- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bama Kathari Patil v. Rohidas Arjun Madhavi And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner (original defendant No. 1) filed an application dated 20 October 2003 seeking recall of the plaintiff for further cross-examination on the ground that an agreement dated 14 August 1986 was exhibited after the plaintiff's cross-examination had concluded. The matter concerns an interlocutory order; the court heard learned counsel for the petitioner and considered whether the late exhibiting of the document justified recall.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to recall the plaintiff for further cross-examination because the agreement was exhibited after the plaintiff's cross-examination concluded.
- What legal effect, if any, follows from a document being exhibited after cross-examination—specifically, whether late exhibition constitutes proof or otherwise prejudices the petitioner.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The agreement dated 14 August 1986 was exhibited only after the plaintiff's cross-examination had ended.
- Because the document was not exhibited at the time of cross-examination, defendant No. 1 did not cross-examine the plaintiff about it and should therefore be given an opportunity to do so now.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any arguments advanced by the plaintiff or other parties.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court noted the impugned order is interlocutory and concluded it was not inclined to entertain the petition because the order did not cause injustice to the petitioner. The court explained that exhibiting a document in court is essentially an administrative act done for convenience (allocation of an Exhibit number) and does not itself constitute proof of the document. Proof of a document must be established in accordance with the provisions of the Evidence Act. Consequently, the petitioner may, at the stage of final arguments, contend that although the agreement has been exhibited, it has not been proved in law. Given this clarification—that exhibition ≠ proof and that the petitioner can challenge proof later—the court found no prejudice to the petitioner and rejected the petition.
Holding and Implications
Petition dismissed.
Direct effect: the petition for recall is rejected; the petitioner remains entitled to challenge the proof of the exhibited agreement at the stage of arguments under the Evidence Act. The court additionally directed that all concerned act on an authenticated copy of the order attested by the court Sheristedar. The opinion does not discuss broader legal implications or establish a new precedent.
D.G Karnik, J.:— Heard learned counsel for the petitioner.
2. Apart from the fact that the impugned order is an interlocutory order, I am not inclined to entertain the petition because, in my opinion, the order does not cause any injustice to the petitioner.
3. By an application dated 20th October 2003, the petitioner (original defendant No. 1) made a prayer for recalling the plaintiff for further cross examination on the ground that the ‘agreement’ dated 14th August, 1986 was exhibited after the cross examination of the plaintiff was concluded. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that as the document was not exhibited at the time of cross-examination, the defendant No. 1 did not cross examine the plaintiff on that document. Since the document has been exhibited after the cross examination of the plaintiff was over, he should be given an opportunity of cross examining the plaintiff regarding the said document. Exhibiting of an document is an administrative act. It is true that a document which is produced in court is ordinarily exhibited only after its proof. But, exhibiting a document does not mean that the document is proved and non-exhibiting a document does not mean that the document is not proved. A document is required to be proved in accordance with the provisions of the Evidence Act. Merely for administrative convenience of locating or identifying a document, it is given an Exhibit number in courts. Exhibiting a document has nothing to do with the proof though, as a matter of convenience, only the proved documents are exhibited.
4. It is therefore open to the petitioner defendant to contend at the stage of arguments that the agreement though exhibited, has not been proved by the plaintiff in accordance with law. With this clarification, no injustice or prejudice would be caused to the petitioner. Hence, with this clarification, petition is rejected.
5. All concerned to act on an authenticated copy of the order attested by the court Sheristedar.
Petition dismissed.
Alert