- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
O.A.O.A.M Muthiah Chettiar v. The Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Madras.
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Delivered by the Chief Justice)
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant was assessed to income-tax by the Income-tax Officer, Cuddalore circle, South Arcot district by an order dated 4 February 1948. The applicant filed an application under s. 33-A(2) for revision of that assessment (application filed 18 February 1949). The Commissioner rejected the revision application in limine on the ground that it was time-barred. The applicant asserted that he received the assessment order only on 24 February 1948 and therefore his revision application was within one year from receipt. The applicant sought a writ of mandamus directing the Commissioner of Income-tax, Madras to entertain and dispose of his revision application in accordance with law. The Commissioner had made the order rejecting the petitioner's revision application on 5 April 1949; the petition for the writ was filed about a year after that date.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the one-year period in s. 33-A(2) must be computed from (a) the date the order was signed/passed by the Income-tax Officer, (b) the date the order was communicated to the taxpayer, or (c) the date on which the taxpayer had an opportunity of coming to know of the order.
- Whether a writ of mandamus is maintainable to compel the Commissioner to entertain an application under s. 33-A(2), and whether delay in seeking the writ bars relief.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The one-year period must be computed from the date when the order was communicated to the party or from the date when it was pronounced or published so that the party is deemed to have had notice. The applicant relied on a series of decisions of this Court, notably Secretary of State for India in Council v. Gopisetti Narayanasami Naidu Garu and Swaminatha v. Latchumanan, which support this approach.
- The applicant contended that his application was within one year from receipt of the assessment order and therefore validly filed.
Respondent's (Income-tax Department) Arguments
- The rule from the Madras decisions is not an inflexible rule applicable to every enactment and each statutory provision must be construed in the context of the particular statute's scheme and legislative history.
- Amendments to the Income-tax Act in respect of some appeal rights specifically provided that time should be computed from date of receipt of the order, but no such amendment was made to s. 33-A; this suggests time should be computed from the date when the order was actually passed.
- Sub-s. (2) of s. 33-A is not a provision prescribing a time limit for the party's exercise of rights but a limit on the Commissioner's revisional power; therefore time must run from the date the order was passed.
- Objection to maintainability: a writ of mandamus should not be issued because the Income-tax Act is a complete code providing adequate remedies for aggrieved assessees.
- Objection based on delay: the petitioner delayed in applying for the writ (about a year after the Commissioner's order rejecting the revision), and long delay can bar relief by prerogative writ.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Secretary of State for India in Council v. Gopisetti Narayanasami Naidu Garu | That the "date of the order" means the date when the order is communicated, pronounced, or published such that the party is deemed to have had notice, not merely the date the officer signed the order. | The Court treated this decision as authoritative and consistent with a salutary principle that limitation should run from the date the aggrieved party actually knew of or had the opportunity to know the order; the Court followed this approach. |
| Swaminatha v. Latchumanan | Support for the proposition that limitation periods run from communication/notice or publication so the party must be presumed to have had knowledge. | The Court relied on this decision (along with the Secretary of State case) as part of a consistent line of authority supporting computation of time from knowledge/communication. |
| Firm of Mohan Lal v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bihar and Orissa | A Bench of the Patna High Court reached a conclusion supporting the prima facie meaning of the statute (i.e., computing time from the date the order is passed). | The Court noted this decision but declined to follow it over the consistent course of authority in this Court; it did not adopt the Patna High Court's approach. |
| Secretary of State for India in Council v. Gopisetti Narayanaswami Naidu Garu | Same principle as the earlier-cited Secretary of State decision (alternate spelling in the text). | The Court cited this authority in support of computing limitation from the date of communication/notice and treated the line of Madras decisions as controlling. |
| Swatninatha v. Latchumanan | Same principle as Swaminatha v. Latchumanan (alternate spelling in the text); used as an example where the limitation period was thirty days. | The Court observed that the length of the prescribed period (thirty days in that case) did not affect the applicability of the rule that time runs from knowledge/communication. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court identified the sole substantive question as how the one-year period in s. 33-A(2) should be computed: from the date the order was passed, from the date it was communicated to the party, or from the date on which the party had an opportunity to know of it. The Court reviewed the line of authorities from this Court (notably the Secretary of State decision and Swaminatha v. Latchumanan) which treat "the date of the order" as meaning the date when the order is communicated, pronounced, or published so that the party is deemed to have notice.
The Court considered and rejected the Income-tax Department's arguments by reasoning as follows:
- The rule in the Madras decisions is not dependent on peculiarities of other statutes; it rests on a general and just principle that a limitation period for invoking a remedy should not be computed from an earlier date than that on which the aggrieved party actually knew or had the opportunity to know of the order.
- The absence of an amendment explicitly stating computation from date of receipt in s. 33-A does not lead to the opposite conclusion; the Court would not speculate on why s. 33-A was not amended and instead focused on the reasoning of the earlier decisions.
- The Department's contention that s. 33-A(2) is a limit on the Commissioner's revisional power (and therefore must run from the date the order was passed) was examined: the Court accepted that while sub-s. (1) involves the Commissioner acting on his own motion, sub-s. (2) creates a right in the aggrieved party to apply for revision and thus functions as a time limit for the party's application. Consequently, the rule that time runs from knowledge/communication applies to sub-s. (2).
- On maintainability, the Court held that the Income-tax Act is a comprehensive code but the petitioner was not seeking the substantive relief available under the Act; he sought a direction to the Commissioner to entertain an application which the statute itself provides. Such a direction is not obtainable under the Act's provisions and therefore a prerogative writ (mandamus) is available to compel the Commissioner to exercise his statutory duty.
- Regarding delay, while acknowledging that long delay can justify refusal of a prerogative writ, the Court took a lenient view because the applicant had (though wrongly advised) sought remedy from the Central Board of Revenue. The Court concluded that the delay should not prevent the applicant from obtaining the relief and indicated that denying costs might address the equities; ultimately the Court made no order as to costs.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court held that the one-year limitation in s. 33-A(2) must be computed from the date on which the aggrieved party actually knew of the order or had an opportunity of knowing it (i.e., from communication/notice), and that the Commissioner's refusal to entertain the revision application on the ground of time-bar, based on a contrary construction, was erroneous. Consequently, the Court directed that a writ of mandamus issue to the Commissioner of Income-tax to take the applicant's revision application on file and dispose of it in accordance with law.
Implications: The direct effect is that the Commissioner must reconsider the petitioner's revision application on its merits (after taking it on file) because the Court has held the application to be within time when computed from the date of receipt/knowledge. The Court addressed objections of maintainability and delay, granting relief despite delay because of the applicant's attempts to seek redress elsewhere; the Court made no order as to costs. The opinion follows existing precedent of this Court on computation of limitation and applies that principle to s. 33-A(2) of the Income-tax Act.
(Delivered by the Chief Justice):
The applicant was assessed to income, tax by the Income-tax Officer, Cuddalore circle, South Arcot district by his order dated 4th February 1948. He filed an application before the Commissioner of Income-tax under S. 33-A(2) of the Act for revision of this order dated 18th February 1949. The application was rejected in limine by the Commissioner on the ground that the revision petition was barred by time. According to the petitioner, the order sought to be revised was received by him only on 24th February 1948. He has filed this application for the issue of a Writ of Mandamus to the Commissioner of Income-tax, Madras, directing him to entertain his application and to dispose of it in accordance with law, because according to him the application was within time as it was filed within one year from the date of the receipt of the assessment order by him.
The only question on the merits which falls for decision is whether the one year has to be computed from the date when the order was signed by the Income-tax Officer, or the date when it was communicated to the petitioner, or the date, if there be any, on which the petitioner had the opportunity of coming to know of the order. The learned Advocate for the petitioner relied on a catena of decisions of this Court of which it is sufficient to refer to two, namely, Secretary of State for India in Council v. Gopisetti Narayanasami Naidu Garu(1) and Swaminatha v. Latchumanan (2), which support his contention that the date of the order does not mean the date when the officer passed the order but the date when such order was either communicated to the party or the date when it was pronounced or published in such a manner that the party must be deemed to have had notice of it or the date of such pronouncement or publication. The learned Judges in Secretary of State for India in Council v. Gopisetti Narayanasami Naidu Garu were no doubt faced with the difficulty of straining the language which prima facie does not import a date different from the date when the order is actually passed. In Firm of Mohan Lal v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bihar and Orissa(3) a Bench of the Petna High Court, without referring to the decisions of this Court, arrived at a conclusion which undoubtedly is supported by the prima facie meaning of the language used in the statute. We see no reason to disregard the consistent course of authority in this Court on this point.
Mr. Rama Rao Sahib, learned Counsel for the Income-tax Department, contended that the rule laid down in the two Madras decisions above cited is not an invariable and inflexible rule applying to the provisions relating to appeals and revisions made in every enactment, and that each such provision in a particular enactment should be construed having regard to the general scheme of that enactment and taking into account the history of legislation in respect of the subject matter of that enactment. He placed strong reliance on the fact that there had been amendments of the Income-tax Act and with regard to certain rights of appeal the amendments had specifically provided that time should be computed from the date of the receipt of the order sought to be appealed against, but there was no such amendment introduced in S. 33-A. It is not for us to consider why the language of S. 53-A(2) was not altered. The only question which we have to decide is whether there is anything in the reasoning of the learned Judges in Secretary of State for India in Council v. Gopisetti Narayanasami Naidu Garu , and Swaminatha v. Lachtumanan , which makes the application of the rule laid down by them dependent on the provisions of a particular statute. We think there is none On the other hand, we consider that, the rule laid down by the learned Judges in the above two decisions—and we are taking the same view—is based upon a salutary and just principle, namely, that if a person is given a right to resort to the remedy to get rid of an adverse order within a prescribed time, limitation should not be computed from a date earlier than that on which the party aggrieved actually knew of the order or had an opportunity of knowing the order and therefore must be presumed to have had knowledge of the order. We do not agree with Mr. Rama Rao Sahib on the length of the period prescribed for filing an appeal or a revision petition or a suit has any bearing on the question. In Secretary of State for India in Council v. Gopisetti Narayanaswami Naidu Garu the period was one year. In Swatninatha v. Latchumanan the period was thirty days.
Mr. Rama Rao Sahib further contend, ed that the provisions in Sub-S. (2) of S. 33-A is really not a provision prescribing a time limit for the exercise of the right of the party aggrieved but it imposes a limit to the exercise of revisional powers by the Commissioner and therefore time must be computed from the date when the order was actually passed. Plausible though this argument may be, so far as Sub-S. (1) of S. 33-A is concerned, we are of opinion that it is not sound so far as the right given to the party aggrieved under Sub-S. (2) is concerned. In a case falling under Sub-S. (1) the Commissioner acts of his own motion. There is no question of the aggrieved party invoking his jurisdiction. There can be no occasion to apply the rule enunciated in Secretary of State for India in Council v. Gopisetti Narayanaswami Naidu Garu . It may be said that the Commissioner's power to call for the record ceases with the lapse of one year from the date of the order by the subordinate authority. But in a case falling under Sub-S. (2) the party aggrieved has got to take the steps of applying for revision and he is allowed one year from the date of the order. The provision is, therefore, certainly in the nature of a time limit for the application for revision.
Mr. Rama Rao Sahib raised two objections to the maintainability of the application. One objection was that a Writ of Mandamus cannot be issued in respect of any proceedings under the Indian Income-tax Act because the Act is a complete Code in itself providing for adequate remedies for aggrieved assessees. It is quite true that the Income-tax Act does contain several provisions for appeals and revisions and reference. It the petitioner had sought to obtain from this Court any relief which he would have been entitled to obtain under any of the provisions of the Income-tax Act, then certainly we would have no hesitation in holding that this Court would not exercise its power to issue prerogative writs to give such relief to an assessee. But this application is not made to obtain any of the reliefs which the assessee might obtain under the provisions of the Income-tax Act. This application is only to direct the Commissioner to entertain an application provided by the Act itself on the ground that he has been improperly denied that right. The relief which he seeks at our hands is only a direction to the Commissioner to entertain and dispose of the application according to law. This relief the petitioner cannot obtain under any of the provisions of the Income-tax Act, We therefore see no substance in this objection.
The other objection is based on the long delay in making the application. The order of the Commissioner rejecting the petitioner's application for revision was made on 5th April 1949, while the application for the issue of a Writ of Certiorari was made about a year after that date. We have held that though there is no period of limitation as such prescribed for application for the issue of prerogative writs, long delay can be one of the grounds for refusing to grant an application for the issue of such writs. In this case, however, we think there are circumstances which should make us take a more lenient view. Though wrongly advised, the applicant appears to have sought some remedy from the Central Board of Revenue, of course, unsuccessfully. Having regard to this fact, we do not consider that the delay should prevent the party from obtaining the relief to which we have found he is entitled. We think that disallowance of the costs of the petition would amply provide for the justice of the case.
As the Commissioner of Income-tax has on a wrong construction of S. 33-A(2) of the Act refused to entertain the application made by the party for a revision of the assessment made by the Income-tax Officer, a Writ of Mandamus will issue to him to take the application on file and dispose of it in accordance with law. As already observed, there will be no order as to costs.
N.R.R
Alert