- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sunil Vassudev Pednekar v. Bicholim Urban Co-Operative Bank Ltd.
Factual and Procedural Background
The Complainant prosecuted the accused under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 for the bouncing of three cheques totaling Rs. 7,20,000/-. The accused challenged two orders of the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class (J.M.F.C.): (1) an order dated 16-01-2001 issuing process against the accused; and (2) an order dated 16-12-2004 permitting the Complainant to examine a witness (Sharad Samant) whose name had not been cited earlier with the complaint. The complaint was not accompanied by a list of witnesses as required by sub-section (2) of Section 204 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. A rule was issued on 10-08-2005. The petition before the High Court sought relief in respect of those two impugned orders.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether this Court should exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to permit belated challenge to the J.M.F.C.'s order dated 16-01-2001 issuing process against the accused.
- Whether, because the Complainant did not file a list of witnesses as contemplated by sub-section (2) of Section 204 Cr.P.C., the Complainant is precluded from examining additional witnesses (specifically the witness Sharad Samant) during trial, and whether the J.M.F.C.'s order dated 16-12-2004 permitting examination of such a witness is sustainable.
Arguments of the Parties
Accused's Arguments (Shri Vahidulla)
- The Complainant was not entitled to examine further witnesses because no list of witnesses had been filed along with the complaint as required by sub-section (2) of Section 204 Cr.P.C.
- Relied on the decision in Sanyogita Shivnath Nandedkar v. Suprabha Rajendra Junghare (2004 All MR (Cri) 2296) to support the contention that the absence of a list could be fatal and justify dismissal or recalled process.
Complainant's Arguments (Shri N.N. Sardessai)
- Filing of a list of witnesses is not fatal to the complainant's case; the complainant can file an additional list and examine more witnesses.
- Relied on precedents of this Court, including Shashi Nair v. R.C. Mehta (1982 (1) Bom. C.R. 358) and Vashu Gokaldas Kukreja v. Meena Vashu Kukreja (2004 Bom. C.R. (Cri) 734), to support the proposition that a magistrate may allow examination of witnesses not named in the original list and that the failure to file a list earlier does not necessarily vitiate proceedings where no prejudice is shown.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sanyogita Shivnath Nandedkar v. Suprabha Rajendra Junghare (2004 All MR (Cri) 2296) | Held that a complaint not filed with the list of witnesses (in conformity with Section 202(2) Cr.P.C. as stated in the opinion) could be dismissed; the Sessions Judge's dismissal was upheld by the High Court on that ground. | The Court acknowledged this authority as relied upon by the accused but did not treat it as controlling on the facts here; the Court found no clear prejudice to the accused from late submission and declined to allow a belated challenge based on this ground. |
| Shashi Nair v. R.C. Mehta (1982 (1) Bom. C.R. 358) | Referred to the principle (via State of Bombay v. Janardhan) that an original list under Section 204(1) could be added to by further names and that witnesses added later could be examined. | The Court relied on the reasoning in this decision to support the proposition that Section 204's list requirement is not absolute and that magistrates may permit additional witnesses to be summoned and examined. |
| State of Bombay v. Janardhan (AIR 1960 Bom 513) | Held that an original witness list under Section 204(1) could be supplemented by further names and those additional witnesses could be examined. | Referenced via Shashi Nair as supporting the view that names can be added and witnesses examined despite not being in the original list; used to support non-mandatory character of Section 204's list requirement. |
| S. Khan v. State (AIR 1960 All 394) | Held that a magistrate could issue summons to a witness whose name was not mentioned in the original list under Section 204. | Relied on by the Court (through Shashi Nair) to support the proposition that non-inclusion in an initial list does not oust the magistrate's power to summon and examine witnesses later. |
| Madhaorao (Madhaorao) Pandurang v. Yeshwant (Cr. Rev. Appl. No. 341/68 decided 17-6-1969) | Held that the jurisdiction of the magistrate under Section 204(1) to issue summons or warrants initially cannot be taken away by the failure of the complainant to file a list of witnesses; Section 204 was not mandatory in this regard. | The Court expressly followed and expressed respectful concurrence with this decision, using it as a principal authority to hold that Section 254(1) is not controlled by Section 204(2) and that magistrates retain power to take evidence and summon witnesses even if a list was not filed earlier. |
| Vashu Gokaldas Kukreja v. Meena Vashu Kukreja (2004 Bom. C.R. (Cri) 734) | Held that failure to submit a list of witnesses prior to issuance of process is not automatically a ground to recall process where, on the relevant date, the list of proposed witnesses was submitted and no prejudice to the accused resulted. | The Court cited and relied on this decision to support the conclusion that late submission or supplementation of a witness list does not necessarily vitiate proceedings where no prejudice is shown. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court addressed the two impugned orders separately.
Concerning the first order (16-01-2001 issuing process): the Court declined to exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to permit a belated challenge. The reasons given were the substantial delay (more than four years and four months) and the fact that the accused had already unsuccessfully sought revision in the Sessions Court. The Court observed that the accused was expected to raise all available grounds when challenging the order earlier and that a belated approach after exhausting other remedies was not appropriate.
Concerning the second order (16-12-2004 permitting the Complainant to examine Sharad Samant): the J.M.F.C. had purported to permit the examination under Section 311 Cr.P.C., but counsel for the Complainant conceded that the correct enabling provision would have been Section 254 (sub-sections (1) & (2)). The Court analysed the statutory scheme:
- Section 254(1) empowers the Magistrate in a summons trial, if the accused is not convicted under Sections 252/253, to “proceed to hear the prosecution and take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution” and to hear the accused and take his evidence.
- Section 254(2) permits the Magistrate, if he thinks fit and upon application by prosecution or accused, to issue a summons to any witness directing attendance or production of documents.
The Court concluded that Section 254(1) confers ample discretion on a J.M.F.C. to take evidence produced in support of the prosecution and to issue summons to any witness. The Court reasoned that if Section 254 depended on prior compliance with Section 204(2), Section 254 would have expressly provided so. The Court emphasised that Section 204(2) serves a salutary protective purpose for accused persons (to guard against harassment) and to inform the Court of proposed witnesses before issuance of process, but that the statutory scheme and binding precedents (Madhaorao Pandurang, Shashi Nair, State of Bombay v. Janardhan, S. Khan v. State, Vashu Kukreja) indicate that the list requirement in Section 204 is not mandatory to the extent of ousting the magistrate's power under Section 254 to take evidence and summon witnesses who were not named earlier.
The Court further noted that the authorities it followed held that absent clear prejudice to the accused caused by a late submission or addition of witnesses, the magistrate's order summoning or permitting such witnesses is not vitiated. The Court found no prejudice to the accused from the J.M.F.C.'s order permitting examination of Sharad Samant and observed that the accused had not timely raised the point earlier in the revision proceedings.
The Court accepted that the learned J.M.F.C. had cited an incorrect enabling provision (Section 311) but held that the substantive power to permit examination of the additional witness was properly traceable to Section 254(1), and therefore the order dated 16-12-2004 could not be faulted.
The Court also recorded the Complainant counsel's assurance that, if further witnesses are required to be examined, the Complainant would file a list of such witnesses and the Magistrate would deal with it according to law.
Holding and Implications
Petition dismissed with costs.
Direct effects and implementation instructions explicitly stated in the opinion:
- The petition seeking relief against the J.M.F.C.'s orders was dismissed and the accused's belated challenge under Section 482 Cr.P.C. was refused.
- The J.M.F.C.'s order dated 16-12-2004 permitting the Complainant to examine the witness Sharad Samant (a witness not named in the original list) was upheld as supportable under Section 254(1) Cr.P.C., despite the J.M.F.C.'s reference to Section 311. The Court found no vitiation in that order.
- Both parties were directed to appear before the learned J.M.F.C., Bicholim, on 2nd May 2006 at 10:00 a.m. for further proceedings.
The opinion does not set out any broader or novel precedent beyond its expression of concurrence with existing authorities (Madhaorao Pandurang, Shashi Nair, State of Bombay v. Janardhan, S. Khan, Vashu Kukreja). It confines itself to applying those authorities to the facts and concludes that no prejudice resulted from the absence of an initial witness list in this case.
1. Heard Shri Vahidulla, the learned Counsel on behalf of the petitioner/accused and Shri N.N Sardessai, the learned Counsel on bhelaf of the respondent/Complainant.
2. The Complainant has prosecuted the accused under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, for bouncing of three cheques in the sum of Rs. 7,20,000/-. The accused has challenged two Order of the learned J.M.F.C in the said case. The first Order dated 16-01-2001, issuing process against the accused and the other dated 16-12-2004, permitting the Complainant to examine a witness, namely, the Bank Manager, a witness who was not cited by the complainant, earlier. In fact, the Complaint was not accompanied by a list of witnesses as required under sub-section (2) of Section 204 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, (Code, for short). Rule was issued on 10-8-2005 and, therefore, this petition deserves to be disposed of on merits though it is otherwise submitted on behalf of the Complainant, that revisional remedy was available to the accused against the said Orders.
3. As far as the first Order dated 16-01-2001 is concerned, I am not inclined to exercise extraordinary jurisdiction under section 482 of the code to allow the accused to challenge the same, as the accused has approached this Court belatedly after more than four years, four months and that too after having unsuccessfully challenged the said Order. In revision before the Court of Sessions. Whether in the said revision the ground of sub-section (2) of Section 204 of the Code was taken or not would be immaterial since it was expected on the part of the accused to have taken all grounds available to him, when he challenged the said Order dated 16-01-2001 issuing process against him.
4. As far as the second Order dated 16-12-2004 is concerned, the learned J.M.F.C has permitted the Complainant to examine one witness by name Sharad Samant, whose name was earlier not cited by the Complainant along with the complaint. The learned J.M.F.C has permitted the Complainant to examine the said witness under Section 311 of the Code and it is conceded on behalf of the Complainant that leave to examine the said witness could not have been granted under Section 311 of the Code but under Section 254 of the Code. Sub-sections (1) & (2) which are relevant reads as follows:
“(1) If the Magistrate does not convict the accused under Section 252 or Section 253, the Magistrate shall proceed to hear the prosecution and take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution, and also to hear the accused and take all such evidence as he produces in his defence.
(2) The Magistrate may, if he thinks fit, on the application of the prosecution or the accused, issue a summons to any witness directing him to attend or to produce any document or other thing.”
5. Shri Vahidulla on behalf of the accused has submitted that the Complainant was not entitled to examine any further witnesses because the Complainant had filed no list of witnesses and in support of the said sub mission, learned Advocate Shri Vahidulla, has placed reliance on the case of Sanyogita Shivnath Nandedkar v. Suprabha Rajendra Junghare (2004 ALL MR (Cri) 2296).
6. On the other hand, Shri Sardessai, the learned Counsel on behalf of the respondents, has submitted that filing of list of witnesses is not fatal to the case of the Complainant and the Complainant could also file additional list and examine more witnesses as contemplated under sub-section (2) of Section 254 of the Code and in support of the said submission, Shri Sardessai has placed reliance on decisions of this Court in the case of Shashi Nair v. R.C Mehta (1982 (1) Bom. C.R 358) and Vashu Gokaldas Kukreja v. Meena Vashu Kukreja (2004 Bom. C.R (Cri) 734).
7. In Sanyogita Shivnath Nandedkar v. Suprabha Rajendra Junghare (supra), the complaint was dismissed by the learned Sessions Judge, as it was not filed along with the list of witnesses. The Complainant having approached the High Court, the High Court held that the approach of the learned Sessions Judge was legal and correct and confirmed the view that since the complaint was not filed or prosecuted in conformity with Section 202(2) of Cr. P.C, the complaint was liable to be dismissed.
8. In the case of Shashi Nair and R.C Mehta (supra), this Court referred to State of Bombay v. Janardhan (AIR 1960 Bom 513), wherein it was held that original list given under Section 204(1) could be added by further names and witnesses so added could be examined. This Court also referred to S. Khan v. State (AIR 1960 All 394), wherein it was held that Magistrate could issue summons to a witness whose name was not mentioned in the original list under Section 204. This Court then referred to another decision of this Court in Madhaorao Pandurang v. Yeshwant (Cr. Rev. Appl. No. 341/68 decided on 17-6-1969) and observed that the jurisdiction of the Magistrate under Section 204(1) to issue summons or warrant in the first instance, cannot be taken away by the failure on the part of the Complainant to file list of witnesses and that Section 204(1-A) (sic.) did not control Section 244(1) or 244(2). Thereafter, this court held that there is nothing in Section 244(1) or (2), which restricts the power of the Magistrate to take evidence only of those witnesses whose names are not mentioned in the list referred to in section 204(1-a) and, therefore, the provisions regarding submission of a list of witnesses in Section 204, cannot be considered as mandatory so as to control the jurisdiction of the Magistrate to proceed with the trial of the accused and record his plea. The Court held that the provisions of Section 204 of the Criminal Procedure Code were not mandatory in nature and if before the list of witnesses is filed, the Magistrate issues a summons to the accused after he is satisfied that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused, he does not act without jurisdiction and further proceedings after the appearance of the accused are not invalid. Unless clear prejudice is shown to have been caused to the accused by a late submission of the list of prosecution witnesses, the order issuing a summons to him cannot be said to be vitiated. The Court also held that the provisions of section 204 were directory and it is the duty of the Magistrate to secure compliance with the requirement of section 204(1 -a), at the earliest possible stage of the proceedings to avoid any prejudice to the accused if for some reasons he did not insist on the list of witnesses to be filed along with the complaint.
9. In the case of Vashu Gokaldas Kukreja v. Meena Vashu Kukreja (supra), an application for recall of process was filed on the ground that before process was issued, the list of witnesses was not submitted and it was held that the defect could not be the reason to recall the process more so when the list of witnesses proposed to be examined was already submitted along with the application as on the date when the application presumably to recall the process was decided and it was held that the view taken by the Court did not, in any way, cause prejudice to the accused but was a step forward in ensuring that miscarriage of justice would not occur.
10. In the case at hand, the accused did not at all challenge the Order issuing process dated 16-1-2001 for a long period on the ground that the issue of process was vitiated on account of non filing of the list of witnesses and although the accused had filed a Revision Application, before the Court of Sessions, the accused did not take up that plea before the Sessions Court. It is obvious that no prejudice was caused to the accused. It would be rather too late in the day now to challenge the said Order issuing process on the ground that sub-section (2) of Section 204 of the Code was not complied with. The only question before the Court is whether because the Complainant had not filed the list of witnesses, as contemplated by subsection (2) of Section 204 of the Code, that the Complainant is precluded from examining other witnesses. Shri Vahidulla, the learned Counsel on behalf of the accused submits that issuing summons to any witnesses, as contemplated by sub-section (2) of Section 254 of the Code would mean issuing summons only to the witnesses whose list was filed by the Complainant. In my view, such a submission cannot be accepted.
11. Section 254 of the Code is found in the Chapter dealing with trial of summons cases by a Magistrate and sub-section (1) thereof provides that if the Magistrate does not convict the accused under Section 252 or Section 253, the Magistrate shall proceed to hear the prosecution and take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution, and also to hear the accused and take all such evidence as he produces in his defence. sub-section (2) of Section 254 of the Code provides that the Magistrate, may, if he thinks fit, on the application of the prosecution or the accused, issue a summons to any witness directing him to attend or to produce any document or other thing.
(Emphasis supplied).
12. Section 254(1) of the Code give ample discretion to a J.M.F.C, to take all such evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution and not only that it also gives discretion to a J.M.F.C to issue summons to any witness directing him to atted and to give his evidence. In case, the provisions of section 254 were subject to the compliance of the provisions of Section 204(2), then Section 254 of the Code, which comes later, would have expressly provided so. In my view, in order to exercise the powers under Section 254(1), it is not a condition precedent that a list of witnesses had to be filed under Section 204(2) of the Code. Likewise, Section 254 also does not contemplate that the witnesses to be examined would be only those witnesses who were cited on behalf of the Complainant, earlier in the list filed, in terms of sub-section (2) of Section 204 of the Code. There is no doubt that subsection (2) of Section 204 of the Code is meant to safeguard the interest of the accused persons against undue harassment at the hands of unscrupulous litigants. The insistence on filing a list of prosecution witnesses before the issue of process to the accused is mainly for that purpose. In other words, the intention is to assure that no person is summoned to stand his trial without the Court first satisfying itself that there is sufficient ground to issue a summons or a warrant, as the case may be, against accused persons and about the witnesses to be produced in support of the case of the Complainant. In a proper case, the Complainant would be entitled to file even an additional list of witnesses. There is nothing in section 204 of the code, which says or indicates that if no list of prosecution witnesses is filed before process is issued to the accused, then none can be filed later. This does not mean that the salutary provision in subsection (2) of Section 204 of the Code can be vitiated with impunity. In this context, reference could also be made to page 2396 of Sohoni's Code of Criminal Procedure, wherein it is stated that the provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 204 of the Code can be vitiated with impunity. In this context, reference could also be made to page 2396 of Sohoni's Code of Criminal Procedure, wherein it is stated that the provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 204 of the Code does not mean and imply that in no circumstances can a person who is not included in a list be permitted to be examined in the course of the trial. If that was the real intention, one would expect a clearer and firmer expression of the view of the Legislature, then what is to be found in sub-section (2). Moreover, if this extreme contention was to prevail, it would have the effect of abolishing Section 254(1) of the Code. This Section does not say that the evidence must be evidence of only those persons whose names appear in the list of witnesses filed under Section 204(2) of the Code. subsection (2) of Section 204 of the Code does not override Section 254(1) of the Code which imposes a duty on the Magistrate to take evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution. In my view, although the learned J.M.F.C has cited a wrong provisions of law by referring to Section 311 of the Code, as the power enabling her to permit the Complainant to lead evidence of the said witness, whose name was not cited, the power to examine other witnesses could be traced to Section 254(1) of the Code and viewed thus, the Order of the learned J.M.F.C dated 16-12-04, could not be faulted. The controversy appears to have been settled with the decisions of this Court in Madharao Pandurang (spura), which was followed in Shashi Nair (supra), which have my respectful concurrence, for other reasons as well stated hereinabove.
13. Shri Sardessai, the learned Counsel on behalf of the Complainant assures that in case more witnesses are required to be examined, then the complainant would certainly file a list of witnesses to be examined on behalf of the Complainant. In case such a list is filed, the learned Magistrate would be at liberty to deal with the same in accordance with law. In the light of the above, I find there is no merit in this petition and consequently the same is hereby dismissed with costs. Both the parties are hereby directed to appear before the learned J.M.F.C Bicholom, on 2nd May, 2006, at 10.00 am for further proceedings.
14. Petition dismissed.
Alert