Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

C. Dhanalakshmi Ammal v. The Income-Tax, Offi...

Madras High Court
Dec 18, 1956
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Judgment — Rajamannar, C.J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking a writ of mandamus to restrain the Income-tax Officer (Second Additional City Circle, Madras), the Collector of Nilgiris and the Tahsildar of Coonoor from attaching or selling properties of the petitioner for recovery of alleged income-tax arrears of her husband, Tharanisingh Gramani. The primary subject was the Benhutty estate, Kulifcai village, Coonoor taluk, which had been purchased by deed dated 1 September 1947 in the petitioner's name.

For recovery of the husband's arrears, the Income-tax Officer issued a certificate under Section 46(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act to the Collector of Nilgiris, who, invoking Section 27 of the Madras Revenue Recovery Act, proceeded to attach the Benhutty estate. The Revenue treated the purchase in the petitioner's name as benami and therefore attributable to the husband.

The respondents contended that the petitioner could pursue a suit for declaration in ordinary civil courts if aggrieved. The petitioner filed an affidavit asserting (i) the estate was purchased with her own funds, (ii) it was registered in her name in government records, (iii) she was in possession and enjoyment, and (iv) she had filed income tax returns and paid taxes in respect of income from that estate and other properties for the assessment years 1947–48 to 1950–51. She contended there was no statutory provision permitting revenue authorities to proceed against property of persons who were not defaulters.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Collector, under the Madras Revenue Recovery Act, may attach and sell land that is registered in the name of a person other than the defaulter for recovery of income-tax arrears of the defaulter.
  2. Whether, by virtue of the proviso to Section 46(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act (conferring the powers of a Civil Court), the Collector may attach property ostensibly standing in another person's name on the Income-tax Department's assertion that the property really belongs to the defaulting assessee.
  3. Whether the petitioner may invoke the supervisory jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution despite the existence of a remedy by ordinary suit in civil courts.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented)

  • The Benhutty estate was purchased with the petitioner's own funds and registered in her name; she has been in possession and enjoyment since purchase.
  • The petitioner has filed income-tax returns and paid tax on income derived from the estate and other properties (assessment years 1947–48 to 1950–51).
  • There is no statutory provision in the Madras Revenue Recovery Act permitting the Collector to attach and sell land not registered in the name of the defaulter; therefore the attachment and sale of property registered in the petitioner's name is not permissible to recover the husband's tax arrears.

Respondents' Arguments (as presented)

  • The attachment proceeded following a certificate under Section 46(2) of the Income-tax Act and under Section 27 of the Madras Revenue Recovery Act on the basis that the purchase in the petitioner's name was benami and the real owner was the husband (the defaulting assessee).
  • If the petitioner was aggrieved, she could institute a suit for declaration in the ordinary courts.
  • Under the proviso to Section 46(2) of the Income-tax Act, the Collector has the powers of a Civil Court for recovery of amounts due under a decree, and hence may, on the Income-tax Department's assertion, go behind the ostensible title and attach property that in form stands in another's name.
  • The petitioner would have the right to prefer a claim (as in execution proceedings) and that claim must be enquired into and disposed of by the Collector; resulting rights of suit would be available to the unsuccessful party.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Purushottam Govindji Halal v. Additional Collector of Bombay Interprets Section 46(2) of the Income-tax Act: collector must proceed as if recovering an arrear of land revenue and the proviso confers additional powers of a Civil Court rather than creating a separate procedure. The Court relied on this interpretation to explain that the collector proceeds under revenue recovery law but, by the proviso, acquires Civil Court powers to facilitate recovery; this was foundational to the view that the Collector may exercise powers to go behind ostensible titles when acting under the proviso.
Zamorin of Calicut v. Sitarama, ILR 7 Mad 405 Where registry stands in name of another and revenue falls into arrears, sale under Revenue Recovery Act after service on registered proprietor passes the landholder's interest to purchaser. Used to support the proposition that under Madras revenue law the registered proprietor is treated as the 'defaulter' for recovery purposes; helped the Court to conclude the Madras Act does not permit attachment of land not registered in the defaulter's name.
Sampath v. Rajah of Yenkata... AIR 1931 Mad 51 Held that where one is real owner and another the registered proprietor, the registered proprietor is the "defaulter" within the meaning of the Revenue Recovery Act provision cited. Relied upon to affirm that, under the Madras Revenue Recovery Act, the term 'defaulter' ordinarily denotes the registered proprietor; supports the conclusion that the Collector acting solely under the Madras Act cannot attach land not registered in the defaulter's name.
Venkappa Chari v. Pompana Gowd, 1918 Mad WN 191 (AIR 1918 Mad 42) Similar principle that the registered proprietor is treated as the defaulter for purposes of revenue recovery. Reinforces the Court's understanding of established Madras authorities about the scope of the Madras Revenue Recovery Act.
Fadhmanabha v. Visalakshmi, AIR 1938 Mad 283 Observed (in another connection) that it would not be competent to the Collector to go into the question of benami. The Court cited this authority when discussing limitations of the Collector's powers under the Madras Act, while distinguishing that under the proviso to Section 46(2) the Collector may exercise Civil Court powers.
Hiraluxmi Pandit v. Income-tax Officer Illustrates a case where, under the Bihar & Orissa Public Demands Recovery Act, there was provision for preferring a claim to attached property and for suit on rejection; also comments on onus in such suits. The Court noted this case but held it was not helpful because the Madras Revenue Recovery Act lacks similar claim/suit provisions; hence Hiraluxmi did not alter the result in this matter.
Union of India v. Firm Ralla Bam Raj Kumar Confirms that a suit for a declaration that attached properties are not those of the assessee but of the plaintiff (and thus not liable for attachment) is maintainable. Supported the Court's statement that a civil suit for declaration would lie for a person claiming ownership of attached properties.
New India Tannery v. M.P. Nigara Holds that existence of an ordinary remedy (a suit) is not always a bar to entertaining a petition under Article 226. Used to justify the proposition that the petitioner could in principle invoke Article 226 despite an alternative remedy by suit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by setting out the statutory framework. Section 46(2) of the Income-tax Act authorises the Income-tax Officer to forward a certificate of arrears to the Collector who is to recover the amount as if it were an arrear of land revenue. The proviso to that sub-section (added by statute) confers on the Collector the powers which a Civil Court has under the Civil Procedure Code for recovery of an amount due under a decree.

Relying on the Supreme Court's exposition in Purushottam Govindji Halal, the Court treated the body of subsection (2) as prescribing the single mode of recovery (i.e., the revenue recovery procedure under local law) and the proviso as conferring additional Civil Court powers to the Collector to facilitate effective recovery; the proviso does not create a distinct or alternative mode of recovery.

The Court analysed the Madras Revenue Recovery Act and the authorities interpreting it and accepted the petitioner's contention that, under the Madras Act itself, there is no power to attach and sell land registered in the name of a person other than the defaulter. Precedents (Zamorin of Calicut; Sampath; Venkappa Chari) establish that for purposes of the Madras Act the registered proprietor is treated as the defaulter and the Collector, proceeding purely under that Act, cannot go behind the register to attach land belonging on the record to another person.

However, the Court then examined the additional Civil Court powers conferred on the Collector by the proviso to Section 46(2). It accepted the respondents' argument that, by virtue of those additional powers, the Collector may — on the Income-tax Department's assertion that a property is in truth the assessee's — attach property ostensible in the name of another. The Court qualified this conclusion by emphasising the procedural safeguards: the ostensible owner has the right to prefer a claim under Order XXI, Rule 58 of the Civil Procedure Code; the Collector must enquire into and dispose of such a claim summarily as a civil court would in execution; and the unsuccessful party thereafter retains the right to bring a suit to establish title.

The Court distinguished the Hiraluxmi Pandit decision as dependent on statutory provisions in the Bihar & Orissa Public Demands Recovery Act which permit claims and suits in a particular way that the Madras Act does not replicate; consequently, Hiraluxmi did not aid the respondents' position under Madras law.

On the question whether the petitioner could seek equitable relief under Article 226 despite availability of a suit remedy, the Court referred to authority (New India Tannery) to observe that the existence of a suit remedy is not an absolute bar to entertaining a writ petition.

Bringing these points together, the Court concluded that: (a) Acting solely under the Madras Revenue Recovery Act the Collector had no power to attach property not registered in the name of the defaulter; but (b) By reason of the proviso to Section 46(2) the Collector enjoys additional Civil Court powers that permit, on the Income-tax Department's assertion of benami ownership, attachment of property in another's name — subject to the ostensible owner's right to prefer a claim under the Civil Procedure Code and subsequent rights of suit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is dismissed.

Summary of Judgment — Rajamannar, C.J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking a writ of mandamus to restrain the Income-tax Officer (Second Additional City Circle, Madras), the Collector of Nilgiris and the Tahsildar of Coonoor from attaching or selling properties of the petitioner for recovery of alleged income-tax arrears of her husband, Tharanisingh Gramani. The principal property in issue was the Benhutty estate, Kulifcai village, Coonoor taluk, which was purchased by a deed of sale dated 1 September 1947 in the petitioner's name.

For the recovery of the husband's arrears, the Income-tax Officer issued a certificate under Section 46(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act to the Collector of Nilgiris, who, invoking Section 27 of the Madras Revenue Recovery Act, proceeded to attach the Benhutty estate. The Revenue treated the purchase in the petitioner's name as benami and therefore attributable to the husband.

The respondents stated that if the petitioner were aggrieved she could institute a suit for declaration in the ordinary civil courts. The petitioner filed an affidavit asserting that the estate was purchased with her own funds, registered in her name in government records, that she was in possession and enjoyment of the property, and that she had submitted returns and paid tax for income derived from that estate and other properties for assessment years 1947–48 to 1950–51. She contended there was no statutory provision permitting the Revenue to proceed against property of persons who were not defaulters.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Collector, under the Madras Revenue Recovery Act, may attach and sell land that is registered in the name of a person other than the defaulter for recovery of income-tax arrears of the defaulter.
  2. Whether, by virtue of the proviso to Section 46(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act (conferring the powers of a Civil Court), the Collector may attach property ostensibly standing in another person's name on the Income-tax Department's assertion that the property really belongs to the defaulting assessee.
  3. Whether the petitioner may invoke the supervisory jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution despite the existence of a remedy by ordinary suit in civil courts.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Benhutty estate was purchased with the petitioner's own funds and is registered in her name; she is in possession and enjoyment.
  • She has submitted income-tax returns and paid assessed tax for income from the estate and other properties for the years 1947–48 to 1950–51.
  • There is no provision in the Madras Revenue Recovery Act enabling the Collector to attach and sell land not registered in the name of the defaulter; therefore the attachment of property registered in the petitioner's name to satisfy the husband's tax arrears is impermissible.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The attachment was made pursuant to a certificate under Section 46(2) of the Income-tax Act and Section 27 of the Madras Revenue Recovery Act because the transaction appeared prima facie to be benami and the real owner the defaulting assessee.
  • If aggrieved, the petitioner could bring a suit for declaration in the ordinary courts.
  • Under the proviso to Section 46(2) the Collector has the powers of a Civil Court and may, on the Income-tax Department's assertion of benami ownership, go behind ostensible titles and attach property standing in another's name; the ostensible owner would, however, have rights to prefer claims and ultimately to sue.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Purushottam Govindji Halal v. Additional Collector of Bombay Explains Section 46(2): Collector must proceed as if recovering an arrear of land revenue; the proviso confers Civil Court powers to assist recovery rather than creating an alternative procedure. The Court relied on this interpretation to conclude the Collector proceeds under revenue recovery law but, by the proviso, acquires Civil Court powers to go behind ostensible titles when appropriate.
Zamorin of Calicut v. Sitarama, ILR 7 Mad 405 Where land is registered in the name of another and revenue is in arrears, a sale under the Revenue Recovery Act after notice to the registered proprietor will pass the landholder's interest to the purchaser. Used to support the proposition that under Madras revenue law the registered proprietor is treated as the 'defaulter' for recovery purposes; assisted the Court in holding that the Madras Act does not permit attaching land not registered in the defaulter's name.
Sampath v. Rajah of Yenkata..., AIR 1931 Mad 51 Holds that where one is real owner and another is registered proprietor, the registered proprietor is the "defaulter" within the meaning of the Revenue Recovery Act provision cited. Relied upon to affirm that under the Madras Act the registered proprietor is treated as the defaulter; supports the limitation on the Collector's power when acting solely under that Act.
Venkappa Chari v. Pompana Gowd, 1918 Mad WN 191 (AIR 1918 Mad 42) Similar authority establishing that the registered proprietor is treated as the defaulter for revenue recovery purposes. Reinforced the Court's view that the Madras Act, as interpreted by local authorities, does not permit the Collector to attach land not registered in the defaulter's name.
Fadhmanabha v. Visalakshmi, AIR 1938 Mad 283 Noted (in another context) that it would not be competent to the Collector to go into the question of benami. Cited to underline the general limitation on the Collector's powers under the Madras Act, though the Court recognised that the proviso to Section 46(2) confers additional Civil Court powers that alter the practical effect.
Hiraluxmi Pandit v. Income-tax Officer Involved a certificate under Section 46(2) and application of the Bihar & Orissa Public Demands Recovery Act where there were statutory provisions for claim and suit; discussed onus in such suits. The Court observed this decision but held it was not of assistance because the Madras Revenue Recovery Act lacks the comparable provisions relied upon in Hiraluxmi.
Union of India v. Firm Ralla Bam Raj Kumar Confirms that a suit for declaration that properties attached for recovery of arrears are not those of the assessee but of the plaintiff is maintainable. Supported the statement that the petitioner could sue for a declaration that the attached properties belonged to her and not to the assessee.
New India Tannery v. M.P. Nigara Holds that the existence of a remedy by ordinary suit is not always a bar to entertaining a petition under Article 226. Justified the Court's willingness to consider the Article 226 petition despite the availability of a suit remedy.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed the statutory scheme and precedent as follows:

  1. Section 46(2) of the Income-tax Act requires the Income-tax Officer to forward a certificate of arrears to the Collector, who shall proceed to recover the amount as if it were an arrear of land revenue; the proviso grants the Collector the powers of a Civil Court under the Civil Procedure Code to aid recovery.
  2. Interpreting that provision in light of Purushottam Govindji Halal, the Court held that the proviso does not create an alternate mode of recovery but confers additional Civil Court powers to the Collector while he proceeds under the normal revenue recovery mechanism.
  3. Examining the Madras Revenue Recovery Act and relevant Madras authorities (Zamorin; Sampath; Venkappa Chari), the Court agreed with the petitioner's submission that the Madras Act itself contains no provision permitting attachment and sale of land not registered in the defaulter's name; for revenue recovery under that Act the registered proprietor is treated as the defaulter.
  4. The Court accepted the respondents' submission that by exercise of the additional Civil Court powers under the proviso to Section 46(2), the Collector may attach property ostensibly standing in the name of another where the Income-tax Department asserts the property really belongs to the defaulting assessee. This power, however, is subject to procedural safeguards: the ostensible owner may prefer a claim under Order XXI, Rule 58 of the Civil Procedure Code; the Collector must enquire into and dispose of that claim summarily as a civil court would in execution; and the aggrieved party retains the right to bring a suit.
  5. The Court distinguished Hiraluxmi Pandit as resting on features of the Bihar & Orissa statute that are not present in the Madras Act, and therefore found that decision not materially helpful here.
  6. Although a suit for declaration would lie (Union of India v. Firm Ralla Bam Raj Kumar), the Court observed that the existence of a suit remedy does not preclude jurisdiction under Article 226 (New India Tannery v. M.P. Nigara).
  7. Weighing these points, the Court concluded that while the Collector acting solely under the Madras Revenue Recovery Act cannot attach land not registered in the defaulter's name, the Collector, empowered by the proviso to Section 46(2), may attach such property on the Income-tax Department's assertion of benami ownership — but the ostensible owner must be permitted to make a claim and seek redress, and has subsequent rights of suit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is dismissed.

Implications:

  • The direct effect on the parties is that the Collector may continue with attachment proceedings by virtue of the additional Civil Court powers conferred by the proviso to Section 46(2) of the Income-tax Act, subject to the procedural protections indicated (the ostensible owner may prefer a claim under Order XXI, Rule 58 of the Civil Procedure Code; the Collector must enquire into and dispose of such claim; and any aggrieved party retains the right to bring a suit, including under Order XXI, Rule 63).
  • The Court acknowledged that, standing alone, the Madras Revenue Recovery Act does not permit attachment of land not registered in the defaulter's name; but the Collector's proviso-derived Civil Court powers change the practical outcome when the Income-tax Department asserts benami ownership.
  • No broader or novel precedent was declared beyond applying established authorities and interpreting the interplay of Section 46(2)'s proviso with the Madras Revenue Recovery Act; the judgment resolves the dispute between the parties by dismissing the petition while recording the procedural safeguards available to the ostensible owner.

Disposition: Petition dismissed; no order as to costs.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT Rajamannar, C.J.

1. This is a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution for the issue of a direction in the nature of a writ of mandamus to the Income-tax Office, Second Additional City Circle Madras, the Collector of Nilgiris Nilgiris district and the Tahsildar of Coonoor, Coonoor taluk, Nilgiris district, restraining them from proceeding to attach, or to bring to sale, the petitioner's properties for the realisation of the alleged income-tax arrears of her husband, Tharanisingh Gramani and in particular from proceeding with the sale of the Benhutty estate, Kulifcai village, Coonoor taluk, Nilgiris district.

2. For the recovery of arrears of income-tax due from the petitioner's husband; Tharani Singh Gramani, a certificate was issued by the Income-tax Officer, the first respondent, to the Collector of Nilgiris (the second respondent) under Section 46(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act The Collector, in pursuance of this certificate,' proceeded under Sec. 27 of the Madras Revenue Recovery Act, to attach the property described as Benhutty estate for the realisation of the said arrears. This estate, it is common ground, was purchased in the name of the petitioner by a deed of sale dated 1st September 1947. Nevertheless, the property was sought to be attached as the property of the' husband Tharanisingh Gramani, treating the purchase in the name of the petitioner as benami for her husband. In the affidavit filed by the Collector before us, the position taken up-by the respondents is set out thus:

"Though the ostensible title stands In the name of the petitioner, -having regard to the-various circumstances which have been the subject of enquiry before the Income-tax authorities, it is clear that prima facie the authorities have a right to come to the conclusion that the petitioner is a benamidar and that the real owner is- ' the defaulting assessee-- the husband -- In cases where prima facie there are materials to show that a particular sale deed could only be a benami transaction, it is open to the revenue authorities to go behind the mask and attach the right, title and interest of the real owner and bring them to sale."

The plea was also taken on behalf of the respondents that if the petitioner was aggrieved, it was open to her to institute a suit for a' declaration and seek her remedy, in the ordinary Courts of law.

3. In the affidavit filed by the petitioner In support of the application, she stated that the estate in question was purchased with her own funds, that it had been registered In her name in Government records ever since her purchase and that she was in possession and enjoyment of the property. She further alleged that in 'respect of the income which she was deriving from the said estate and other properties which she owned, she had submitted returns to the income-tax authorities for the assessment years 1947-48 to 1950-51 and had paid the tax which had been assessed on the said income. Her contention was that' there was no statutory provision enabling the Revenue authorities to proceed against the property of persons who were not defaulters,

4. Section 46 (2) or the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, runs thus:

"The Income-tax Officer may forward to the Collector a certificate under his signature specifying the amount of arrears due from an assessee, and the Collector, on receipt of such certificate, shall proceed to recover from such assessee the amount specified therein as if it were an arrear of land revenue:

Provided that without prejudice to any other powers of the Collector in this behalf, he shall, for the purpose of recovering the said amount, have the powers which under the Civil Procedure Code, 1908, a Civil Court has for the purpose of the recovery of an amount due under a decree.'' The proviso was added by section 16 of act xviii of-1933. In Purushottam Govindji Halal v. Additional Collector of Bombay, (A) the Supreme Court explained the scope of this provision thus:

"On a proper reading, that sub-section does not prescribe two alternative modes of procedure at all. All that the sub-section directs the Collector to do is to proceed to recover the certified amount as If it were an arrear of 3and revenue, that is to say, he is to adopt the procedure prescribed by the appropriate law of his State for the recovery of land revenue and that in thus proceeding he is, under the proviso, to have all the powers a civil Court has under the Code. The sub-section does not prescribe two separate procedures... ..In our opinion the proviso does not indicate a different and alternative mode of recovery of the certified amount of tax but only confers additional powers on the Collector for the better and more effective application of the only mode of recovery authorised by the body of Sub-section (2) of Section 46."

5. The Madras Revenue Recovery Act prescribes the procedure for recovery of arrears of revenue. The recovery can be made in -different ways; by the seizure and sale of moveable. property; by attachment and sale of immoveable property; and by execution against the person of the defaulter. (Vide Section 5). Section 25 prescribes the service of a written demand upon the defaulter, and under Section 26 when the amount due has not been paid, the Collector can proceed to recover the arrear by the "attachment and sale of the defaulter's land". The mode of attachment is laid down in Section 27., There are other provisions relating to the procedure to be followed on the sale of the attached property. Section 59 saves the right of parties aggrieved by any proceedings taken under the Act to apply to the civil Courts for redress though a short period of limitation of six months from the time at which the cause of action arose is fixed for the institution of any suit.

6. The contention of Mr; M.K. Nambiar, learned counsel for the petitioner, was that there is no provision in the Madras Revenue Recovery Act which enables the Collector to attach and sell" any land other than the land of the defaulter; and land which is registered in the name of some one other than the defaulter cannot be deemed to be the land of the defaulter for the purpose of the Revenue Recovery Act. He relied on the principle of several decisions of this Court which have held that "defaulter" can only mean, for the purpose of the Madras Revenue Recovery Act, the registered proprietor of the land, even though the real owner may by someone else.'

7. In Zamorin of Calicut v. Sitarama, ILR 7 Mad 405 (B), it was held that where a landholder allows the registry of land to stand in the name of another and the revenue falls into arrears, a 'sale of the land under the provisions of Revenue Recovery Act (Madras Act II of 1864), effected after service of notice upon the person in whose name the patta stands, will pass the landholder's interest to the purchaser at the revenue sale. In Sampath V. Rajah of yenkatagirt, AIR 1931 Mad 51 (C), Ma-dhavan Nair J. after referring to earlier authorities, held that where one person was the real owner and another was the registered proprietor, the latter and not the former was the "defaulter" within the meaning of Section 35 of the Revenue Recovery Act (Vide also Venkappa Chari v pompana Gowd, 1918 Mad WN 191: (AIR 1918 Mad 42) (D).

We agree with Mr. Nambiar that there is no provision in the Madras Revenue Recovery Act which enables the Collector to attach and sell land" not registered in the defaulter's name for arrears of 'revenue due from the defaulter. In Fadhmanabha v. Visalakshmi, AIR 1938 Mad 283 (E), It was pointed out, though in another connection, that It would not be competent to the Collector to go into the question of benami.

8. We agree, however, with Mr. Rama Rao Sahib, who appeared for the respondents, that in, exercise of the additional powers conferred on the Collector under the proviso to Section 48 (2) of the Indian Income-tax Act, i.e., the powers of a civil Court for the purpose of the recovery of an amount due under a decree, the Collector may attach property ostensibly standing in the name of a person other than the defaulter on the assertion by the Income-tax department that the property really belongs to the defaulting assessee. But then the ostensible owner will have the right to prefer a claim under Order XXI, 'Rule 58, Civil P. C., and such claim must be enquired into and disposed of, though summarily, by the Collector in the same way as a Court would be bound to dispose of a claim in the course of execution of a decree.

It would also follow that the unsuccessful party,--it may be the claimant, or it may be the Income-tax department--will have the right to file a suit to establish the tight claimed by either. But for the additional powers conferred on the Collector by the above-mentioned proviso, we are of the opinion that the Income-tax Act does not provide for recovery of arrears due from the assessee from persons in possession of property which they do not admit to be the assessee's property For instance, under Section 46 (5-A) the Income-tax Officer may, at any time, require any person who holds money for, or on account of, the assessee to pay to the Income-tax Officer such money. But where a person to whom such a notice is sent objects to it on the ground that he does not hold any money for or on account of, the assessee, then nothing contained in the section shall be deemed to require such person to pay any such sum, or part thereof, to the Income-tax Officer.

9. Mr Rama Rao Sahib contended firstly that the petitioner would have a right to prefer a claim, eyen though the Collector purported to proceed under the provisions of the Revenue Recovery Act only, and cited in this connection Hiraluxmi Pandit v. Income-tax Officer, (F). In that case, on a certificate sent by the Income-tax Officer under Section 46 (2) of the Income-tax Act, the Collector proceeded to put up for sale certain property as the property of the assessee; but the widow of the assessee claimed that the property was her own. Her claim was rejected and she thereupon filed a suit to vindicate her right.

It was held that the suit was maintainable without the Union of India being made a party, and on the question of onus it was held that though ordinarily where a transaction was challenged as benami, the onus was upon the person who challenged the apparent tenor of the document, in a suit under Section 25 of the Public Demands Recovery Act of Bihar and Orissa the onus was on the plaintiff to establish that the transaction was not benami. We are not aware of the exact provisions of the Bihar and Orissa Public Demands Recovery Act, but from the Judgment of Sinha J. it is clear that there is provision in that Act for preferring a claim to the attached property on the ground that the property belonged to the claimant and not to the defaulter; and on the rejection of such a claim, the claimant has also a right of suit. This decision is therefore of no assistance to us 'as the Madras Revenue Recovery Act does not contain similar provisions.

10. There can be no doubt whatever that a suit for a declaration that the properties attached for realisation of arrears of income-tax due from an' assessee were hot the properties of the assessee but were the properties of the plaintiff and therefore were not liable for - attachment and sale would lie. This would be so even If the Collector was not exercising the additional powers under the proviso to Section 46 (2) of the Act, Vide Union of India v. Firm Ralla Bam Raj Kumar, (Q). But then we are prepared to hold that though an aggrieved party may have a right of suit, he will not be precluded from invoicing our power under Article 226 of the Constitution to obtain appropriate orders for preventing the Collector from proceeding to attach and sell property registered in his name. The existence of a remedy by way of a suit is not always a bar to the entertainment of a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution. (Vide New India Tannery v. M.P. Nigara, (H) ).

11. As we have held above that the Collector, acting merely under the Madras Revenue Recovery Act. has no power to attach and cell property registered in the name of any one other than the defaulter, we would have issued a writ of mandamus to forbid him from continuing the proceedings against the property of the petitioner. But in view of the fact that the Collector has also additional powers, which would enable him to attach the property ostensibly standing in the name of the petitioner, as property belonging to the defaulter, we do not think it necessary to make and such order, especially because Mr. Rama Bao Sahib appearing for the respondents has intimated, that the attachment in this case would be treated as an attachment under the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure and the petitioner will be entitled to prefer a claim, if she chooses to, and the claim will be enquired into and disposed of by the Collector. It will also follow that the party aggrieved by the decision of the Collector will have a right of suit under Order XXI, Rule 63 of the Code.

12. The petition is therefore dismissed; but in the circumstances there will be no order as to costs.

.