- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mothey Krishna Rao v. Grandhi Anjaneyulu And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, Mothey Krishna Rao (plaintiff below), sued for a declaration that he continued to be the Secretary and Treasurer of Sri Krishna Jute Mills Ltd., Eluru. The learned Additional Subordinate Judge of Eluru dismissed that suit with costs. The factual incidents leading to the suit, as described in the opinion, are:
- At a Board meeting on 1-7-1950 defendants 1 to 4 caused such disorder that police intervention was necessary. After the plaintiff left the room, defendants 1 to 4 passed a resolution co-opting defendant 5 as director, suspending the plaintiff as Secretary and Treasurer, and appointing defendant 2 to act temporarily in those duties.
- The plaintiff obtained an order in his favour under Section 144 CrPC in the Stationary Sub-Magistrate's Court but that order was vacated by the High Court on 24-3-1950.
- Exhibit A-5 is a letter from defendant 2 (Chairman and acting Secretary and Treasurer) forwarding the Board's resolution which found the plaintiff guilty of certain charges, suspended him, and recommended his outright dismissal to an extraordinary general meeting to be convened.
- The Board did not hold such a meeting to implement the recommendation; instead, on 25-7-1950 the Board removed the plaintiff from the post of Secretary. The suit for a declaration was filed on 1-10-1950.
- The company was formed in 1904. Initially, Article 111 appointed joint Secretaries and Treasurers and included a proviso that they could be removed only by a resolution at an extraordinary general meeting by at least a three-fourths majority. Article 114 regulated remuneration; amendments in 1935 and on 12-3-1938 (by extraordinary general meeting) made Mothey Krishna Rao the sole Secretary and Treasurer and deleted the protective proviso in Article 111. At the 1938 meeting Article 114 was again amended to adjust remuneration.
- The plaintiff was also a substantial shareholder and, since 1940, the company had been leasing the Jute Mills to a lessee, limiting day-to-day duties for the Secretary.
- After the suit was filed, ancillary proceedings (commissioner appointed, receiver appointed on appeal, a general meeting where six directors were re-elected) occurred, but the Court regarded those subsequent events as immaterial to the merits of this appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, under the Articles of Association, the Board of Directors had the power to remove the plaintiff from the offices of Secretary and Treasurer, or whether only the general body of shareholders by a special resolution at an extraordinary general meeting could remove him.
- Whether a shareholder or office-holder can sue the company for a declaration based on rights asserted to arise directly from the Articles of Association (i.e., whether the Articles operate as a contract enforceable by the plaintiff).
- Whether the Court may grant a mere declaratory relief (that the plaintiff continues to be Secretary and Treasurer) without consequential relief, in view of the proviso to the relevant provision of the Specific Relief Act (referred to in the opinion as the proviso to Section 42 / Section 142 of the Specific Relief Act).
- Whether the Court can grant specific enforcement or injunctive relief of duties or office when the relief would amount to specific performance of a contract of personal service (referencing Section 21 of the Specific Relief Act as to categories not specifically enforceable).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (Mr. Thiruvenkatachari)
- The appellant confined his case to a pure question of law: that under the Articles of Association the Board of Directors was not competent to remove the plaintiff from the offices of Secretary and Treasurer.
- He contended that the plaintiff had been appointed by a special resolution at an extraordinary general meeting and therefore only that authority (the general body by special resolution) could lawfully remove him.
- He relied on the historical amendments to the Articles (notably the substitution of Article 111 appointing the plaintiff sole Secretary and Treasurer and the deletion of the original proviso protecting removal) as the factual foundation for his legal position.
- On discovering a technical defect in the plaint (seeking only a declaration), he sought permission at the close of argument to amend the plaint to add a consequential injunction restraining defendants from interfering with the plaintiff's exercise of the powers and duties as Secretary and Treasurer.
Respondents' Arguments (Mr. Thyagarajan)
- The defendants argued that the Board of Directors had full power to remove the Secretary by virtue of Article 112 (which describes wide powers of Joint Secretaries and Treasurers to appoint, remove or suspend staff "upon such terms and conditions as they shall think proper", subject to the general control of the Board).
- Article 99 was cited as conferring on Directors all powers not expressly directed to be exercised by the company in general meeting; thus the Board retained authority.
- It was noted that the protective proviso to the original Article 111 had been specifically omitted when the plaintiff became sole Secretary and Treasurer, leaving him without the earlier protection under the Articles.
- He distinguished statutory protection given to Managing Agents under Section 87.B(f) of the Companies Act (requiring general meeting approval for removal) from any protection for a mere Secretary, arguing no similar statutory protection existed for the plaintiff.
- Mr. Thyagarajan pointed out that the Board itself initially proposed that the dismissal be effected by general meeting (as per Ex. A-5), but subsequently the Board acted itself to suspend and remove the plaintiff.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Eley v. Positive Govt. Security Life Assurance Co. Ltd., (1876) 1 Ex D 88 (on appeal from (1876) 1 Ex 20) | The articles are an agreement inter socios; an appointment in the articles (as solicitor for life) was regarded as res inter alios acta for the individual concerned; a shareholder could not sue the company on the articles as if they were a contract with him. | Used to support the proposition that a party cannot sue the company on the basis of the Articles where the right asserted is personal to him; indicates limitation on treating articles as a contractual basis for personal appointment claims. |
| Brown v. La Trinidad, (1887) 37 Ch. D. | Followed the view that articles do not create enforceable personal contractual rights beyond member rights generally. | Cited among authorities reinforcing the rule that the articles are not typically a source of enforceable personal employment rights against the company. |
| Hickman v. Kent, (1915) 1 Ch. 881 | Reviewed authorities and held that articles constitute a contract between the company and its members in respect of their ordinary rights as members (Astbury J.'s review noted). | Referenced to show the nuanced position that while articles bind members inter se for ordinary member rights, they do not ordinarily give individual members special contractual rights enforceable as personal service contracts. |
| Beattie v. Beattie Ltd., 1933 Ch. 703 | Followed the established view limiting the contractual effect of the articles in respect of individual personal rights. | Appears with other authorities to show consistent judicial approach that the articles do not confer enforceable personal employment rights against the company. |
| Port Darwin Gold Mining Co., (1889) 1 Meg. 385 | Example where Court inferred an implied contract from the articles (articles provided for specified director remuneration); the articles were used to derive terms upon which the director served. | Referred to as an instance where courts have treated articles as evidence of terms of service and inferred an implied contract; Court noted such decisions but observed the question of whether an implied contract can be varied against the other party has not been finally decided. |
| Ramkumar Potdar v. Sholapur Spinning & Weaving Co. Ltd., AIR 1934 Bom 427 | The Court will not interfere with internal management and will not ordinarily enforce termination or termination disputes of employment contracts at the instance of a minority shareholder; the memorandum is not a contract with third parties; Court will not order specific enforcement of personal service. | Relied upon to show judicial reluctance to interfere with internal company management and to refuse specific enforcement of contracts for personal service; supports denial of relief sought by a member/minority asserting personal employment rights. |
| I.M. Lall related authorities: I.M. Lall v. Secretary of State, AIR 1944 Lah 240; Secretary of State v. I.M. Lall, AIR 1945 PC 47; High Commissioner for India v. I.M. Lall, AIR 1948 PC 121 | Instances where Courts (including Privy Council) granted a declaration that removal was void but did not grant consequential relief in circumstances explained in those decisions; showed special circumstances where a declaration was given without awarding further relief. | The Court distinguished those cases and held they could not be treated as general authority for bypassing the proviso to the Specific Relief Act; the I.M. Lall line was not a basis here to permit a mere declaratory order in place of appropriate consequential relief where the plaintiff omitted to seek it. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court approached the matter principally as a question of law about the legal effect of the Memorandum and Articles of Association and the remedies available when a complainant relies upon rights asserted under the Articles. The step-by-step reasoning in the opinion is as follows:
- Scope of Suit: The Court observed that the suit was narrowly framed and confined to the Articles of Association. The plaintiff had not sued for damages for wrongful removal but only for a declaration that he continued to be Secretary and Treasurer because, he asserted, the Board lacked power under the Articles to remove him.
- Statutory Foundation: The opinion cited Section 21 of the Indian Companies Act (quoted in the judgment) that the memorandum and articles, when registered, bind the company and members "to the same extent as if they respectively had been signed by each member" subject to the Act. The Court then reviewed the judicial authorities interpreting the contractual effect of articles.
- Judicial Authorities: The Court reviewed an established line of English decisions (including Eley and others) laying down that the Articles do not usually give rise to enforceable personal contracts between the company and an individual office-holder or outsider; rather the articles operate inter se among members for ordinary rights. The Court acknowledged that in some cases (e.g., Port Darwin) courts have inferred implied contracts from articles as to terms of service, but it observed that it had been referred to no decision where a shareholder, after removal from office in the company, succeeded in obtaining a declaration that the removal was invalid and that he continued to hold the office.
- Effect of Appointment: The Court found that the plaintiff's appointment as Secretary must be regarded as one "de hors" (outside) the Articles and governed by an independent contract between the plaintiff and the company. However, there was no evidence of any contract outside the Articles; the only material was the Articles themselves.
- Maintainability of Relief: The Court identified a procedural/statutory impediment: the plaint sought only a bare declaration without consequential relief. The Court relied on the proviso to the relevant provision of the Specific Relief Act (referred to in the opinion as the proviso to Section 42 / Section 142) which limits making declarations where the plaintiff, though able to seek further relief than a mere declaration, omits to do so. The Court held that the plaint's omission to seek consequential relief (such as damages) was a bar to granting the declaration alone.
- Attempted Amendment: The appellant sought belated permission to amend the plaint to add an injunction restraining defendants from interfering with plaintiff's exercise of the powers and duties. The Court allowed the amendment but observed that this brought into play Section 21 of the Specific Relief Act (provisions about contracts not specifically enforceable) and the principle that courts do not specifically enforce contracts of personal service.
- Specific Performance / Personal Service: The Court concluded that the declaration sought together with the consequential relief effectively amounted to specific performance or enforcement of a contract of personal service; Section 21 of the Specific Relief Act (as described in the judgment) sets out categories of contracts which cannot be specifically enforced. Consequently, the Court could not grant the specific-type relief sought.
- Other Considerations: The Court noted it was unnecessary to decide whether the Board was competent to remove the plaintiff as a Director (under Article 96 and the requirement of a three-fourths extraordinary general meeting reference to Section 86-G) because the plaintiff's claim was only in his capacity as Secretary and Treasurer and his directorship was derived from that appointment.
- Rejection of Subordinate Judge's Reasoning: The Court rejected the Subordinate Judge's reason for maintaining the suit (that company property being in "custodia legis" by magisterial proceedings prevented seeking consequential relief) observing that magisterial custody during Section 145/145-type proceedings does not displace the civil court's jurisdiction or render a mere declaration appropriate.
- Distinguishing Authorities: The Court distinguished the I.M. Lall decisions (where a declaration was granted without consequential relief) on the basis that those cases involved special circumstances and did not constitute a general authority to bypass the proviso to the Specific Relief Act.
- Final Assessment: For these reasons — inability to sue on the ARTICLES as a source of enforceable personal rights in the form claimed, absence of substantive contractual evidence outside the Articles, and statutory limits on declaratory relief and the specific enforcement of personal service contracts — the Court found it impossible to grant the plaintiff the relief as framed.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The Court's final decision was to dismiss the appeal. The core ruling is:
APPEAL DISMISSED.
Consequences and implications:
- The plaintiff was not entitled to the declaratory relief as framed because he could not properly invoke the Articles of Association as a contractual basis for personal rights in the manner advanced, and because the plaint omitted consequential relief which the proviso to the Specific Relief Act precludes the Court from ignoring.
- The Court allowed a belated amendment to seek injunctive relief but held that such relief would amount to specific performance of a contract of personal service, which is not enforceable under the provisions of the Specific Relief Act relied upon in the opinion; accordingly such relief could not be granted.
- The Court directed that the parties should bear their own costs throughout.
- The opinion did not purport to lay down any broad new precedent; it distinguished prior authorities relied upon by the appellant and treated the outcome as dictated by existing principles limiting reliance on the Articles as a source of enforceable personal employment rights and by statutory bars on enforcing personal service contracts.
B/H.G.P
JUDGMENT
1. Appellant, Mothey Krishna Rao, is the plaintiff, whose suit for a declaration that “he is the Secretary and Treasurer of Sri Krishna Jute Mills Ltd. Eluru” has been dismissed with costs by the learned Additional Subordinate Judge of Eluru. Defendants 1 to 4 were Directors of this company when on 1-7-1950 a meeting of the Board ended in disorder and confusion which necessitated police intervention to restore order. According to the plaint, after the regular business on the agenda had been done, defendants 1 to 4 wanted other matters brought up, which led to this fiasco. After the plaintiff left the room, defendants 1 to 4 passed a resolution co-opting defendant 5 as director, suspending the plaintiff from the post of Secretary and Treasurer and appointing defendant 2 to look after the duties of Secretary and Treasurer temporarily. Plaintiff filed a petition under Section 144 of the Cr PC in the Stationary Sub-Magistrate's Court and obtained an order in his favour, which was vacated by the High Court on 24-3-1950. Ex. A-5 is a letter written by defendant 2 as Chairman of the Board and Secretary and Treasurer to the plaintiff forwarding to him copy of the Board's resolution, which found him guilty of certain charges, suspended him from acting as Secretary and Treasurer, with a recommendation for his outright dismissal to an extraordinary general body meeting to be convened for the purpose along with the annual general body meeting to be held during the year. This course, however, was not adopted and on 25-7-1950 the Board removed the plaintiff from the post of Secretary. This suit was filed on 1-10-1950.
2. The scope of the suit is very limited and confined to the Articles of Association of the Company. Plaintiff has not sued for damages for wrongful removal or dismissal, but for a declaration that he still continues to be the Secretary and Treasurer on the ground that the Board had no power to remove him under the Articles of Association. There has been no argument before us at all on the merits of the removal of the plaintiff or as regards any alleged misconduct by him, which justified his removal. Mr. Thiruvenkatachari for the appellant took his stand on this pure question of law that under the Articles of Association the Board of Directors was not competent to remove the plaintiff, and that the only competent authority, which could remove him was the general body of shareholders by a special resolution at an extraordinary general meeting. To appreciate this contention, it is necessary to consider the relevant articles and the genesis of the plaintiff's appointment as Secretary and Treasurer. This company was formed in 1904 and under Art. 111, plaintiff's uncle Mothey Gangarazu and Venkata Subbarao were the first Joint Secretaries and Treasurers of the company. The article contained an important proviso, that it shall be lawful for the company to remove them and appoint others in their place by resolution passed at an extraordinary general meeting by a majority of not less than three-fourths of the shareholders of the company. Article 114 regulated the remuneration of the Joint Secretaries, Treasurers and Manager. In 1935 at an extraordinary general meeting, a new Art. 114 was substituted fixing the remuneration for Secretaries and Treasurers at 9 per cent, on the net profits or Rs. 4000 a year, whichever is higher. Under Art. 114-A. the plaintiff Mothey Krishna Rao was appointed working Secretary and Treasurer entitled to draw the whole of this remuneration. Article ill was not itself amended till 12-3-1938 also by a resolution at an extraordinary general meeting. In its place was substituted the following:
“Mr. Mothey Krishna Rao, Zamindar, Eluru shall be the sole Secretary and Treasurer.”
3. At that same meeting, there was an amendment to Art. 114 entitling him to remuneration of only a commission of 9 per cent on the net profits of the company. It is noteworthy that the proviso to Art. 111 that the original Joint Secretaries and Treasurers could not be removed, except by a resolution at an extraordinary general meeting was specifically deleted when the plaintiff was appointed sole Secretary and Treasurer.
4. The plaint case is based entirely on the legal position sought to be made out of the fact that by this combination of circumstances the appointment of the plaintiff as sole Secretary and Treasurer was in fact from 1933, Art. 111. It is common ground that plaintiff is himself a substantial shareholder and that the company did not itself run the Jute Mills from 1940 since when it had been annually leased out to the East India Commercial Company, Calcutta. There was, therefore, apparently not much day-to-day business for the sole Secretary to do.
5. The short point for consideration is the legal effect of the Memorandum and the Articles of Association. Under Section 21 of the Indian Companies Act,
“The memorandum and articles shall, when registered, bind the company and the members thereof to the same extent as if they respectively had been signed by each member and contained a covenant on the part of each member, his heirs and legal representatives, to observe all the provisions of the Memorandum and of the Articles, subject to the provisions of this Act.”
6. There is long catena of English decisions, which have unhesitatingly laid down that not only a third party, but even a shareholder cannot sue the company on anything contained in the Articles, treating the Articles as a contract by the company with him, and that it is incumbent on the party suing to make out a contract outside and independently of the articles. In the earliest case — ‘Eley v. Positive Govt. Security Life Assurance Co. Ltd.’, (1876) 1 Ex D 88 on appeal from (1876) 1 Ex 20 (A), the articles contained a clause providing that A should be employed for life as Solicitor for the company end should not be removed except for misconduct. He took office and later became a shareholder. The company discontinued his employment. While still a shareholder, he sued in damages for breach of contract. It was held that no action lay. The Court of Appeal disposed of the matter summarily. Lord Cairns L.C refusing the plaintiff relief observing that the articles were an agreement ‘inter socios’ whereas the appointment of Eley as Solicitor for life in the articles so far as he was concerned was ‘res inter alios acta’. Eley had advanced a sum of £. 200 to be expended in the formation of the company and the company-promoter arranged that he should be appointed permanent solicitor for life.
7. This view was followed in — ‘Brown v. La Trinidad’. (1887) 37 Ch. D. (B) — ‘Hickman v. Kent’. (1915) 1 Ch. 881 (C) and — ‘Beattie v. Beattie Ltd.’, 1933-Ch. 703 (D) and in a number of other decisions, which need not, be specifically cited. In. — ‘(1915) 1-Ch. 881 (C), the authorities as to whether the articles constitute contract as between the company and its members were reviewed by Astbury J. who decided that the result of apparently ??? decisions and dicta was that though the articles can neither constitute a contract between the company and an outsider, nor give any individual member of the company special contractual rights beyond those of the members, generally, they do in fact constitute a contract between a company and its members in respect of their ordinary rights, as members (See Buckley's Companies Act, 11th Edn. page 35).
8. Palmer has at pp. 30 and 31 of his Company Law, 19th Edn., indicated the difficulty of reconciling the rule in these cases with Section 20 of the English Act of 1948 which corresponds to S. 21 of our Act. There have been a series of cases in which Courts have inferred from the articles themselves implied contracts. In the case of — ‘??? v. Port Darwin Gold Mining Co.’, (1889) 1 Meg. 385 (E), the articles provided for the payment to each Director by way of remuneration of & specified sum per annum. The company reduced this, by a special resolution, whereupon the plaintiff resigned and sued the company for three months' remuneration for services prior to the date of his resignation. The Court held that he was entitled, to recover on the footing of an implied contract in the terms of the clause. “The articles”, said Lord Esher, “do not themselves form a ??? but from them you get the terms upon which the Director is serving.” The articles ??? constitute evidence in a wide field such as the terms of remuneration of Managing Director, Secretaries, Treasurers and so on. Palmer has observed at p. 31 that the question whether an implied contract so entered into was capable of being varied by the company against the will of the other party has not been finally decided and he has cited decisions, which appear to take different views. A discussion of those decisions would not be relevant for purposes of the present appeal. We have been referred to no decision either in English or in Indian law in which a share-holder has succeeded, after removal from an office in the company, in obtaining a declaration that such removal was invalid and that despite it he continues to hold the office.
9. Mr. Thiruvenkatachari for the appellant has taken his stand on the basis that as the plaintiff was appointed by a special resolution at an extraordinary general body meeting, that is the only authority which can legally remove him according to the articles of association. Mr. Thyagarajan for the defendants has argued contra that the Directors of the company have full powers to remove the Secretary by virtue of Art. 112, which defines the wide powers of Joint Secretaries and Treasurers, inter alia, to appoint, to remove or suspend Managers, Engineers, clerks and so on upon such terms and conditions as they shall think proper, subject of course to the general control of the Board of Directors. Article 99 confers on Directors all powers, which are not expressly directed to be exercised by the company in general meeting. Mr. Thyagarajan urges that the proviso to the original Art. 111 having been specifically omitted, to be plaintiff is bereft of any protection even under the articles, and that the Board had full powers to remove him as secretary. He also argued that Managing Agents cam under Section 87.B(f) of the Companies Act be removed only subject to approval by a resolution at as general meeting of the company and that no such statutory protection is given to a mere Secretary. As regards the contention that the plaintiff, having been appointed by a special resolution at an extraordinary general meeting can only be removed by the authority who appointed him and not by the Board or Directors, it would indeed appear that this was also the view taken by the Board itself when in their original resolution contained in the letter Ex. A. 5 communicating to the plaintiff his suspension, they recommended his outright dismissal to be given effect to at a general body meeting. This recommendation however was not implemented before this suit was filed and we have instead the Board itself just suspending “him” and then removing him outright.
10. The plaintiff is also, by virtue of his position as Secretary, an ex-officio Director under Art. 82. A Director may be removed under Art. 96 only by a resolution at an extraordinary general body meeting with a three-fourths majority in accordance also with Section 86-G of the Companies Act. We do not think that it is necessary for us to decide in this suit as framed whether the Board of Directors at a meeting was competent to remove the plaintiff from the post of Secretary and Treasurer and whether this can only be validly done by a special resolution at an extraordinary general body meeting. The plaintiff has sued only in his capacity as Secretary and Treasurer and as Mr. Thyagarajan has urged, his position as Director is derived from his appointment as Secretary. We find on the pure question of law, on which this appeal is pressed, that the plaintiff has no cause of action against the company as such on the basis of the Articles of Association and that his appointment as Secretary must be regarded as one ‘de hors’ the articles and governed by an independent contract as between the plaintiff and the company, as regards which, there is no other evidence apart from the articles themselves.
11. In — ‘Ramkumar Potdar v. Sholapur Spinning & Weaving Co. Ltd.’, AIR 1934 Bom 427 (F), a Bench of the Bombay High Court held that the Court does not interfere with the internal management of the affairs of a company and that, if a majority of shareholders consider that a particular contract of employment should be terminated, the Court would not ordinarily consider the matter at the instance of a minority of shareholders. It further held that the memorandum of association of a limited company does not constitute a contract between the company and the third party, who may be mentioned therein and that the Court would not make an order, the effect of which would be to enforce specifically a contract of personal service.
12. In this suit filed for a bare declaration, there are two other hurdles in the way of a Court giving plaintiff any relief. Plaintiff has not sued for damages in breach of contract but for a declaration without any consequential relief, which is in ‘prima facie’ violation of the proviso to Section 142 of the Specific Relief Act. Section 42 gives the Court discretion to declare a person entitled to any legal character or to right as to any property, with a proviso that no Court shall make any such declaration where the plaintiff being able to seek further relief than a mere declaration of title omits to do so. In the present suit, the plaintiff has not asked for relief by way of damages consequent on the wrongful termination of his services as Secretary and Treasurer, which is a normal relief claimed in cases where the services of a servant or employee are wrongfully terminated.
13. Mr. Thiruvenkatachari has sought to draw a line distinction between the case of a person who has been removed by an authority incompetent to do so and by a person wrongfully removed by a competent authority. In the present case, however, the incompetence of the Board of Directors is sought to be inferred from the Articles of Association themselves, which plaintiff cannot, for this purpose invoke so as to give him a cause of action. The learned Subordinate Judge found that the suit for a mere declaration was maintainable on the very curious ground that as the company property was in ‘custodia legis’ of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Eluru in S. 115 proceedings in M.C No. 53 of 1950, it was not in the possession of the defendants and, therefore, it was not possible for the plaintiff to ask for consequential possession. The proviso to Section 42 of the Specific Relief Act cannot be bypassed in this manner. When a dispute between two parties gives rise to proceedings under Section 145 of the Cr PC the property falls only temporarily under magisterial control subject to the rights of the parties being, determined by a civil Court. The pendency of those proceedings will not make this suit for mere declaration maintainable.
14. It is urged that there are some decisions in which Courts have granted relief by way of mere declaration in case of removal from an office. We have been referred to the Privy Council decision in — ‘High Commissioner for India v. I.M Lall’, AIR 1948 PC 121 (G). Mr. Lall, a member of the Indian Civil Service, was dismissed from service on certain charges. He filed a suit, which was tried by a Bench of the Lahore High Court in the first instance in which he asked for a declaration that his removal was ‘ultra vires’ and invalid under Section 240 of the Government of India Act and for consequential relief that he still continued to be a member of the Indian Civil Service and was entitled to all the rights and privileges attaching to the office. The High Court gave him only the declaration he sought: (see — ‘I.M Lall v. Secy. of State’, AIR 1944 Lah 240 (H) and, on appeal, the Federal Court, while confirming the declaration that his removal was wrongful, permitted him to amend his plaint with a consequential relief for damages and remitted it to the trial Court for further disposal, the judgment being reported in — ‘Secy. of State v. I.M Lall’, AIR 1945 PC 47 (I). Their Lordships of the Privy Council in an appeal against the decision of the Federal Court merely granted a declaration that the order dismissing Mr. Lall was void and inoperative and that he continued to be a member of the Indian Civil Service. No consequential relief was given to him on the ground that a member of the Indian Civil Service, for reasons which we need not go into here, had no statutory right to institute a suit for the recovery of arrears of salary and emoluments. There were special circumstances in that case in which the Court proceeded on the presumption that the Secretary of State for India and the Government of India would abide by and act upon the Court declaration by reinstating Mr. Lall without any consequential relief by way of a specific Court order against them.
15. We cannot take that decision as an authority for bypassing the proviso to Section 42 of the Specific Relief Act and as general authority for Courts to make declarations where the plaintiff being able to seek further relief omits to do so. In order to meet this technical defect in the plaint, Mr. Thiruvenkatachari at the close of the arguments filed a petition for permission to amend the plaint for the following consequential relief viz., an injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with the plaintiff's exercise of powers and duties as Secretary and Treasurer of Sri Krishna Jute Mills Ltd., Eluru. Normally, we would not hesitate to grant an amendment of this sort even at this late stage, if it is intended to overcome a mere technicality. We have decided to allow this amendment, though belated, but we find that the effect of it is really to magnify another hurdle, which confronts the plaintiff in his search for Court relief.
16. This is Section 21 of the Specific Relief Act which sets out contracts, which cannot be specifically enforced. One such category is S. 2(b) which is so dependent on to be personal qualifications or volition of the parties or otherwise from its nature is such that the Court cannot enforce specific performance of its material terms.
17. The declaration sought by the plaintiff with the consequential relief he belatedly asks for is really tantamount to specific performances of a contract of personal service.
18. It is regrettable that the Board did not call for an extraordinary general body meeting to ratify their action in accordance with their own declared intention in Ex. A. 5. It is brought to our notice that in a petition filed by the appellant, a commissioner was appointed by this Court on 2-5-51 to prepare a list of all documents and registers and that he was discharged on 2-8-1951 by Panchapakesa Aiyar J. In an appeal against that order, Govinda Menon J. and Ramaswami Gounder J. appointed a Receiver, who called a general body meeting at which six directors were re-elected. It is sufficient to say that during all this period, defendant 2 continued to function as Secretary and Treasurer. What happened subsequent to the suit is quite immaterial and cannot affect its merits.
19. For reasons given supra, it is quite impossible for us to give the plaintiff any relief in the plaint as framed and on the footing on which he has come to Court. We dismiss his appeal, but we consider this to be a fit case in which the parties should be directed to bear their own costs throughout and direct accordingly.
B/H.G.P
20. Appeal dismissed.
Alert