- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramalinga Padayachi And Others v. Srinivsalu Naidu Alias Boorasami Naidu And Others.
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Delivered by the Chief Justice)
Factual and Procedural Background
These are two Letters Patent appeals (L.P.A. No. 15 of 1951 and L.P.A. No. 26 of 1951) arising out of the judgment of Viswanatha Sastri J. in A.S. No. 602 of 1946, which itself was an appeal from the decree of the Subordinate Judge of Cuddalore in O.S. No. 36 of 1944. The underlying suit sought possession of properties that had belonged to a joint family comprising the plaintiff, the first respondent (the minor at the time of the transactions) and his father, Sundararajulu Naidu (d. 29 December 1928).
After the father's death, the first defendant purported to act as guardian of the minor (the appointment under the father's will being invalid in law) and managed the minor's affairs as a de facto guardian. Two sale deeds executed by the first defendant while the first respondent was a minor are central to these appeals: Ex. D.33 dated 16 September 1936 (sale to the third defendant for Rs. 4,000) and Ex. D.1 dated 29 November 1936 (sale to the second defendant for Rs. 1,500). Both transactions were said to be in partial discharge of a chain of promissory notes traceable to Ex. D.26 (4 February 1926) and subsequent renewals, including Ex. D.29 (17 October 1930) and Ex. D.32 (20 March 1935).
At trial the two impugned alienations were held to be binding on the first respondent. Viswanatha Sastri J., on appeal in A.S. No. 602 of 1946, allowed the plaintiff's appeal in respect of these two sales and held they were not binding on the plaintiff-respondent. The present Letters Patent appeals were brought by the purchasers (one appeal by the fifth defendant relating to Ex. D.33; the other by the first and second defendants relating to Ex. D.1).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a de facto guardian of a Hindu minor can validly execute a promissory note or effect a sale in discharge of such a promissory note so as to bind the minor.
- Whether Section 68 of the Indian Contract Act (relating to reimbursement for necessaries supplied to a person incapable of entering into a contract) can validate an alienation of the minor's property to discharge a debt on behalf of the minor.
- Whether the equitable doctrine of subrogation (allowing a creditor who has paid the guardian's personal obligation to stand in the guardian's shoes and enforce reimbursement from the minor's estate) applies to justify the impugned alienations.
- Whether a surety (the second defendant) who has discharged or renewed liability has a right of indemnity against the minor's estate and whether an alienation in his favour (Ex. D.1) can be sustained as discharging that indemnity right.
Arguments of the Parties
Arguments advanced for the appellants / defendants
- Mr. Ramachandra Aiyar (for the fifth defendant, appellant in L.P.A. No. 15 of 1951) accepted that Ex. D.32 was not binding on the minor but advanced two distinct grounds to sustain the sale Ex. D.33:
- Section 68 of the Contract Act: argued that "necessaries" might include discharge of binding debts of a Hindu minor, and hence reimbursement could be claimed from the minor's estate.
- Principle of subrogation: relied on passages in the Federal Court decision in Sriramulu v. Pundarikakshayya to argue that a creditor who has paid a guardian's contractual obligation might be subrogated to the guardian's right of reimbursement out of the minor's estate.
- Mr. Viswanathan (for the appellant in L.P.A. No. 26 of 1951, the second defendant) contended that the second defendant, as surety for the debt originally owed by the father, retained a right to proceed against the plaintiff (and his estate) and, after discharging the debt, to obtain indemnity; the alienation (Ex. D.1) must be deemed to discharge the plaintiff's estate insofar as indemnifying the second defendant for Rs. 1,500 paid in partial discharge of the historical liability traced to Ex. D.28.
Arguments advanced for the plaintiff / first respondent
- Mr. Venkatarama Aiyar (for the plaintiff first respondent) argued that there was no evidence that the surety (second defendant) had been called upon by the creditor to pay the debt, and relied on the proposition (from Bashyam & Adiga on Negotiable Instruments Act) that a creditor taking a fresh security or note from one of several debtors may ordinarily have the effect of discharging the others.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sriramulu v. Pundarikakshayya (Federal Court) | The Federal Court held that a de facto guardian cannot in law execute a promissory note in the name of the minor that binds the minor; a sale by such a de facto guardian in discharge of such a promissory note will not bind the minor. The decision further explained circumstances in which the creditor might be subrogated to the guardian's right of reimbursement (subject to accounts between guardian and ward) or when the debt was for necessaries. | The court treated this decision as authoritatively applicable. It found that the principle established there meant Ex. D.32 and the sale under Ex. D.33 could not bind the minor. The court also considered, and rejected on the facts, the subrogation arguments that Sriramulu discussed. |
| Maharana Skri Rammal Singji v. Vadilal Vakhat Chand | The case concerned recoverability from a minor's estate of sums advanced by a creditor for purposes that were held not to be necessary; the debts could not be recovered from the minor's estate. | The court observed that this decision "has no direct bearing on this case" but cited it to illustrate limits of the doctrine of necessaries. |
| Subramanian Ohetti v. Muthiah Ohetti | (Referenced by counsel; the opinion does not detail the principle from this authority in the text.) | The court stated that that decision "has no bearing on the facts of the case before us." |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in two main strands corresponding to the two impugned alienations (Ex. D.33 and Ex. D.1).
1. Application of Sriramulu v. Pundarikakshayya to Ex. D.33 (sale to the third defendant):
- The court found that the legal rule in Sriramulu — that a de facto guardian cannot in law execute a promissory note in the name of the minor so as to bind the minor, and that a sale by a de facto guardian in discharge of such a promissory note will not bind the minor — applied to the facts before it.
- Counsel for the purchaser (Mr. Ramachandra Aiyar) conceded Ex. D.32 was not binding on the minor and therefore could not be relied on to support the sale as a discharge of a binding promissory note.
- The court addressed the two alternative grounds advanced to sustain the sale:
- Section 68 (necessaries): the court rejected the contention because no one had advanced moneys to discharge any debt binding on the minor so as to create a right of reimbursement from the minor's property. The court noted the minor was not under an obligation in respect of Ex. D.32.
- Subrogation: the court found no scope for subrogation on the facts. The question had not been pleaded; there was no evidence of the state of accounts between guardian and ward; and under Ex. D.32 the first defendant was not personally liable (a point conceded by counsel). The court also observed there was no cited decision where subrogation had been invoked successfully to support an alienation by a guardian. For these reasons the sale Ex. D.33 could not bind the first respondent.
- Conclusion on Ex. D.33: the court agreed with Viswanatha Sastri J. that the alienation could not bind the first respondent and consequently dismissed L.P.A. No. 15 of 1951 with costs.
2. Analysis of Ex. D.1 (sale to the second defendant) — different considerations:
- The court accepted the trial court's and Viswanatha Sastri J.'s finding that the primary liability under Ex. D.28 lay with the plaintiff's father and that the second defendant was only a surety; this factual finding was not challenged before the court.
- The court considered whether the second defendant, as surety, had the right to be indemnified out of the minor's estate after discharging the obligation, and whether the alienation Ex. D.1 could be deemed to discharge the minor's liability to indemnify the second defendant for Rs. 1,500 (paid in partial discharge of the historic liability traceable to Ex. D.28).
- Mr. Viswanathan argued (and the court found force in the argument) that the second defendant had the right to proceed against the plaintiff/father and, after discharging the debt, to be indemnified; the second defendant had acted within his rights in renewing his liability by executing Exs. D.29 and D.32.
- The court rejected the plaintiff's contention (Mr. Venkatarama Aiyar) that there was no evidence the surety was called upon to pay, noting Ex. D.2 — a notice dated 19 July 1935 from the creditor (the third defendant) calling upon the plaintiff's guardian and the second defendant to pay principal and interest due under Ex. D.32 — supported the position that the surety had been called upon.
- The court also addressed the suggestion that taking a fresh note from one of several debtors extinguishes liability of the others; it observed the creditor had in effect taken the fresh note from both debtors (the first defendant executed as guardian), and there was no manifest intention to discharge either debtor.
- On this basis the court concluded that the first defendant, even as a de facto guardian, was entitled to alienate the minor's property to discharge an obligation binding on the minor's estate — namely the obligation to reimburse the second defendant in Rs. 1,500 — and that Ex. D.1 must be deemed to be in discharge of that indemnity/liability.
- Accordingly, L.P.A. No. 26 of 1951 was allowed: the decree against the second defendant in respect of the property covered by Ex. D.1 in A.S. No. 602 of 1946 was set aside and the trial court's decree dismissing the suit as against the second defendant was restored.
- The appellant second defendant was awarded costs of the appeal both in this Court and before Viswanatha Sastri J.
Holding and Implications
Holding: L.P.A. No. 15 of 1951 — dismissed with costs; the alienation under Ex. D.33 is not binding on the first respondent.
L.P.A. No. 26 of 1951 — allowed; the decree against the second defendant in respect of the property covered by Ex. D.1 is set aside and the trial court's decree dismissing the suit as against the second defendant is restored. The second defendant is entitled to costs.
Implications:
- The immediate effect is that the sale under Ex. D.33 (to the third defendant) does not bind the first respondent, while the sale under Ex. D.1 (to the second defendant) stands to the extent it discharged the second defendant's right of indemnity in Rs. 1,500 traceable to the earlier indebtedness.
- The court applied existing Federal Court authority (Sriramulu v. Pundarikakshayya) to deny binding effect to alienations made by a de facto guardian in discharge of promissory notes that are not binding on the minor, and it clarified that subrogation and Section 68 arguments fail on the facts where there is no personal liability of the guardian under the relevant note, no pleading/evidence of accounts, and no payment by a third party that would create a right of reimbursement under Section 68.
- This opinion resolves the parties' rights in these appeals on the particular facts before the court; the court's reasoning relied on established authority rather than announcing a novel precedent in the text of the opinion.
Prepared strictly from the information contained in the provided opinion. No facts, arguments, or legal propositions have been added beyond what appears in the text.
(Delivered by the Chief Justice.)
These are two appeals under the Letters Patent against the judgment of Viswanatha Sastri J. in A.S No. 602 of 1946, which was an appeal preferred against the decree and judgment of the Court of the Subordinate Judge of Cuddalore in O.S No. 36 of 1944. That was a suit for possession of properties which had belonged to the first respondent and which bad been alienated by the first defendant acting as his guardian when the first respondent was a minor. The first respondent alleged that the alienations were not binding on him. The impugned alienations were four sales of which we are concerned in these appeals with two only, viz., those covered by sale deeds, Exs. D.33 and D.1 dated 16th September 1936 and 20th November 1936 respectively. The properties in suit belonged to the joint family consisting of the plaintiff, first respondent and his father, one Sundararajulu Naidu who died on 29th December 1928. Sundararajulu Naidu is alleged to have left a will dated 29th December 1928 appointing the first defendant, a relation, as the guardian of his minor son, the first respondent, and his properties. The first defendant, it is common ground, managed the affairs of the first respondent during his minority. It was not disputed before us that the appointment of the first defendant as the testamentary guardian of the first respondent was not valid in law, and therefore the status of the first defendant was only that of a de facto guardian, Both the alienations with which we are concerned in these appeals can be traced to a debt which was admittedly due by Sundararajulu Naidu under a promissory note, Ex. D.26, dated 4th February 1926, executed by him and the second defendant for a sum of Rs. 4200-2-3. This promissory note itself appears to have been in renewal of an earlier promissory note, but that is of no consequence. It was alleged, and it has been found, by both the trial Court and by the learned Judge on appeal, that in respect of this promissory note the second defendant was only a surety, and it was the father of the first respondent who was the principal debtor. After the father's death, a promissory note was executed by defendants 1 and 2 on 17th October 1930, Ex. D.29, for discharge of the amount due under Ex. D.28 In this promissory note, the first defendant is thus described:
“Rangaswanii Naidu, son of A.S Veeraswmi Nayudu, guardian of minor Srinivasulu alias Bhuvarahaswami Nayudu, son of late A.S Sundararajulu Naidu.”
There were several successive endorsements of this promissory note, till finally it was transferred to one Pankajammal. There were two payments in October 1933 and March 1934, which were acknowledged by the first and second defendants on the promissory note. On 20th March 1935, defendants 1 and 2 executed a fresh promissory note in favour of the said Pankajammal for Rs. 5898-2-0 in discharge of the debt due under Ex. D.29 This promissory note Ex. D.32, was in its turn endorsed to the thud defendant on 15th July 1935. It purports to be executed by the minor represented by his guardian, the first defendant. The first defendant executed a sale deed, Ex. D.33, on 16th September 1936 in favour of the third defendant, conveying some of the suit items for Rs. 4000, the consideration going in partial discharge of the promissory note, Ex. D.32 On 29th November 1936, the first defendant conveyed certain other items in suit to the second defendant himself, Ex. D.1, for a sum of Rs. 1500, which amount was paid by the second defendant to the third defendant, in partial discharge of Ex. D.32 The first respondent impugned these two sale deeds as not binding on him. The learned Judge, who tried the suit, held that they were binding on the first respondent and dismissed the suit in respect of these two alienations. The plaintiff appealed to this Court (A.S No. 602 of 1946). Viswanatha Sastri J. allowed the appeal in respect of these two sale deeds which he held were not binding on the plaintiff-respondent. L.P.A No. 15 of 1951 is by the fifth defendant, and L.P.A No. 26 of 1951 is by the first and second defendants and relate to the two alienations respectively.
On the facts set out above, there appears to us to be no doubt as to the law to be applied, because it has been authoritatively enunciated by the Federal Court in Sriramulu v. Pundarikakshayya(1). The facts of the case before the Federal Court are substantially similar to the facts in the case before us. There the plaintiff was the adopted son of one Chalamayya. When he was a minor, his estate was being managed by his adoptive mother. She, as the de jure guardian of the minor, executed on 23rd April 1925 a promissory note in renewal of an earlier promissory note which had been executed by Chalamayya himself in 1923 to the defendant, On the Same date, she also executed another promissory rote to the defendant for the fees due to him for professional work done during the lifetime of Chalamayya. On 23rd April 1928, she executed a consolidated promissory note in renewal of the two previous notes. She died in November 1928 and thereafter the plaintiff's natural father, China Seshayya, entered upon the management of the estate. He acted as the de facto guardian of the minor plaintiff. On 22nd June 1931, Seshayya, professing to act as the guardian of the minor plaintiff, purported to renew the promissory note of 1928. On 2nd June 1932, Seshayya conveyed immoveable properties belonging to the minor to the defendant in discharge of the debt due under the promissory note and a sum of Rs. 4596-9-6 paid to another creditor. The plaintiff, after attaining majority, instituted a suit in which he attacked the validity of this alienation. It was held both by this Court and by the Federal Court that a de facto guardian of a Hindu minor could not in law execute a promissory note in the name of the minor even in respect of a debt binding on the minor's estate, and a sale by such a de facto guardian in discharge of such promissory note executed by him would not bind the minor, in the face of this decision Mr. Ramachandra Aiyar, learned Counsel for the 5th defendant, appellant in L.P.A No. 15 of 1951, could not, and did not, contend that the promissory note Ex. D.32 was binding on the minor, nor that the sale to the third defendant could be supported on the ground that it was in partial discharge of that promissory note. He, however, sought to sustain the validity of the sale on two grounds. The first ground was based on S. 68 of the Contract Act which runs as follows:
“If a person incapable of entering into a contract, or any one whom be is legally bound to support is supplied by another person with necessaries suited to his condition in life, the person who has furnished such supplies is entitled to be reimbursed from the property of such incapable person.”
His argument was that the term “necessaries” in this section would include a discharge of binding debts in the case of a Hindu minor. But assuming this is so, we fail to see how this section can in any way help the appellant to maintain the validity of the sale. No one here has advanced moneys to discharge any debt binding on the minor to entitle that person to be reimbursed from the property of the minor. Nor does the following passage from Trevelyan on the “Law relating to Minors” 5th Edn. carry the matter any further:
“The circumstances that to meet the necessities of his ward the guardian has pledged his personal credit, does not disentitle him to charge or sell the ward's property, bat he can only charge or sell it for the purpose of paying money which the minor was under an obligation to pay,”
We have found that the minor is not under an obligation to pay anything under the promissory note, Ex. D.32, to discharge which the alienation was made. The decision in Maharana Skri Rammal Singji v. Vadilal Vakhat Chand, has no direct bearing on this case. There, a creditor sued to recover from the minor and his estate a sum advanced by him for the purpose of a pilgrimage undertaken by the minor's mother and to defray the expenses of the minor himself. The learned Judges held that the debts were not contracted for necessary purposes, and could not be recovered from the minor's estate.
The second ground was based on the principle of subrogation. Certain passages from the judgments of the learned Judges in the decision of the Federal Court were relied upon by Mr. Ramachandra Aiyar. Kania C.J observed (page 591):
“In my opinion it is therefore right to hold that when a loan is taken for the purpose of necessity or benefit of the minor's estate by a de facto manager, he cannot effect a transaction so as to exclude his own liability. So far as the creditor is concerned, this involves no hardship because he can proceed against the de facto manager and make the minor's estate liable on the principle of subrogation.”
Fazl Ali J. said at page 596:
“There may however be cases in which the minor's needs have to be met and in such cases, the third principle enunciated by the Privy Council can come into play, that is to say the manager or guardian can show that the estate ought to bear the burden which he had taken upon himself. In such cases, by the principle of subrogation the creditor might be allowed to stand in the shoes of the guardian and invoke the latter's right to reimbursement out of the minor's estate. That right must usually be subject to the estate of accounts between the guardian and his ward.”
Mukherjea J. deals with this point at greater length than the other two learned Judges thus (page 609):
“When the guardian himself is party to the contract in his capacity as guardian, a suit can certainly be instituted against him and a decree obtained. But simply because the defendant issued in his capacity as guardian the estate of the ward cannot be proceeded against in execution of the decree obtained in such suit. In order to bind the minor's estate, the minor must also be made a party to the suit property represented. Now on what basis can a decree be made in such a suit making the minor's estate liable for the money borrowed by the guardian? The minor being incapable of being a party to a contract there could be No direct contractual liability established against him or his estate. But as the guardian was personally liable under the contract, he would be entitled to reimbnrsemet from the minor's estate under the rule of Hindu law if the borrowing was for necessity or benefit of the minor. The creditor in such circumstances can invoke the equitable doctrine of subrogation in his favour and claim to be placed in the position of the guardian for enforcement of the latter's right of reimbursement against the minor's estate. Instead of there being two suits, one by the creditor against the guardian and the other by the guardian against the minor, both the reliefs may be worked out in one and the same suit and thereby multiplicity of litigation could be avoided. This is the only proper way in which the Hindu law rights of the guardian in the matter of contractual debts for necessity or benefit of the minor could be given effect to in perfect consonance with the well established principles of the law of contract and the ordinary rules of procedure in personal actions. The application of this rule would be just and equitable to the minor also. As the creditor stands only in the shoes of the guardian and can claim the rights of indemnity which the latter can assert against the minor's property it would be open to the minor to show that the guardian himself was in default and would not be entitled to any indemnity if accounts were properly taken.
Again, at page 610:
“The position therefore is that in case of contractual debts borrowed either on simple bonds or promissory notes, the creditor can have recourse to the minor's estate indirectly on principle of subrogation, when the guardian has the right of indemnity against the estate of the ward; and he would have the right of direct reimbursement out of the properties of the infant, only when the debt is for necessaries supplied to the infant.”
In our opinion, there is no scope for the application of this principle of subrogation in this case. In the first place, there was no pleading raising this question. And as the learned Judge, Viswanatha Sastri J. points out, there was no attempt to justify a claim based on the right of indemnity available to a de facto guardian. There was no evidence of the state of accounts as between the de facto guardian and the minor. Under Ex. D.32 in partial discharge of which the sale deed, Ex. D.33, was executed, the first defendant was not personally liable, and this position is accepted by Mr. Ramachandra Aiyar. He, therefore, fell back on the prior promissory note, Ex. D.29 But the learned Counsel for the appellant was unable to cite any decision in which the principle of subrogation has been invoked successfully to support an alienation by the guardian. We therefore, agree with Viswanatha Sastri J. that the alienation under Ex. D.33 could not bind the first respondent. L.P.A No. 15 of 1951 is dismissed with costs.
The alienation, which is the subject matter in L.P.A No. 26 of 1951 in favour of the second defendant stands on a different footing. As already mentioned, Viswanatha Sastri, J., did not disturb the finding of the trial Court that the primary liability for the debt due under Ex. D.28 was of the plaintiff's father and that the second defendant was only a surety. This finding was not challenged before us. The learned Judge, however, held that under Ex. D.29 the second defendant must be deemed to be only a surety for the first defendant and the creditor could not have enforced the payment of the debt from the plaintiff or his estate under Ex. D.29 or the later promissory note, Ex. D.32 Mr. Viswanathan, learned Counsel for the appellant, contended that the second defendant as surety had always a right to proceed against the plaintiff's father, and after his death against the plaintiff and his estate, after discharging the debt, and this right would not be lost even if the original liability of the plain tiff's father did not subsist on the date of the discharge. The second defendant was undoubtedly acting within his rights in renewing his liability by executing the two later promissory notes, Exs. D.29 and D.32 The alienation in his favour, Ex. D.1, must be deemed to be in discharge of the liability of the plaintiff and his estate, to indemnify the second defendant as surely in the sum of Rs. 1,500 which he paid to the creditor. We see considerable force in this contention of the appellant's Counsel. Mr. Venkatarama Aiyar for the plaintiff first respondent urged that there was no evidence that the surety was called upon by the creditor to pay the debt. But this objection is not tenable in the face of Ex. D.2 a notice issued by the creditor, the third defendant, on 19th July 1935, calling upon the plaintiff's guardian and the second defendant to pay the principal and interest due under Ex. D.32 Mr. Venkatarama Aiyar then relied upon the fact that a fresh promissory note was taken by the creditor, Ex. D.29, the result of which in law be the extinguishment of the liability under the prior note Ex. D.28 He relied upon the following passage in Bashyam and Adiga on the Negotiable Instruments Act:
“If the creditor takes a fresh security or a separate bill or note from one of several partners who are already his debtors or parties to a bill or note or otherwise, it has ordinarily the effect of discharging the other co-partner.”
But, immediately, we find the following:
‘But he may reserve his right against the others.”
There is no scope in this case for the application of this rule. The creditor did not take a fresh security or bill from one of the debtors. He in effect took from both the debtors, because it is obvious that the first defendant executed the promissory note as guardian of the minor plaintiff. There is no intention manifest to discharge either of the debtors. The decision in Subramanian Ohetti v. Muthiah Ohetti, has no bearing on the facts of the case before us.
In our opinion, the first defendant, even as a de facto guardian of the minor was entitled to alienate the minor's property to discharge an obligation binding on the minors estate, namely, the obligation to reimburse the second defendant in the sum of Rs. 1,500 which went in partial discharge of the liability which can be traced to Ex. D-28. This aspect of the case was not evidently emphasised before Viswanatha Sastri, J. In this view, L.P.A No. 26 of 1951 must be allowed. The decree against the second defendant in respect of the property covered by Ex. D.1 passed in A.S No. 602 of 1946 is set aside and the decree of the trial Court dismissing the suit as against the second defendant is restored. The appellant second defendant will be entitled to the costs of the appeal here and before Viswanatha Sastri, J.
V.C.S
Alert