the plaintiff's share in certain properties originally belonging to one Moideenkutti, who died about 20 years prior. The plaintiff claims a share by assignment from some legal representatives of Moideenkutti. Defendants 8, 10, and 11 also claim shares through assignments from other legal representatives. Due to disputes regarding the shares, devolution of rights, and the original partition, these defendants filed an application (R.I.A. No. 517 of 1956) in the lower court seeking to implead the assignors as parties. The plaintiff resisted, arguing that the assignors have no subsisting rights and that impleading them would cause unnecessary complications, delay, and expense. The District Munsif of Badagara made an order on this application, which is now challenged by this Civil Revision Petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court can order the addition of parties (assignors) who have no subsisting rights over the property in a partition suit under Order I, Rule 10(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. Whether the plaintiff can be compelled to implead persons to safeguard the rights of the defendants when such persons have only indirect or remote interest.
  3. Whether the third party procedure under Order VIII-A of the Code of Civil Procedure can be invoked to add parties in the present circumstances.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants' Arguments

  • The assignors of the defendants should be impleaded as parties because there is a keen dispute regarding shares, devolution of rights, and the original partition.
  • The presence of these assignors is necessary to fully adjudicate and settle all questions involved in the suit.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The assignors have no subsisting rights over the properties and cannot be compelled to be impleaded.
  • Impleading such persons would cause unnecessary complications, delay, and expense.
  • The plaintiff cannot be compelled to add parties solely to safeguard the rights of defendants; such matters should be pursued separately if necessary.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kalian Rai v. Ram Ratan, ILR 18 All 306 (A) Limitation on adding parties with only indirect or remote interest under Order I, Rule 10(2) CPC. Used to emphasize that courts should not add parties with indirect interest or unrelated claims to avoid complicating the suit.
Joy Cobind v. Gouree Proshad, 7 Suth WR 201 (13) Requirement of identity or community of interest for addition of parties. Supported the principle that a person can only be added if questions arise directly and incidentally relating to the original cause of action.
Naraini Kuar v. Durjan Kuar, ILR 2 All 738 (C) Community of interest necessary for addition of parties. Reinforced that only parties with direct interest should be added.
Mahomed Badsha v. Nicol, ILR 4 Cal 355 (D) Community of interest and necessity for addition of parties. Supported the restrictive approach to adding parties.
Vithobe v. Secretary of State, AIR 1925 Nag 373 (E) Plaintiff as dominus litis and protection against addition of defendants against plaintiff's will. Held that no defendant should be added against plaintiff’s will even if defendant’s interests are affected.
Vaithilinga Pandara Sannadhi v. Sadasiva Iyer, AIR 1926 Mad 838 (F) Addition only if party is necessary, not merely proper or permissible. Confirmed that addition cannot be ordered if objected to by plaintiff and party is not necessary.
Sitaramayya v. Ramappayya, 5 Mad LW 207; AIR 1918 Mad 1137 (G) Meaning of "questions involved in the suit" limited to parties involved. Clarified that only questions between parties to the suit are relevant for addition.
Palanisamy v. Komara Chettiar (H) Necessity of presence of proposed parties for adjudication. Order for addition should not be made merely to avoid multiplicity of suits.
Gosto Behari v. Sur's Estate Ltd., ILR (1946) 1 Cal 656 (I) General principles on addition of parties. Reinforced the need for necessity in adding parties.
Virbhadrappa v. Snekabai, AIR 1939 Bom 188; ILR 1939 Bom 232 (J) Principles relating to addition of parties and avoiding unnecessary complications. Supported restrictive approach in party addition.
Moser v. Marsden, (1892) 1 Ch 487 (K) General principles on party addition. Referenced for guidance on discretion in adding parties.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the provisions of Order I, Rule 10(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, which grants wide discretion to add or strike out parties but is limited by two conditions: (1) the person must have been originally impleadable under Order I, Rule 1 or Rule 3 CPC; and (2) their presence must be necessary to effectually and completely adjudicate all questions involved in the suit. The court emphasized that discretion must be exercised reasonably to avoid inconvenience or embarrassment, and parties with only indirect or remote interests should not be added. The cited precedents reinforce that the plaintiff, as dominus litis, generally controls the parties in the suit and that addition against the plaintiff’s will is not favored unless overriding considerations exist.

Applying these principles, the court found the persons sought to be impleaded have no subsisting rights and are proposed to be added only to facilitate their evidence, which is insufficient. The court also noted that the petitioners’ concern about having to file a separate suit is not a sufficient ground to compel addition. Furthermore, the court clarified that third party procedure under Order VIII-A CPC applies only upon proper application, which was not made here.

Holding and Implications

The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is that the order of the District Munsif refusing to implead the assignors as parties stands affirmed. The persons without subsisting rights will not be added to the suit. No new precedent is set; the ruling adheres to established principles limiting party addition to necessary and proper cases, respecting the plaintiff’s control over the suit’s parties.

Show all summary ...

1. This is a Civil Revision Petition sought to be preferred against the order made by the learned District Munsif of Badagara in K. I. A. No. 517 of 1936 in O. S. No. 339 of 1955.

2. The facts are:-- The suit is one for partition and separate possession of the plaintiff's share in the properties shown in the plaint. The properties, it is alleged, originally belonged to one Moideenkutti who died about 20 years ago. Plaintiff alleges that he has obtained a share in the property by virtue of an assignment from some of the legal representatives of the said Moideenkutti, Defendants 8, 10 and 11 also claim shares in the property by virtue of assignments executed in their favour by certain persons who are also stated to be some of the legal representatives of the said Moideenkutti. Therefore, these defendants preferred R. I. A. No. 517 of 1956 in the lower Court contending that in view of the fact that there is keen dispute between the parties regarding the shaves, regarding devolution of right and regarding the original partition set up in the written statement and some other matters raised therein, their assignors should also be impleaded. The plaintiff resisted this application on the ground that he cannot be compelled to implead the assignors in view of the admitted position that they have no subsisting right over the properties and that it is only an attempt to cause unnecessary complications and put the plaintiff to trouble, delay and expense and that he cannot also be compelled to implead persons for the purpose of safeguarding the rights of the party-defendants which should be left open to be agitated by them if necessary in separate proceedings.

3. Order I, Rule 10 (2) of the Code of Civil Procedure states:

''The Court may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without the application of either party, and on such terms as may appear to the Court to be jast, order that the name of any party improperly joined, whether as plaintiff or defendant, be struck out, and that the name of any person who ought to have been joined, whether as plaintiff or defendant, or whose presence before the Court may be necessary in order to enable the Court effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved iu the suit, be added."

4. The sub-rule corresponds to the second sentence of Order XVI, Rule 11, of the English Rules of Sup-reme Court and confers wide discretion to [he Court to meet every case of defect of parties but is subject to two limitations, viz., (1) that the Court has no power to join a person as a party if he could not have been originally impleaded under Order 1, Rule 1, or Rule 3, C. P. C., and (2) that the presence of the person added must be necessary to effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle all points involved in the suit.

5. The discretion must be exercised in a reasonable manner so as not to cause inconvenience or embarrassment. In exercising the powers under this rule Courts ought to see that they do not load the record with parties who are shown to have only indirect or remote interest and that the trial of the suit is not embarrassed by the simultaneous investigation of totally unconnected controversies. This rule does not authorise the Court to introduce into a suit as a defendant a person who claims the property in the suit by a title quite distinct from that under which any of the parties to the suit claims, Kalian Rai v. Ram Ratan, ILR 18 All 306 (A). See Joy Cobind v. Gouree Proshad, 7 Suth WR 201 (13). A person can be added only when there are questions directly arising out of and incidental to the original cause of act in which such person has identify of community of interest with one or original plaintiff or defendant. Naraini Kuar v. Durjan Kuar, ILR 2 All 738 (C): so also Mahomed Badsha v. Nicol; ILR 4 Cal 355 (D). The plaintiff who pays heavy court-fee is after all the dominus lites and is entitled in the absence of the overriding considerations provided in Order I, Rule 10 (2), to prescribe the carriage of his own suit. The Court should not re-write the plaint or queer the plaintiff's pitch or ordinarily add parties without the concurrence of the plaintiff.

6. The following three decisions are in point. In Vithobe v. Secretary of State, AIR 1925 Nag 373 (E), it is held that the plaintiff is the best judge of his own interests and no defendant should be added against the plaintiff's will even when the defendant asserts that his interests will be alfeeted by the plaintiff's suit and that it is not the intention of law to let third persons ventilate their own grievances in, and thus derive profit from, a suit commenced by another. In Vaithilinga Pandara Sannadhi v. Sadasiva Iyer, AIR 1926 Mad 838 (F), it was held that when a party sought to be added as defenadnt is not a necessary party but only permissible or proper party, addition cannot be ordered if objected to by the plaintiff and that all questions involved in the suit, refers to questions only between parties to the suit Questions involved in the suit do not mean all chums which may possibly he put forward by anybody: Sitaramayya v. Ramappayya, 5 Mad LW 207: (AIR 1918 Mad 1137) (G). In Palanisamy v. Komara Chettiar, (H), it was held that the Court should consider mainly whether the presence of the proposed parties would be necessary for adjudicating upon the questions that are involved. in the suit and an order for addition of parties should not be made merely with a view to avoid multiplicity of'suits if otherwise their presence is not necessary for determining the real questions involved in the suit. See also Gosto Behari v. Sur's Estate Ltd., ILR (1946) 1 Cal 656 (I); Virbhadrappa v. Snekabai, AIR 1939 Bom 188: ILR 1939 Bom 232 (J); Moser v. Marsden, (1892) 1 Ch 487 (K).

7. Bearing these principles in mind, if We examine the facts of this case, we find that the learned District Munsif came to the correct conclusion and the persons who are now sought to be impleaded have no subsisting right over the properties and they are sought to be impleaded only for the purpose of getting their evidence and it would not be proper to make them parties to the suit and that the petitioners' apprehension that they would be driven to the necessity of filing a separate suit against these persons is not a sufficient justification to compel the plaintiff to implead them as parties to the suit.

8. The endeavour of the learned advocate, therefore, before me was that the learned District Munsil should have allowed the addition of the parties invoking the provisions for third party procedure. In doing so the learned advocate overlooks the fact that the Court can consider the third party procedure only on ail application filed in terms of Order VIII-A of the Code of Civil Procedure. Such is not the case here and it is open to the petitioners to prefer such an application in the lower Court,

9. This Civil Revision Petition is dismissed.