- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Commissioner Of Central Excise And Another v. M/S Indorama Textiles Ltd., Butibori And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ petition challenges an order dated 22-8-2005 passed by respondent No. 2 (The Joint Secretary, Government of India, Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue)). A preliminary objection was raised by respondent No. 1 that the petition is not maintainable because the order was passed by the Central Government and the petitioners are subordinate officers of the Central Government. The matter was heard by D.D. Sinha, J., who considered submissions and the relevant statutory provision (section 35E of the Central Excise Act, 1944) and cited authorities before delivering the order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a writ petition challenging an order passed by the Central Government (specifically a revisional order by the Joint Secretary under section 35E of the Central Excise Act, 1944) is maintainable when filed by subordinate officers of the Central Government.
- Whether the revisional authority constituted under section 35E of the Central Excise Act, 1944 exercises administrative/policy powers (and thus its orders are not amenable to writ) or judicial powers as a Tribunal (and thus its orders are amenable to writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227).
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent No. 1's Arguments
- The writ petition is not maintainable because the impugned order is passed by the Central Government and the Central Government is bound by that order; it cannot challenge its own order (estoppel/illegitimacy of government attacking its own decision).
- The petitioners, being subordinate officers of the Central Government, are not legally entitled to challenge an order passed by the Central Government.
- Reliance placed on State of Orissa v. Union of India, 1995 Supp (2) SCC 154, and Hindustan Distilleries… v. State Of Maharashtra…, 3999 (1) Mh. LJ. 704 to support these contentions.
Petitioners' Arguments
- The writ petition is maintainable because the revisional authority exercised powers under section 35E of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and is constituted by the legislature to deal with disputes brought before it.
- By virtue of the scheme of the Act, proceedings before the revisional authority indicate it acts under statutory provisions and has judicial complexion; it is a Tribunal vested with judicial powers and therefore its orders are amenable to writ jurisdiction.
- Reliance placed on Indo-China Steam Navigation Co. Ltd. v. Jasjit Singh, Additional Collector of Customs, Calcutta, 1983 (13) E.L.T 1392 (SC), and State of Orissa v. Union of India, 1995 Supp (2) SCC 154 to support tribunal/judicial character of revisional power.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State of Orissa v. Union of India, 1995 Supp (2) SCC 154 | Observed that a State Government (not merely subordinate) may have locus to challenge an order (example given: owner of mines directed to issue a lease has locus under Article 226). | The court held these observations had no positive bearing on the facts of the present case and were of no help to respondent No. 1. |
| Hindustan Distilleries… v. State Of Maharashtra…, 3999 (1) Mh. LJ. 704 | Principle that the State cannot challenge the validity of its own earlier government decision (estoppel of the State in challenging its own order). | The court found this decision inapplicable to the present case because the revisional authority acts as a Tribunal required to act judiciously; thus the cited principle did not assist respondent No. 1. |
| Indo-China Steam Navigation Co. Ltd. v. Jasjit Singh, Additional Collector of Customs, Calcutta, 1983 (13) E.L.T 1392 (SC) | Used to support the contention that certain statutory revisional bodies have the character of tribunals exercising judicial powers. | The court treated this decision as supporting the petitioners' contention that the revisional authority under section 35E has judicial complexion and its orders can be subject to writ scrutiny. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the wording and scheme of section 35E (and related provisions) of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and the authorities cited. It distinguished ordinary administrative or policy decisions of the Central Government (which bind subordinate authorities) from orders passed by the Joint Secretary exercising revisional powers under section 35E. The court concluded that the powers exercised under section 35E are not administrative but have a judicial complexion: the revisional authority conducts inquiries, decides disputes brought by aggrieved persons and is required to act judiciously. Because the revisional authority functions as a Tribunal vested with judicial powers, any order it passes that is inconsistent with established principles of law is amenable to writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution. The court considered the precedents relied upon by respondent No. 1 (State of Orissa and Hindustan Distilleries) and found them inapplicable to the factual and legal matrix before it.
Holding and Implications
Preliminary objection rejected; the writ petition is maintainable.
Direct effect: The court rejected the objection that the Central Government and subordinate officers cannot challenge or be subject to challenge in respect of the revisional order; it held that orders passed by the revisional authority under section 35E are susceptible to writ jurisdiction if inconsistent with established legal principles. No broader new precedent beyond this application was explicitly declared in the opinion.
D.D Sinha, J.:— Heard Shri A.B Chaudhari, the learned Assistant Solicitor General for the petitioners, and Shri M.G Bhangde, the learned Senior Counsel for respondent No. 1.
2. The present writ petition is filed against the order dated 22-8-2005 passed by respondent No. 2 - The Joint Secretary, Government of India, Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue).
3. Shri M.G Bhangde, the learned counsel for respondent No. 1, raised a preliminary objection about the maintainability of the present writ petition on the ground that the order is passed by the Central Government and, therefore, the Central Government is bound by the said order and cannot challenge its own order by filing the writ petition. Similarly, the petitioners being the subordinate officers of the Central Government, are not legally entitled to challenge the order passed by the Central Government and, therefore, the writ petition itself is not maintainable and the same should be dismissed on this preliminary issue alone. In order to substantiate these contentions, reliance is placed on the decision of the Apex Court in the case of State of Orissa v. Union of India, reported in 1995 Supp (2) SCC 154, as well as the decision of this Court in the case of Hindustan Distilleries… v. State Of Maharashtra…, reported in 3999 (1) Mh. LJ. 704.
4. Shri A.B Chaudhari, the learned Assistant Solicitor General for the petitioners, on the other hand, contended that the writ petition is very much maintainable. It is submitted that the revisional authority exercised revisional power under section 35E of the Central Excise Act, 1944. It is further contended that the revisional authority is constituted under the provisions of section 35E of the said Act by the Legislature and is empowered to deal with the disputes brought before it by the aggrieved persons. It is further contended that by virtue of the scheme of the provisions of the Act, the proceedings brought before the revisional authority indicates that the revisional authority acts under the relevant provisions of the Act and, therefore, the revisional authority is a Tribunal, which is vested with judicial powers of the State and is required to act judiciously. It is, therefore, contended that even if the order is passed by the Joint Secretary, Government of India, Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue), the said Officer has acted as a Tribunal and hence the order impugned is amenable to the writ jurisdiction of this Court. In order to substantiate these contentions, reliance is placed on the decisions of the Apex Court in the case of Indo-China Steam Navigation Co. Ltd. v. Jasjit Singh, Additional Collector of Customs, Calcutta, reported in 1983 (13) E.L.T 1392 (SC), as well as in the case of State of Orissa v. Union of India, reported in 1995 Supp (2) SCC 154.
5. We have considered the contentions canvassed by the respective counsel and perused the provisions of section 35E of the Central Excise Act, 1944 as well as the decisions relied on and cited by both the counsel. It is no doubt true that a simpliciter policy decision or any other decision taken by the Central Government in its executive/administrative capacity would be a decision binding on the Central Government as well as the authorities subordinate to the Central Government. However, so far as the powers exercised by the Joint Secretary, Government of India, Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue), in view of the provisions of section 35E of the said Act are concerned, the same cannot be treated to be administrative powers exercised by the Central Government. On the other hand, by very nature of the scheme of section 35EE of the said Act, the powers, which are exercised by the revisional authority, have judicial complexions and are undoubtedly required to be exercised judiciously. Similarly, the revisional authority constituted under section 35E of the Act is empowered to deal with the disputes brought before it by the aggrieved persons. Taking into consideration the scheme of the Act, the nature of proceedings initiated before the revisional authority in view of section 35EE of the Act, the kind of enquiry required to be undertaken by the revisional authority, etc., all these factors undoubtedly indicate that the revisional authority acting under section 35EE of the Act acts as a Tribunal and, therefore, the powers, which it exercises, are judicial powers and the Tribunal is required to act judiciously.
6. Since the revisional authority acts as a Tribunal and is required to act judiciously, any order passed by such authority inconsistent with the established principles of law is an order amenable to the writ jurisdiction of this Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
7. So far as the decision of the Apex Court in the case of State of Orissa v. Union of India, cited supra, relied on by the learned counsel for respondent No. 1 is concerned, in para 12 of its judgment, the Apex Court has observed thus:
“In this connection, it is necessary to note that in the first place, the State Government is not merely an authority subordinate to the Central Government which would, undoubtedly, be bound by the revisional orders of the superior authority. It is also the owner of the mines and minerals in question. If it is directed to issue to a mining lease in favour of any party, it has locus standi to challenge that order under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.”
8. The above-referred observations of the Apex Court, in our view, has no positive bearing in view of the facts and circumstances as well as the issue involved in the present writ petition. We have already observed hereinabove that the order of the Central Government, which is administrative in nature, is undoubtedly binding on the State Government, which is the authority subordinate to the Central Government. However, in the instant case, the basis gamut of the issue is completely different and distinct and, therefore, these observations of the Apex Court, in our view, are of no help to respondent No. 1.
9. Similarly, so far as the decision of this Court in the case of Hindustan Distilleries… v. State Of Maharashtra…, cited supra, relied upon by the learned counsel for respondent No. 1, is concerned, this Court has observed in para 29 of its judgment as under:
“What has happened in the present case is that after a conscious decision of the Government some subordinate officer felt that the decision was running counter to the declared policy of the Government and in view of such Government Policy, note was put up or submission was made to the concerned Minister by the Officer who was admittedly subordinate to the Secretary. On the basis of which the later decision of rejecting the license to the petitioner for manufacture of country liquor was taken. In fact, this decision is also taken by the concerned Minister and is a Government decision. In view of the earlier decision of the Government communicated to the petitioner in clear terms, inducing petitioner to act upon it and to materially alter his position, the State is challenging its own earlier decision, although it has not come to the Court, but has been brought before us as respondent. It is an established principle that the State, as a petitioner cannot challenge the validity of its own order as it is governed by general principle of estoppel, and if it is debarred from doing so, as a petitioner, the same principle would apply preventing the State from attacking its own decision even if it has come to the Court as a respondent.
10. There is no quarrel about the observations made by the Apex Court referred to hereinabove, since the Government itself is not entitled to challenge its policy decision. However, in the instant case, we have already observed hereinabove that the revisional authority, while exercising revisional powers, acts as a Tribunal and is required to pass an order judiciously. In that view of the matter, we are afraid that the abovereferred decision of this Court is also of no help to respondent No. 1.
11. For the reasons stated hereinabove, the preliminary objection raised by the learned counsel for respondent No. 1 is misconceived and, therefore, the same stands rejected.
12. S.O to 20-4-2006.
Order accordingly.
Alert