- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Maroti v. The State Of Maharashtra
DATE : 7th August, 2008.
:
1. The present Civil Revision Application came up for final hearing. Heard Both the sides at length.
2. Writ Petition No.2958/1995 filed by the present petitioner, lateron was converted to Civil Revision Application numbered as above, as per the order of Division Bench of this Court dated 06.06.2003.
3. The petitioner has challenged the order dated 05.08.1992 passed by Special Land Acquisition Officer, Nanded, rejecting the land acquisition reference filed by the present petitioner for enhanced compensation. Admittedly, reference was received by Special Land Acquisition Officer, Minor Irrigation Nanded on 28th March, 1988 within a period of six weeks of the receipt of the notice from the Collector under Section 12, sub-section (2) of the said Act. The petitioner waited and waited and did not get any favourable response from the respondents till 05.08.1992, for a period over four years.
4. On 05.08.1992, after about four years, Special Land Acquisition Officer, Nanded communicated his decision of rejection of reference of the petitioner, for accepting the amount of award, without protest. Petitioner had not recorded "under protest", while receiving the amount of award.
5. Feeling aggrieved by the said rejection, the petitioner has filed the present petition, challenging the legality and propriety of the impugned order dated 05.08.1992 of Special Land Acquisition Officer, Nanded.
6. On record a reply was filed on affidavit, stating that there was delay and latches on the part of the petitioner and petitioner also failed to give his appearance at the time of hearing and also reiterated that he had not recorded his protest at the time of receiving the amount of compensation, consequently, his request i.e. reference was rejected. The similar reply came to be filed in other matters, and those petitioners are also represented by learned counsel Mr.A.G.Godhamgaonkar, who urged before this Court that because of impugned order of rejection dated 05.08.1992 of respondent No.2, no reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred as, the "said Act") Act" was forwarded to the Civil Court in the matter of enhancement of the compensation, at no fault of the petitioner. As mentioned above, petitioner presented his written application within a period of six weeks of the receipt of the notice from the Collector under section 12, sub-section (2) of the said Act, and therefore, there was no valid reason or legal grounds, so that respondent No.2 should reject his application for reference under Section 18 of the said Act, for determination of enhanced compensation by Civil Court. The Collector is duty bound to refer the same to the Civil Court and on his failure to do so the remedy is provided under Section 18(3) of the said Act, by way of revision under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. This legal position is not disputed by Mr.M.L.Dharashive, learned AGP for the respondent. On ig record there is a detailed application dated 28.03.1988 submitted to the Office of Special Land Acquisition Officer, Nanded, within the period prescribed i.e. six weeks. That itself is recording the "protest", and evident that he has not accepted the award finally. The protest need not in writing at the time of receiving amount in award for compensation and, therefore, the objection of the respondent does not sustain. So far as the alleged delay and latches, much hue and cry was made by the respondent. In fact, from record, it is evident that the respondent No.2 itself is guilty of delay and latches for not communicating the rejection to petitioner for a period over 4 years. It is not only the petitioner or a person receiving compensation as per award, is interested but the Collector also is an interested party to refer the matter by way of a reference to the Civil Court under Section 18 of the said Act, for determination of fair and reasonable compensation to those whose land was compulsorily acquired under the said Act, for the public purpose. Thus, payment of compensation as per the award passed by the Land Acquisition Officer, is indecisive and not a final award. But a Judicial Inquiry in the matter, by way of a reference to the Civil Court is contemplated under the said Act. Civil Court is the only forum which is a competent forum to decide "fair and reasonable compensation". Thus, it appears that the order of rejection of reference i.e. the impugned order dated 05.08.1992 passed by the Land Acquisition Officer, Nanded, is without any jurisdiction and the learned Special Land Acquisition Officer, Nanded, had failed to exercise his jurisdiction to forward the reference to the Civil Court. It is illegal and deserves to be quashed and set aside.
7. Upon consideration of the record and after hearing both the sides, the impugned order dated 05.08.1992 passed by the learned Special Land Acquisition Officer, Nanded is quashed and set aside.
8. This Civil Revision Application is allowed and respondents are directed to forward the reference made by the petitioner to the Civil Court within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of communication of this order.
Alert