- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shapoor M. Mehta v. Allahabad Bank .
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner is an eighty-seven year old former employee of the Allahabad Bank (First Respondent) who retired on 30 May 1986 as a Special Assistant after thirty-nine years of service. Prior to nationalisation, the bank had Pension Rules that entitled award staff (including special assistants, clerks and cash clerks) to a pension at 35% of full monthly basic pay for the twelve months preceding retirement, with a minimum pension of Rs. 50 per month. The petitioner received pension under those Pension Rules after nationalisation.
The Retired Employees Association moved the Allahabad High Court asserting a statutory right to gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The High Court held that retired employees were entitled to gratuity; the bank appealed. On 15 December 2009 the Supreme Court, in Allahabad Bank v. All India Allahabad Bank Retired Employees Association, (2010) 2 SCC 44, dismissed the bank's appeal and held that payment of gratuity under the Act is a statutory right unless exempted by the appropriate government.
Following that decision, the bank issued a circular on 30 October 2010 deciding to discontinue the scheme for payment of pension in lieu of gratuity pending amendment to the Officers Service Regulations. The petitioner’s pension of Rs. 5,660 per month was stopped effective 1 October 2010. The petitioner challenged this stoppage by filing a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, which was taken up for hearing and final disposal by consent.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the unilateral stoppage by the bank of the petitioner’s pension (a retiral benefit he had been receiving under the Pension Rules) was lawful.
- Whether pension constitutes a valuable vested right (property) and, if so, whether deprivation of such pension by a public employer must meet the standards of fairness and equality under Article 14 of the Constitution.
- What is the legal effect of the Supreme Court’s decision in Allahabad Bank v. All India Allahabad Bank Retired Employees Association (2010) 2 SCC 44 — specifically whether entitlement to statutory gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 can justify withdrawal of pension payments that had already vested.
- Whether provisions of the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1969 (notably section 12(2) and the regulation-making power in section 19) permitted the bank to alter pension rights in the manner it did, and whether any rule-making power (e.g., a clause permitting amendment) could be exercised so as to deprive already vested rights.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Pension is not a gratuity or largesse but a valuable right in property; the stoppage of pension to an 87‑year‑old retiree is arbitrary and violates natural justice.
- Payment of pension was governed by Pension Rules in force prior to nationalisation and continued thereafter; those terms protected the petitioner’s entitlement to pension.
- Under section 12(2) of the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1969 the employee’s terms and conditions (including pension and gratuity) continue unchanged on transfer to the new bank unless formally altered; Regulation 19 empowers the Board to frame regulations regarding pension funds but cannot be used to divest vested rights unjustifiably.
- The First Respondent’s withdrawal of pension by an administrative circular pending amendment of officers’ regulations was arbitrary and violated Article 14; as award staff the petitioner’s rights could not be divested on the pretext of pending amendments to officers’ regulations.
Respondent's (First Respondent / Bank) Arguments
- The petitioner did not come with clean hands: the petition alleged he was never given an option between gratuity and pension, but the bank’s affidavit stated that on 14 January 1986 an option was given and on 6 March 1986 the petitioner opted for pension at retirement.
- The Supreme Court decision concerned payment of statutory gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 only; because the bank is required to pay gratuity under the Act it purported to be within its rights to withdraw pension in light of clause (9) of the pension scheme which empowers the bank to amend, vary, rescind or modify the rules.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Allahabad Bank v. All India Allahabad Bank Retired Employees Association, (2010) 2 SCC 44 (Supreme Court; decision dated 15 December 2009) | The Supreme Court held that payment of gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 is a statutory right which cannot be divested unless an exemption is granted by the appropriate government. It also held that pension and gratuity are separate retiral benefits and one does not exclude the other; only where the gratuity component under a scheme is better than statutory gratuity may the Government grant exemption. | The court relied on this decision to conclude that the bank’s obligation to pay statutory gratuity did not justify depriving retired employees (including the petitioner) of pension payments they were entitled to under the Pension Rules; the Supreme Court’s characterization of pension and gratuity as separate benefits reinforced the conclusion that the bank could not stop pension as a reprisal for the gratuity ruling. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by applying established legal principles to the facts recited in the petition and the respondent's affidavits:
- The court accepted the proposition, stated as a matter of principle, that retiral benefits (including pension and gratuity) constitute a valuable right in property and are paid in recognition of long service. Where the employer is a public employer, deprivation of such rights must satisfy constitutional standards, in particular the equality and fairness mandated by Article 14.
- The petitioner had been receiving pension under the pre‑existing Pension Rules and continued to do so until the bank unilaterally stopped payment effective 1 October 2010. The bank did not dispute that the petitioner had been entitled to and in receipt of pension under the old Pension Rules.
- The Supreme Court’s decision in Allahabad Bank v. All India Allahabad Bank Retired Employees Association was examined: the judgment recognized gratuity as a statutory right under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and declared that pension and gratuity are separate components of retiral benefits; a statutory right to gratuity could not be withheld on the ground that pension was being paid under a scheme.
- The court characterized the bank’s conduct — stopping pension payments after being required to pay statutory gratuity — as arbitrary and a "reprisal" against retired employees. The court found nothing to justify treating the statutory entitlement to gratuity as a reason to divest already vested pension rights.
- The Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1969 was considered: section 12(2) preserves the terms and conditions (including pension and gratuity) of employees on transfer to the corresponding new bank; section 19 confers power to frame regulations (including in relation to superannuation and pension funds) and provides that existing rules continue until regulations are framed. Although the old Pension Rules contained a clause permitting amendment, the court held that such power cannot be exercised arbitrarily to divest vested rights.
- The court emphasized the need for the exercise of statutory and regulatory powers by a nationalised bank (an authority of the State) to be reasonable and fair, especially because pension is an important source of subsistence for senior citizens. Depriving the petitioner of a pension that had accrued and vested was found to be unfair, violative of Article 14 and unlawful.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court allowed the petition and granted the relief sought. In the court's own terms, the action of the bank in stopping the petitioner's pension was quashed and set aside.
Core Ruling: The petition is allowed; the bank's unilateral stoppage of the petitioner's pension is quashed and set aside, the bank deposit made in court pursuant to an interim order may be withdrawn by the petitioner, and payment of pension to the petitioner is to be restored forthwith. The bank was directed to pay costs of Rs. 15,000 to the petitioner.
Implications:
- The direct effect of the decision is restoration of the petitioner’s pension payments and release of the deposit to him, together with a costs award of Rs. 15,000.
- The court treated the stopping of pension as arbitrary and unlawful in the circumstances; it applied existing principles—particularly the Supreme Court’s ruling that gratuity is a statutory right and that pension and gratuity are separate—to conclude that entitlement to gratuity does not permit divesting vested pension rights.
- The opinion does not purport to create a new legal principle beyond applying established law; it enforces protection of vested retiral rights against arbitrary executive action and emphasizes that rule‑making or amendment powers cannot be exercised so as to divest already vested rights without due process and legal justification.
Petition allowed.
Dr. D.Y Chandrachud, J.:— By consent, the Petition is taken up for hearing and final disposal.
2. The Petitioner is an eighty seven year old senior citizen. On 30 May, 1986 he retired from the Allahabad Bank, the First Respondent, as a Special Assistant after thirty-nine years of service. The Petitioner, it is undisputed, belongs to the category of award staff. In the Allahabad Bank as it was prior to nationalisation, there was a pension scheme, governed by Pension Rules which stipulated that special assistants, clerks (including typists) and cash clerks would be entitled to pension at the rate of 35% of the full monthly basic pay drawn during the twelve months immediately preceding the date of retirement with a minimum pension of Rs. 50/- per month. The Petitioner continued to receive pension under the Pension Rules even after the nationalisation of the bank.
3. The Retired Employees Association of the bank had moved the High Court of Allahabad in assertion of the statutory right of the retired employees to receive gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The High Court held that the retired employees of the bank were entitled to the benefit of gratuity under the Act. The judgment of the High Court was carried in appeal to the Supreme Court. On 15 December, 2009, in Allahabad Bank v. All India Allahabad Bank Retired Employees Association, (2010) 2 SCC 44 the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal filed by the bank. The Supreme Court held that the payment of gratuity under the Act was a statutory right unless an exemption was granted by the appropriate government under the Act. The Supreme Court noted that pensionary benefits or retirement benefits, whether governed by a scheme or rules, constitute a package and pensionary benefits may include the payment of pension as well as gratuity. Upon the dismissal of the appeal filed by the bank, a circular was issued on 30 October, 2010 stating that it had been decided to discontinue the scheme for payment of pension in lieu of gratuity pending amendment to the Officers Service Regulations. The Petitioner was in receipt of a princely sum of Rs. 5,660/- per month towards pension which came to be stopped with effect from 1 October, 2010. Aggrieved, the Petitioner is before this Court in proceedings under Article 226.
4. Counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioner submitted that—
(i) The payment of pension as a retiral benefit is not a largesse, but constitutes a valuable right in property; (ii) The sudden stoppage of pension to a retired employee aged eighty seven years is patently in violation of the principles of natural justice and even otherwise unlawful; (iii) Payment of pension was governed by the Pension Rules which were in force even prior to nationalisation; (iv) Under section 12(2) of the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1969 the services of every employee in an existing bank were to continue on the same terms and conditions in the corresponding new bank inter alia with the same right to pension, gratuity and other matters until his employment in the new bank was terminated or until his remuneration terms and conditions were duly altered. Under Regulation 19, a power has been conferred upon the Board of Directors to frame regulations inter alia in regard to the establishment and maintenance of pension funds; (v) The conduct of the First Respondent in withdrawing the payment of pension by an administrative circular is completely arbitrary and violative of the fundamental rights of the Petitioner inter alia under Article 14 of the Constitution. Besides, as a member of the award staff, the rights of the Petitioner could not have been divested ostensibly pending an amendment to the regulations governing the officers.
5. On the other hand, counsel appearing on behalf of the First Respondent urged two submissions: (i) The Petitioner has not moved this Court with clean hands since in paragraph 3 of the Petition he has stated the he was never given an option to forego his gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act and opt for pension in lieu thereof whereas at his retirement, the Petitioner was given an option and had opted for pension on retirement; (ii) The issue before the Supreme Court in the decision noted earlier in the case of the Allahabad Bank v. All India Allahabad Bank Retired Employees Association related to the payment of statutory gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 only. Since the bank is required to pay gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, it was within its right to withdraw pension particularly since clause (9) of the pension scheme empowers the bank to amend, vary, rescind or modify the rules.
6. There is no merit in the submission which has been urged that the Petitioner has suppressed facts from this Court. The affidavit in reply would show that on 14 January, 1986 an option was given to the Petitioner to opt for pension or gratuity and that on 6 March, 1986 he had opted for pension on retirement. As the Supreme Court noted, it was not the case of the bank that at the time of superannuation of the employees, there was a scheme for payment of gratuity which was more beneficial in comparison to the provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. In any event, even the bank does not dispute the fact that the Petitioner was entitled to the payment of the pension under the old pension scheme and that he was in receipt of pension until it was unilaterally stopped with effect from October, 2010.
7. On the state of the law as it stands, as a matter of first principle, retiral benefits including pension and gratuity constitute a valuable right in property. Retiral benefits are paid in recognition of long service rendered by employees to the organisation of the employer. Where the employer is a public employer, those rights are constitutionally protected and their deprivation ha to answer the mandate of the right to fair treatment guaranteed under the equality provisions of Article 14. An employer cannot grant or withhold retiral benefits at his whim and caprice. The Petitioner was in receipt of pension under the Pension Rules which were in existence in the bank even prior to nationalisation. The Petitioner was an employee of the erstwhile Allahabad Bank prior to its nationalization and retired on 30 May, 1986 after thirty-nine years of service. The Petitioner was paid pension under the old Pension Rules. The issue which was raised initially before the Allahabad High Court and thereafter in appeal before the Supreme Court in Allahabad Bank v. All India Allahabad Bank Retired Employees Association was whether the retired employees were entitled to gratuity which is a statutory entitlement under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The Supreme Court upheld the judgment of the Allahabad High Court and came to the conclusion that a statutory right to the payment of gratuity could not be divested unless an exemption was granted by the appropriate government under the provisions of the Act. The Supreme Court held that pension and gratuity are separate retrial benefits and hence the statutory right to the payment of gratuity could not be withheld on the ground that the employees were in receipt of pension under a pension scheme or rules. In paragraphs 22 and 23 of the judgment, the Supreme Court observed as follows:
“In our considered opinion, pensionary benefits or the retirement benefits as the case may be whether governed by a scheme or rules may be a package consisting of payment of pension and as well as gratuity. Pensionary benefits may include payment of pension as well as gratuity. One does not exclude the other. Only in cases where the gratuity component in such pension schemes is in better terms in comparison to that of what an employee may get under the Payment of Gratuity Act the Government may grant an exemption and relieve the employer from the statutory obligation of payment of gratuity.
In the result, we find merit in the submissions made by the learned Senior Counsel, Shri P.P Rao appearing for the Association that pension and gratuity are separate retrial benefits and right to gratuity is a statutory right.”
8. The judgment of the Supreme Court upholding the right of retired employees to the payment of gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 has been met with a reprisal by depriving the employees of the right to the payment of pension. Nothing more arbitrary can be conceived of. The manner in which the payment of pension has been unilaterally stopped by an executive act is arbitrary. The judgment of the Supreme Court held that the employees were entitled to gratuity in addition to pension since the payment of gratuity was a statutory right. The bank had no basis whatsoever to deprive the Petitioner of his pension to which he was entitled under the Pension Rules.
9. section 12(2) of the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1969 provides that every officer or other employee of an existing bank shall become on the commencement of the Act an officer or employee of the corresponding new bank and shall hold his office or service in that bank on the same terms and conditions and with the same rights inter alia to pension, gratuity and other matters as would have been admissible if the undertaking of the existing bank had not been transferred to and vested in the corresponding new bank and would continue to do so unless the terms of employment are duly altered. The power to frame regulations is contained in section 19. Under clause (f) of sub-section (2) of section 19 the power to frame regulations includes the subject of establishing and maintaining superannuation, pension, provident or other funds. Sub-section (3) stipulates that until any regulation is made under sub-section (1) every regulation, rule, byelaw or an order made by an existing bank shall be deemed to be a regulation made under sub-section (1). Though the old Pension Rules, when they were framed in 1890, contained a power in clause (9) to amend, vary, rescind or modify those rules, the power cannot be exercised arbitrarily. The status of the First Respondent in any event went through a metamorphosis once the First Respondent became a nationalised bank. All powers by an authority of the State have to be exercised reasonably and fairly. Even if the conditions of service could be altered, they have to be altered in accordance with law. Pensionary payments constitute an important source of wherewithal for senior citizens to live the years of twilight in dignity. Depriving employees who have put in long years of service of a right which has accrued and vested in them to receive pension cannot be regarded as fair conduct. The deprivation in the present case has taken place patently in violation of law and is violative of the guarantee of equal protection under Article 14 of the Constitution.
10. In these circumstances, we allow the Petition by quashing and setting aside the action of the bank, the First Respondent, in stopping the payment of pension to the Petitioner. The deposit which has been made by the bank in this Court in pursuance of the interim order passed by the Division Bench on 23 November, 2011 is permitted to be withdrawn by the Petitioner and the payment of pension to the Petitioner shall stand restored forthwith. Rule is made absolute in these terms. The First Respondent shall pay costs to the Petitioner quantified at Rs. 15,000/-.
Petition allowed.
Alert