Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohd. Ansar Salik And Others v. Shaikh Hamid Babumiya Inamdar And Others

Bombay High Court
Feb 9, 2010
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicants moved an application under section 36 of the Wakf Act, 1995, with the Chief Executive Officer (C.E.O.), Maharashtra State Board of Wakfs (respondent No. 25), seeking registration of property CTS No. 395.A (15.28 R.), Nana Peth, Pune, as a Wakf in the name "Raj Mohammad Takiya of Nana Peth, Pune 2". The C.E.O., by order dated 24-4-2008, directed registration and issued a certificate.

Respondent Nos. 1–23 challenged that registration by filing Application No. 28/2008 before the Maharashtra Wakf Tribunal, Aurangabad. The applicants had sought to strike the respondents' pleadings in that Tribunal proceeding (Exh.33) invoking Order VI Rule 16 and Order VII Rule 11-A CPC; the Tribunal rejected that strike application by order dated 17-4-2009. A Civil Revision Application (No. 41/2009) was earlier disposed of by this Court keeping points open.

The learned Presiding Officer of the Wakf Tribunal, after hearing the parties, by order dated 24-9-2009 rejected registration of the property as a Wakf under the Maharashtra Wakf Act. The present civil revision impugns that Tribunal order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the registration order of the C.E.O., dated 24-4-2008, and the subsequent registration application (filed 21-2-2008) were barred by the time-limit in section 36(8) of the Wakf Act, 1995, given the Board's establishment on 4-1-2002.
  2. Whether section 36(8) permits any relaxation or condonation of the three-month limitation prescribed for registration of wakfs created before or after commencement of the Act.
  3. Whether the C.E.O. complied with the inquiry and notice obligations in section 36(7) before registering the wakf (i.e., whether the C.E.O. conducted the necessary verification and heard persons administering the wakf property).
  4. Whether the legal principle "once a Wakf, always a Wakf" (as relied upon from Sayyad Ali) and earlier adjudications recognising the property as Wakf alter the effect of the statutory limitation under section 36(8).

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' / Mr. Gangapurwala's Arguments

  • The Presiding Officer wrongly negated the effect of earlier litigation (First Appeal No. 469/1977; confirmed in LPA No. 39/1992) which had treated the property as a Wakf; accordingly the C.E.O. was justified in directing registration.
  • There is a distinction between a right and an obligation: registration was an obligation to be performed in terms of the final adjudication, and thus section 36(8)'s strict limitation should not prevent registration in this case.
  • The property's long user (no burials since 1933) does not mean loss of character as a Wakf; "once a Wakf, always a Wakf" (reliance on Sayyad Ali v. A.P. Wakf Board).
  • The registration under the Bombay Public Trusts Act was ministerial after the LPA judgment, and applicants are third parties with no personal gain, only sectarian interest in the property.
  • Reliance placed on Garware Chemicals Ltd. v. BIFR to argue the Board's obligation and to contest the strict operation of limitation where the statutory obligation exists.

Respondents' / Mr. Shah's Arguments

  • Section 36(8) of the Wakf Act operates as a bar of limitation for registration and there is no power in the Board to relax that limitation; it is not open to the Board to condone delay.
  • Section 36(8) is pari materia to section 25(8) of the Wakf Act, 1954; reliance was placed on M.P. Wakf Board v. Subhan Shah (2006) 10 SCC 696 to show that late applications are barred by the statutory period.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sayyad Ali v. A.P. Wakf Board, Hyderabad, (1998) 2 SCC 642 Principle that a wakf is a permanent dedication and "once a Wakf, always a Wakf". The applicants relied on this as supporting the property's continuing character as a Wakf; the Court noted the principle but held it must be considered against the statutory limitation and the facts of the case.
Garware Chemicals Ltd. v. Board of Industrial and Financial Reconstruction, 2004 (2) Mh.L.J. 707 Used by applicants to argue that an obligation to approach a statutory Board may not be strictly time-barred or that delay can be considered in context (analogy from SICA jurisprudence). The Court distinguished this authority as not applicable: unlike SICA, the Wakf Act contains no penal consequences for failure to register and the present application before the C.E.O. left no room for exemption from the statutory time-limit.
M.P. Wakf Board v. Subhan Shah, (2006) 10 SCC 696 Interpretation of section 25 (and specifically sub-section (8)) of the Wakf Act, 1954 — showing that statutory time-limits (three months) for registration operate as a bar to late applications. The Court accepted the force of this precedent, treating section 25(8) of 1954 as pari materia to section 36(8) of the 1995 Act, and used it to support the conclusion that the applicants' registration application was time-barred.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the chronology and statutory scheme. Key dates were noted: the earlier First Appeal order (17-10-1989) and LPA (26-2-1993), the Board's establishment (4-1-2002), the applicants' registration application (21-2-2008) and the C.E.O.'s registration order (24-4-2008).

The Court reproduced section 36 (particularly sub-sections (1), (2), (7) and (8)) and analysed the combined effect of section 36(1) and section 36(8). Section 36(8) provides that, for wakfs created before commencement of the Act, every application for registration must be made within three months from such commencement and, for wakfs created after commencement, within three months from creation; where there was no Board at creation, the application must be within three months of establishment of the Board.

Applying those provisions to the facts (Board established 4-1-2002; application filed in 2008), the Court concluded the application and C.E.O.'s registration order were barred by section 36(8). The Court held that the statute did not provide any power to relax or condone the statutory period; the rigour of limitation must be mandatorily adhered to.

The Court considered the applicants' contentions that registration was an obligation and relied on authorities to contend the limitation should not operate in that context. The Court distinguished the Garware/BIFR authority relied on by applicants, observing that the Wakf Act lacks penal consequences for non-registration and that the present application was an original proceeding before the C.E.O., leaving no room for an exemption to the statutory period.

The Court also considered procedural duties under section 36(7). It found that the C.E.O. failed to make requisite inquiries and to give notice/hearing to the persons administering the wakf property: many columns in the application were left blank, the affidavit contained incorrect statements (e.g., asserting that the applicant was managing the property despite that not being true), and the C.E.O. did not hear the respondents (who were descendants and persons administering the wakf property). Thus the C.E.O. registered the wakf on an incomplete and insufficiently verified record.

The Court observed that development of the property by builders (respondent Nos. 24(a)(b)) did not alter the legal conclusion because any development is subject to the outcome of rights decided in earlier proceedings (F.A. 469/1977). The Tribunal's rejection of the registration application was therefore in accordance with the record and law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Civil Revision Application was found to be without merit and was REJECTED. The rule was discharged and the Tribunal's order rejecting registration of the property as a Wakf was upheld.

Immediate consequences for the parties:

  • The registration application filed on 21-2-2008 and the C.E.O.'s registration order dated 24-4-2008 were held to be barred by section 36(8) of the Wakf Act, 1995, having regard to the Board's establishment on 4-1-2002.
  • The C.E.O.'s failure to conduct the inquiries mandated by section 36(7) and to hear the persons administering the wakf property was identified as a procedural defect; the C.E.O. acted on an incomplete application and made registrations without proper verification or notice.
  • Any development carried out by private developers remains subject to rights determined in earlier proceedings (F.A. 469/1977) and does not affect the statutory limitation analysis.

Broader legal implication stated by the Court:

  • The Court emphasised that section 36(8) prescribes a strict statutory limitation for registration of wakfs and that the statute contains no provision for relaxation or condonation of that period; the rigour of the limitation must be observed.

Note on precedent and novelty: The opinion applied established authorities and statutory interpretation to the facts; it did not purport to create a new legal principle beyond affirming that section 36(8) admits no relaxation and that C.E.O.s must comply with section 36(7)'s inquiry and notice obligations.

Order accordingly.
Show all summary ...

1. Heard, by consent, finally. Rule. Counsel for respondents waives service.

2. An application under section 36 of Wakf Act, 1995, was moved by the applicants herein with the Chief Executive Officer, Maharashtra State Board of Wakfs (respondent No. 25) (hereinafter referred to as “C.E.O, Wakfs”), to register the property CTS No. 395.A admeasuring 15.28 R. situate at Nana Peth, Pune, as a Wakf property (hereinafter referred to as “the property”), to be in the name and style as Raj Mohammad Takiya of Nana Peth, Pune 2. The C.E.O, Wakfs, by his order dt. 24-4-2008, directed to register the said property as Wakf property, and issued a certificate of registration to that effect.

3. This order was challenged by present respondent Nos. 1 to 23 by an Application bearing No. 28/2008 before the learned Presiding Officer, Maharashtra Wakf Tribunal, Aurangabad. The present applicants submit, said proceeding was an abuse of process of law as the respondent staked claim to the said property as ancestral property in spite of earlier judgment of this Court. An application Exh. 33 invoking provisions of Order VI Rule 16 and Order VII Rule 11-A of Civil Procedure Code was moved, thereby praying for striking of the pleadings and rejecting Application No. 28/2008. The learned Presiding Officer of the Wakf Tribunal, by order dt. 17-4-2009, rejected said application. The Civil Revision Application moved before this Court (No. 41/2009) is disposed of by this Court, keeping all points open.

4. Learned Presiding Officer, after hearing both the sides has, by order dt. 24-9-2009, rejected registration of the property to be a Wakf property under the Maharashtra Wakf Act, said order is now impugned.

5. Mr. Gangapurwala submits that the learned Presiding Officer erred in ignoring and negating the effect of earlier litigation between the parties, arising out of First Appeal No. 469/1977 dt. 17-10-1989, confirmed in LPA Court (No. 39/1992). The learned Presiding Officer should have considered that the C.E.O, Wakfs, has justifiably directed registration. Law will have to be interpreted to achieve object of the Act. There is distinction between a right and obligation. There was an obligation to register the property as a Wakf in terms of final adjudication in LPA, treating the property as Wakf. The fact situation, according to him, also needs consideration, since 1933 A.D no burials are taken place in the property, still its character as a Wakf will not be lost. It was a ministerial act after the judgment in the L.P.A to carry registration under the Bombay Public Trusts Act. The applicants are third parties, they have no personal gains in the property but are interested in it being belonging to the same sect. The section 36(8) of Wakf Act will not apply as the property is Wakf by user. He stressed, by placing reliance to the judgment in the matter of Sayyad Ali v. A.P Wakf Board, Hyderabad, (1998) 2 SCC 642, once a Wakf, always a Wakf.

6. Mr. Shah, senior Counsel, contended, in terms of section 36(8) of the Wakf Act, there operates a bar of limitation for registration and no power vests in the Board to relax the limitation. There is no enabling provision to relax the limitation. He stressed, section 36(8) is pari materia to section 25-A of the Wakf Act, 1954.

7. The status of the property to be Wakf is conclusively indicated in F.A No. 469/1977, confirmed in LPA No. 39/1992. Its registration under the Bombay Public Trusts Act was a ministerial act. However, its such status will not get a recognition of the registration under the Wakf Act, 1995, in terms of the legal hurdles indicated hereinbefore. The contention of applicant that once a Wakf always a Wakf needs to be considered in the background of the above discussed facts. It is settled, as indicated in the matter of Sayyad Ali, a Wakf is a permanent dedication of the property for purposes recognized by Muslim Law as pious, religious or charitable and the property having been found as Wakf, always retains its character as a Wakf.

8. The definition of the “Board” in section 3(c) indicates, a Board of Wakfs established under sub-section (1) or, as the case may be, under sub-section (2) of section 13 and shall include a common Wakf Board established under section 106.

“13. Incorporation.— (1) With effect from such date as the State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, appoint in this behalf, there shall be established a Board of Wakfs under such name as may be specified in the notification.

(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), if the Shia wakfs; in any State constitute in number more than fifteen per cent., of all the wakfs, in the State or if the income of the properties of the Shia wakfs in the State constitutes more than fifteen per cent., of the total income of properties of all the wakfs in the State, the State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, establish a Board of Wakfs each for Sunni wakfs and for Shia wakfs under such names as may be specified in the notification.

(3) The Board shall be a body corporate having perpetual succession and a common seal with power to acquire and hold property and to transfer any such property subject to such conditions and restrictions as may be prescribed and shall by the said name sue and be sued.”

Section 14 contemplates composition of the Board.

9. The orders referred above in the First Appeal is of 17-10-1989 while of the LPA Court is dt. 26th February, 1993 in LPA No. 39/1992. The establishment of the Board is dt. 4th January, 2002. The application under section 36 of the Wakf Act by the applicant is dt. 21-2-2008 while the order of the C.E.O, Wakf, is dt. 24-4-2008, directing registration. By virtue of effect of section 36(8), the application should have been made within three months from the date of creation of the Wakf, or within three months from the date of establishment of the Board.

10. section 36 of the Wakf Act, 1995, relevant for the purposes of the present application, is reproduced as under:

“36. Registration.— (1) Every wakf, whether created before or after the Commencement of this Act., shall be registered at the office of the Board.

(2) Application for registration shall be made by the mutawalli:

Provided that such applications may be made by the wakf or his descendants or a beneficiary of the wakf or any Muslim belonging to the sect to which the wakf belongs.

(7) On receipt of an application for registration, the Board may, before the registration of the wakf make such inquiries as it thinks fit in respect of the genuineness and validity of the application and correctness of any particulars therein and when the application is made by any person other than the person administering the wakf property, the Board shall, before registering the wakf, give notice of the application to the person administering the wakf property and shall hear him if he desires to be heard.

(8) In the case of wakfs created before the commencement of this Act, every application for registration shall be made, within three months from such commencement and in the case of wakfs created after such commencement, within three months from the date of the creation of the wakf:

Provided that where there, is no board at the time of creation of a wakf such application will be made within three months from the date of establishment of the Board.”

Mr. Gangapurwala submits, reading section 36(1) with section 36(8), it was an obligation cast on the Board to register the property to be a Wakf. The strict limitation in terms of section 36(8) would be applicable when any person stakes right to the property. It will not be applicable for a matter where it is an obligation. In order to stress his point, learned Counsel relied to the judgment in the matter of Garware Chemicals Limited v. Board of Industrial and Financial Reconstruction, 2004 (2) Mh.L.J 707. The Division Bench observed in para 11 that section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act (SICA Act) does not lay down any period of limitation although it creates an obligation upon the Board of Directors to approach the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction within the time stipulated by the section and failure to discharge the obligation may entail penal consequences as provided by section 33(1) of the Act. The Division Bench also observed, “however, we may hasten to add that Board is within its rights to reject the reference where the Board finds that the Directors are guilty of supine indifference or there is lack of bona fides on the part of the Directors or where the only purpose of making reference is to take shelter of the protection given by the Act. In such cases the Board would be undoubtedly justified in rejecting the reference on the ground of delay and laches”.

11. The above judgment will not be applicable in the present case as there is no provision under the Wakf Act striking penal consequences for non registration of the obligation to register a Wakf. The application for registration is in the shape of original proceedings before C.E.O, hence no room left for extending exemption to the Statute. Section 36(1) and (8) read together speaks of registration of Board by the Mutawalli. Present case is within the bracket of proviso to sub-section (2) of section 36 which contemplates that such application may be made by the Wakf or any Muslim belonging to the sect to which the Wakf belongs.

12. It is evident, the legislation did not contemplate relaxation and condonation of limitation in making an application for registration by any Muslim belonging to the sect concerned. The law mandates, the rigour of limitation will prevail to be strictly adhered to no-cognizance could be taken in the eye of law if there is bar in terms of section 36(8) of making the application. Thus, power of relaxation of the period of limitation, is not indicated anywhere. The creation of statute is naturally unknown to common law.

13. Mr. Shah, learned senior Counsel, referred to M.P Wakf Board v. Subhan Shah, (2006) 10 SCC 696. section 25(1) of the wakf act, 1954, which is as under, is apparently in pari materia to the section 36(8) of the Wakf Act, 1995.

“25. Registration.— (1) Every wakf whether created before or after the commencement of this Act shall be registered at the office of the Wakf Commissioner.

(2) Application for registration shall be made by the mutawalli:

Provided that such applications may be made by the wakf or his descendants or a beneficiary of the wakf or any Muslim belonging to the sect to which the wakf belongs.

(7) On receipt of an application for registration, the Wakf Commissioner may, before the registration of the wakf, make such inquiries as he thinks fit in respect of the genuineness and validity of the application and the correctness of any particulars therein and when the application is made by any person other than the person administering the wakf property, the Wakf Commissioner shall, before registering the wakf, give notice of the application to the person administering the wakf property and shall hear him if he desires to be heard.

(8) In the case of wakfs created before the commencement of this Act, every application for registration shall be made, within three months from such commencement and in the case of wakfs created after such commencement, within three months from the date of the creation of the wakf.”

In the matter of M.P Wakf Board, One Hazrat Sha Walli was a Peer. On his death, a Dargah was established in his memory. Erstwhile Maharaja Holkar Darbar, granted Mafi Inayat Land to the Dargah. Allegedly, the land in question was held to be not forming a part of Wakf in terms of the provisions of the Wakf Act, 1954. One Munna Bai filed an application for getting her name mutated in respect of the property in question. It was dismissed on 4-2-1967. She thereafter filed an application under section 25 of the 1954 Act for registering the Dargah as a Wakf. A notice was issued to Subhan Shah and others who were the heirs of the said Hazrat Sha Walli. They filed their cause denying and disputing that the property in question was a Wakf property.

It is observed in paragraph No. 12:

“Maintainability of the suit, therefore, is not in question. The property was dedicated to the Dargah, if any, a long time back. An application for registration of the said property as a Wakf property in terms of section 25 of the 1954 Act, therefore, could have been filed only within the period specified thereunder, viz., nine months from the date of coming into force of the said Act. Registration of Wakfs whether created before or after the commencement of the said Act is governed by section 25. A copy of the Wakf deed was also required to be enclosed with such an application. Sub-section (7) of section 25 of the 1954 Act provides for making of an inquiry into the correctness or otherwise of the contents of the said application.”

Paragraph No. 18 is as under:

“18. Title to a property has a definite connotation. It is not the same as user. The Tribunal failed to deal with the question as to whether the Board had the requisite jurisdiction to entertain the application filed by Munna Bai being barred by limitation, insofar as period of limitation provided for under sub-section (8) of section 25 is merely three months, Munna Bai filed an application after 12 years after coming into force of the 1954 Act.”

Mr. Shah submits, the law laid down by the Apex Court applies with same force in the present matter.

There should not be any controversy to accept this proposition.

14. These details, unmistakably, indicate that the initiation of the proceedings dt. 21-2-2008 in terms of section 36 of the Wakf Act by the applicant and the order thereon dt. 24-4-2008 by the C.E.O, Wakf, is barred by section 36(8) of the Wakf Act, 1995, in view of establishment of Board on 4th Jan.,2002.

I hold section 36(8) of the Wakf Act, 1995, stipulates limitation of making application and no relaxation thereto is provided in the Statute. Its rigour needs to be mandatorily adhered to.

15. The development of the properties by the builder/developer, respondent Nos. 24(a)(b) though is apparent, however, it will not change the scenario, as the development and construction, if any, will be subject to outcome of rights of parties, decided in earlier proceedings F.A 469/1977.

16. Another facet of the matter is: while dealing with applications under section 36 for registration of the Wakf, section 36(7) obligates the C.E.O for making such enquiries about the genuineness and validity of the application, correctness of the particulars therein. When the application is made by any person other than the person administering the Wakf property, the Board shall before registering the Wakf, give notice of the application to the person administering the Wakf property and shall hear him if he desires to be heard.

17. Respondents herein are the persons administering the Wakf property being descendants of Raj Mohammad Takiya of Nana Peth, Pune-2. Before causing any inquiry, the C.E.O Wakf was duty bound to verify the genuineness and validity of the application, which he apparently did not. Most of the columns in the application are left blank. C.E.O blindly acted on incomplete application. In verification, a incorrect statement on oath is made, showing the applicants to be managing or in charge of property, or, nobody else is looking after the property in question. This affidavit/declaration appearing at page No. 193 of the paper book, under signature of applicant Mohd. Ansar Salik is contrary to the fact as he was never a person of any committee appointed to look after the Wakf. The learned C.E.O Wakf did not bother to call upon the respondent herein to hear them before such registration.

18. The learned C.E.O, Wakf, was duty bound to have taken into consideration to the development of the property legally effected by respondent and application of the Maharashtra Slums Area (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971, as it was under a special scheme the property was developed.

19. There is no illegality in the order of the learned Presiding Officer, Wakf Tribunal as the order is in tune with the available record and law. The maintainability of the application for registration itself being under cloud, it was rightly rejected by the learned Presiding Officer. Civil Revision Application lacks merit. Rejected. Rule discharged.

Order accordingly.