Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Karmaveer Bhaurao Pa... v. All India Council Fo...

Bombay High Court
Aug 14, 2015
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary: Anoop V. Mohta, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Petitioners are a college run by a public charitable trust, imparting technical education on the basis of approval granted by Respondent No. 1. The Petitioners challenged Respondent No. 1's decision dated 30 April, 2015 which placed the Petitioner-college into a "no admission" category (zero intake capacity) for the academic year 2014-15 and related actions arising from that decision. The Petition sought related reliefs including directions for issuance of a revised Extension of Approval (EOA) with full intake capacity for 2014-15 and/or 2015-16.

The Writ Petition was filed on 5 May, 2015. This Court (Coram: Anoop V. Mohta & K.R. Shriram, JJ.) granted ad interim relief on 8 May, 2015, permitting the Petitioners to participate in CAP admission for the academic year 2015-16. The petition was heard finally along with a connected group of matters, and the Court applied reasons recorded in Saraswati Education Society's Saraswati College of Engineering v. All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) (Writ Petition No. 4586 of 2015) dated 14 August, 2015 to dispose of the present petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the decision dated 30 April, 2015 to place the Petitioner-college in the "no admission" category (zero intake capacity) for the academic year 2014-15 was justified on the basis of the reported deficiencies.
  2. Whether the deficiencies noted by the Respondents were material and substantial enough to warrant the drastic action of denying admissions, or whether they were curable in nature.
  3. Whether the Petitioners were entitled to relief including directions for reconsideration and issuance of revised EOA with full intake capacity for 2014-15 and/or 2015-16 (as framed in the petition).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Petitioners placed material on record to justify compliance with deficiencies raised by Respondents in the letter/communication dated 27 March, 2014, and presented a deficiencies and compliance status report for 2015-16 (marked "X").
  • Faculty strength met the norms and was accepted by the Standing Complaint Committee (SCC); the deficiencies noted by the EVC regarding faculty were erroneous. Detailed lists of faculty members were placed on record.
  • The reservation/roster policy of the State Government was not clearly defined at the relevant time, preventing finalisation of the roster by the University; Petitioners sought university approval to recruit regular candidates and proposed filling posts through the University's selection process after roster approval and advertisement.
  • All regular faculty were being paid salaries as per the 6th Pay Commission; explanations were provided as to why regular appointments could not yet be made.
  • Physical infrastructure deficiencies were addressed: campus was barrier-free, toilets for physically challenged existed, new ramps inaugurated, photographs and architects' certificates were submitted, tutorial rooms and laboratories existed as per the process handbook, seminar halls and common facilities met requirements.
  • The documents submitted by the Petitioners (photographs, certificates, drawings) were not considered by AICTE before taking the impugned action.

Respondents' Position

  • Deficiencies were recorded by the External Visiting Committee (EVC) in a communication dated 27 March, 2015.
  • The Standing Complaint Committee (SCC) made observations and recommendations dated 22 April, 2015 concerning those deficiencies.
  • On the basis of the reported deficiencies and the SCC observations/recommendations, Respondent No. 1 placed the Petitioner-institute in the "no admission" category for the relevant academic year.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Saraswati Education Society's Saraswati College of Engineering v. All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) (Writ Petition No. 4586 of 2015) dated 14 August, 2015, [reported in 2016 (1) Mh.LJ 235] The Court recorded basic reasons in that case on issues of law and related aspects which the present Court regarded as applicable. The Court held that the reasons and decision in the Saraswati case were fully applicable to the present facts; disposed of the present petition for the same reasons and granted relief subject to the conditions recorded in the Saraswati decision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the materials placed on record by the Petitioners and the deficiency reports/observations by the EVC (dated 27 March, 2015) and the SCC (dated 22 April, 2015). The Court specifically noted:

  • The Petitioners produced documentary material and an affidavit demonstrating compliance with many of the deficiencies identified by Respondents; the Court took the deficiencies and compliance status report for 2015-16 on record (marked "X").
  • On faculty-related issues, the Petitioners produced details of faculty members and asserted that faculty strength met prescribed norms and was accepted by SCC; the Court found the EVC's deficiency findings in this regard to be erroneous or overstated.
  • The Petitioners explained the delay in finalising roster-based appointments as caused by the absence of a clearly defined State reservation policy and indicated a plan to fill posts through the University's selection process once roster approval and advertisement were completed; salaries were being paid as per the 6th Pay Commission.
  • On infrastructural matters, the Petitioners produced photographs, architects' certificates, and drawings to show compliance: barrier-free campus, toilets for the physically challenged, ramps, tutorial rooms, laboratories, seminar halls and other common facilities meeting requirements as per the process handbook.
  • The Court assessed these materials and concluded that the deficiencies were curable in nature, that steps had already been taken to remove them, and that the documented submissions did not justify the drastic sanction of placing the institution in a "no admission" category.
  • Relying on the principles and reasons set out in the Saraswati Education Society case, the Court determined that relief was appropriate in the present facts and circumstances and that the matter should be disposed on the same basis as that precedent.

Holding and Implications

Writ Petition allowed.

Direct orders and immediate consequences as recorded by the Court:

  • The Writ Petition is allowed in terms of prayer clause (a).
  • The interim order granted on 8 May, 2015 (permitting participation in CAP admission for 2015-16) is confirmed.
  • The Respondents are directed to consider the Petitioners' representation specifically on cadre and faculty and related aspects, to afford the Petitioners an opportunity of hearing, and to pass a reasoned order at the earliest.
  • The Respondent-University is directed to decide, in an expeditious and time-bound manner, proposals related to draft advertisements, roster approval, nomination of subject experts and Vice-Chancellor's nominee, and approval of candidates selected through duly constituted Selection Committees, so as to avoid delays that may lead to AICTE showing deficiencies in future approval proposals.
  • The Petitioners are directed to take steps to remove any deficiencies as early as possible.
  • The Rule is made absolute and there shall be no order as to costs.

Broader implications: The Court disposed of the petition by applying the reasons recorded in the earlier Saraswati Education Society case; the decision effects the direct reliefs and procedural directions set out above. The opinion does not set out any additional novel precedent beyond applying the Saraswati decision to the present facts.

Show all summary ...

Anoop V. Mohta, J.:— Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith. Heard finally by consent of parties.

2. The Petitioners is a college, run by public charitable trust and imparting technical education on the basis of approval granted by Respondent No. 1.

3. By this Petition, the Petitioners have challenged the decision dated 30 April, 2015 of Respondent No. 1 to put the Petitioner-College into no admission category i.e (“zero”) intake capacity for the academic year 2014-15 and/or related action arising out of the same and further prayed for the related prayers including directions to Respondent No. 1 to issue revised EOA with full intake capacity for 2014-15 and/or 2015-16.

4. Petition was filed on 5 May, 2015. This Court (Coram : Anoop V. Mohta & K.R Shriram, JJ.), on 8 May, 2015 has granted ad interim relief and permitted the Petitioners to participate in CAP admission for the current academic year 2015-16.

5. Heard finally along with other group of connected matters. We have recorded basic reasons in Saraswati Education Society's Saraswati College of Engineering v. All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) (Writ Petition No. 4586 of 2015) dated 14 August, 2015, [reported in 2016 (1) Mh.LJ 235] both on issues of law and related aspects. The reasons and the decision in said case, is fully applicable to the present facts and circumstances of the case, as the Petitioner is similarly situated and challenging the similar action/orders of the Respondents. Therefore, in view of the reasons so recorded, we are disposing of the present Writ Petition for the same reasons.

6. So far as the deficiencies in the present facts of the case are concerned, after hearing both the counsel, we have noted that the Petitioners have pointed out and placed on record material to justify the compliances so made as to deficiencies raised by the Respondents in letter/communication dated 27 March, 2014. After going through the relevant papers/documents, i.e deficiencies noted by EVC dated 27 March, 2015 and observations/recommendation of Standing Complaint Committee dated 22 April, 2015, we have noted that there are no material deficiencies exist to justify passing of such drastic order to put the Petitioner-institute in no admission category. Deficiencies and compliance status report 2015-16 submitted by the learned counsel for the Petitioners during the course of argument is taken on record and marked as “X” for identification.

7. It is argued by learned counsel for Petitioners that the faculty strength exist as per the norm and accepted by SCC. The deficiencies noted by EVC in this regard is erroneous. According to him, the faculty requirement for all the courses are duly complied with. He has placed on record, the details of faculty members. It is further explained by filing additional affidavit that the reservation policy of the State Government is not yet clearly defined therefore, roaster could not be finalized by the University. According to the learned counsel, all the regular faculty members working in the Petitioner-institute, are paid salary as per 6th Pay Commission. The Petitioners sought approval for recruiting regular candidates from the University. The statement is also made that after getting roaster approval and advertisement, post will be filled through the University selection process. The Petitioners have also explained as to why the regular appointment could not be made.

8. So far as the other deficiencies are concerned, the learned counsel for the Petitioners submitted that campus is barrier free. Toilet for physically challenged are also ready and new ramps are already inaugurated. Photographs of existing facilities were presented to the SCC during the hearing on 22 April, 2015. Tutorial rooms are as per the process handbook. The documents submitted by the Petitioners were not considered by AICTE. Respondents also submitted drawings in respect of halls. The photographs and architects certificate were also enclosed in support of explanations. Although the laboratory exists as per the process handbook, still same was not considered. According to the Petitioners, one seminar hall for two UG Courses and 1 seminar hall for PG Courses are also available. Boys and Girls common room, cafeteria, computer center are as per the requirement.

9. Therefore, taking overall view of the matter, we are of the view that deficiencies referred above are curable in nature. They have already taken steps to remove such deficiencies as pointed out by AICTE. The submissions so advanced is supported by documents. So also deficiencies are not sufficient to take such drastic action against the Petitioners. We are convinced from the documents placed on record that such deficiencies including faculty and cadre ratio is maintained to great extent and no major deficiencies substantial in nature exist. In the facts and circumstances of the present case, we are of the view that the case is made out to grant relief subject to conditions so recorded in Saraswati Education Society's Saraswati College of Engineering v. All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE), WP No. 4586 of 2015, dated 14 August, 2015 [reported in 2016 (1) Mh.L.J 235]. Therefore, the following order.

a) Writ Petition is allowed in terms of prayer clause (a).

b) Interim order passed by this Court on 8 May, 2015, is confirmed.

c) The Respondents are directed to consider the representation/case of the Petitioners, specifically on the issue of cadre and faculty and other related aspects by giving opportunity of hearing to Petitioners and pass the reasoned order, at the earliest.

d) The Respondent-University is directed that in order to avoid the delay in appointments of teaching faculty in the institution like the Petitioners, the proposals received for approval of draft advertisement, roaster, nomination of the subject experts, nomination of nominee of the Vice Chancellor and approval of the candidates selected through duly constituted Selection Committee, such proposals be decided in expeditious and time bound manner so as to avoid deficiencies in respect of the same being shown by AICTE in the proposals of such institution for extension of approval.

e) The Petitioners to take steps to remove the deficiencies, even if any, as early as possible.

f) Writ Petition is accordingly allowed.

g) Rule made absolute accordingly.

h) There shall be no order as to costs.

Petition allowed.