Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sonal Garments v. Trimbak Shankar Karve .

Bombay High Court
Aug 29, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner employer challenged the Award dated 7th January, 1995 passed by the Labour Court in Reference I.D.A No. 447 of 1992, arising out of an industrial dispute raised by the respondent workman. The dispute was referred to the Labour Court by the State Government under section 10(1)(c) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The respondent workman claimed to have been employed since June 1990 and alleged that he was orally terminated from employment with effect from 23rd April, 1991 without retrenchment compensation or wages in lieu of notice. The petitioner employer contended that the respondent was never terminated but remained absent without authorization from February 1991 and was welcome to resume duties. Both parties filed pleadings and adduced oral evidence before the Labour Court. The Labour Court found the termination to be illegal, ordered reinstatement with full backwages and continuity of service, and held that the respondent had completed 240 days of continuous employment, entitling him to benefits under section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent workman was illegally terminated by the petitioner employer.
  2. Whether the respondent workman was entitled to reinstatement with full backwages and continuity of service.
  3. Whether the respondent workman’s failure to accept the petitioner employer’s offer to reinstate affects his entitlement to backwages and reinstatement.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner Employer's Arguments

  • The respondent workman was never formally terminated but remained absent from February 1991 without authorization.
  • The respondent was welcome to resume duties and explain his absence at any time.
  • The offer to reinstate the respondent was made unconditionally in the written statement dated 10th January, 1994.
  • The respondent’s failure to accept the offer to resume work indicates abandonment of employment.

Respondent Workman's Arguments

  • The respondent claimed oral termination effective 23rd April, 1991 without payment of retrenchment compensation or wages in lieu of notice.
  • The respondent denied abandoning employment and contended he was illegally terminated.
  • He sought reinstatement with full backwages and continuity of service.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court accepted the Labour Court’s factual findings that the respondent workman was illegally terminated and entitled to benefits under section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act based on continuous employment. However, the court found the Labour Court erred in awarding full backwages without considering the petitioner employer’s written offer to reinstate the respondent. The respondent did not accept or act upon this offer, nor did he report to work after the offer was made, which was evident from the absence of any oral evidence to the contrary. The court held that where an unconditional offer of reinstatement is made by the employer and the workman fails to accept it, the workman cannot claim reinstatement or backwages from the date of such offer. The respondent’s conduct supported the employer’s version that the respondent abandoned employment rather than being terminated. Consequently, the court concluded that the respondent was not entitled to reinstatement or backwages.

Holding and Implications

The Award is quashed and set aside.

The court’s decision nullifies the Labour Court’s order granting reinstatement with full backwages. The direct effect is that the respondent workman is not entitled to reinstatement or backwages due to his failure to accept the employer’s unconditional offer of reinstatement. No new legal precedent was established; the ruling reinforces the principle that acceptance of reinstatement offers is a prerequisite to claiming backwages and reinstatement relief.

Show all summary ...

R.J Kochar, J.:— The petitioner employer is aggrieved by the Award dated 7th January, 1995 passed by the Labour Court in Reference I.D.A No. 447 of 1992 in the industrial dispute raised by the respondent workman and referred by the State Government for adjudication to the Labour Court under section 10(1)(c) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

2. According to the respondent workman, he was employed by the petitioner employer in June 1990. According to him, he was terminated from employment with effect from 23rd April, 1991 orally.

3. It was his case that no retrenchment compensation was given to him and no wages in lieu of one month's notice were also offered at the time of termination. Both the parties appeared before the Labour Court and filed their pleadings. According to the petitioner employer, the respondent workman was never terminated from employment but he remained absent from February 1991. It was further averred in the written statement that as and when he reports for duty, he will have to explain his unauthorised absence. The petitioner employer further specifically averred that if the respondent workman was really interested to resume duties he cold do so. It was the specific case of the petitioner employer that the respondent workman was never terminated by the petitioner and that he remained absent unauthorisedly and that he was welcome to join his duties. It appears that the offer of the petitioner employer was not heeded and accepted by the respondent workman and he never reported for work as stated by the petitioner employer in its written statement dated 10th January, 1994. Both the parties adduced oral evidence in support of their pleadings. The Labour Court recorded its findings that the respondent workman was illegally terminated and that he was entitled to be reinstated with full backwages and continuity of service. It appears that the Labour Court accepted the date of termination as 23rd April, 1991 and, therefore, computed that the respondent workman had completed 240 days of continuous employment and that he was entitled to get the benefit of section 25-F of the I.D Act. The Labour Court further accepted that the petitioner employer had orally terminated the employment of the respondent and that the respondent workman had not abandoned the employment. The Labour Court did not accept the version of the petitioner employer. The findings recorded by the Labour Court are entirely based on the facts and evidence on record. It is, therefore, not possible for me to interfere with the Award for reinstatement under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.

4. The Award of full backwages, however, is totally erroneous. The Labour Court has not at all considered the offer of the petitioner employer in the written statement that the respondent workman, if really, interested to resume duties, could do so. In my opinion, the respondent workman will not be entitled to get the backwages from the date of the written statement as it appears that there was no response from the respondent workman and that he did not report for work at all. Had he reported for work after the written statement was filed, he would have definitely stated so in his oral evidence which was recorded on 3rd September, 1994 to say that he had reported for work but he was not taken back as stated in the written statement. The respondent workman is absolutely silent on that point. It is, therefore, clear that the respondent workman did not accept the offer of reinstatement given by the petitioner employer in his written statement. At the time of admission of the petition, this Court had granted rule only to the extent of backwages. There was no rule on the reinstatement.

5. However, as the offer of petitioner to reinstate the respondent was not accepted, he is not entitled to the relief of reinstatement and any backwages at all. His conduct lends support to the version of the employer that he had abandoned the employment and that he never came back to report for duty and that it was not a case of termination by the petitioner employer. Whenever the employer offers to reinstate the workman at any stage of the dispute or proceeding and if the workman does not accept the offer even without prejudice to his rights and contentions he will not be entitled to continue his claim for reinstatement in the proceedings and he will also be not entitled to claim any backwages from the date of such offer, conditional or unconditional. He must first accept the offer and get reinstated in employment and therefore continue to contest for the relief of back wages, if any. In the present case there was an unconditional offer of reinstatement made by the employer in the written statement itself but it was not accepted by the workman. Therefore, as stated by me hereinbefore, he is not entitled to get reinstatement with full ??? wages at all.

6. The Award is therefore, quashed and set aside. Rule is made ??? No orders as to costs.

7. Rule made absolute.