- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shivshankar Gundu Jawanjal And Another v. State Of Maharashtra And Others
Judgment Summary — B.H. Marlapalle, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
This consolidated judgment disposes a group of petitions in which petitioners (described as "Unpaid Candidates" or "Unpaid Copying Clerks") seek retrospective absorption as permanent/confirmed Class III employees of the State Government. The factual matrix as set out in the opinion (and kept here strictly to the material in the judgment) is as follows:
- The State issued a Resolution dated 30-10-1961 revising recruitment rules for Revenue Clerks, setting minimum qualifications (SSC), age limits, and a procedure by which enlisted candidates could be sent for training, act as copyists when not in acting vacancies, and be paid fees on a sharing basis (70% to candidate, 30% to State).
- Those enlisted but not absorbed into clerk vacancies worked as copyists (“Unpaid Candidates”) from about 1968 onwards, following office timings, maintaining muster rolls, and receiving income largely from the fee-sharing arrangement (reported earnings around Rs. 3,000 per month in the petitioners' accounts).
- The State framed the Maharashtra Land Revenue (Inspection, Search and Supply of Copies of Land Records) Rules, 1970 (effective 6-7-1970) regulating certified-copy fees and confirming the fee-sharing regime.
- Representative litigation: O.A. No. 153 of 1991 before the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal (MAT) led to a MAT judgment dated 20-10-1992 with directions for preferential absorption/age relaxation and application procedures for unpaid candidates. The State’s SLP was dismissed by the Supreme Court on 14-7-1995.
- Following MAT and Supreme Court outcomes, the State issued Government Resolutions (G.R.s) dated 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996 to implement MAT directions, including cut-off dates and terms for absorption (notably fixing 30-11-1995 as a cut-off in the 22-10-1996 G.R.). A later G.R. of 10-3-2005 was also issued.
- Some unpaid candidates were discontinued or faced discontinuation; a total of 184 unpaid candidates were either discontinued or sought to be discontinued. Subject to interim orders, 150 posts were directed to be kept vacant by this Court's order dated 18-12-2003 for potential absorption.
- The petitions addressed both entitlement to absorption under the G.R.s and whether certain unpaid candidates constituted "backdoor entrants" (thereby disentitling them from regularisation) in the light of later Supreme Court authority (notably Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (2006) 4 SCC 1) and A. Umarani (2004) 7 SCC 112.
- The High Court heard parties, applied the relevant rules, MAT judgments and G.R.s, and issued the present decision allowing the petitions in part and setting out categories of eligible and ineligible unpaid candidates. The Court also made an interim direction permitting continued service for a limited period for a subset of candidates who wished to appeal to the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether unpaid candidates who were enlisted and worked as copyists are eligible for absorption/regularisation as permanent Class III State Government employees under MAT directions and the State's G.R.s (notably G.R. 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996) and related policy instruments.
- Whether unpaid candidates who entered or continued in service after specified dates (particularly after 12-2-1987, 13-2-1987 and after the establishment of Regional/Subordinate Service Selection Boards on 9-2-1988) qualify as "backdoor entrants" and thus are disqualified from regularisation.
- What is the impact of the Supreme Court's decisions (notably Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi and A. Umarani) on claims for regularisation by unpaid candidates who were not appointed through the recognised recruitment procedure?
- What relief and consequential benefits should be granted to those unpaid candidates found eligible for absorption, and how are available vacant posts to be allocated?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- Petitioners asserted they were enlisted candidates (from as early as 1968), worked as unpaid copyists under the procedure established by the 1961 Resolution and 1970 Rules, and were therefore entitled to absorption/regularisation pursuant to the MAT judgments and the State G.R.s (21-10-1995, 22-10-1996 and, where invoked, 10-3-2005).
- Some petitioners claimed that those who did not get the benefit of later G.R. dated 10-3-2005 had, by that date, completed ten years of service and therefore should be absorbed under the 10-3-2005 scheme.
- For those appointed after 13-2-1987, counsel for some petitioners argued that denying regularisation would create discrimination vis-à-vis similarly placed candidates; they sought parity and the benefit of G.R.s where appropriate.
- In the hearing's oral application, petitioners asked for status quo for unpaid workers who wished to challenge the decision at the Apex Court, so that their employment continue pending any appeal.
State / Respondent Arguments
- The State, in affidavits-in-reply, primarily opposed relief on the ground that many petitioners did not satisfy the qualifying service period of ten years as required by the G.R.s dated 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996.
- The State also contended that unpaid candidates could not be regarded as government servants for purposes of invoking MAT jurisdiction (i.e., matters were not maintainable before the Tribunal for some applicants).
- Following the Constitution Bench decision in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi ((2006) 4 SCC 1), the State argued that relief of regularisation could not be granted to persons who had entered government employment by side-entrances/backdoor entries and who were not appointed through the prescribed recruitment procedure.
- When pressed on failing to implement G.R. 10-3-2005 for many petitioners, the State did not supply reasons in the record; in a later affidavit it relied on Umadevi to oppose grant of relief for those not otherwise eligible under earlier G.R.s.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| O.A. No. 153 of 1991 (Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal) — Judgment dated 20-10-1992 | Directed preferential treatment/age relaxation and modes of application/selection for unpaid candidates (preference for those with more than 10 years' service, other application routes for those with less time, registration with employment exchange, not referring some to Regional Subordinate Selection Board). | The Court treated MAT's directions as a foundation for the G.R. dated 21-10-1995 and relied on the MAT's analysis to determine who should be regarded as eligible for regularisation. The Court noted some MAT observations but distinguished the MAT's remark that applicants "cannot claim the benefits of regular employees under Articles 14 and 16" as inapplicable to all petitioners once the 1961 G.R. and selection procedure were considered. |
| O.A. No. 895 of 1995 (Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal) — Judgment dated 30-11-1995 | Addressed unpaid candidates working on licence with more than 10 years' service and, on compassionate grounds, directed the State to frame a scheme consistent with the earlier MAT judgment for ad-hoc appointments; influenced the G.R. dated 22-10-1996 which fixed 30-11-1995 as a cut-off. | The Court accepted that the 22-10-1996 G.R. adopted the 30-11-1995 cut-off derived from this MAT judgment; it held unpaid candidates who completed ten years by that cut-off were eligible for absorption under the G.R. dated 22-10-1996 and that those candidates had been wrongly denied benefits. |
| A. Umarani v. Registrar, Co-operative Societies, (2004) 7 SCC 112 | Sets out limits on regularisation/confirmation where appointments are not made by following the prescribed selection procedure; invoked in High Court orders cited by the parties (including W.P. No. 942 of 2004). | The High Court earlier followed Umarani in W.P. No. 942 of 2004 to deny regularisation in certain cases. In the present judgment the Court treated Umarani as a binding principle governing situations where appointments were not through prescribed procedure, and referenced it when assessing the validity of the G.R. dated 10-3-2005 and whether certain candidates could be regularised. |
| Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi, (2006) 4 SCC 1 (Constitution Bench) | Affirms that persons appointed temporarily/contractually or through backdoor entries cannot claim regularisation or a right to permanent appointment where appointments should have been made only by following proper recruitment procedure; rejects legitimate-expectation claims to confer permanency where recruitment rules were not followed. | The State invoked Umadevi to resist regularisation for candidates who entered by backdoor routes. The High Court applied Umadevi to hold that unpaid candidates who entered service after 13-2-1987 (and particularly after establishment of selection boards on 9-2-1988) — i.e., those whose appointment was not in keeping with prescribed recruitment procedure — could not be regularised under the GRs. The Court nonetheless distinguished those appointed earlier (on or before 12-2-1987) as not being backdoor entrants and therefore not barred by Umadevi from relief under the G.R.s dated 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeds largely by mapping the historical recruitment regime, Government Resolutions, MAT directions and later Supreme Court authority onto the dates and factual status of the petitioners in order to determine eligibility for regularisation. The reasoning in the opinion, reproduced here faithfully and concisely, follows these steps:
-
Historical framework and recruitment procedure:
- The Court reviewed the G.R. dated 30-10-1961 (revised rules for enlistment and training of revenue clerks), the Maharashtra Land Revenue Rules, 1970 (procedures for certified copies and fee-sharing) and subsequent administrative instruments establishing selection boards (notably G.R. dated 9-2-1988 establishing Regional and State Subordinate Service Selection Boards; these Boards were later dissolved and reconstituted at different times).
- Those enlisted under the 1961 G.R. were required to attend training and, until a clerk vacancy arose, to work as copyists paid on a fees-sharing basis; the Court found this to be a formal procedure of enlistment rather than a mere informal arrangement.
-
Identification of two classes of unpaid candidates by reference to dates and policy changes:
- The Court identified 12-2-1987 and 13-2-1987 as critical dates (the G.R. and circular of 13-2-1987 had banned appointment of unpaid copying clerks in the future). It found that candidates appointed on or before 12-2-1987 were not "backdoor entrants" and had been enlisted in accordance with previously prescribed procedures; those appointed on or after 13-2-1987 — and especially those appointed after the establishment of Regional/Subordinate Selection Boards (9-2-1988) — were backdoor entrants whose appointments did not follow the prescribed recruitment mode.
-
Application of MAT directions and State G.R.s:
- The Court noted MAT's judgment in O.A. No. 153 of 1991 and MAT's subsequent order in O.A. No. 895 of 1995, and observed that the State had implemented MAT's directions by issuing G.R. dated 21-10-1995 and G.R. dated 22-10-1996 (with the latter fixing 30-11-1995 as the relevant cut-off date for ten years' service in some contexts). The Court treated eligible unpaid candidates (those enlisted before the ban) as entitled to benefits under the G.R.s if they satisfied the conditions (minimum qualification, registration etc.).
- The Court concluded that candidates who completed ten years by the relevant cut-off (notably by 30-11-1995 for the 22-10-1996 G.R.) were entitled to absorption and had been wrongly denied such benefit.
-
Effect of Supreme Court authority (Umarani and Umadevi):
- The Court recognized that A. Umarani and the Constitution Bench decision in Umadevi constrain the power to regularise employees who obtained employment otherwise than by the proper selection process. It accepted the principle that those who entered by backdoor entries or only as temporary/contractual employees cannot claim a right to regularisation as a vested entitlement.
- Applying the Umadevi principle, the Court held that unpaid candidates appointed from 13-2-1987 onwards (and especially those appointed after the establishment of selection boards in Feb 1988 who were not selected through those Boards) could not be regularised under the G.R.s.
- However, the Court distinguished petitioners who were appointed on or before 12-2-1987 as having been recruited under the older enlistment rules and therefore not "backdoor entrants" within the meaning of Umadevi; for them, Umadevi's bar did not apply and they were eligible for regularisation consistent with the State's own G.R.s.
-
Remedies and practical orders:
- The Court identified the 150 posts that were kept vacant by its own earlier order (18-12-2003) and directed that those posts be filled from among the unpaid candidates who fall in the eligible category (appointed on or before 12-2-1987 and presently in employment).
- The Court held that those to be regularised would be entitled to consequential benefits on par with similarly placed unpaid workers earlier absorbed pursuant to the G.R.s dated 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996.
- For unpaid candidates appointed from 13-2-1987 onwards who wished to approach the Supreme Court against denial of regularisation, the Court allowed an oral application to maintain status quo and directed that such candidates presently continued in employment by orders of the Court or Tribunal be permitted to continue for a period of eight weeks (to seek further remedies).
- On the 10-3-2005 G.R.: The Court observed (without inventing reasons) that the State had not provided reasons for denying benefits of the 10-3-2005 G.R. to petitioners, and that the State later relied on the Umadevi judgment to resist such claims; the Court criticised the timing and use of the 10-3-2005 G.R. in light of prior High Court decisions but did not extend its own equitable intervention to those who were backdoor entrants.
- Final disposition of legal principles: The Court thus synthesized the statutory/regulatory history, MAT directions and binding Supreme Court precedents to draw a date-based demarcation of entitlement and non-entitlement, applying the bar on regularisation from Umadevi to those who entered after the policy change banning unpaid copyist recruitment and after the establishment of selection boards.
Holding and Implications
Primary Holding: The petitions are allowed in part. The High Court (per B.H. Marlapalle, J.) made the following core rulings:
- Those Unpaid Candidates appointed on or before 12-2-1987 cannot be characterised as backdoor entrants and are eligible for regularisation/absorption under the State's schemes (G.R. dated 21-10-1995 and G.R. dated 22-10-1996). These candidates should be considered for filling the 150 Class III posts that the Court had directed to be kept vacant (order dated 18-12-2003).
- Those Unpaid Candidates appointed from 13-2-1987 onwards are not entitled to the benefits of the G.R.s dated 21-10-1995, 22-10-1996 or 10-3-2005; their claims for regularisation are barred by the principles in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi and related authorities unless it is demonstrated that their appointment conformed to the prescribed recruitment procedure.
- The regularised unpaid candidates will receive consequential benefits on par with similarly placed unpaid workers who had earlier been absorbed pursuant to the State G.R.s.
- The Court made the Rule absolute (i.e., granted the reliefs described) with no order as to costs.
- As an interim practical relief, unpaid candidates appointed from 13-2-1987 onwards who are currently continued in employment by Court or Tribunal orders and wish to appeal to the Supreme Court may be continued in service for a period of eight weeks (to enable them to seek further remedies).
Implications (direct effects):
- The immediate effect is organisational and administrative: 150 Class III posts are to be filled by the concerned Departments from among the eligible unpaid candidates (appointed on or before 12-2-1987) who are presently employed.
- Those successful in being regularised will be entitled to consequential benefits comparable to those already regularised under the G.R.s of 1995 and 1996 (the judgment explicitly grants parity of consequential benefits).
- Individuals appointed from 13-2-1987 onwards who did not follow the prescribed selection procedures are, as a class, denied regularisation under the Court's application of Umadevi; this does not preclude challenges to individual cases where it could be demonstrated that recruitment followed the proper procedure.
- No new legal doctrine beyond application of existing precedent (A. Umarani and Umadevi) is announced; the Court applied those authorities to the historical facts and G.R.s before it to determine eligibility by reference to dates and recruitment procedure compliance.
Order made absolute; no costs. Oral application for temporary continuation granted for eight weeks for specified unpaid candidates wishing to approach the Supreme Court.
B.H Marlapalle, J.:— This group of petitions is being disposed off by a common judgment as all the petitioners are seeking a common relief for being absorbed as permanent/confirmed employees of the State Government in Class III posts with retrospective effect, on the basis of the judgment of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal in O.A No. 153 of 1991 dated 20th October, 1992 and in O.A No. 895 of 1995 dated 30-11-1995, as well as the Government Resolutions issued on 21-10-1995, 22-10-1996 and 10-3-2005.
2. The Government of Maharashtra by its Resolution dated 30-10-1961 revised Rules for the recruitment of Revenue Clerks and fixed the minimum qualifications of S.S.C and maximum age limit of 23 years (open category) and 26 years (backward category). The selected candidates were to be assigned to an office to work in a clerical post and when not employed, he/she would be employed as a copyist and allowed to receive the fees. The enlisted candidates were to be sent for training with stipend and at the end of the training period if he/she would pass the test, he/she would remain as a candidate till a vacancy became available for appointing as a Clerk. A candidate who failed in the first training test would be kept on the waiting list as enlisted candidate till the result of the next such training test. Whereas the next test would be within a period of three months and if he/she again failed, the name would be removed from the list of the enlisted candidates. No person except from the approved list would be appointed to a purely temporary post. Accordingly those who were on the enlisted list but could not be absorbed against an available vacancy either on temporary or permanent post were called upon to work on payment of fees, under the Revenue Department, Settlement Commissioner Land Records, City Survey Office and the Forest Department etc.
3. The petitioners claim to be such candidates who were enlisted from 1968 onwards but could not be appointed against any available vacancies and, therefore, continued as “Unpaid Candidates” as per an appointment order issued for a Class III post. They were engaged in copying work from the public documents on the basis of sharing of fees. Out of the fees received for such public documents, 70 per cent of the amount could be paid to the petitioners while the remaining 30 per cent was to be credited in the Government Treasury. A regular muster roll was being maintained by the concerned departments in respect of these “Unpaid Candidates”. They were also required to follow the office timings, were not entitled for any salary including salary for paid/festival holidays etc. Sometimes they were given artificial breaks of few days. The earnings on fees sharing basis were to the tune of Rs. 3000/- per month.
4. The State Government framed the Maharashtra Land Revenue (Inspection, Search and Supply of Copies of Land Records) Rules, 1970 and they were brought into force with effect from 6th July, 1970. The rates of fees were fixed for certified copies of any record to be paid by the persons applying for the same and such work of copying was to be entrusted to the candidates appointed as copyists and popularly known as “Unpaid Candidates”. The remuneration for copying each document was again on the sharing basis of 70 per cent to be paid to the candidate and the balance 30 per cent to be credited to the Government treasury under the head of account “I-Land Revenue Miscellaneous”. The copying work was entirely entrusted to such Unpaid Candidates and it was not required to be undertaken by a regular member of the office establishment. However, as and when such regular employees were assigned the work of copying documents, the entire amount of fees received was to be remitted to the State Treasury, as was made clear by a subsequent Resolution dated 15-6-1972 by the State Government.
5. O.A No. 153 of 1991 was filed in the representative capacity by the Secretary of Bhoomi Abhilekh Vina-vetan Karmachari Sanghatna (an unregistered organisation) praying for the Government policy of employing “Unpaid Candidates” as arbitrary, illegal and null and void, as well as to issue directions for their regular absorption against the vacant posts and to extend them all such benefits under the Service Rules applicable to a regular permanent employee with effect from the initial date of appointment in the Revenue and Forest Department. White partly allowing the said application, the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal by its judgment dated 20-10-1992 directed as under:
(a) Unpaid candidates who have put in more than ten years of service should be given preference by relaxing their age for their absorption in Land Records Department, if they fulfil the conditions of qualifications and registration with the Employment Exchange in accordance with the orders issued by the Government vide Government Resolution dated 17-10-1978 without referring them to the Regional Subordinate Selection Board.
(b) Unpaid candidates who had put in less than ten years service but were overage should be given three more chances to apply to the Regional Subordinate Selection Board.
(c) Unpaid candidates who were within the age limit should be permitted to apply to the Regional Selection Board or MPSC whenever posts suitable to their qualifications were advertised. And
(d) Unpaid candidates should be selected for initial appointment from amongst the candidates sponsored by the District Employment Exchange instead of entertaining the direct applications and the condition that they would be free to apply to the Regional Selection Board or MPSC whenever posts suitable to their qualifications are advertised should be incorporated in the appointment order itself.
6. The State Government had belatedly challenged this decision of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal in an SLP which came to be dismissed by the Supreme Court on 14-7-1995. Per force, the State Government issued its Resolution dated 21-10-1995 for implementation of the directions set out by the MAT in O.A No. 153 of 1991. The Unpaid Candidates with more than ten years of service were directed to be absorbed against available vacant posts if they satisfied the prescribed requirements of educational qualifications and their names were registered with the employment exchange, but without referring their cases to the Regional Selection Board and also by relaxing the maximum age limit. Those who had put in less than ten years of service but had crossed the higher age limit were allowed to apply to the Regional Selection Board three times, as and when proclamations for recruitment were issued. It is thus clear that those who were appointed as Unpaid candidates on or upto 20-10-1982 were required to be absorbed against available regular vacancies whereas those who joined after 20-10-1982 were allowed to take three chances by applying to the Regional Selection Board for regular employment under the State Government and by relaxing the higher age limit prescribed and provided that every one of them possessed the minimum qualification of SSC.
7. Some of the unpaid candidates from Revenue Department approached the Aurangabad Bench of MAT and filed O.A No. 895 of 1995. When O.A No. 895 of 1995 was decided on 30-11-1995 the G.R dated 21-10-1995 was already holding the field but the applicants were working on licence basis for more than ten years. The Tribunal made it clear that by no stretch of imagination the applicants could claim to have a right of preference over the applicants in O.A No. 153 of 1991 and in the matter of getting regular employment under the Government. Only on account of compassionate consideration the Tribunal directed the State Government to frame a scheme as envisaged in its earlier judgment dated 20-10-1992 for ad-hoc appointments. The State Government issued a G.R dated 22-10-1996 for the absorption of the Unpaid candidates in the Revenue Department and fixed 30th November, 1995 as the cut off date which implied that those Unpaid candidates who had completed ten years of service as on 30-11-1995 would be entitled for absorption by following the order dated 30-11-1995 in O.A No. 895 of 1995. It was also made clear that such absorbed candidates would not be eligible for leave salary and pensionary benefits for the period they had worked as Unpaid candidates.
8. In spite of both these Resolutions issued by the State Government for absorption of the Unpaid candidates, the petitioners were either sought to be discontinued or were in fact discontinued as Unpaid candidates and when some of them had approached the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal, it was contended by the State Government that the applicants being Unpaid candidates, could not be termed as Government servants so as to invoke the Tribunal's jurisdiction under the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 thereby implying that the applications filed by them were not maintainable before the Tribunal. Consequently this set of petitions came to be filed and admittedly a total of 184 Unpaid candidates were either discontinued or sought to be discontinued. Barring a total of 33 Unpaid candidates all others were continued in the respective Departments on account of the stay orders granted by this Court or by the Tribunal. The Unpaid candidates who were directed to be continued are about 151 and on account of the orders passed by this Court on 18th December 2003, 150 posts were directed to be kept vacant for their absorption subject to the final outcome of these petitions. In Writ Petition No. 2150 of 1998 a Division Bench of this Court passed an order on 16-10-2002 and by referring to the amended Maharashtra Land Revenue (Inspection, Search and Supply of Copies of Land Records) Rules, 2001 the Unpaid candidates were directed to be paid a minimum salary of Rs. 3200/- in addition to sharing of the fees if it exceeded the said minimum salary. These directions more particularly read as under:
“In our view the demand of the Unpaid candidates that they should be paid minimum salary of Rs. 3200/- deserves to be accepted. Therefore, sharing ratio between the Government and Unpaid candidates shall be 30 percent and 70 percent respectively till Unpaid candidate receives a minimum salary of Rs. 3200/-. However, over and above, the amount of Rs. 3200/-, the sharing ratio of fees between the Government and Unpaid candidates shall be 75 per cent for the Government and 25 per cent for Unpaid Candidates. In other words Unpaid candidates shall be entitled to minimum salary of Rs. 3200/- irrespective of whether they have been assigned any work or not, provided they attend the work place on all working days. However, in case copying charges payable to Unpaid candidates exceed Rs. 3200/-, then ratio of sharing the fees shall be 75 per cent for the Government and 25 per cent for Unpaid candidates.”
9. These revised rates were directed to be made effective from October 2001 and the arrears were to be paid in two equal instalments.
10. When the State Government through the concerned Departments filed affidavits-in-reply in all these petitions, the reliefs sought for were opposed solely on the ground that the petitioners did not fulfil the qualifying service period of ten years as set out in the G.Rs dated 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996. It appears that during the pendency of these petitions one more G.R came to be issued by the State Government on 10-3-2005. This GR refers to the orders passed by this Court in Writ Petition Nos. 2067, 1885 and 1882 of 2002 for absorption of 126 Unpaid candidates as per the scheme framed by the State Government vide its G.R dated 22-10-1996. Some of the petitioners who had not put in ten years of qualifying service as on the cut off date i.e 30-11-1995 claim that as on 10-3-2005 they had completed ten years of service and, therefore, they are entitled for being absorbed under the scheme framed by the Government vide G.R dated 10-3-2005. It has been admitted that none of the petitioners who are before us are given the benefit of the latest G.R dated 10-3-2005 and all of them or the others who are similarly placed and are included in the total figure of 150 candidates are not given the benefit of absorption as per the said G.R Though no reasons are given by the State Government for denying the benefits of absorption as per the latest G.R dated 10-3-2005, by filing an additional affidavit, it-has been now contended by the State Government that in view of the Constitution Bench decision in the case of Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi, (2006) 4 SCC 1, the relief prayed for by the petitioners cannot be granted, though it is admitted that some of the petitioners were eligible for absorption pursuant to the G.R dated 21-10-1995 as well as the second G.R dated 22-10-1996.
11. In Writ Petition No. 3127 of 1998 the Superintendent of Land Records, Mumbai Suburban District has filed an affidavit-in-reply and to the same the details of all these Unpaid candidates, most of whom are the petitioners before us, have been furnished. In the said affidavit the cut off date was treated to be 20-10-1992. However, we do not find any justification in fixing the cut off date as 20-10-1992 when in the G.R dated 22-10-1996 the State Government itself has shifted the cut off date from 20-10-1992 to 30-11-1995 i.e the date on which the second judgment of the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal was rendered in O.A No. 895 of 1995. We, therefore, have no doubt in our mind that the abovementioned candidates were illegally denied benefit for absorption as per the scheme formulated by the State Government vide its G.R dated 22-10-1996 and they are eligible for being absorbed against the 150 posts directed to be kept vacant by this Court as per the order dated 18th December, 2003 passed in Writ Petition No. 2151 of 1998 and this has not been very seriously disputed by the learned AGP who addressed before us on behalf of the State Government.
12. Coming to the case of the remaining petitioners i.e those who are not covered by the G.R dated 22-10-1996, our attention has been invited by the learned AGP to the order passed by this Court in Writ Petition No. 942 of 2004 on 4-2-2005, by relying upon the law laid down by the Apex Court in the case of A. Umarani v. Registrar, Co-operative Societies, (2004) 7 SCC 112. The petitioner in Writ Petition No. 942 of 2004 had relied upon the G.R dated 22-10-1996 and the cut off date as 30-11-1995 and prayed for directions for being regularised as the State Government employee. The order dated 4-2-2005 concluded in the following words:
“4. It would, therefore, be clear that in such appointments there can be no case of regularisation. No writ, therefore, could have been issued by this Court in such matters. We reiterate the said proposition as carved out from the judgment in A. Umarani (supra). For the aforesaid reasons Rule discharged. There shall be no order as to costs.
5. Considering the law as laid down by the Apex Court in A. Umarani v. Registrar, Co-operative Societies [(2004) 7 SCC 112 the State Government may take steps to issue G.R in the matter of regularisation strictly in terms of the judgment in A. Umarani (supra) and as explained by this Court in this Judgment.”
13. If regards be had to the order of this Court in Writ Petition No. 942 of 2004 following the law laid down in A. Umarani's case (supra), the State Government would have done well in not issuing the G.R dated 10-3-2005, though the said G.R states that it was issued in obedience of the orders passed by this Court in Writ Petition Nos. 1882, 1885 and 2067 of 2002. It is not known whether the orders passed by this Court in these three petitions were placed on record when Writ Petition No. 942 of 2004 was decided on 4-2-2005 and even otherwise the G.R has been issued thereafter i.e on 10-3-2005. Nothing stopped the State Government from filing a civil application in Writ Petition No. 942 of 2004 to seek appropriate directions-modifications before issuing the G.R dated 10-3-2005. The scheme framed for absorption vide the G.R dated 10-3-2005 has, in fact, removed the cut off date and the scheme clearly envisages ten years or more service as on the date the G.R was issued and now the State Government appears to have woken up by the Constitution Bench judgment in the case of Umadevi (supra), in support of its contentions that the unpaid candidates or any others who were not appointed against regular posts and who have entered the Government departments by backdoor entries are not entitled for regularisation. There can be no dispute on this proposition that those who have entered the Government service by backdoor entries cannot claim regularisation of service by way of a vested right. However, this doctrine will not be applicable to those petitioners who were otherwise eligible for regularisation of service as per the GRs dated 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996, inasmuch as all those petitioners were wrongly denied the benefit of the scheme framed by the State Government vide the said Government Resolutions. For the other petitioners, unless it is demonstrated that their appointment was by following the due procedure for recruitment to Class III posts or their entry was not a backdoor entry, they cannot pray for a writ of mandamus for regularisation of their service.
14. We have no doubt in our mind that those petitioners who were covered by the G.Rs dated 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996, their entry as Unpaid Candidates in all the concerned departments could not be said to be backdoor entry. As set out in the opening paragraph of this judgment, the Unpaid Candidates came to be recruited as per the initial G.R dated 30-10-1961 and they had undergone the due selection process as was prevailing at the relevant time.
15. In the judgment in O.A No. 153 of 1991 the Tribunal recorded the mode of appointment of the Unpaid candidates as under:
“Neither the applicant nor the Respondents have stated the manner in which applicant and others have been appointed as Vina-Vetan Candidates but from the appointment order it appears that the applicant and others have been appointed on their applications. They have nowhere stated whether they were selected after they were sponsored by Employment Exchange nor the Respondents have stated that the applicants were appointed after inviting the applications by issuing an advertisement. Thus the applicant cannot claim the benefits of regular employees under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.”
16. After hearing the learned counsel for the petitioners and the learned AGP, we are satisfied that the abovesaid observations of the Tribunal do not imply that all the petitioners are the backdoor entrants or that their appointments were made without following the recruitment procedure prescribed under the relevant Rules or Resolutions. It is more than clear that none of the parties had invited the Tribunal's attention to the G.R dated 30-10-1961 and the procedure for enlisting the candidates for being trained and appointed in the clerical posts in the Revenue Department was formulated. The said Resolution in its preamble stated:
“In view of the changed circumstances after the issuance of orders contained in Government Resolution No. 5756/33 dated February, 1957, particularly after the introduction of the training scheme for revenue Clerks, it is found necessary that the various provisions with regard to the procedure for enlistment period, training and appointment of the enlisted candidates, as laid down in the various Government orders should be compiled together in a consolidated order. In view of this and also the need for having uniformity throughout the State, Government is pleased to lay down the following revised rules. They come into force from the date of issue of this order in all the areas of the State. These rules should be deemed to have superseded rules, orders etc. issued on the subject by the former States of Madhya Pradesh and Hyderabad.”
17. These Rules very clearly laid down the eligibility conditions and the procedure for enlisting the eligible candidates, lower as well as higher age limit, educational qualifications (SSC), reservation for backward classes etc. rules 9 to 12 of the said revised Rules read as under:
“9. Each candidate shall be assigned to an office and shall work there except when sent for training in the clerks training centre or appointed in an acting vacancy in that or in any other office. When not employed in an acting vacancy, he should be employed as copyist and allowed to receive the fees.
10. Each candidate shall be required to attend office regularly and punctually and no candidate shall be allowed to absent himself without leave.
11. If an existing list of enlisted candidates in any district happens to contain a greater number of names than as prescribed by this Resolution the Collector, shall forthwith wood out unsuitable candidates.
12. The enlisted candidate, before he is sent for training with stipend, shall give an undertaking as prescribed in Government Resolution Revenue Department No. TDX 1060-F dated 4th April, 1968 (before they are under training). After passing the test he shall remain as a Candidate till a vacancy becomes available for appointing him as a Clerk.
18. The State Government thereafter framed the Maharashtra Land Revenue (Inspection, Search and Supply of Copies of Land Records) Rules, 1970 regulating, inter alia, the procedure for supplying the certified copies of records (including land records) and these Rules were brought into force with effect from 6th July 1970. The enlisted candidates who passed the test and who remained on such list on account of non-availability of vacancy for appointment as a clerk, were called upon to work as copyist in the Revenue and Forest Department and for supplying the certified copies of the records as contemplated under the MLR Rules of 1970. From the record we have also noted that the Government of Maharashtra had subsequently (sometimes in the year 1978) established Regional and Special Selection Boards for recruitment to Class III posts and these Boards were dissolved in June, 1983. By its Resolution dated 9-2-1988 the Government of Maharashtra established the Maharashtra Subordinate Service Selection Board as well as the Regional Subordinate Service Selection Boards. These Boards were entrusted with the responsibility of recruitment to the Class III posts. However, these newly created Boards also were dissolved by the State Government vide its Resolution dated 11-6-1999. It is, therefore, clear that from 9-2-1988 to 11-6-1999 appointments to Class III posts in all Government Departments as well as Self Government bodies were made through these Regional Subordinate Selection Boards as well as the apex Board at the State level which was named as Maharashtra Subordinate Service Selection Board. There is nothing on record to show that any of the petitioners who were appointed after 9th February, 1988 were in fact selected by such Regional Subordinate Service Selection Boards or by the Maharashtra Subordinate Service Selection Board and, therefore, any of the petitioners who have started working as Unpaid candidates after 9th February, 1988 are the backdoor entrants inasmuch as their appointment as such was not in keeping with the prescribed mode of recruitment and/or as per the Rules framed by the State Government for such recruitments.
19. Between June, 1983 to 8-2-1988 though there was no Subordinate Service Selection Board, the State Government had laid down the procedure for recruitment to Class III posts as is evident from the G.R dated 9-2-1988. The preamble of the G.R dated 9-2-1988 and as reproduced hereinbelow clearly indicates that the recruitments from June, 1983 till 8-2-1988 were being made as per the prescribed procedure:
“After the dissolution of former Regional and Special Selection Boards in June, 1983, an issue was under consideration of the Government as to which procedure should be adopted to make selection of the candidates to the Class III posts in Subordinate Services of the State Government. As a temporary measure, till the final decision is taken thereon, the said task is carried out by the Appointing Authority concerned as well as pursuant to the advise of the Selection Committees (in respect of the Government Servants) set up by the - Ministerial Departments and through the District and Divisional Selection Boards (in respect of Zilla Parishad employees).”
20. From the perusal of the G.R dated 22-10-1996 it is clear that on 13-2-1987 the State Government issued a Circular banning the recruitment/appointment of Unpaid Clerks. The relevant portion of the said preamble from the G.R dated 22-10-1996 reads as under
“Before the Regional Selection Board came into being there was a prevalent procedure to prepare waiting list to make recruitment to the post of the clerk in each District. Till the candidates of such waiting list are absorbed in the actual service, they were being assigned the work as Unpaid Copying Clerk. After the Regional Board came into being, naturally the practice of preparing waiting list for filling up the post of Clerk and of assigning the work as “Unpaid Copying Clerk” till the candidates in the list are absorbed in the actual service was cancelled. In spite of it, in the various offices of the Revenue Department licences have been granted to the Unpaid Copying Clerks. Vide Government Circular, Revenue and Forest Department, No. Est-1086/3618/483.E-7 dated 13th February, 1987, all the Divisional Commissioners, as well as all the Collectors were clearly given instructions not to appoint Unpaid Copying Clerk in future. In spite of it, disregarding the said instructions, Unpaid Copying Clerks have been appointed in many offices.”
21. From all this material on record we have no hesitation to hold that the Unpaid Candidates who were appointed till 12-2-1987 were not the backdoor entrants and certainly those who were appointed from 13-2-1987 onwards or after the establishment of the Regional Subordinate Selection Boards as per the G.R dated 9-2-1988 are the backdoor entrants. In our view the petitioners who were appointed as Unpaid Candidates initially on or before 12-2-1987 will have to be given the benefit of the scheme for regularisation as implemented by the State Government vide its GRs dated 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996. As noted by the Tribunal in its Judgment in O.A No. 153 of 1991 the State Government had issued the first G.R on 17-10-1978 for regularisation of the Unpaid candidates. We may for ready reference reproduce the following observations set out in para 9 of the MAT's judgment in O.A No. 153 of 1991:
“It has been admitted in the affidavit filed on behalf Respondents that Government had regularised services of some of the unpaid candidates by order dated 17-10-1978 issued by the Revenue and Forests Department to regularize services of the unpaid candidates working in Land Records (M.S), Pune.”
22. These appointments were without reference to the Regional Subordinate Service Selection Boards already in existence and, therefore, the appointments made till 12-2-1987 as Unpaid Candidates in the Revenue and Forest Department of the State Government, are required to be regularised as per the G.R dated 22-10-1996 or on the lines of the said policy, as they cannot be termed as backdoor entrants.
23. In respect of the petitioners who came to be appointed as Unpaid candidates from 13-2-1987 onwards it was contended by the learned counsel for the petitioners that denying the benefit of regularisation as per the G.Rs dated 21-10-1995, 22-10-1996 and 10-3-2005 would certainly result in discrimination between the similarly placed petitioners. We do not agree with these submissions and more so when we have already noted that after the re-establishment of the Subordinate Service Selection Boards vide G.R dated 9-2-1988 it is not the case of any of the petitioners who joined after the said date i.e 9-2-1988 that they were selected through the Regional Service Selection Board and were assigned the copying work as Unpaid candidates on account of suitable clerical vacancies being not available. The Government Circular dated 13-2-1987 had clearly banned the appointment of Unpaid candidates in the Revenue and Forest Department and all such appointments made thereafter were clearly the backdoor appointments and in spite of the fact that they have continued to work as such either on account of stay orders passed by this Court or the orders of continuation issued by the authorities concerned. The law laid down by the Constitution Bench in the case of Umadevi (supra) does not permit us to issue a writ of mandamus or directions in the like nature for extending the benefit of the G.Rs dated 21-10-1995, 22-10-1996 and 10-3-2005 in favour of those petitioners who entered the said posts from 13-2-1987 onwards. For ready reference we may reproduce the relevant observations in Umadevi's case (supra):
“38. When a person enters a temporary employment or gets engagement as a contractual or casual worker and the engagement is not based on a proper selection as recognized by the relevant rules or procedure, he is aware of the consequences of the appointment being temporary, casual or contractual in nature. Such a person cannot invoke the theory of legitimate expectation for being confirmed in the post when an appointment to the post could be made only by following a proper procedure for selection and in concerned cases, in consultation with the Public Service Commission. Therefore, the theory of legitimate expectation cannot be successfully advanced by temporary, contractual or casual employees. It cannot also be held that the State has held out any promise while engaging these persons either to continue them where they are or to make them permanent. The State cannot constitutionally make such a promise. It is also obvious that the theory cannot be invoked to seek a positive relief of being made permanent in the post.
39. It was then contended that the rights of the employees thus appointed, under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, are violated. It is stated that the State has treated the employees unfairly by employing them on less than minimum wages and extracting work from them for a pretty long period in comparison with those directly recruited who are getting more wages or salaries for doing similar work. The employees before us were engaged on daily wages in the concerned department on a wage that was made known to them. There is no case that the wage agreed upon was not being paid. Those who are working on daily wages formed a class by themselves, they cannot claim that they are discriminated as against those who have been regularly recruited on the basis of the relevant rules. No right can be founded on an employment on daily wages to claim that such employee should be treated on a par with a regularly recruited candidate, and made permanent in employment, even assuming that the principle could be invoked for claiming equal wages for equal work. There is no fundamental right in those who have been employed on daily wages or temporarily or on contractual basis, to claim that they have a right to be absorbed in service. As has been held by this Court, they cannot be said to be holders of a post, since, a regular appointment could be made only by making appointments consistent with the requirements of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. The right to be treated equally with the other employees employed on daily wages, cannot be extended to a claim for equal treatment with those who were regularly employed. That would be treating unequals as equals. It cannot also be relied on to claim a right to be absorbed in service even though they have never been selected in terms of the relevant recruitment rules. The arguments based on Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution are therefore overruled.”
24. We have also noted earlier that those of the petitioners who came to be appointed from 13-2-1987 onwards cannot rely upon the G.R dated 10-3-2005 and for more than one reasons. Firstly though the said GR was purportedly issued in compliance with the orders passed by this Court in Writ Petition Nos. 2067, 1882 and 1885 of 2002, the said G.R was contrary to the order passed by this Court on 4th February 2005 in Writ Petition No. 942 of 2004 by following the judgment of the Apex Court in Umarani's case (supra). Denying the benefit of the G.R dated 10-3-2005 to such petitioners would not, in our view, violate the protection of equality as enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution and this issue finally stands settled by the Constitution Bench in Umadevi's case (supra).
25. In the premises, we allow these petitions partly and hold that:
(a) All those Unpaid Candidates appointed till 12-2-1987 cannot be termed as backdoor entrants and they are eligible for the scheme formulated under the G.Rs dated 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996.
(b) The Unpaid Candidates who have been appointed from 13-2-1987 onwards are not entitled for the benefit of any of the G.Rs viz. the G.Rs dated 21-10-1995, 22-10-1996 and 10-3-2005.
(c) The 150 posts directed to be kept vacant in Class III by the order of this Court dated 18th December 2003 passed in Writ Petition No. 2151 of 1998, shall be filled in by the concerned Departments from amongst those Unpaid Candidates who fall in Category (a) above and are presently in the employment in any of these Departments.
(d) We also hold that the regularised Unpaid Candidates will be entitled for consequential benefits on par with similarly placed but already absorbed Unpaid Workers by the State Government consequent to the Resolutions dated 21-10-1995 and 22-10-1996.
26. Rule made absolute accordingly with no order as to costs.
27. After the pronouncement of this Judgment, Mr. Apte, the learned Senior Counsel and Mrs. Bhatia appearing for the petitioners stated that the unpaid workers who fall in Clause (b) of para 21 of this Judgment desire to approach the Apex Court as they have been denied the benefit of absorption/regularisation and, therefore, they pray for status quo as of now in case they are in employment. The learned AGP has opposed this application.
28. This oral application is allowed and it is directed that those Unpaid Candidates who have been appointed from 13-2-1987 onwards and are presently continued in the respective Departments under the orders of this Court, they shall be continued further for a period of eight weeks.
Order accordingly.
Alert