Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajaram v. Baliram

Bombay High Court
Dec 23, 2005
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Civil Revision under Section 115 CPC

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a Civil Revision under section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code challenging the order dated 15-12-1997 passed by the 2nd Joint Civil Judge (Junior Division), Khamgaon, District Buldhana in Regular Civil Suit No. 40 of 1997. The impugned order permitted the plaintiff (the present respondent in revision) to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit on the same cause of action.

The underlying suit was for declaration and permanent injunction, alleging that the defendant (the present revision applicant) committed encroachment on the plaintiff's property on 21-2-1997. The plaint allegedly omitted, inadvertently, certain reliefs (declaration about encroachment and its extent, restoration of possession, return of material taken away, and permanent injunction). The plaintiff applied under Order 23 Rule 1 CPC seeking permission to withdraw the suit with leave to file a fresh suit on the same cause of action, asserting the defects were of a formal nature and caused prejudice to him. The defendant had filed a written statement and opposed withdrawal; he also noted that the plaintiff had filed two separate amendment applications which the defendant opposed.

The trial Court considered various precedents, held that most were inapplicable except AIR 1989 NOC (Orissa) 193, found that the plaint required "major changes" and that the plaintiff had been poorly advised by his counsel, and allowed withdrawal with liberty to file a fresh suit subject to costs of Rs. 300/-. The revision applicant challenged that order before the High Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defects in the plaint (mis-joinder of parties, improper drafting by counsel, non-payment/incorrect payment of Court fees, non-valuation of suit property, and omission of specific reliefs) are defects of a "formal nature" within the meaning of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC, thereby justifying permission to withdraw the suit with leave to file a fresh suit.
  2. Whether the trial Court, by permitting withdrawal of the suit with leave to file a fresh suit on the same cause of action, exercised jurisdiction not available to it under Order 23 Rule 1 CPC (i.e., whether the trial Court erred in law in its application of Order 23 Rule 1).

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Applicant's (Defendant's) Arguments

  • Advocate Shri Paliwal (for revision applicant) contended that the Court below exercised jurisdiction not available to it.
  • He argued that failure to claim relief or defects in drafting of the plaint are not defects of a formal nature so as to enable exercise of power under Order 23 Rule 1 CPC.
  • He relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court reported at AIR 2000 SC 2132 (K.S. Bhoopathy v. Kokila) to support the contention that withdrawal with liberty to file a fresh suit should not be allowed in circumstances where jurisdiction under O.23 R.1 is not properly invoked.

Respondent's (Original Plaintiff's) Arguments

  • The respondent/plaintiff explained that defects in the plaint arose from improper drafting by his counsel and included mis-joinder of parties, non-payment of proper Court fees, non-valuation of the suit property, and failure to claim certain reliefs (declaration about encroachment, extent, restoration of possession, return of material, and permanent injunction) which were said to be inadvertent omissions.
  • The respondent maintained these defects caused prejudice to him and were of a formal nature, justifying permission to withdraw and file a fresh suit on the same cause of action.
  • It was also noted that the plaintiff had filed two separate applications for amendment of the plaint, which were opposed by the defendant.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court (as described in the opinion)
AIR 2000 SC 2132 — K.S. Bhoopathy v. Kokila The duty of a court (particularly at appellate/second appellate stage) to be satisfied that proper grounds exist before permitting withdrawal with leave to file a fresh suit; permission cannot be granted merely because the defendants' interest can be provisionally safeguarded; prejudice to defendant from withdrawal at appellate stages is significant. The revising Court relied on this judgment to observe that the trial Court failed to consider whether the grounds before it were sufficient to invoke O.23 R.1; the trial Court's reasoning was inadequate in that respect.
AIR 1989 NOC (Orissa) 193 Express statement (as cited) that withdrawal of suit cannot be permitted if amendment of the plaint would remedy the defect. The trial Court relied on this precedent to the extent that it recognized amendment as an alternative; however, the trial Court ultimately concluded the plaint required major changes and allowed withdrawal. The revising Court noted the trial Court cited this authority but nevertheless permitted withdrawal, contrary to the principle mentioned.
AIR 1972 P & H 30 Referenced by the trial Court (context: authorities dealing with O.23 R.1 applications at the fag end of trial). The trial Court mentioned this case but held it not relevant to the facts because such rulings concerned O.23 R.1 applications made at the fag end of trial.
AIR 1971 Mysore 334 Referenced by the trial Court (context: authorities dealing with O.23 R.1 applications at the fag end of trial). The trial Court mentioned this case but held it not relevant to the facts because such rulings concerned O.23 R.1 applications made at the fag end of trial.
AIR 1983 Madras 160 Referenced by the trial Court (context: authorities dealing with O.23 R.1 applications at the fag end of trial). The trial Court mentioned this case but held it not relevant to the facts because such rulings concerned O.23 R.1 applications made at the fag end of trial.
AIR 1961 Punjab 421 Referenced by the trial Court (context not elaborated in the impugned order excerpt). The trial Court mentioned this case but, as reported in the impugned order, treated it as not relevant to the present facts.
AIR 1940 Bombay 121 — Ramrao Bhagwanrao v. Bau Appanna (Full Bench) Interpretation of clauses (a) and (b) of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC: clauses read together; clause (a) illustrative of grounds in clause (b); grounds must be at least analogous to clause (a); formal defects include mis-joinder, rejection of material document for lack of proper stamp, erroneous valuation; "formal defect" to be given wide meaning but not to include defects of substance. The revising Court applied this Full Bench authority to hold that formal defects include certain kinds of errors but that defects of substance cannot be treated as formal; the Court relied on this reasoning in concluding the trial Court erred in permitting withdrawal when amendment could cure the defects.
AIR 1956 Bombay 632 — Tarachand v. Gaibihaji Held that non-joinder of parties or failure to make proper claim is not a formal defect; such omissions cannot be treated as formal defects warranting withdrawal under O.23 R.1 and should be addressed by amendment. The revising Court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that failures to make particular claims or to implead parties are not formal defects justifying withdrawal and that the plaintiff in the present case could have sought amendment rather than withdrawal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court's reasoning proceeded in the following steps, strictly following the content of the opinion:

  1. Identification of the impugned order and grounds of challenge: The Court noted that the trial Court permitted withdrawal under Order 23 Rule 1 CPC on the grounds that the plaint suffered from drafting defects (by counsel), mis-joinder, non-payment/incorrect payment of Court fees, non-valuation of suit property, and omission to claim certain reliefs.
  2. Examination of the trial Court's treatment of authorities: The trial Court had referred to several precedents but considered most inapplicable because they dealt with applications under O.23 R.1 made at the fag end of trial; it relied in part upon AIR 1989 NOC (Orissa) 193 which suggests withdrawal should not be permitted where amendment would suffice. Nevertheless the trial Court concluded that the plaint required major changes and allowed withdrawal.
  3. Application of binding and relevant authorities: The revising Court analysed and applied the principles laid down by the Full Bench in AIR 1940 Bombay 121 (Ramrao Bhagwanrao v. Bau Appanna), which interprets clauses (a) and (b) of O.23 R.1 and explains what may be regarded as a "formal defect", and the authority in AIR 1956 Bombay 632 (Tarachand v. Gaibihaji), which holds that non-joinder or failure to make a proper claim is not a formal defect.
  4. Assessment of whether defects were formal or substantive in the present case: On the facts before it, the High Court found that none of the defects pointed out were fatal or of such a nature that amendment could not cure them. The Court observed that the plaintiff had in fact filed two amendment applications (the results of which were not disclosed in the impugned order), and that matters such as valuation or Court fee payment are capable of rectification by amendment.
  5. Conclusion about exercise of jurisdiction: The High Court concluded that the trial Court failed to properly determine whether the grounds before it were sufficient to invoke the jurisdiction under Order 23 Rule 1 and therefore exercised jurisdiction not available to it by allowing withdrawal when amendment could have remedied the defects.
  6. Resulting remedial step: On that basis, the High Court quashed and set aside the impugned order, allowed the Civil Revision, and made the Rule absolute, with no order as to costs.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The impugned order dated 15-12-1997 is quashed and set aside; the Civil Revision Application is allowed and the Rule is made absolute.

Implications (direct and as discussed in the opinion):

  • The direct effect on the parties is that the trial Court's order permitting the plaintiff to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit on the same cause of action is invalidated. The opinion does not specify any further immediate directions about future procedure in the suit beyond quashing the withdrawal order.
  • The Court's decision rests on established authorities about the proper scope of Order 23 Rule 1 CPC: where defects in a plaint can be cured by amendment (including mis-joinder, valuation, fee issues, or omissions to claim particular reliefs), permission to withdraw a suit with leave to file a fresh suit should not be granted; instead amendment should be sought. The trial Court's failure to assess whether the defects fell within the scope of O.23 R.1 constituted a jurisdictional error.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities; it emphasizes faithful application of precedents such as AIR 1940 Bombay 121, AIR 1956 Bombay 632, AIR 2000 SC 2132 and AIR 1989 NOC (Orissa) 193 to the facts at hand.
Application allowed.
Show all summary ...

In this Civil Revision under section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code, challenge is to the order dated 15-12-1997 passed by 2nd Joint Civil Judge (Junior Division) Khamgaon, District Buldhana in Regular Civil Suit No. 40 of 1997 instituted by present respondent permitting him to withdraw said suit with liberty to file fresh one.

2. I have heard Advocate Shri Paliwal for Revision applicant. Nobody has appeared for respondent though served. Advocate Paliwal has invited attention to impugned order and also to the provisions of Order 23 Rule 1 of Civil Procedure Code to contend that the Court below has exercised jurisdiction not available to it. He argues that failure to claim relief or defect in drafting of plaint is not in defect of formal nature so as to enable the Court to exercise powers under said provision. In support he has placed reliance upon judgment of Hon'ble Apex Court reported at AIR 2000 SC 2132 between K.S Bhoopathy v. Kokila.

3. Perusal of impugned order reveals that the defects pointed out by present respondent in his application under Order 23 Rule 1 are about the drafting of plaint by his counsel, mis-joinder of the parties, non-payment of proper Court fees, non-valuation of suit property and not claiming proper reliefs. The suit is for declaration and injunction with grievance that defendant has committed encroachment on property of present respondent. It is plaintiff's case that the defendant/present revision applicant encroached upon portion of his property in his absence on 21-2-1997 but relief for declaration about encroachment, its extent, restoration of possession and return of material illegally taken away by defendant as also relief of permanent injunction are not sought for inadvertently. It is contended that therefore suit suffers from material defects which cause prejudice to plaintiff and hence he should be permitted to withdraw it with liberty to file fresh on same cause of action. It is also added that defects are of formal nature. The revision applicant opposed withdrawal on the ground that he had already filed written statement and disclosed his defence. The defendant pointed out that two separate applications were moved by plaintiff for amendment of plaint and same were opposed by defendant. The trial Court while passing the impugned order only mentioned AIR 1972 P and H 30, AIR 1971 Maysore 334, AIR 1983 Madras 160, AIR 1989 NOC (Orissa) 193, AIR 1961 Punjab 421. However it held that except AIR 1989 NOC (Orissa) 193 the other rulings were not relevant because there the applications moved under O. 23 R. 1 at fag end of the trial have been considered. So far as AIR 1989 NOC (Orissa) 193 is concerned, it observed that withdrawal of suit cannot be permitted if by amendment the defect can be remedied. Thereafter it found that the counsel for plaintiff did not draft the plaint properly and applications for amendment moved by him were also not proper. It found that the present respondent/plaintiff was not at fault and he was not properly guided by his advocate. It further found that though amendment is possible, the plaint required major changes. It found that amendment of plaint will not be sufficient and as case of plaintiff came within four corners of Order 23 Rule 1, his application deserved to be allowed. It therefore permitted present respondent to withdraw his suit with liberty to file fresh suit on same cause of action subject to costs of Rs. 300/- only.

4. It is therefore necessary to find out whether the defects mentioned by respondent above are defects of formal nature as envisaged by Order 23 Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code. In AIR 2000 SC 2132, K.S Bhoopathy v. Kokila. In said matter the plaintiffs filed a suit and sought relief, inter alia, of injunction against defendants restraining them from establishing and running a flour mill on their property and for further injunction restraining them from disturbing the plaintiffs' exclusive user of the pathway lying between the properties of the plaintiffs on one side and defendants on the other. Defendants in the suit as owners sold portions of their land by separate sale deeds executed in favour of plaintiffs. It was the case of the plaintiffs that establishment of the proposed flour mill by the defendants would be a nuisance and would seriously prejudice the plaintiffs' user of their property on which they have constructed a clinic. Regarding the pathway the case of the plaintiffs was that they have exclusive right of user of the same and the plaintiffs should not be permitted to interfere with their right in any manner. The trial Court decreed the suit holding inter alia that the plaintiffs' have an exclusive right of user over the pathway. The trial Court also accepted the case of the plaintiffs' in respect of the prayer for injuncting contesting defendants from establishing a flour mill on their property. On appeal first Appellate Court modified the decree relating to the pathway holding that the plaintiffs have no exclusive right of user of the pathway and all the parties were entitled to use the same as it was a common pathway. The plaintiffs filed the second appeal, and before said appeal was admitted the plaintiffs filed an application under O. 23, R. 1(3), Civil Procedure Code seeking permission of the Court to withdraw the suit with leave to file a fresh suit as no prayer for declaration of plaintiffs title over the pathway was made in the plaint and in view of the cloud raised against their exclusive title and right of user in the judgment of the lower appellate Court, it was necessary to withdraw the suit and file a fresh suit properly constituted and seeking appropriate relief. The application filed by the plaintiffs was allowed by the High Court. The Hon'ble Apex Court found that the High Court could not be said to have considered the relevant aspects of the matter. High Court's approach had been that since the interest of the defendants can be safeguarded by giving them permission for user of the pathway till adjudication of the controversy in the fresh suit to be filed, permission for withdrawal of the suit as prayed for can be granted. Hon'ble Apex Court observed that such an approach would be clearly erroneous. It is the duty of the Court to feel satisfied that there exist proper grounds and reasons for granting permission for withdrawal of the suit with leave to file fresh suit by the plaintiffs and in such a matter the statutory mandate is not complied by merely stating that grant of permission will not prejudice the defendants. As per this judgment, in case such permission is granted at appellate or second appellate stage, prejudice to defendant is writ large as he loses the benefit of the decision in his favour in the lower Court. Thus the order of the High Court granting permission for withdrawal of the suit with permission to file fresh suit was held liable to be set aside by Hon'ble Apex Court. Here, in view of the judgment. AIR 1989 NOC (Orissa) 193, the learned trial Court found that present respondent could have amended his plaint instead of withdrawal and then found that plaint required major amendment. It thereafter found that no prejudice would be caused to present revision applicant. However, it failed to find out whether the ground put forth before it was sufficient to invoke jurisdiction under Order 23 Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code to grant such permission to present respondent. Thus, error committed by it is same and failure to exercise jurisdiction is apparent.

5. Hon'ble Full Bench of this High Court in AIR 1940 Bombay 121, Ramrao Bhagwanrao v. Bau Appanna, the Hon'ble Bench has considered position prevailing before the Civil Procedure Code was enacted in 1859 and several cases on the point. While construing clause (a) and clause (b) of O. 23 R. 1 it has been held that the two clauses are required to be read together and one has in clause (a) an illustration of the sort or reason which the Legislature thought would be sufficient, and in that way clause (a) may, to some extent, limit the generality of the words in clause (b). It is observed that clause (a) is illustrative of the “grounds” referred to in clause (b), and although the “grounds” need not be ejusdem generis with the ground mentioned in clause (a), they must be “at least analogous” to it. The ground in clause (a) requires that suit must fail by reason of some formal defect; whereas the grounds contemplated in clause (b) need not necessarily be fatal to the suit, but must be analogous to formal defect. It is further held that the formal defects include mis-joinder of parties or of matters in the suit, rejection of a material document for not having a proper stamp, erroneous valuation of subject matter of suit. It has been held that expression “formal defect” must be given wide and liberal meaning, and must be deemed to connote every kind of defect which does not affect the merits of the case, whether that defect be fatal to the suit or not. In the facts of case before Hon'ble Full Bench, opponents were allowed to withdraw suit in appeal after trial Court held that they failed to prove that the site was an alluvion. They wanted to withdraw the suit in order to file another claiming title to the said site and it was held that it was no defect of form but a defect of substance arising out of their inability to prove the title on which they had based their claim and in allowing the suit to be withdrawn on this ground, the Assistant Judge acted without jurisdiction.

6. In AIR 1956 Bombay 632, Tarachand v. Gaibihaji, Hon'ble Shri Gajendragadkar J. (as he then was) held that the non-joinder of parties or failure to make proper claim is not a formal defect. The Appellate Judge was told that as the plaintiff had failed to attack the mortgage decree and parties to the mortgage were not impleaded in the suit, there was formal defect and on that ground the suit was allowed to be withdrawn with liberty under Order 23 Rule 1. It has been observed that plaintiff was fighting against auction purchaser who was trying to recover possession and plaintiff's purchase was affected by lis pendens and the suit filed was with full knowledge that the auction purchaser was seeking to enforce his rights as such, and still no allegations were made in plaint that mortgage decree was not binding upon him and no relief was claimed in that behalf. It is observed by this Court that failure to make this claim and failure to implead parties in respect of the claim cannot be regarded as formal defect which is fatal to the suit. The appeal was therefore restored to the file of Appellate Court and plaintiff was given leave to apply for amendment in plaint.

7. In the facts of present case also, it cannot be said that there was any fatal defect of form in the suit. All the defects pointed out by the respondent/plaintiff could have been cured by moving appropriate amendment application. In view of facts pleaded, the original plaintiff could have asked, for appropriate declaration and injunction along with relief for restoration of possession and return of material. The defect about valuation of suit property or suit or payment of Court fee is never treated as defect which cannot be rectified. In fact, the plaintiff appears to have moved two amendment applications but their fate is not disclosed in the impugned order. AIR 1989 NOC (Orissa) 193 cited before the lower Court expressly states that the withdrawal of suit cannot be permitted since amendment of plaint to incorporate necessary reliefs can be sought for. Here though the law is noticed, on the ground of no prejudice only to the present revision applicant, suit has been allowed to be withdrawn. Hence, it is apparent that the Court below has exercised jurisdiction not available to it by permitting the respondent to withdraw suit with liberty to file fresh one on same cause of action.

8. The impugned order is, therefore, quashed and set aside. Civil Revision Application is allowed. Rule is made absolute in above terms. There shall be no order as to costs.

Application allowed.