- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Arvind Vyankatrao Tarar v. State Of Maharashtra
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion addresses an application for restoration of Land Acquisition Case No. 19 of 2001, which had been dismissed by the Reference Court under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act. The dismissal was based on the ground that the case was not maintainable as it had been decided on merits after all issues were answered, despite the absence of the applicant and his counsel and no evidence being led. The petitioner filed an application under Order IX, Rule 9 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C) for restoration of the reference, contending that the dismissal should have been by default and not on merits. The trial court dismissed this application as not maintainable, leading to the present writ petition challenging that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an application under Order IX, Rule 9 read with Section 151 of C.P.C is maintainable for restoration of a Land Acquisition reference dismissed on merits in the absence of the applicant and his counsel.
- Whether the trial court erred in dismissing the application for restoration on the ground of non-maintainability instead of deciding it on merits.
- The appropriate legal remedy available to a claimant when a Land Acquisition reference is dismissed ex parte or without hearing evidence, specifically the applicability of Order IX Rules 9 and 13 of C.P.C and Section 151 of C.P.C vis-à-vis an appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The petitioner argued that the dismissal of the Land Acquisition reference was in effect an ex parte dismissal due to the absence of the applicant and his counsel, and thus the court should have dismissed the case in default rather than deciding it on merits.
- The petitioner contended that the appropriate remedy was to file an application under Order IX, Rule 9 read with Section 151 of C.P.C for restoration of the case to enable adjudication on merits.
- Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court decision in Rajmani v. Collector, Raipur (1996) 5 SCC 701, which clarified that an application under Order IX Rule 9 read with Section 151 C.P.C is an appropriate remedy for restoration in such circumstances, even though an appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act also lies.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Rajmani v. Collector, Raipur, (1996) 5 SCC 701 | Clarification that an application under Order IX Rule 9 read with Section 151 C.P.C is maintainable for restoration of a Land Acquisition reference dismissed ex parte or without hearing evidence; alternative remedy to appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act. | The court relied on this precedent to hold that the trial court erred in dismissing the application as not maintainable and that the application should have been decided on merits. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the procedural history and the legal provisions applicable to restoration of Land Acquisition references. It noted that the Reference Court dismissed the case on merits despite the absence of the applicant and his counsel, which was contrary to the proper procedure where dismissal in default should have been entered. The court referred to the Supreme Court's ruling in Rajmani v. Collector, Raipur, which established that an application under Order IX Rule 9 read with Section 151 C.P.C is the appropriate remedy to restore a case dismissed ex parte or without proper hearing, as an alternative to an appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act. The court concluded that the trial court committed an error by holding the application as not maintainable and by dismissing it without deciding on merits. Accordingly, it quashed the impugned order and directed the trial court to decide the restoration application on its own merits.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is allowed.
The order dated 05.07.2013 passed by the trial court dismissing the application for restoration is quashed and set aside. The trial court is directed to decide the restoration application (M.J.C No. 340 of 2012) on its merits. This decision directly affects the parties by restoring the opportunity for the petitioner to have the Land Acquisition reference adjudicated properly, but it does not establish any new precedent beyond reaffirming the applicability of established legal principles from the cited Supreme Court authority.
ORAL JUDGMENT
1] Rule made returnable forthwith.
Heard the matter finally by consent of the learned counsels appearing for the parties.
2] The Reference Court under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act has dismissed an application under Order IX, Rule 9 read with Section 151 of C.P.C for restoration of Land Acquisition Case No. 19 of 2001, on the ground that it is not maintainable, as the reference has been decided on merits by answering all the issues framed.
3] In Land Acquisition Case No. 19 of 2001, the Court decided all the issues after holding that the applicant and his counsel are absent and no evidence has been led to substantiate the claim on merits. This dismissal of reference was on 13.08.2012
4] The petitioner who is the original applicant had two remedies, either to file Regular Civil Appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act or to file an application under Order IX, Rule 13 of C.P.C to set aside the ex parte decree. The applicant has preferred an application under Order IX, Rule 9 read with Section 151 of C.P.C for restoration of the Land Acquisition Reference case, proceeding on the footing that the reference need to be decided on merits after framing the application to lead evidence in support of the claim. In the absence of the applicant and his counsel before the Reference Court, which is an undisputed fact in the present case, according to the petitioner, the option with the Court was to dismiss the application in default and there was no occasion for the court to decide the case on merits. Therefore, presuming that the matter has been dismissed in the absence of the applicant and his counsel, the application under Order IX, Rule 9 of C.P.C is filed.
5] Shri Shelat, the learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon the decision in the case of Rajmani v. Collector, Raipur, Raipur, reported in (1996) 5 SCC 701, more particularly Paragraph No. 4, which is reproduced below;
“4. The question then is whether the application would be under Order 9 Rule 9 or Order 9 Rule 13 or Section 151(2)? It is settled law that the statement under Section 19 in terms of the objection under Section 18 of the Act is not treated as a plaint. Upon service of the notice on the claimant or interested person, he is treated to be a plaintiff and Land Acquisition Collector to be a defendant for the purpose of conducting the proceedings as envisaged under Section 22 of the Act. They are entitled to be represented by counsel. On receipt of the application, it is the duty of the claimant and burden is always upon him, who seeks higher compensation to adduce evidence and prove in the Court that the compensation awarded by the Collector was inadequate and that the acquired lands were possessed of higher value for award of the compensation to be just and adequate compensation. The Land Acquisition Officer is to rebut the evidence adduced by the claimant/interested person. The burden is always on the claimant. Ultimately, it is the duty and power of the court to determine just and adequate compensation on relevant facts and law sitting in the armchair of a prudent purchaser in an open market. If the notice is not served on the claimant, he is deprived of his valuable opportunity. If the award in such circumstances came to be passed after setting aside the claimant ex parte, though an appeal would lie under Section 54 of the Act against such an award, alternative remedy is also available. The appellate court may not be in a position to decide the correctness of the award except again to fall back upon the question whether notice was properly served on the claimant and whether his remaining ex parte is correct in law. That question could equally be gone into on an application filed by the claimant either under Order 9 Rule 9 CPC or under Order 9 Rule 13 or Section 151 CPC. We are of the view that the appropriate provision that would be applicable to the claimant would be Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 CPC. Therefore, he has rightly filed an application though under Order 9 Rule 13 but it could be treated as one under Order 9 Rule 9 read with Section 151 CPC. Section 26(2) of the Act declares that the award is a decree obviously as defined in Section 2(3) CPC and the grounds in support thereof is a judgment under Section 2(9) CPC. The appeal under Section 54 would be dealt with under Order 41 CPC”.
6] The Apex Court has held that though an appeal would lie under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act against such an award, alternate remedy is also available. It further holds that whether the application is filed under Order IX Rule 9 of C.P.C or under Order 9 Rule 13 or under Section 151 C.P.C, it does not make any difference. In view of this, the trial Court has committed an error in holding that the application under Order IX Rule 9 of C.P.C read with Section 151 of C.P.C was not maintainable. The application should have been decided on its own merits and it should not have been dismissed on the ground that it is not maintainable.
7] In the result, the writ petition is allowed. The order dated 05.07.2013 passed by the trial Court in M.J.C No. 340 of 2012 below Exh.1 is hereby quashed and set aside. The trial Court is directed to decide the M.J.C No. 340 of 2012 on its own merits.
Rule is made absolute in these terms. No orders as to costs.
Alert