Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Lodha Estate Private Limited v. Kishan Waman Bhoir

Bombay High Court
Oct 21, 2011
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Judgment

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs instituted Special Civil Suit No. 186/2011 claiming cancellation of a Development Agreement and related reliefs, asserting that an irrevocable Power of Attorney executed in favour of the defendants covered more properties than agreed and that oral assurances of additional consideration (market-value based) were not honoured. The Development Agreement and Power of Attorney were executed on 30 August 2005, the stated consideration being Rs. 3,11,04,007/-, and possession was handed over to the defendants. The plaintiffs served notices of cancellation in December 2009 and August 2010 and filed the suit in February 2011 after alleging continued development by the defendants.

The plaintiffs sought interim (ad-interim) restraining reliefs (temporary injunction) preventing the defendants from carrying out development, construction, procuring permissions, creating third party rights and transferring possession. The trial court granted an injunction by order (Exhibit 5) dated 13 May 2011. The defendants (appellants) appealed against that order; with the parties' consent the appeal was taken up for final disposal and heard by the court whose judgment is summarized here.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court committed error in granting interim injunction (Exhibit 5) restraining the appellants from carrying out development and creating third party interests over the suit properties.
  2. Whether the plaintiffs had established a prima facie case, balance of convenience and risk of irreparable injury to warrant injunctive relief.
  3. Whether alleged fraud/deception arose from inclusion of three additional properties in the Power of Attorney (i.e., whether plaintiffs were deceived regarding Survey Nos. 25 Hissa 8, 26 Hissa 3 and 2 Hissa 7).
  4. Whether oral assurances purportedly promising payment of additional consideration based on future market value could be relied upon in contradiction of written Development Agreement (with reference to Sections 91 and 92 of the Indian Evidence Act).

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The Development Agreement covered only seven properties; the Power of Attorney covered ten properties, and the additional three properties were included without consideration and without plaintiffs' intention to authorize development of those properties.
  • The plaintiffs were given oral assurances that additional consideration (based on market value at time of conveyance) would be paid; defendants did not honour these assurances.
  • The defendants took undue advantage of the plaintiffs' poverty and illiteracy to secure the Power of Attorney; plaintiffs therefore sought cancellation, declarations and interim injunctions restraining development, permissions and creation of third party rights.
  • The plaintiffs served notices of cancellation in December 2009 and August 2010, but the defendants continued development, prompting filing of the suit in February 2011.

Defendants' Arguments

  • There was no oral promise to pay additional consideration; the Development Agreement recorded that Rs. 3,11,04,007/- represented the market value agreed between the parties on 30 August 2005.
  • No fraud or undue advantage was taken; consideration was passed and possession handed over to the defendants.
  • Defendants had secured an Exemption Order under Section 20 of the Urban Land Ceiling Act, obtained permissions (N.A. permission dated 27 December 2007) and had invested substantial sums (over Rs. 100 crores) in constructing several multi-storey buildings from 2008–2011.
  • Defendants had created third-party interests and sold or agreed to sell over 500 residential units by registered agreements; therefore, there was neither prima facie case nor balance of convenience in favour of the plaintiffs.
  • As to the additional properties: earlier litigation (Special Civil Suit No. 262/1988) and a compromise decree showed that rights to Survey Nos. 25 and 26 had already passed to a sister concern (Shri Sainath Enterprises) or to Kishore Kanungo; Survey No. 2 was claimed to have been acquired under a separate registered Development Agreement (dated 25 June 2003) — thus plaintiffs had no entitlement in respect of those properties.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M. Gurudas v. Rasaranjan, (2006) 8 SCC 367 Principles governing grant of injunctions: consideration of (i) prima facie case, (ii) balance of convenience, and (iii) irreparable injury; and that a prima facie finding is a finding of fact but must be accompanied by other factors requisite for grant of injunction. The court applied these principles to conclude that plaintiffs lacked a convincing prima facie case and that the balance of convenience and potential irreparable injury favoured the defendants, leading to quashing of the trial court's injunction order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a fact-focused, document-led analysis. Key steps of its reasoning were:

  1. Documentary primacy and evidence law: The court examined the Development Agreement (dated 30 August 2005) and noted its recital that Rs. 3,11,04,007/- represented the market value agreed between the parties. The court invoked the principle (citing Sections 91 and 92 of the Indian Evidence Act) that oral terms inconsistent with a written agreement cannot be taken into account; accordingly, the plaintiffs' pleadings alleging contrary oral assurances were inconsistent with the written Development Agreement and could not prevail at the interlocutory stage.
  2. Consideration and possession: It was not disputed that the plaintiffs received the consideration amount and handed possession to the defendants. The court treated receipt of consideration and handover of possession as significant against the plaintiffs' claim for equitable relief.
  3. Substance of fraud/deception claims on additional properties: Regarding the allegation that inclusion of three additional properties in the Power of Attorney amounted to fraud, the court reviewed earlier litigation (Special Civil Suit No. 262/1988) and the compromise terms showing that rights in Survey Nos. 25 and 26 had passed to a third party (Shri Sainath Enterprises / Kishore Kanungo). The predecessor-in-title of the plaintiffs had admitted sale and transfer of those properties in earlier pleadings, undermining the plaintiffs' contention of deception in respect of those two properties.
  4. Survey No. 2: The court found that plaintiffs had not established entitlement to Survey No. 2; defendants asserted they acquired it legitimately by a separate registered Development Agreement (25 June 2003).
  5. Delay and defendants' investment: The court emphasized the timeline — documents executed in 2005, exemptions and permissions in 2007, construction from 2008–2011 and substantial investment (around Rs. 100 crores) and creation of numerous third-party interests (agreements with over 500 purchasers). The plaintiffs waited about six years to challenge the documents and approximately two years after sending cancellation notices to bring the suit. This delay and the progress of development weighed against granting injunctive relief.
  6. Application of injunction principles: Applying the three-pronged test from M. Gurudas v. Rasaranjan (prima facie case, balance of convenience, irreparable injury), the court concluded that the plaintiffs had not established a prima facie case on the evidence presented at the interlocutory stage, and the balance of convenience and potential for irreparable harm favoured the defendants.
  7. Resulting limitation: Although the court allowed the appeal and set aside the injunction, it clarified that whatever development activities the defendants undertake and whatever third-party interests are created shall remain subject to the final determination of the substantive suit.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The appeal against the trial court's order granting interim injunction is allowed; the impugned injunction order dated 13 May 2011 is quashed and set aside.

Consequences and implications:

  • Direct effect: The defendants are no longer restrained by the interlocutory order from continuing development activities or creating third-party interests in relation to the suit properties; they may continue such activities subject to the final outcome of the substantive suit.
  • Costs: There shall be no order as to costs in the appeal.
  • Auxiliary proceedings: The connected civil application does not survive and is disposed of as a consequence of allowing the appeal.
  • Precedential impact: The judgment applies established principles for injunctions (as cited) to the facts; the opinion does not state that it establishes any new legal precedent beyond applying existing principles to the facts of this case.

All information in this summary is drawn exclusively from the text of the provided opinion. No facts or legal conclusions beyond those contained in the opinion have been added.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT:

Heard Counsel for the parties.

Admit.

With the consent of the parties, Appeal taken up for final disposal.

2. The appellants-original defendants are taking exception to the order passed below exhibit 5 in Special Civil Suit No. 186/2011 thereby granting an order of injunction in favour of the respondents-original plaintiffs and against the defendants restraining them from making and/or continuing any construction over the properties of the plaintiff including the suit properties and the lands bearing Hissa Nos. 8 and 3 of Survey Nos. 25 and 26 respectively of village Majiwade, Dist. Thane. The original defendants-appellants herein are also restrained temporarily during the pendency of the suit from creating third party interest in respect of aforesaid properties. The plaintiff instituted a Special Civil Suit No. 186/2011 for the following reliefs:-

“a) the suit may be decreed;

b) in the Schedule mentioned in Para No. 6, since Suit Properties No. 1 to 7 were included in the unregistered agreement dated 30/8/2005 rendering the unregistered agreement illegal and hence the suit Agreement may be cancelled and for the declaration that the Defendants do not have any right to carry out any lawful work and Development Work in the suit properties and the illegal construction work carried out by is not binding upon the Defendants.

c) the order of this Hon'ble Court for Declaration that, the Defendants have kept the Plaintiffs in dark and cheated the Plaintiffs by adding three (3) properties in the suit Power of Attorney as mentioned in para No. 7 of this suit at Sr. No. 1 to 10 is illegal and any work and acts done by the Defendants in furtherance of the suit Power of Attorney is not binding upon the Plaintiffs and for declaration that, all the work/acts done by the Defendants in furtherance of the Suit Agreement and Suit Power of Attorney, permissions and approvals obtained without any rights and hence are illegal and hence the said permissions are not binding upon the Plaintiffs.

d) Hon'ble Court may by it's order and directions required the Plaintiff demolish the any type of constructions carried out the suit properties and handover, vacant and peaceful possession of the suit property to the plaintiffs.

e) permanent injunction against the defendants, their agents, their workers and any other persons claiming through the Defendants by restraining them from entering into, carrying out Development Work, Construction Work, procuring permissions, approvals on the basis of the suit deeds, transferring/creating third party rights in respect of the constructions in the suit properties in favour any persons, institutions by any agreement, deed act, restraining the transfer and parking of possession by the Defendants.

f) Ad-interim relief in terms of temporary injunction against the Defendants, their agents, their workers and any other persons claiming through the Defendants by restraining them from entering into, carrying out Development Work, Construction Work, procuring permissions, approvals on the basis of the suit deeds, transferring/creating third party rights in respect of the constructions in the suit properties in favour any persons, institutions by any agreement, deed, act, restraining the transfer and parking of possession by the Defendants.

g) ex-parte Ad-interim reliefs in terms of prayer clause 7(A) till the filing of reply/written statements by the Defendants.

h) any other orders in favour of the Plaintiffs as the court may deem fit.

i) for cost of this Suit.”

3. On 30th August. 2005 under a Development Agreement executed between the appellants and the respondents i.e Defendants and plaintiffs, the plaintiffs granted rights to develop certain properties 7 Survey Nos. situated at Village Majiwade, Thane. The consideration amount mentioned was Rs. 3,11,04,007/-. The terms and conditions are specified in the Development Agreement executed between the parties. On the same day the plaintiffs executed in favour of the appellant-original defendants an irrevocable Power of Attorney in respect of property situated at Village Majiwade, Dist. Thane enlisting 10 Survey Nos. details whereof are set out in the Deed of Power of Attorney. It is not disputed that the possession of the property is handed over to the Developer/Defendant nor there is any serious dispute in respect of receipt of consideration amounting to Rs. 3,11,04,007/- by the respondents-original defendants. The grievance made by the plaintiff in the plaint is that at the time of entering into agreement, they were informed by the defendants that the consideration of the 7 properties would be decided after taking into consideration the market value of the properties at the time of registration of conveyance. It is also stated in the plaint that defendants informed the plaintiff that after obtaining necessary permission, after conducting survey of the suit property and after submitting the plans for approval in the Municipal Corporation, Thane, they have executed and registered conveyance in respect of 7 properties and assured the plaintiffs that they will be paid additional consideration as per the market value of the said property prevailing at that time. According to the plaintiff the defendants are not abiding by the assurances given by them and neither the Development Agreement is registered nor the plaintiffs have paid additional amount equivalent to market value. It is also contended in the plaint that infact the Development Agreement executed by the plaintiff with the defendant is in respect of 7 properties whereas the irrevocable Power of Attorney is secured by the defendant in respect of 10 properties. The properties i.e Survey Nos. 25 Hissa No. 8, Survey No. 26 Hissa No. 3, Survey No. 2 Hissa No. 7 were not part of the Development Agreement and without paying any consideration amount for the said properties, those have been included in the irrevocable Power of Attorney. Infact there was no intention to authorize the defendants to undertake development work in respect of the additional 3 properties. According to the plaintiffs, the defendants have taken undue advantage of their poverty and illiteracy and secured execution of irrevocable Power of Attorney in respect of additional 3 properties. It is also contended that oral assurances given in respect of payment of amount equivalent to the market value of the property is not being adhered to by the defendants. The plaintiff, therefore, proceeded to issue a notice through Advocate to the defendant thereby cancelling the Power of Attorney as well as the Development Agreement. The notice was addressed to the defendant on 26 December, 2009 and same was followed by a 2 notice dated 4 August, 2010. The defendants did not pay any heed/attention to the notice and continued with the development work. The plaintiffs were, therefore, constrained to file a suit which was presented in the month of February, 2011.

4. In a pending suit, the plaintiff presented an application seeking an order of injunction restraining the defendants from entering into, carrying out development work or construction work, procuring permissions, approvals on the basis of suit deeds, transferring/creating third party rights in respect of the constructions in the suit property in favour of any persons, institutions by any agreement, deed, act, restraining the transfer and parking of possession by the defendants.

5. The defendants appeared and resisted the application by filing say. It is denied by the defendants that there was any oral assurance given by them for paying additional amount equivalent to market rate at the time of execution of the registered deed. It is also contended that the allegations in respect of taking disadvantage of the situation or the illiteracy or poverty of the plaintiff have been denied by the defendant. It is contended that no fraud as alleged has been committed in securing the Development Agreement or the irrevocable Power of Attorney. It is the contention of the defendant that the consideration amount of Rs. 3,11,04,007/- was the market value of the property on the date of execution of the Development Agreement and the Power of Attorney which was agreed between the parties to be the market value after due negotiations. The document namely the Development Agreement contains a recital that an amount of Rs. 3,11,04,007/- is a market value of the property on the date of execution of the document which is agreed between the parties to be the market value. Therefore, no question of agreeing to pay any additional consideration at subsequent point of time arises. It is also contended that after execution of the documents namely the Development Agreement and Power of Attorney by the plaintiffs in favour of the defendants, the defendants obtained a Exemption Order under Section 20 of the Urban Land Ceiling Act, 1976 in respect of the suit property. The defendants mortgaged the suit property with a view to raise funds for the proposed construction of the suit property. They also obtained permission for development in respect of the suit property on 27 December, 2007. After obtaining requisite permissions and NOC from various authorities the appellant commenced the development activities on the suit properties and the lands attached thereto. Since between the year 2008-2011 the appellants have constructed several multi storey buildings and expended over Rs. 100 Crores towards the construction of the said building. The defendants-appellants herein have also sold over 500 residential units to various third parties by and under registered agreements. In this view of the matter, it is contended that there is neither prima-facie case in favour of the plaintiff nor balance of convenience lies in their favour. Sofar as the execution of the Power of Attorney in respect of the 10 properties is concerned, it is contended that there was an earlier litigation wherein the issue in respect of Survey No. 25, Hisa no. 8 and Survey No. 26, Hisa No. 3 is settled. There was a Compromise decree in favour of one Shri Sainath Enterprises, a sister concern of the defendant in earlier litigation and in view of the Compromise decree, the defendant had acquired the rights in respect of Survey Nos. 25 and 26. Sofar as Survey No. 2 is concerned, the same has been acquired by the defendant from one Saghunabai under the registered Development Agreement dated 25 June, 2003 and the defendants have no concern and are not liable to pay any consideration in respect of the said Survey Number. Thus, it is contended that the application tendered by the plaintiff seeking an interim injunction does not warrant favourable consideration. The trial Court after hearing both the parties was pleased to allow the application Exhibnit 5 tendered by the plaintiff and issue restraint order restraining the defendants from making and/or continuing any construction activities over the suit property including the lands bearing Nos. 25 and 26 of Village Majiwade, Dist. Thane. The defendants are also restrained from creating third party interest.

6. I have heard the arguments advanced by the respective Counsels. My attention is invited to the document i.e Development Agreement dated 30 August, 2005. In Paragraph D, it is clearly mentioned that the consideration amount of Rs. 3,11,04,007/- which is in accordance with current market rate is acceptable to the executants i.e plaintiffs. There is also recital to the effect that defendants are authorized to develop the property alongwith other properties and may construct one or several buildings thereon and may also transfer the constructed units to third parties and earn profit. On perusal of the Development Agreement it does not transpire that there was an agreement in respect of deciding the price of the property at the future dates or at the time of executing the registered agreement. The pleadings raised in the plaint appears to be contrary and is not in consonance with the written agreement. The terms of the oral agreement which are contrary to the written document cannot be taken into consideration in view of the provisions of Section 91 and 92 of the Indian Evidence Act. Sofar as the passing of consideration amount is concerned, there is little doubt in that regard and it is not seriously disputed that the amount of consideration mentioned in the document i.e the Development Agreement executed on 30 August, 2005 amounting to Rs. 3,11,04,007/- has already been passed over to the original plaintiffs. Thus it transpires that the plaintiffs have received the total amount of consideration and handed over the possession of the property to the defendants and have agreed for grant of development rights so also agreed for creation of third party interest by the Developer after developing the property. There does not appear to be prima-facie any force in the contention of the plaintiff that they have been deceived by the defendants.

7. Sofar as another contention raised by the plaintiff that Development Agreement makes a mention of 7 (seven) properties whereas by virtue of execution of irrevocable Power of Attorney, the defendants have secured development rights in respect of 10 (ten) properties which itself amounts to fraud. In that regard, my attention is invited to terms of Compromise decree presented in Special Civil Suit No. 262/1988. It was a suit presented by one Shri Sainath Enterprises which is a sister concern of the defendants. The predecessor in title of the plaintiff Waman B. Bhoir and Rajaram B. Bhoir were party to the suit. The terms of Compromise are recorded between the plaintiff in the said suit and defendant no. 4 i.e Kishore Kanungo. The defendant no. 4 has given up his rights and entitlement in relation to the property Survey No. 25 and 26 in favour of Sainath Enterprises. It is also agreed and noted in the terms of Compromise that the plaintiff no. 1 shall be put in possession and occupation of the suit property and every part thereof. Thus from the terms of the Compromise recorded between Shri Sainath Enterprises which is a sister concern of the defendant herein and the defendant no. 4, it is clear that the Sainath Enterprises was in possession of the property and has received the same in view of the terms of the settlement between the plaintiff and the defendant no. 4 therein. Sofar as entitlement of defendant no. 4 is concerned, one has to look to the written-statement presented by the pre-decessor in title of the plaintiff in the said suit. The pre-decessor in title of the plaintiff in suit who were defendants 1 and 2 in the said suit have stated in Paragraph 25 of the written-statement presented in Special Civil Suit No. 262/1988 that they have already sold the suit property and parted with possession thereof in favour of Shri Kishore Kanungo before filing of the suit. It is also reiterated in the written-statement that the concerned defendants have already created third party rights in favour of Kishore Kanungo and, therefore, the question of again trying to create third party interest does not arise. It is also stated in the written-statement in Paragraph 25 that since neither of the defendants nor plaintiffs are in possession of the suit property and possession of the suit property having been handed over to said Kishore Kanungo, the allegations made by the plaintiff are without justification, incorrect and wrong. In view of the statement, stand taken by the pre-decessor in title of the plaintiff that they are not in possession of the property, said Kishore Kanungo was impleaded as defendant in the suit and the terms of settlement are reached and recorded between the plaintiffs and Kishore Kanungo in Special Civil Suit No. 262/1988. In view of the clear admission of the pre-decessor in title of the plaintiff, they have no concern with the property Survey No. 25 and 26. The plaintiffs herein are not entitled to claim any right, entitlement in relation to the said property. The pre-decessor in title of the plaintiff has categorically stated and admitted in S.C Suit No. 262/1988 that they have sold property in favour of Kishore Kanungo with whom the defendants have entered into Compromise and have received the possession of the said properties. The contention of the defendant that by act of inclusion of 2 additional properties while executing the irrevocable Power of Attorney, they have been deceived, therefore, appears to be incorrect. The plaintiffs were surely aware of the fact that their predecessors have already sold property in favour of the Kishore Kanungo from whom the defendants have acquired the property i.e Survey Nos. 25 and 26. On account of inclusion of Survey Nos. 25 and 26 in the Deed i.e Irrevocable Power of Attorney, it cannot be said that the plaintiffs have been deceived or that the defendants have played any fraud by inclusion of said property in the Power of Attorney.

8. Sofar as the property bearing Survey No. 2 is concerned, the plaintiffs have not been able to establish that said property belongs to them. The defendants have contended that they have entered into separate Development Agreement in respect of said Survey No. 2 with the owner thereof and the plaintiffs do not have any entitlement in relation to the said property deserves to be accepted. Thus, the contention raised by the plaintiffs that they have been deceived or some fraud has been practiced upon by the defendants, does not appear to be correct and allegations made in that behalf prima-facie do not appear to have any substance.

9. It is not seriously disputed that the plaintiffs have received a consideration amount mentioned in the document i.e Development Agreement to the tune of Rs. 3,11,04,007/- which is in subsistence the market value arrived at between the parties while executing the documents. Having received the amount in the year 2005 or thereabout, it is not open for the plaintiff to prohibit the defendants from conducting any development activities on the suit property.

10. It is contended that the document executed in favour of defendant is an unregistered Development Agreement and unregistered Power of Attorney and, therefore, need not to be taken into consideration. Having received the advantage under the document, i.e the unregistered Development Agreement and the Power of Attorney, it is not open for the plaintiffs to contend that the document cannot be acted upon. The plaintiffs are recipients of the amount which is equivalent to prevailing market value which was arrived at between the parties after due negotiations. The plaintiffs have also waited to raise the challenge to the transaction for about six years from the date of execution of the documents and atleast for about two years after transmitting the notice of cancellation of agreement. In the meantime, the defendants have secured all the clearances and started development activities over the property. It is pointed out that the several structures having about 22 storey have been built on the properties involved in the suit. Considering the progress of the development activity and the stage of the construction, the irreparable loss that would be caused to the defendants is more if they are prohibited from continuing with the development activities. Having received the amount of consideration in respect of the properties, the prima-facie case and balance of convenience also does not tilt in favour of the plaintiffs for securing an order of injunction against the defendants restraining them from developing the property. Certain dates and events are material for considering as to whether the balance of convenience lies in favour of the plaintiff. The Development Agreement and the Power of Attorney are executed on 30 August, 2005 and the plaintiffs have been paid the entire consideration amount in or about the year 2005. The defendants secured Exemption orders under Section 20 of the Urban Land Ceiling Act in the year 2007 and also secured N.A Permission on 27 December, 2007 and thereafter started development activities over the property. The construction was started and was continued during the year 2008 till 2011 and defendants have invested an amount to the tune of Rs. 100 Crores for constructing several multi storey buildings. The defendants also contend that they have created third party interest in favour of about 500 persons and residential units have been agreed to be sold to the prospective purchasers.

11. Thus, considering the sequence of events stated above, balance of convenience does not lie in favour of the plaintiff. The principles governing grant of injunctions are stated in the matter of M. Gurudas v. Rasaranjan(2006) 8 SCC 367. In Paragraph 18 of the Judgment it is observed that While considering an application for injunction, it is well-settled, the courts would pass an order thereupon having regard to:

(i) Prima facie

(ii) Balance of convenience

(iii) Irreparable injury.

In Paragraph 19 it is stated further that a finding on ‘prima facie case’ would be a finding of fact. However, while arriving at such finding of fact, the court not only must arrive at a conclusion that a case for trial has been made out but also other factors requisite for grant of injunction exist.

In Paragraph 21 of the Judgment it is observed that

“While considering the question of granting an order of injunction one way or the other, evidently, the court, apart from finding out a prima facie case, would consider the question in regard to the balance of convenience of the parties as also irreparable injury which might be suffered by the plaintiffs if the prayer for injunction is to be refused. The contention of the plaintiffs must be bona fide. The question sought to be tried must be a serious question and not only on a mere triable issue.”

12. In the instant matter, considering the fact that the Development Agreement as well as the irrevocable Power of Attorney is executed in the year 2005 and the amount of consideration amounting to more than Rs. 3 Crores have been passed in favour of the plaintiffs, I do not find that the plaintiffs are entitled to any equitable relief. Having received the amount of consideration and permitted the defendants to develop the property and having invested the amount to the tune of Rs. 100 Crores by the defendants, it would not be appropriate at this stage to prohibit the defendants from continuing with the development activities or even putting a restraint in respect of creation of third party interest. In my opinion, the plaintiffs are not litigating in a bonafide manner nor the prima-facie case and balance of convenience lies in favour of the plaintiffs. The trial Court has committed serious error in granting injunction and stalling the development project wherein the defendants have invested more than Rs. 100 Crores. The impugned order of injunction passed by the trial Court on 13 May, 2011, therefore, deserves to be quashed and set aside and the same is accordingly quashed and set aside. Since the substantive suit presented by the plaintiff is pending for adjudication before the trial Court, it is made clear that whatever the development activities the defendants may carry on and the third party interest which the defendant may create would be subject to final outcome of the suit.

13. The Appeal from Order, thus, stands allowed. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

14. In view of disposal of Appeal from Order, Civil Application does not survive and stands disposed of.