- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
P.N.S Aiyar v. K.J Nathan
Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner in this criminal revision is the complainant in C.C. No. 1292 of 1947 on the file of the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate. The learned Magistrate dismissed the complaint by order dated 9 June 1947 under Section 203 Cr.P.C., on the ground that there were no sufficient reasons to proceed further.
Procedurally, the lower court initially took the complaint on file and, under Section 203 Cr.P.C., forwarded it to the Commissioner of Police for investigation and directed a police report to be submitted by 16 May 1947. The police investigated and returned a report; after considering that report the Magistrate found no justification for continuance and dismissed the complaint.
On the facts recorded before the lower court: the complaint was reduced to writing, read over and explained to the complainant on 2 May 1947, and the complainant admitted its contents to be correct on solemn affirmation administered in the presence of the Magistrate. However, the record shows that the complainant was not examined on oath by the Chief Presidency Magistrate.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a Presidency Magistrate is obliged, before postponing the issue of process and directing a police inquiry under Section 202(1)/Section 203 Cr.P.C., to examine the complainant on oath under Section 200 Cr.P.C. (having regard to the proviso to Section 200 and the proviso to Section 202(1)).
- Whether the omission by a Presidency Magistrate to examine the complainant on oath before ordering inquiry under Section 202(1) is an irregularity curable under Section 537 Cr.P.C. or an illegality which vitiates the magistrate's order.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the Magistrate was obliged to examine the complainant on oath under Section 200 Cr.P.C. before postponing the issue of process and directing a police investigation; because this step was not taken, the Magistrate's procedure in rejecting the complaint under Section 203 was illegal.
Respondent / Accused's Arguments
- Mr. B.T. Sundararajan for the accused argued that the words of the proviso to Section 202(1) — "unless the complainant has been examined on oath under the provisions of S. 200" — should be read so that where Section 200 does not make an examination on oath compulsory for a Presidency Magistrate, it is not necessary for the Presidency Magistrate to examine the complainant on oath before postponing issue of process and directing inquiry.
- Reliance was placed on earlier decisions (including Re Velu Nattan and Queen-Empress v. Murphy) and on authorities such as In Re Mirabai Sheik Hussain and Hashim Moosa v. Mrs. G. Booth to support the contention that where a written complaint is clear, merely reading it to the complainant and obtaining a subscription/affirmation may sometimes suffice.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Rekha Chamar… Applicant; v. King-Emperor… Opposite Party. [1924] A.I.R All 664 | Authority concerning magistrates taking cognizance of complaints and the procedure to be followed when directing inquiry under Section 202/Section 203 (decision involved moffussil/ordinary magistrates). | The court cited it as one of the authorities showing the obligation on magistrates (in the moffussil context). The court noted these decisions dealt with ordinary moffussil Magistrates (not Presidency Magistrates). |
| Bhagwands v. Emperor [1935] A.I.R All. 745 | Authority on obligations of magistrates in complaint proceedings (again in the context of ordinary magistrates). | Used alongside Rekha Chamar to show established authority for the obligation on ordinary magistrates; the court observed these did not directly decide the Presidency Magistrate point. |
| Re Velu Nattan (Spencer J.) | Held that a Presidency Magistrate may dismiss a complaint under Section 203 on a police report without examining the complainant; verification on oath was sufficient compliance. | The court considered this decision but treated it as having been decided before the insertion of the present proviso to Section 202(1) and therefore not of binding authority after the amendment; effectively not followed as overriding precedent given statutory change. |
| Queen-Empress v. Murphy [1887] I.L.R 9 All. 666 | Authority relied upon in Re Velu Nattan (pre-dates proviso to Section 202(1)). | The court observed it was a pre-proviso decision and therefore of limited relevance after the proviso's enactment; it was not treated as dispositive of the present question. |
| In Re Mirabai Sheik Hussain (18 July 1904) | Holds that when a written complaint is clear, the magistrate may sometimes comply with Section 202 by reading the complaint and having the complainant subscribe it on oath; extensive examination may be required only where complaint is obscure or vague. | The court noted this decision was from 1904 and pre-dated the proviso to Section 202(1); it therefore did not control the present case where the proviso now requires examination in the circumstances described. |
| Hashim Moosa v. Mrs. G. Booth [1932] A.I.R Sind. 58 | Decision dealing with revision petition to the Judicial Commissioner of Sind (on procedural issues in complaint cases). | The court observed that the revision in that case did not arise from an order of a Presidency Magistrate and therefore the decision was not directly applicable to the present question. |
| Subramanina Aiyar v. King Emperor [1902] I.L.R 35 Mad. 61 P.C. | Judicial Committee held that disregard of an express statutory provision as to the mode of inquiry is not a mere irregularity curable under remedial provisions like Section 537 Cr.P.C. but an illegality going to the root of the proceedings. | The court relied on this principle to hold that non-examination on oath (where mandated by the proviso to Section 202(1)) is not a mere irregularity curable under Section 537 Cr.P.C. but an illegality invalidating the proceedings. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by examining the statutory language of Section 200 (and its proviso) together with the proviso to Section 202(1), the legislative history of the amendment, and relevant authorities.
Key steps in the analysis:
- Interpretation of Section 200 proviso(b): The proviso gives a Presidency Magistrate discretion as to whether the examination required by the earlier portion of Section 200 is on oath, but this discretion does not permit a Presidency Magistrate to dispense with any form of examination whatsoever. The court emphasized that the power to avoid examination completely is not conferred.
- Nature of "examination": The court explained that the act of the complainant admitting the written complaint to be true on affirmation does not amount to the "examination" contemplated by the statute. Examination involves interrogation by the magistrate on the allegations to test whether they are prima facie true; merely affirming the written averments is insufficient.
- Reading Section 202(1) proviso: The proviso to Section 202(1) states no direction for inquiry shall be made "unless the complainant has been examined on oath under the provisions of S. 200" (save where complaint made by a Court). The court read this language as creating an obligation on the magistrate to examine the complainant on oath before directing inquiry.
- Legislative history and purpose: The court referred to the Joint Committee report on the amending bill (Gazette of India, Part V, 9 September 1922) which expressly stated that Presidency Magistrates should be required to examine the complainant and to record his statement in cases where the court intends to postpone the issue of process and order inquiry under Section 202(1). The court saw the omission of certain earlier qualifying words in the amendment as deliberate, reinforcing the mandatory character of the present proviso.
- Treatment of precedents: Decisions relied upon for a contrary position (Re Velu Nattan, Queen-Empress v. Murphy) were noted but distinguished on the ground that they pre-dated the statutory proviso. Other cases (In Re Mirabai Sheik Hussain, Hashim Moosa) were also found not to control the present situation because they were decided before the proviso or did not involve orders of Presidency Magistrates.
- Principle on irregularity vs. illegality: Relying on Subramanina Aiyar v. King Emperor, the court concluded that failure to comply with the mandatory statutory provision as to the mode of inquiry is not merely an irregularity curable under Section 537 Cr.P.C., but an illegality which goes to the root of the proceedings.
- Practical rationale: The court observed that examination on oath is practically necessary because it often elicits additional facts and clarifications, particularly where complaints are oral or where written complaints may be clarified by interrogation; thus, before sending a complaint to the police the magistrate should test the truth of the complaint by examination on oath of the complainant.
On this basis the court found that the Chief Presidency Magistrate's omission to examine the complainant on oath before ordering inquiry and ultimately dismissing the complaint under Section 203 amounted to non-observance of a mandatory provision. The omission could not be cured by Section 537 Cr.P.C. and therefore constituted error of law.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The order of the learned Chief Presidency Magistrate is set aside.
Directions and immediate implications:
- The Magistrate is directed to inquire into the matter afresh by examining the complainant on oath and thereafter to dispose of the complaint according to law in the light of the observations in the judgment.
- The court expressly clarified that this judgment does not decide or express any opinion on the merits of the allegations made in the complaint; it addresses only the procedural error and requires compliance with the statutory mode of inquiry.
- The court treated the failure to examine as an illegality that vitiates the proceedings rather than a curable irregularity under Section 537 Cr.P.C.; the direct practical effect is the annulment of the Magistrate's previous dismissal and a mandated fresh inquiry.
Broader precedent implications:
The judgment enforces the mandatory character of the proviso to Section 202(1) as read with Section 200 when a Presidency Magistrate intends to postpone issuing process and order an inquiry: the complainant must be examined on oath. The court's reasoning distinguishes earlier contrary authorities decided before the proviso's insertion, and it applies the established principle that disregarding an express statutory mode of inquiry is an illegality. The opinion does not claim to lay out any other novel legal principle beyond these applications to the facts at hand.
The complainant in C.C No. 1292 of 1947 on the file of the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate is the petitioner in this criminal revision case, which is to revise the order of the learned Magistrate dated 9th June 1947 dismissing the complaint under S. 203 Cr.P.C on the ground that there were no sufficient reasons to proceed with it any further. The lower court took the complaint on file and forwarded the same to the Commissioner of Police for investigation under S. 203 and for the submission of a report by 16th May 1947. Accordingly, the police enquired into the matter and submitted their report to the lower court. After considering this report the learned Magistrate found that there was no justification for proceeding with the complaint and dismissed the same.
It may be stated at the outset that the complaint was not an oral one, but had been reduced to writing before presentation to the court and its contents were read over and explained to the complainant on the 2nd May 1947 when it was presented: and he admitted the same to be correct on solemn affirmation administered in the presence of the learned Magistrate. According to the record of the proceedings before the lower court, it is found that the complainant was not examined on oath by the Chief Presidency Magistrate.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner contended before me, that it was obligatory on the Magistrate to examine the complainant on oath under the provisions of S. 200 Cr.P.C before postponement of the issue of process and directing investigation by the police officer: and in this case, since such a course had not been followed by the magistrate, his procedure in rejecting the complaint under S. 203 is illegal. The question therefore for consideration is how far the provision of S. 200 read with proviso to S. 202 are applicable to the facts of the present case. S. 200 proviso (b) lays down that where the Magistrate is a Presidency Magistrate, the examination contemplated by the earlier portion of the section may or may not be on oath as the Magistrate in each case thinks fit. But in any case unlike any other Magistrate who when taking cognizance of an offence on complaint, is obliged to examine the complainant on oath, a Presidency Magistrate is given the discretion to dispense with the examination on oath but the power is not given to him to completely do away with, any kind of examination at all. What has happened before the learned Presidency Magistrate in the case in question, is that the contents of the complaint were admitted to be correct on solemn affirmation by the complainant. It cannot be said that this is an examination of the complainant either on oath or otherwise. All that the complainant has done is, to state before the court that the averments mentioned in the complaint are true and nothing more. The examination of the complainant signifies that the magistrate ought to interrogate him on the allegations or averments contained in the complaint to test whether they are prima facie true or not. Nothing like that has been done in the present case.
The proviso to S. 202 (1) is as follows: —
“Provided that, save, where the complaint has been made by a court, no such direction shall be made unless the complainant has been examined on oath under the provisions of S. 200”.
This proviso was, for the first time, enacted when the Code was amended in 1923. Even then, the whole of this provision was not in existence. The words “save where the complaint has been made by a Court” were inserted only by an amending Act, Act II of 1926. For the purpose of the present case this addition to the proviso is immaterial. What we have to find out is whether on the proviso as it stands now, it is an obligatory duty on the magistrate before postponement of the issue of process by directing a police officer to enquire into the case, to examine the complainant on oath under the provisions of S. 200. That there is such an obligation cast upon the Magistrate is clear from the words of the section itself. If any authorities were necessary they are found in the decisions in Rekha Chamar…Applicant; v. King-Emperor…Opposite Party. [1924] A.I.R All 664 and Bhagwands v. Emperor [1935] A.I.R All. 745. Both these cases dealt with the complaints before ordinary moffussil Magistrates and not before a Presidency Magistrate. In Re Velu Nattan3, Spencer J. has observed that a Presidency Magistrate may dismiss a complaint under S. 203 on a police report without examining the complainant. The verification on oath of a complainant before a Magistrate is a sufficient compliance with the provisions of S. 203. The omission to examine will, at the most, amount to an irregularity of the description covered by S. 537 Cr.P.C The learned Judge relies upon a decision of the Allahabad High Court in Queen-Empress v. Murphy [1887] I.L.R 9 All. 666.. It has to be observed that this decision was long prior to the insertion of the proviso in S. 202 (1). One can safely assume that when the proviso was inserted, the framers of the statute were aware of the decision in Re Velu Nattan and the proviso was enacted with the object of making that decision no longer of any binding authority. Mr. B.T Sundararajan for the accused argues that the words “unless the complainant has been examined on oath under the provisions of S. 200” denote that if no examination on oath is compulsory under S. 200, it will not be necessary for the Presidency Magistrate to examine the complainant on oath where he postpones the issue of process. I am unable to agree with this contention. If it had been the intention of the legislature to dispense with the examination on oath of a complainant by a Presidency Magistrate, where he postpones the issue of process, the section would have been worded thus: “Provided that save where the complaint has been made by a Court or to a Presidency Magistrate no such direction shall be made unless the complainant has been examined on oath under the provisions of S. 200”. In the absence of any words to that effect in the section it is impossible to hold that the imperative necessity of examining a complainant on oath inserted by the proviso has been dispensed with in the case of a Presidency Magistrate. That this view is correct is seen from the report of the Joint Committee on the bill to amend the Code of Criminal Procedure published in the Gazette of India, Part V dated 9th September 1922, page 236 at 260 where it is stated as follows:
“We consider that Presidency Magistrates should be required to examine the complainant and to record his statement in cases where the court intends to postpone issue of process and order any inquiry under S. 202 (1) “.
The unamended proviso contained the words, “where such examination is prescribed by the Code” and they were purposely omitted by the amendment. If these words had been there, it could have been successfully contended that there was no obligation upon the Court to exa- mine a complainant on oath where the Magistrate is a Presidency Magistrate. The omission of those words and the insertion of an exemption where the complaint is by a court make it absolutely clear that there is no difference between any other Magistrate and a Presidency Magistrate in the case of examining the complainant before the postponement of the issue of process and the ordering of an inquiry under S. 202 (1).
Mr. Sundararajan relies upon a decision in In Re Mirabai Sheik Hussain5 as authority for holding that only when a written complaint made before a Magistrate, is obscure or vague, is the Magistrate bound to examine the complainant at sufficient length for the purpose of clearly ascertaining the allegations on which the complaint is made: and when however, the complaint is made in writing and is sufficiently clear, it may frequently be a sufficient compliance with S. 202 if the Magistrate reads it over to the complainant and he is asked on oath to subscribe it. No doubt, this decision of Chandavarkar and Aston JJ. was passed on a criminal revision case from a Presidency Magistrate, but at the time, it was passed on July 18, 1904, the proviso to S. 202 was not in the Code. The other decision which he invited my attention to, was one by the Court of the Judicial Commissioner of Sind reported in Hashim Moosa v. Mrs. G. Booth [1932] A.I.R sind. 58. All that I need say is that the revision petition there, did not arise from any order of a Presidency Magistrate as in this case.
Apart from authority on principle also the above view is essentially justified. It may be that when a complainant is examined on oath by the Magistrate, more facts are likely to be elicted than are originally obtained from a complainant. Where the complaint is oral, an examination will certainly elucidate matters to a great extent and where it has been reduced to writing an examination would probably clarify the situation. In either of these contingencies, before the Magistrate sends the complaint to the police for enquiry, he should ascertain the truth or falsehood of the complaint by an examination on oath of the complainant.
The failure by the Magistrate to observe this mandatory provision of the Code cannot be cured, in my opinion, by S. 537 Cr.P.C The non-examination on oath is not an error, omission or irregularity in the complaint. It is a non-observance of a mandatory provision of law, the infraction of which, is, according to the decision of their Lordships of the Judicial Committee in Subramanina Aiyar v. King Emperor [1902] I.L.R 35 Mad. 61 P.C, a disregard of an express provision of law as to the mode of inquiry and as such was not a mere irregularity such as could be remedied by S. 537 Cr.P.C It is an illegality which goes to the very root of the proceedings. I am therefore of opinion that the learned Chief Presidency Magistrate has erred in law in not complying with the provisions of S. 202 Cr.P.C The order of the learned Magistrate is set aside and he is directed to enquire into the matter afresh by examining the complainant on oath and dispose of the complaint according to law, in the light of the observations in this judgment.
I desire to be distinctly understood that this judgment of mine should not, in any way, be interpreted as either, accepting or rejecting any of the allegations made in the complaint. I am expressing no opinion whatever, on the merits of the complaint.
Alert