- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rao Bahadur M. Vaidyanathan v. The Sub Divisional Magistrate Erode & Others.
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The Agricultural and Industrial Corporation Ltd., incorporated in 1947 under the Indian Companies Act, 1913, experienced changes in managing directors in 1949: the petitioner was elected Managing Director on 5-3-1949, and, according to the petitioner, A.S. Venkata Rao was elected in his place on 17-7-1949 and took charge thereafter. The petitioner says he ceased involvement in management after 4-5-1950.
A balance sheet filed on 7-3-1949 disclosed tangible assets of nearly Rs. 49,000, and no subsequent balance sheet was alleged to have been filed. Disputes arose among directors and ex-directors.
On 8-6-1955 the Registrar of Companies wrote to the Inspector-General of Police, Madras (copy filed as Ex. A), referring to departmental enquiries and the Public Prosecutor’s advice that there was a prima facie case under sections 406, 409 and 477-A of the Indian Penal Code, and asked for a thorough investigation. That letter was treated as a police complaint and registered at Kanjanur police station as Criminal No. 48 of 1955; later the matter was registered at Erode as Cr. No. 892 of 1955 and treated as an FIR. The Criminal Investigation Department (C.I.D.) eventually took over the investigation; an Inspector of Police of the C.I.D. (third respondent) was placed in charge and the investigation was not completed at the time of the opinion.
The petitioner was arrested without warrant at Bombay on 29-10-1955 and released on bail. He appeared before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Erode, on 24-11-1955. In March 1956 the petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking a writ of prohibition to restrain further proceedings in Cr. No. 892 of 1955 before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Erode.
The petitioner later amended his prayer (after impleading the C.I.D. Inspector as third respondent) to seek a writ of prohibition prohibiting further investigation by the third respondent in so far as the petitioner was concerned in relation to affairs of the company.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the third respondent (the C.I.D. Inspector in charge of the investigation) had jurisdiction to investigate alleged offences (notably under Ss. 406 and 409 and 477-A, I.P.C.) in respect of the petitioner.
- Whether the Registrar of Companies acted in excess of his jurisdiction by sending the letter dated 8-6-1955 to the Inspector-General of Police and, if so, whether that tainted or barred police investigation.
- Whether provisions of the Companies Act — specifically S. 630 (penalty for wrongful withholding of property) and provisions concerning the Registrar’s and Central Government’s powers (Ss. 234 and 242) — operate as statutory bars to a police investigation or prosecution for cognizable offences arising from a company's affairs.
- Whether any irregularity in the initiation of the investigation (including the mode in which the complaint to police arose) vitiates the investigation or entitles the petitioner to a writ of prohibition.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The Registrar of Companies acted in excess of his statutory jurisdiction when he addressed the letter dated 8-6-1955 to the Inspector-General of Police and thereby sought police investigation.
- Section 630 of the Companies Act (Act I of 1956) provides a summary remedy for wrongful withholding of company property and, the petitioner’s counsel contended, that S. 630 barred police investigation/prosecution even for cognizable offences committed in relation to company affairs.
- Provisions dealing with powers of the Registrar and the Central Government (including Ss. 234 and 242) were relied upon to contend that statutory channels must be followed and that these provisions restrict or displace police jurisdiction.
- The petitioner sought a writ of prohibition to restrain further investigation or prosecution insofar as he was concerned.
Respondents' / State's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)
- Police officers have statutory powers under the Criminal Procedure Code (Ss. 154, 156(1) and 157(1)) to investigate cognizable offences on the basis of a complaint or other information; those powers were invoked here.
- The Registrar of Companies, even if he did not follow internal statutory procedures under the Companies Act when sending his letter, was entitled as a citizen to bring suspected cognizable offences to the notice of the police.
- Section 630 of the Companies Act provides a summary civil/criminal remedy limited to officers or employees of a company and does not by itself bar independent police investigation or prosecution for cognizable offences under the Indian Penal Code.
- Sections such as S. 242(1) (an enabling provision permitting the Central Government to prosecute after legal advice) do not divest the police of their jurisdiction under the Cr.P.C.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vernan v. Watson [1891] 2 Q.B. 288 | Explained scope of a summary procedure under S.16 of the Friendly Societies Act, 1875; distinguished summary statutory procedure from ordinary criminal/civil rights and observed that criminal proceedings do not of themselves oust civil remedies; application of ordinary legal principles to different parts of a combined statutory procedure. | The court used the reasoning in Vernan v. Watson to analogise and explain the scope of S. 630 of the Companies Act (a summary remedy). Although S. 630 lacks an express saving clause comparable to S.16 of the Friendly Societies Act, the court found the principles from Vernan applicable in understanding that a statutory summary procedure does not necessarily bar criminal proceedings by the State. |
| Rishbud v. State of Delhi [1955] M.W.N. 232 | Where cognizance has been taken and the case proceeded to termination, invalidity of prior investigation does not vitiate the result unless there has been a miscarriage of justice; when such breach is raised early, the court may order reinvestigation as appropriate. | The petitioner relied on this precedent to argue for prohibition. The court observed the principle but held it inapplicable because the petitioner had not established that the third respondent was acting illegally or outside jurisdiction; consequently the petitioner had no entitlement to the writ of prohibition on that basis. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined both the factual matrix and the relevant statutory provisions before concluding whether the third respondent had jurisdiction to investigate and whether that exercise of jurisdiction could be restrained by a writ of prohibition.
Steps in the court's analysis:
- Factual foundation: The court accepted the material showing that the Registrar's letter of 8-6-1955 was treated as a complaint, that it was registered as a cognizable case, and that the investigation progressed through local police stations to the Criminal Investigation Department. The petitioner’s arrest in Bombay on 29-10-1955 without a warrant and subsequent bail were undisputed.
- Statutory powers of the police: The court set out ss. 154, 156(1) and 157(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code and explained their operation:
- S.154 requires that information relating to commission of a cognizable offence, given orally or in writing, be reduced to writing and signed by the informant — the Registrar’s letter satisfied S.154.
- S.156(1) authorises the officer in charge of a police station to investigate a cognizable case without a Magistrate’s order.
- S.157(1) allows a police officer, even without a written complaint, to report to a Magistrate empowered to take cognizance and to arrange investigation where there is reason to suspect commission of a cognizable offence.
- Effect of irregularity in the complaint: The court explained that even if the Registrar’s letter was irregular or if the Registrar had acted without invoking his statutory powers, that irregularity did not deprive the police of jurisdiction under S.157(1) Cr.P.C to investigate. The court noted that the Registrar, as a citizen, could bring suspected offences to the attention of police and that nothing in the Companies Act expressly prohibited him from doing so.
- Analysis of the Companies Act provisions relied on by petitioner:
- S.630 of the Companies Act: The court analysed the scope of S.630 (a summary remedy for wrongful withholding or misapplication of company property available to the company or certain specified persons). It held that S.630 provides a summary remedy confined to officers or employees of the company and does not, by itself, bar a police investigation or prosecution for cognizable offences (such as under Ss. 406 and 409 I.P.C.). The court noted that some acts within S.630 might not constitute criminal misappropriation under the Penal Code and that it was not deciding whether punishment under S.630 would bar later criminal conviction.
- Ss. 234 and 242 (and powers of Registrar/Central Government): The court observed S.242(1) is an enabling provision (the use of "may") allowing the Central Government, after legal advice, to prosecute; by itself it does not divest police jurisdiction under the Cr.P.C.
- Precedent and remedial principles: The court considered Rishbud v. State of Delhi (principle that invalid antecedent investigation does not vitiate a trial absent miscarriage of justice) but held that the petitioner had not shown any illegality in the third respondent’s conduct or jurisdiction. Consequently, the Rishbud principle did not assist the petitioner in obtaining prohibition.
- Conclusion on jurisdiction and writ: Because the third respondent had jurisdiction under the Cr.P.C. to investigate cognizable offences and because neither S.630 nor the other Companies Act provisions barred that exercise, the court held that a writ of prohibition could not issue to restrain the investigation. The court therefore dismissed the petitioner’s claim for prohibition.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The petition is DISMISSED. The rule is discharged and there will be no order as to costs. The court held that the third respondent (the C.I.D. Inspector) had jurisdiction to investigate the alleged offences and that neither the Companies Act provisions cited (including S.630 and S.242) nor any asserted irregularity by the Registrar of Companies deprived the police of jurisdiction under Ss. 154, 156(1) and 157(1) Cr.P.C.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The police/C.I.D. investigation against the petitioner may continue; the petitioner was denied the writ of prohibition he sought, and the petition was dismissed.
- Statutory interpretation consequence: The court interpreted S.630 as a summary remedy available to specified private parties (officers or employees) and concluded that it does not, by itself, operate as a statutory bar to criminal investigation or prosecution by the State for cognizable offences under the I.P.C.
- Broader precedent: The opinion does not purport to create a novel broad rule displacing police powers; it confines its decision to the questions before it and expressly refrains from deciding whether a conviction under S.630 would bar a conviction under Ss. 406/409 I.P.C. Therefore, no new, sweeping precedent was announced beyond the application of established statutory principles to the facts of this case.
Petition dismissed.
The Agricultural and Industrial Corporation Ltd was incorporated in 1947 under the provisions of the Indian Companies Act, 1913. At the meeting of the General Body of the shareholders held on 5-3-1949 the petitioner was elected the Managing Director of the company in the place of one Narayana Rao who had been the Managing Director up to then. The petitioner claimed that on 17-7-1949 at another meeting of the General Body of the share holders, one A.S Venkata Rao was elected the Managing Director, and the petitioner handed over charge of the affairs of the comapany to Venkata Rao. The claim in the counter affidavit of the second respondent was, that the petitioner functioned along with A.S Venkata Rao till 4-5-1950, though Venkata Rao had been elected as director in charge on 17-7-1949. The petitioner further claimed that after 4-5-1950 he ceased to have anything to do with the management of the company. He was employed thereafter at Kozhikode and later at Bombay.
From the averments in the counter affidavit of the second respondent it appears that in the balance sheet of the company, filed with the Assistant Registrar of Companies at Erode on 7-3-1949, tangible assets of the company to the extent of nearly Rs. 49000 were disclosed. It was alleged that no balance sheet was filed with the Registrar of companies subsequent to that. There were charges and counter charges as between the directors and ex-directors of the company. On 8-6-1955 the Registrar of Companies addressed a letter to the Inspector-General of Police, Madras. A copy of that letter was filed as Ex. A, annexed to the counter affidavit filed by the second respondent. In that letter the Registrar referred to the enquiries conducted by the officers of his department and to the advice of the Public Prosecutor, Cuddalore, in whose opinion “there was a prima facie good case for police investigation and charging the officers of the company for offences under ss. 406, 409 and 477-A, I.P.C” The Registrar requested the Inspector-General of Police to cause a thorough investigation to be made in the matter.
The letter of the Registrar dated 8-6-1953 was treated as a complains to the police, and it was eventually registered at Kanjanur police station in South Arcot District as Cr. No. 48 of 1955, under ss. 406, 409 and 477-A, I.P.C In November 1955 the further investigation was transferred to the police officers in charge of the Erode police station. It was registered as Cr. No. 892 of 1955, and a copy of the complaint was lodged as the First Information Report with the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Erode. Further investigation into the complaint was eventually taken over by the Criminal Investigation Department Madras, and from the affidavit of the third respondent it appeared that the third respondent, an Inspector of Police of the Criminal Investigation Department was placed in charge of the investigation. The investigation has not yet been completed.
The petitioner averred in the affidavit he filed in support of the petition that he was arrested at Bombay on 29-10-1955 without a warrant and he was subsequently released on bail by the Additional Presidency Magistrate, Esplanade, Bombay. The petitioner appeared before the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Erode, on 24-11-1955, but what happened further in that court he did not say.
In March 1956 the petitioner applied under art. 226 of the Constitution impleading the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Erode, and the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies, Madras, as respondents 1 and 2 respectively. The relief asked for was “the issue of a writ of prohibition prohibiting all further proceedings in Cr. No. 892 of 1955 before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Erode………………….”
Though he had not been impleaded as a party to these proceedings at that stage, the Inspector of Police, Criminal Investigation Department, who was in charge of the investigation, swore to an affidavit on 9th July, 1936 to explain what further proceedings were taken after the investigation was taken over by the C.I.D Subsequent to that the petitioner was permitted in C.M.P No. 5646 of 1956 to implead the Inspector of Police as the third respondent in these proceedings, and also to amend the prayer in W.P No. 394 of 1956. The relief that the petitioner asked for after that amendment was the issue of a writ of prohibition “prohibiting all further investigation by the third respondent in so far as the petitioner is concerned in respect of the affairs of the Agricultural and Industrial Credit Corporation Ltd.”
The petitioner's claim was that he was arrested at Bombay on 29-10-1955 and that he was subsequently released on bail. The truth of that was not challenged. The petitioner himself apparently did not know on what charges he was arrested. The arrest was without a warrant. Even in the counter affidavit filed by respondents 1 and 3 there was nothing to show what led to the arrest of the petitioner on 29-10-1955. Nor even was there anything to indicate that the arrest was effected on the basis of the letter dated 8-6-1955, which was treated as a complaint for purposes of investigation by the police. When the petitioner appeared before the sub Divisional Magistrate, Erode, the petitioner was apparently under the impression, that he had been arrested in the course of investigation into the complaint dated 8—6— 1955, which was at that stage treated as the First Information Report in Cr. No. 892 of 1953 of the Erode police station. It may not be necessary to refer further to the arrest or the circumstances under which that arrest was effected for the disposal of this petition. I shall proceed on the basis, that the letter of the Registrar dated 8-6-1955 was a complaint to the police within the scope of the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code. The offence the petitioner, among others, was alleged to have committed were specified as those punishable under S. 406, 409 and 477A I.P.C of these, offences punishable under S. 406 and 409, I.P.C are cognisable offences. These are cases in which the person accused of having committed those offences could be arrested by the police without a warrant issued by a Magistrate. S. 154 Cr.P.C runs:
“Every Information relating to the commission of a cognizable offence if given orally to an officer in charge of a police station shall be reduced to writing by him or under his direction and be read over to the informant; and every such information, whether given in writing or reduced to writing as aforesaid, shall be signed by the person giving it, and the substance thereof shall be entered in a book to be kept by such officer In such form as the State Government may prescribe in this behalf.”
The letter dated 8-6-1955, though addressed to the inspector General of Police, satisfied the requirements of S. 154, Cr.P.C It was eventually registered apparently under the provisions of S. 154 by the officer in charge of the police station at Kanjanur. S. 156(1) authorises any officer in charge of a police station to investigate any cognisable case without the order of a Magistrate. Under S. 157(1), even without a complaint in writing, “if from the information received or otherwise”, an officer in charge of a police station has reason to suspect the commission of a cognisable offence he could send a report of the same to a Magistrate empowered to take cognisance of such an offence upon a police report and thereafter arrange for the investigation of the case.
I have referred to the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code to explain what the statutory duties of a police officer are, when he is informed by a complaint in writing or even otherwise that a cognizable offence has been committed. At that stage even the disclosure of the name of the person suspected to have committed the offence may not be necessary to authorise an investigation by the police officer.
The relief that the petitioner eventually asked for in these proceedings before me under art. 226 of the Constitution was, that a writ of prohibition should issue to restrain the third respondent from investigating into the charges against the petitioner, the charges that he was suspected of having committed offences punishable under Ss. 406, 409 and 477-A I.P.C If the third respondent, who is now in charge of the conduct of the investigation, has jurisdiction to investigate the charges against the accused, then obviously no writ of prohibition can issue. The complaint of the learned counsel for the petitioner was that the Registrar of companies acted in excess of his jurisdiction when he addressed the letter dated 8-6-1955 to the Inspector General of Police asking for an investigation. I shall deal with that contention a little later. Even if the Registrar acted in contravention of any statutory porvisions in preferring a complaint to the police, that in my opinion, may not affect the jurisdiction of the police officer to investigate into a complaint of the commision of cognisable offences like those punishable under ss. 406 and 409, I.P.C Even if any irregularity tainted the complaint dated 8-6-1955, 157(1) Cr.P.C is sufficient to clothe the police officer with jurisdiction to investigate. Even on information received from whatever source that information was received or even otherwise, if the police officer in charge of the police station has reason to suspect that a cognisable offence has been committed, he has jurisdiction to investigate, S. 157(1) Cr.P.C In fact it would be his statutory duty to investigate.
The Criminal Procedure Code itself does not provide for any statutory bar to such an investigation. Whether there is any other statutory bar to the investigation entrusted to the third respondent is the next question.
The learned counsel for the petitioner relied on S. 630 of the Companies Act (Act I of 1956) and urged that that barred an investigation by the police even into charges of the commission of cognisable offences if the acts on which these charges were founded were in relation to the affairs of a company incorporated under the Companies Act. The Companies Act (Act I of 1956) replaced the earlier enactment the Indian Companies Act, 1913. It should be more convenient to refer to the statutory provisions as they stand numbered in Act I of 1956 without any need to quote the corresponding provisions of the earlier Act, the Indian Companies Act, 1913. In the rest of this judgment I shall refer to the Companies Act (Act I of 1956) as the Act. Section 630 of the Act runs:
“penalty for wrongful withholding of property—
(1) If any officer or employee of a company—
(a) wrongfully obtains possession of any property of a company; or
(b) having any such property in his possession, wrongfully withholds it or knowingly applies it to purposes other than those expressed or directed in the articles and authorised by this Act, he shall on the complaint of the company or any creditor or contributory thereof, be punishable with fine which may extend to one thousand rupees.
(2) The Court trying the offence may also order such officer or employee to deliver up or refund, within a time to be fixed by the Court, any such property wrongfully obtained or wrongfully withheld or knowingly misapplied, or in default to suffer imprisonment for a term which may extend to two years.”
The learned Advocate-General pointed out that there was no statutory provision in the English Companies Act to correspond to S. 630 of the Act S. 630 of the Act is really based on and is analogous to S. 16 of the Friendly Societies Act, 1875 of England. The scope of the summary procedure provided for by S. 16 of the Friendly Societies Act and that of the reliefs that could be claimed or granted under that section were explained by the Court of Appeal in Vernan v. Watson [1891] 2 Q.B 288. Lord Halsbury, L.C observed:
“If the operation of the statute had been confined to criminal proceedings I should have entertained no doubt that imprisonment for the criminal offence afforded no answer to a civil claim for the debt.”
After pointing out that in S. 16 two different proceedings were mixed up together, the Lord Chancellor observed:
“We must apply the ordinary principles of law to each part of the procedure. In fact the legislation itself points in that direction, because one part of the section provides that the criminal proceedings taken under it shall not interfere with the right to indict…………………..,…”
That was based on the statutory provision that “nothing herein contained prevents any such person from being proceeded against by way of indictment, if not previously convicted of the same offence under the provisions of this Act.” It is true that there is no such saving clause in S. 630 of the Act. But that, in my opinion, makes no real difference to the application of the principles laid down with reference to S. 16 of the Friendly Societies Act, 1875.
S. 630 of the Act by itself imposes no bar to the initiation of proceedings in a criminal court even with reference to acts committed in relation to the affairs of a company, if those acts amount to offences like those punishable under S. 406, and 409 I.P.C S. 630 of the Act provides for a summary procedure. It authorises an officer or an employee of the company, and only these two, to apply under S. 630. The acts spcified in clauses (a) and (b) of S. 630(1) of the Act may not by themselves and with nothing more amount to criminal misappropriation as defined by the Indian Penal Code and made punishable under S. 406 or 409 I.P.C For example, knowingly applying any property of the company to purposes other than those expressed or directed in the articles and authorised by the Act falls within S. 630(1)(b): There might he nothing criminal, punishable under S. 406 of the Indian Penal Code in such an application. Yet it would fall under S. 630 of the Act. I have referred to these at some length only to explain the scope of S. 630 of the Act. It provides a summary remedy and the persons who are entitled to ask for that remedy are specified. It is confined to an officer or an employee of the company. Whether, when in proceedings initiated under S. 630 (1) of the Act a punishment follows, that would bar a conviction under S. 406 or 409 I P.C I am not called upon to decide in these proceedings and I express no opinion. We are still at the stage of initiation of proceedings. The Registrar of Companies could not himself invoke S. 630 of the Act. He complained to the police that offences punishable under ss. 406 and 409 I.P.C appeared to have been committed. Those are offences against the State. In the prosecution of a person suspected of having committed such offences, it is the State representing society as a whole that is interested. The benefits conferred by S. 630 of the Act are confined to the company, to its representatives specified by S. 630 itself. It is a little difficult to see any real basis for the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner, that S. 630 of the Act bars an investigation or prosecution for offences punishable under ss. 406 and 409 I.P.C.S 630 of the Act provides no statutory bar to the exercise of the jurisdiction vested in a police officer by ss. 154, 156 (1) and 157 (1), Cr.P.C
The learned counsel for the petitioner next referred to the provisions of the Act dealing with the powers of the Registrar and the Central Government, and in particular to ss. 234 and 242 of the Act. S. 242 (1) is only an enabling provision, as the use of the word “may” in the passage “the Central Government may, after taking such legal advice as it thinks fit prosecute such a person for the offence” indicates. By itself S. 242 (1) does not divest a police officer of the jurisdiction conferred upon him either under S. 154, 156 or 157 Cr.P.C No more than S. 630 of the Act does S. 242 bar the exercise of the jurisdiction of the third respondent to investigate into a complaint of the commission of cognisable offences punishable under ss. 406 and 409 of the Indian Penal Code.
I pointed out earlier that even if there was any irregularity or even illegality attendant on the letter dated 8-6-1955, which was treated as a complains by the police for purposes of investigation, neither the jurisdiction to investigate nor the exercise thereof by the police officer could be affected. The learned Advocate-General pointed out that it was not in the discharge of any statutory duties imposed upon him that the registrar sent the letter dated 8-6-1955, asking for an investigation by the Police. Even as a citizen he had the right to bring to the notice of the police that one or more cognizable offences had been committed. He set the machinery of law in motion, and that, he was entitled to do. It may not be necessary to discuss this aspect further for the disposal of this application. I am unable to accept the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner, that the Registrar did something illegal, something prohibited by the Act, when he addressed the letter on 8-6-1955, without availing himself of the powers vested in him by S. 234 and other relevant provisions of the Act. True, nothing in the Act specifically authorised him to prefer a complaint to the police. But then, there was no prohibition in the Act against asking the police to investigate into a case, where cognisable offences punishable under ss. 406 and 409 I.P.C were suspected to have been committed. There was nothing illegal about the letter dated 8-6-1955 which was eventually treated as a complaint in writing to a police officer within the meaning of S. 154(1) Cr.P.C
The learned counsel for the petitioner referred to Rishbud v. State of Delhi [1955] M.W.N 232 where the learned Judges laid down where the cognisance of the case has in fact been taken and the case proceeded to termination, the invalidity of the precedent investigation does not vitiate the result, unless miscarriage of justice has been caused thereby. Their Lordships laid down further:
“When such a breach is brought to the notice of the Court at an early stage of the trial, the Court will have to consider the nature and extent of the violation and pass appropriate orders for such reinvestigation as may be called for, wholly or partly, and by such officer as it considers appropriate………………………”
Apparently the learned counsel relied upon this principle to support his contention, that he was entitled to a writ of prohibition. But, as I have held, he failed to establish that the third respondent was doing anything illegal, anything prohibited by the statute in conducting the investigation with which he has been entrusted. The writ asked for is one of prohibition. If the third respondent had jurisdiction to undertake and continue the investigation, the writ asked for cannot issue. The third respondent has that jurisdiction. This application fails.
The rule is discharged and this petition is dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.
N.T.RPetition dismissed
Alert