- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ankush v. State Of Maharashtra
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal challenges the judgment and order in Sessions Case No. 27 of 1994 from the Court of the 3rd Additional Sessions Judge, Jalna. The trial court convicted all appellants for offences punishable under Sections 306, 498A and 34 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced them to rigorous imprisonment. The original record was called for perusal and both sides were heard in the appeal.
The core factual narrative in the trial and appeal is as follows. Deceased Rukmini (also called Sumitrabai) was married to appellant no.1 about two years before the incident. Appellant nos. 2 and 3 are the elder brothers of appellant no.1; accused no.4 (Jayvantrao), the father of the appellants, died during trial. The parties lived in a joint family. After around six months of marriage the deceased told her parents that the accused had demanded Rs. 5,000 to install an electric motor on their well and that she was being ill-treated and harassed. During two years of cohabitation she allegedly made such disclosure on at least two occasions; the parents promised to arrange money but could not do so in time.
On 11.10.1993 Sumitrabai committed suicide by consuming poison. The father filed a report on 12.10.1993 and Crime Registration No. 212 of 1993 was registered at Jalna Tahsil Police Station. PSI Andurkar investigated. At trial the prosecution examined four witnesses (the deceased's parents, her maternal uncle, and the Investigating Officer). The defence examined one witness, Raosaheb More, a relative. The trial court accepted the prosecution case that there was a demand for Rs. 5,000, ill-treatment was meted out to force the demand, and the suicide was caused by that ill-treatment; the appellants were convicted accordingly. The appellants appealed that conviction.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the prosecution proved the offence of "cruelty" under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code in the facts of this case.
- Whether the prosecution proved the offence under Section 306 IPC (abetment of suicide) in the absence of proof of cruelty as defined under Section 498A.
- Whether the presumption available under Section 113A of the Evidence Act could or should be invoked in this case.
- Whether the investigation was conducted fairly and whether the investigating agency collected material records (for example, land records) relevant to the prosecution case.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments (as presented on appeal)
- The investigation was not conducted fairly; the police did not collect records to verify whether the appellants owned land or genuinely needed money for an electric motor.
- Evidence was brought on record indicating that the deceased spent most of the time with her parents after marriage and was reluctant to return to the matrimonial home; this creates a probability that she committed suicide to avoid living with the appellants rather than because of ill-treatment.
- Specific suggestions were made in cross-examination that the accused did not own agricultural land and hence had no genuine need for the alleged Rs. 5,000 demand; these suggestions were raised to cast doubt on the prosecution narrative.
Prosecution's Case and Trial Court's Position
- The prosecution's case (accepted by the trial court) was that the appellants demanded Rs. 5,000 and ill-treated the deceased to force that demand, and that the ill-treatment drove the deceased to commit suicide.
- The trial court believed the prosecution witnesses and found that the suicide was committed due to the ill-treatment by the appellants.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Girdhar Shankar Tawade v. State of Maharashtra, 2003 Bom.C.R. (Cri) 575 | The statutory purport of Section 498A IPC and the statutory definition of "cruelty" (explanation (a) and (b)); the requirement that willful acts or conduct by the accused which have direct relation to the death must be established to bring home guilt under Section 498A. | The court relied on the principle that specific willful conduct directly relating to the death must be proved to establish cruelty under Section 498A; applying that standard, the appellate court concluded prosecution evidence was insufficient to prove cruelty and therefore no presumption under Section 113A of the Evidence Act could be drawn to sustain a Section 306 conviction. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The appellate court undertook a focused review of the evidence and the trial court's findings. Key points of the court's analysis, drawn directly from the opinion, are:
- Examination of witnesses: The primary prosecution witnesses were the deceased's father (Karbhari, PW-1), mother (Parvatabai, PW-2), maternal uncle (Radhakishan, PW-3), and the Investigating Officer (PW-4). The defence called one relative, Raosaheb More.
- Admissions and inconsistencies: The witnesses admitted that the deceased regularly visited her parents' house (including for festivals) and that appellant no.1 repeatedly requested relatives to send the deceased back to the matrimonial home. These admissions created a probability that the husband desired resumption of cohabitation and was not imposing conditions for it.
- FIR and testimony gaps: The FIR did not mention that the deceased had returned to the matrimonial home a few days prior to the incident; the first mention of that came only during cross-examination of PW-1. PW-1 could not precisely fix when the first disclosure of ill-treatment was made. The court found that the claimed multiple disclosures were not convincingly established.
- Investigative omissions: The IO's evidence showed the incident occurred on land (survey no. 66) owned by Ramkisan Gajar, and the prosecution witnesses did not present account of lands owned by the accused. No reason was provided by the IO for failing to obtain records concerning the accused's agricultural land ownership. The appellate court regarded this failure as an absence of fair and full investigation into a material aspect of the prosecution case (the alleged need for money to install an electric motor).
- Assessment of probabilities: The court found that the collective circumstances—the admissions about visits to parents' home, the lack of documentary verification of land ownership, the failure of witnesses to give complete accounts, and other inconsistencies—generated reasonable doubt about the prosecution's narrative that there was a demand for Rs. 5,000 and that ill-treatment in consequence of that demand drove the deceased to suicide.
- Legal standard under Section 498A and need for direct connection to death: Relying on the cited precedent, the court emphasized that to convict under Section 498A, willful conduct directly related to causing suicide or grave injury must be established. Because the prosecution failed to prove cruelty as so defined, the court held that the presumption under Section 113A of the Evidence Act could not be invoked to sustain a Section 306 conviction.
- Conclusion from analysis: Given the reasonable doubts and gaps in investigation and proof, the appellate court concluded that the trial court erred in accepting the prosecution's account without adequately weighing the admissions and surrounding circumstances; therefore, the appellants were entitled to benefit of doubt.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL ALLOWED — convictions set aside; all appellants acquitted.
Direct consequences of the decision (as stated in the opinion):
- The appeal is allowed and the judgment and order of the trial court are set aside.
- All appellants stand acquitted of all the offences for which they were charged and tried.
- Bail bonds of all the appellants stand cancelled (i.e., the sureties/obligations attached to bail are discharged as per the order).
- Any fine amount recovered from the appellants is to be returned to them.
Broader implications: The opinion does not announce any new legal principle; it applies existing law (including the precedent cited) to the facts and emphasizes that where prosecution fails to prove statutory cruelty under Section 498A, the presumption under Section 113A Evidence Act cannot be invoked to sustain a charge under Section 306. The decision therefore affects only the parties in this case and does not purport to establish new precedent beyond the application of cited authorities.
1. Appeal is filed against the judgment and order passed in Sessions Case no. 27 of 1994, which was pending in the Court of 3rd Additional Sessions Judge, Jalna. The trial Court has cria216.00 convicted all the appellants for offences punishable under Sections 306, 498A and 34 of the Indian Penal Code and they are sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment. Both sides are heard in appeal. Original record was called for perusal.
2. In short, the facts leading to the institution of appeal, can be stated as follows :-
Deceased Rukmini @ Sumitrabai was a daughter of complainant. She was given in marriage to appellant no.1 about two years prior to the date of incident. Appellant nos. 2 and 3 are elder brothers of the appellant no.1. Accused no.4 Jayvantrao was the father of the appellants and he died during trial. All the appellants were living in joint family at the relevant time when Rukmini started cohabiting with appellant no.1.
3. After six months of the marriage, the deceased visited the house of her parents and disclosed that the accused persons had asked her to bring Rs. 5,000/- from her parents. She disclosed that accused were in need of money as they wanted to install the electric motor on their well. She disclosed that there was illtreatment to her and accused were harassing her on this count.
She disclosed to her parents that accused were giving abuses to cria216.00 her, they were not providing sufficient food to her and she was driven out of matrimonial house time and again. She said to the parents that she will go to matrimonial house only when the amount of Rs. 5,000/- was given to her.
4. During two years of cohabitation, deceased had made such disclosure at least on two occasions to her parents. On both the occasions the parents promised her that they would make some arrangement and they would give amount after few months.
About two months prior to the incident in question, the complainant had direct talk with accused no.1 and his brothers and on that occasion the complainant had given promise to give money within two to three months. However, the complainant could not make such arrangement.
5. Sumitrabai committed suicide by consuming poison on 11.10.1993. Father gave report against the appellants on 12.10.1993 and crime at C.R. No. 212 of 1993 came to be registered in Jalna Tahsil Police Station for the aforesaid offences.
PSI Shri Andurkar made investigation of the case. Statements of some of the relatives of the deceased on parents side came to be recorded.
cria216.00
6. The defence has not disputed that Sumitrabai died due to poisoning. Relevant record in this regard is admitted. In the trial Court the prosecution examined four witnesses who include the parents of the deceased, the maternal uncle of deceased and Investigating Officer. In defence, accused examined one Raosaheb More, who is relative of both the sides. Trial Court has believed the prosecution witnesses and finding is given that there was demand of Rs. 5,000/- from the accused and to force this demand illtreatment was given to the deceased by the appellants. Trial Court has further held that suicide was committed due to illtreatment given by the appellants. In appeal it was submitted that the investigation was not done fairly. It was submitted that no record was collected by the police to ascertain as to whether the appellants really own lands and they were really in need of any electric motor. It was submitted that specific material was brought on record to show that deceased was living with her parents for most of the time after the marriage and she was reluctant to come to matrimonial house. It was submitted that the material on record has created probability that Sumitrabai committed suicide to avoid to live with appellants.
7. The death took place within two years of the marriage. Karbhari (PW-1), father of deceased has given evidence cria216.00 that for one year after the marriage there was no illtreatment to the deceased. He has deposed that after one year of the marriage the deceased made first disclosure about the illtreatment and such disclosures were made on two to three occasions. PW-1 has deposed that the deceased disclosed that all the appellants were asking her to bring Rs. 5,000/- from her parents as they wanted such amount to install the electric motor on their well. PW-1 has deposed that the deceased disclosed that there was threat of live given to her by the accused. PW-1 has deposed that he had promised to give amount after Diwali festival. PW-1 has deposed that he had given advise to accused no.1 in this regard.
8. F.I.R. at Exhibit - 52 is proved in the evidence of Karbhari (PW-1). In the Court no convincing substantive evidence is given on the nature of illtreatment by Karbhari. He has tried to say that the deceased was driven out of house by the appellants and threat of life was given to her but other evidence which includes his cross examination shows that the deceased was probably never driven out of the matrimonial house. Other evidence has created one probability that the husband was always interested in resuming cohabitation and he was asking relatives of the deceased on parents side to send her back to the matrimonial house.
cria216.00
9. Parvatabai (PW-2), the mother of deceased has given similar evidence. She has further deposed that she had reached the deceased to matrimonial house two to three days prior to the date of incident in question. She has deposed that she had promised accused that their demand would be meet with at the time of Diwali festival. She has deposed that she had requested accused not to give illtreatment to the deceased. Radhakishan (PW-3), the maternal uncle of the deceased has given similar deposition on so called disclosures made by the deceased.
10. The evidence of Karbhari (PW-1) shows that the deceased used to visit his house on the occasions of festivals. The maternal uncle of the deceased has admitted that deceased celebrated first Diwali festival in the house of her parents. Thus the evidence shows that the appellants never prevented deceased from visiting house of her parents. On the other hand, the evidence of three witnesses does not show that at any time they were required to request accused to accept the deceased back in matrimonial house. The evidence in cross examination of PW-1 shows that he was not able to tell as to exactly when the first disclosure was made by the deceased regarding the illtreatment. The evidence that on two to three occasions such cria216.00 disclosures were made, does not appears to be convincing in nature.
11. In the F.I.R., there is no mention that the deceased had returned to matrimonial house few days prior to incident.
Only during cross examination of PW-1 he admitted that the deceased had just returned to matrimonial house. It is suggested to this witness during cross examination that the deceased did not like the husband and so she was not ready to return to matrimonial house. It is further suggested that deceased was sent back to matrimonial house against her will and probably due to that reason she committed suicide. It is also suggested to PW-1 that the accused persons do not own any agricultural lands and so there was no need of money for installation of electric motor. All these suggestions are denied by the PW - 1.
12. In cross examination, PW-2 has admitted that the deceased had visited the house of parents on five to six occasions. She has admitted that accused no.1 had visited her house and he had requested the parents of deceased to send deceased back to matrimonial house. Radhakishan (PW-3) has admitted in cross examination that whenever accused no.1 had met, him accused no.1 had asked him to send the deceased back cria216.00 to matrimonial house. These vital admissions have created probability that the accused no.1 had desire to resume cohabitation and he was not putting any condition for the same.
13. No evidence is given by the prosecution witnesses as to for how many months the deceased had stayed in her parents house. Positive attempt was made by the witnesses to hide many material things from the Court. These circumstances and conduct of the prosecution witnesses have created reasonable doubt of case of prosecution that there was illtreatment to the deceased or there was demand of money from the appellants and due to that the deceased committed suicide. Even if the evidence given by Raosaheb, defence witness is ignored, the aforesaid circumstances are sufficient to create probability in favour of accused that deceased was reluctant to return to matrimonial house and as she was forced to return, she committed suicide.
14. Three relatives of the deceased on parents side have not given account of any lands owned by the accused. In the evidence of Investigating Officer (PW-4) it is brought on record that the incident took place in land survey no. 66 which is owned by Ramkisan Gajar. The evidence of maternal uncle shows that parents of deceased had many relatives in the said village, but no cria216.00 such relative had come forward in support of prosecution case. No reason is given by the Investigating Officer as to why the record in respect of agricultural land of the accused is not collected. In such case, it become necessary for Investigating Agency to collect the record to ascertain truth. It can be said that the investigating agency did not act fairly.
15. In view of the aforesaid discussions, this Court holds that the case of the prosecution that there was demand of Rs.5,000/- and on that account the illtreatment was given to the deceased cannot be believed. Material on record has created other probability. For proving the offence punishable under Section 498A the prosecution is required to prove the ingredients mentioned in Section 498A which are as under :-
"In Section 498A of IPC, the word `cruelty' is defined as follows :-
(a) any willful conduct which is of such a nature as is likely to drive the woman to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or health (whether mental or physical) of the woman; or
(b) harassment of the woman where such harassment is with a view to coercing her or any cria216.00 person related to her to meet any unlawful demand for any property or valuable security or is on account of failure by her or any person related to her to meet such demand."
16. In the case reported as "Girdhar Shankar Tawade V/s State of Maharashtra" 2003 Bom.C.R. (Cri) 575), the Hon'ble Apex Court has observed that :
"The basic purport of the statutory provision in Sec. 498A is to avoid `cruelty' which stands defined by attributing a specific statutory meaning attached thereto as noticed hereinbefore. Two specific instances have been taken note of in order to ascribe a meaning to the word `cruelty' as is expressed by the legislature : Whereas explanation (a) involved three specific situations viz. (i) to drive the woman to commit suicide or (ii) to cause grave injury or (iii) danger to life, limb or health, both mental and physical and thus involving a physical torture or atrocity. In explanation
(b) there is absence of physical injury but the legislature thought it fit to include only coercive harassment which obviously as the legislature intent expressed is equally heinous to snatch the physical injury; whereas one is patent, the other one is latent but equally serious in terms of the provisions of the statute since the same would also embrace the attributes of `cruelty' in terms of sec. 498A".
cria216.00 It is further observed by the Apex Court at para nos. 16, 17 and 18 that in order to bring home guilt for offence u/Sec. 498A of IPC, willful act or the conduct of Accused which have direct relation to the death, need to be established. "
17. The evidence discussed shows that the evidence is not sufficient to prove the offence punishable under Section 498A of IPC. The other probability has created reasonable doubt about the case of the prosecution and so the benefit of doubt must go to the accused. This Court holds that the trial Court has not considered the aforesaid circumstances, admissions in proper perspective and so error is committed. When prosecution fails to prove the offence of cruelty as defined under Section 498A of IPC, there is no question of drawing presumption which is available under section 113a of the evidence act. For proving of offence punishable under Section 306 of IPC in the case like present one, there is necessity to use such presumption. So this Court holds that all the appellants are entitled for benefit of doubt and appeal deserves to be allowed.
18. In the result, the appeal is allowed. The judgment and order of trial Court is hereby set aside. All the appellants stand acquitted of all the offences for which the charge was framed and cria216.00 for which they were tried. Bail bonds of all the appellants stand cancelled. Fine amount, if any recovered from the appellants is to be returned to them.
Sd/-
[ T. V. NALAWADE, J. ] sga/
Alert