Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Girish Vasantrao Bhoyar And Another v. Nimbaji Warluji Bambal .

Bombay High Court
Apr 30, 2009
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners filed a writ petition seeking to quash and set aside an order dated 18-7-2008 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Junior Division, Kalmeshwar, in Regular Civil Suit No. 110 of 2004. The impugned order appointed a Commissioner under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC). The underlying suit involved the respondent seeking restoration of possession, recovery of damages, removal of encroachment, and vacant possession of a disputed field. The petitioners contested the respondent's claims and denied any encroachment. During proceedings, the respondent applied under Order 26, Rule 10A CPC read with Section 151 CPC for appointment of an expert Commissioner to investigate and ascertain the boundaries of the disputed land based on records and title deeds. The petitioners opposed this application, contending that it amounted to collecting evidence for the respondent. The Civil Judge allowed the application and appointed the Commissioner to measure specified survey fields and conduct joint measurement. The petitioners challenged this order by filing the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the learned Civil Judge exceeded jurisdiction by appointing a Commissioner under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC for measuring land and conducting joint measurements, allegedly amounting to collecting evidence for the respondent.
  2. Whether the appointment of a Commissioner to investigate and demarcate boundaries in a boundary dispute is permissible under the Civil Procedure Code.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The learned Judge exceeded jurisdiction by appointing a Commissioner, as such an order effectively allows the Commissioner to collect evidence for the respondent.
  • Relied on the judgment of this Court in Sanjay N. Khandare v. Sahebrao K. Khandare, where appointment of a Commissioner to ascertain possession was held impermissible.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The application for appointment of the Commissioner was not for collecting evidence but to facilitate proper adjudication by ascertaining the true boundaries.
  • Joint measurement of disputed survey numbers was necessary to demarcate boundaries and resolve the dispute effectively.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sanjay N. Khandare v. Sahebrao K. Khandare, 2001 (2) Mh.L.J 959 : 2001 (1) Bom. C.R 800 Appointment of Commissioner to ascertain actual possession is impermissible. Distinguished on facts; appointment here was for measurement and demarcation, not possession determination.
Haryana Waqf Board v. Shanti Sarup, (2008) 8 SCC 671 Appropriateness of appointing a local Commissioner under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC for land demarcation disputes. Followed; supported the appointment of Commissioner for investigation in boundary disputes.
Kashinath Ramkrishna Chopade v. Purushottam Tulshiram Tekade, 2005 (4) Mh.L.J 471 : 2005 (6) Bom. C.R 267 Boundary disputes and land identity controversies justify local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC. Applied to affirm the propriety of the Commissioner’s appointment for joint measurement and investigation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the nature and purpose of the Commissioner’s appointment. It distinguished the present case from the precedent relied upon by the petitioners, where the Commissioner was appointed to determine possession, which was impermissible. Here, the Commissioner was appointed specifically to measure the lands and conduct joint measurements to demarcate boundaries, which is a permissible local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC. The Court referred to authoritative Supreme Court and this Court judgments that recognize the appropriateness of appointing Commissioners in boundary disputes for local investigations. The Court found no jurisdictional error or infirmity in the impugned order and concluded that the appointment was lawful and necessary to facilitate just adjudication.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is dismissed.

The Court upheld the appointment of the Commissioner for measuring and demarcating the disputed land, confirming the trial Court's jurisdiction under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC in boundary disputes. The decision directly affects the parties by allowing the local investigation to proceed but does not set any new precedent beyond affirming established principles. No order as to costs was made, and the interim stay was vacated.

Show all summary ...

1. Heard Shri Patwardhan, learned counsel for the petitioners Shri Vaidya, learned counsel for the respondent. Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith with the consent of the parties.

2. This is a petition filed seeking to quash and set aside the order dated 18-7-2008 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Junior Division, Kalmeshwar, in Regular Civil Suit No. 110 of 2004, whereby the Commissioner was appointed under Order 26, Rule 9 of Civil Procedure Code. It is the case of the petitioners that the respondent has filed a suit against the petitioners for restoration of possession and recovery of damages and to remove the encroachment and to place the respondent in vacant possession of the suit field as prayed for in the suit. The petitioners filed their written statement disputing the claim of the respondent as well as his contention that they had encroached upon his property. During the course of the proceedings, the respondent filed an application under Order 26, Rule 10A of Civil Procedure Code read with section 151 of Civil Procedure Code, stating that there is a dispute regarding the area and boundary of the field of the respondent and as such it was necessary to appoint an expert Commissioner to investigate and ascertain the boundaries in respect of field of the petitioners as well as the respondent as per records and title deeds of the respective parties. The petitioners opposed the said application filed by the respondent by filing their reply and contended that in case such an application is allowed, it would amount to allowing the Commissioner to collect the evidence. By order dated 18-7-2008, the learned Civil Judge, Junior Division, Kalmeshwar, allowed the said application and appointed T.I.L.R, Kalmeshwar, as a Court Commissioner to measure the lands i.e Field Survey No. 175 and Field Survey No. 41 situated within the local limits of Mouza - Nimji, P.H No. 23, Tahsil -Kalmeshwar, District - Nagpur, and to carry out joint measurement of the land at the earliest on payment of requisite expenses. The said order passed by the learned Judge is sought to be impugned in the present petition. During the course of the arguments, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners urged before me that the learned Judge has exceeded his jurisdiction while passing the impugned order inasmuch as by such order, it would amount to collecting evidence for the respondent. In support of his submissions, he has relied upon the judgment of this Court in the case of Sanjay N. Khandare v. Sahebrao K. Khandare, reported at 2001 (2) Mh.L.J 959 : 2001 (1) Bom. C.R 800.

3. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent urged that the present application has been filed not for the purpose of collecting any evidence but on the contrary for considering the matter in proper perspective in order to facilitate the Court to decide the controversy considering the fact that the petitioners and the respondent are claiming rights to different survey numbers and joint measurements would be feasible to demarcate the boundary between the properties claimed by the petitioners and the respondent.

4. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the impugned order, I feel that there is no jurisdictional error committed by the learned Judge while passing the impugned order. The judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioners is not applicable to the facts of the present case inasmuch as in the case in the said judgment, the Court Commissioner was appointed for the purpose of ascertaining who is in possession of the property in dispute. In such facts, this Court held that a Court Commissioner cannot be appointed to ascertain who is in actual possession of the suit field. The purpose of appointment of the Commissioner is totally different in the present case. The Court Commissioner has been appointed for the specific purpose as stated in the impugned order viz., to measure the lands claimed by the respondent and the petitioners and also to take joint measurements of such lands.

5. In the case of Haryana Waqf Board v. Shanti Sarup, reported in (2008) 8 SCC 671, the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that whenever there is a dispute of demarcation of the disputed land, it was appropriate for the Court to direct an investigation by appointing a local Commissioner under Order 26, Rule 9 of Civil Procedure Code. This Court in the case of Kashinath Ramkrishna Chopade v. Purushottam Tulshiram Tekade, reported at 2005 (4) Mh.L.J 471 : 2005 (6) Bom. C.R 267, has held that cases of boundary dispute and dispute about the identity of the lands are instances where a Court should order a local investigation under Order 26, Rule 9 of Civil Procedure Code. In order to determine whether there is an encroachment, it is always desirable to get the measurements of the land encroached upon. Considering the said judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court as well as the judgment of this Court, I find that there is no infirmity of any kind committed by the learned trial Judge while passing the impugned order and appointing a Commissioner for the purpose of carrying out the local investigation as ordered in the impugned order.

6. There is no jurisdictional error committed by the learned Judge while passing the impugned order and consequently, the present writ petition does not deserve any consideration. As such, the present petition is dismissed. However, in the circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs. Interim stay is vacated.

Petition dismissed.