Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M.S Ranjana Kumar And Others v. Indian Dyestuff Industries Ltd.

Bombay High Court
Aug 24, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Legal Summary — Order of R.J. Kochar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners sought an order for winding up the respondent-company under sections 433 and 434 of the Companies Act, 1956, alleging inability to pay redemption amounts due on debentures held by them. The petitioners held two series of debentures: (a) 1,98,687 debentures at 19.5% (face value Rs. 100 at a premium of Rs. 5) and (b) 2,00,000 debentures at 14% (face value Rs. 100 at a premium of Rs. 5). It was alleged that the company failed to pay redemption values on maturity; the petitioners had extended time for payment and conditionally agreed to a reduction in interest in correspondence on record. The petition alleged outstanding amounts aggregating to Rs. 9,63,582.65 under the first series and Rs. 1,70,25,975 under the second series.

The record also shows payments made by the respondent-company at various times (including payments in 1997, instalments between August–December 1998, and several payments in 1999), and further payments of Rs. 10 lakhs on July 16 and July 31, 2001. The petitioners are secured debenture holders under a trust deed in favour of ICICI (debenture trustees) and hold a second charge on the company's properties.

The respondent-company contended that it is a solvent going concern, showing substantial turnover and asset values, employing around 3,000 workmen, and that nonpayment resulted from a temporary cash crunch and adverse market conditions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, having regard to the company's asserted inability to pay redemption amounts on debentures, a winding-up order under sections 433 and 434 of the Companies Act, 1956 should be made.
  2. Whether the court should exercise its discretion to refuse admission of the winding-up petition despite an alleged inability to pay debts, and instead permit the company time to pay subject to protective conditions for the debenture holders.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The respondent-company failed and was unable to pay debts due to the petitioners, specifically the redemption amounts of the debentures they held.
  • The petitioners had extended time and conditionally accepted reductions, but substantial sums remained outstanding.

Respondent-Company's Arguments

  • The company is a solvent, going concern with substantial turnover (Rs. 2,838.62 lakhs for 1998–99; Rs. 3,874.47 lakhs for 1997–98) and a large asset base (gross fixed assets reported as Rs. 22,698 lakhs as on 30 June 1999, per the opinion).
  • The company had made substantial payments to petitioners at various times and was ready to pay the outstanding amounts if given sufficient time.
  • Nonpayment was attributable to a temporary cash crunch caused by market conditions; admitting the winding-up petition would bring the company to a halt, harming employees (about 3,000 workmen) and the business.
  • The petitioners are secured (debenture trust deed in favour of ICICI) and hold a second charge; therefore the petition should not be admitted where revival is possible.
  • Learned counsel for the company relied upon judicial authorities supporting the exercise of discretion to refuse winding up where revival is feasible.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rishi Enterprises, In re, [1992] 73 Comp Cas 271, 272 (Guj) The court has judicial discretion under the Companies Act: a running company in temporary financial difficulty should not be wound up merely because it cannot pay debts at the moment; courts should prefer revival to affirming death of a company. The court cited this principle to support the exercise of discretion against admitting the winding-up petition in view of the company's ongoing operations, past payments and prospects of revival.
New Swadeshi Mills of Ahmedabad Ltd. v. Dye-chem Corporation, [1986] 59 Comp Cas 183, 186 (Guj) Even where a company is unable to pay debts, the court should exercise sound discretion and consider factors pointing to a reasonable prospect of resurrection; the policy is to attempt revival where reasonable prospects exist. The court relied on this authority to justify refusing immediate winding up where there appeared to be prospects (including specific proposals or payments) justifying a chance of revival.
American Express Bank Ltd. v. Core Health Care Ltd., [1999] 96 Comp Cas 841 (Guj) Winding up is discretionary (section 433); the court may exercise discretion at the stage of considering admission and is not obliged to admit the petition before considering whether to wind up. The court invoked this headnote to support its approach of considering the totality of materials at admission stage and declining to make a winding-up order where discretion favoured refusal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded from statutory and factual premises set out in the opinion.

  1. Statutory discretion: The court observed that sections 433 (and by reference 434) use the word "may", indicating that even if a ground under section 433 is made out (such as inability to pay debts), the grant of winding-up relief is discretionary and not mandatory.
  2. Consideration of authorities: The court reviewed authorities emphasising that courts should, where reasonable prospects of revival exist, prefer revival over winding up and should discreetly exercise their discretion when a running concern temporarily cannot meet obligations.
  3. Factual assessment: Applying the statutory discretion to the present facts, the court noted:
    • The respondent-company was a going concern with substantial turnover and a substantial asset base.
    • The company had made periodic substantial payments to the petitioners, including specific payments in 1997–1999 and two payments of Rs. 10 lakhs in July 2001 as assured before the court.
    • The petitioners were secured debenture holders with a debenture trust deed in favour of ICICI and a second charge on company properties.
    • The company employed about 3,000 workmen, paid wages and was meeting arrears under an agreement, indicating social and commercial consequences if operations ceased.
    • From information furnished, the court concluded assets exceeded liabilities and the company was not commercially insolvent but experiencing a cash crunch attributable to market conditions.
  4. Balancing interests: While recognising the need to protect the debenture holders' interests, the court concluded it would be injurious to admit the petition or advertise it at the stage, since doing so could cause the commercial death of an operational company endeavouring to overcome temporary difficulties.
  5. Conditional relief by order: The court resolved the competing interests by refusing immediate winding up but ordering a binding payment schedule and protective conditions for the petitioners; the order set consequences for defaults (admission and advertisement) and specified terms relating to release and continuation of charges on company assets.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court dismissed the winding-up petition, subject to the respondent making payments as per a detailed schedule annexed to the order; in the event of two defaults by the respondent in payment under the schedule, the petition shall stand admitted and be advertised after notice.

Immediate Consequences and Practical Effects

  • The respondent must make payments set out in the annexed schedule by their respective due dates; if the respondent complies, the petition is dismissed.
  • Two defaults in payment (each default defined as failure to pay the full amount of any instalment within seven days of its due date) will cause the petition to be admitted and advertised one week after written intimation to the respondent.
  • The petitioners undertook (on instructions) to grant no objection to release of their charge on the assets of the solvent dyes business having book value not exceeding Rs. 10 crores as on July 31, 2001, within two weeks of identification by the respondents and written intimation; existing charge on the balance assets will continue until full dues are paid.
  • On full payment under the schedule, the petitioners will be deemed to have accepted the payment in full and final settlement of their claims; the charge on balance assets will be released on such full payment.
  • The petition was dismissed with no order as to costs; certified copy to be expedited and distributed to concerned parties via the company Registrar.

The opinion does not purport to create a new legal precedent; it applied established principles of judicial discretion (as expressed in cited authorities) to the facts before the court and fashioned a conditional order balancing the company's opportunity to pay with protective measures for the debenture holders.

Show all summary ...

R.J Kochar, J.:— The petitioners have prayed for an order of winding up of the respondent-company under sections 433 and 434 of the Companies Act, 1956, alleging failure and inability on the part of the company to pay the debts due to the petitioners being the redemption amount of the debentures held by the petitioners. The petitioners were holding two series of debentures of the respondent-company one being 1,98,687—19.5 per cent, debentures of the face value of Rs. 100 at a premium of Rs. 5 and the other being 2,00,000—14 per cent, debentures of the face value of Rs. 100 at a premium of Rs. 5.

2. It is alleged by the petitioners that the respondent-company failed to pay the redemption value of the shares on maturity. There is correspondence on record to indicate that the petitioners extended the time for payment from time to time and even conditionally agreed to a reduction in the interest rate.

3. It is the contention of the petitioners that despite accommodation, the respondent-company could not pay amounts aggregating to Rs. 9,63,582.65 under the first series of debentures and Rs. 1,70,25,975 under the second series of debentures, whilst is still outstanding and payable.

4. However, the genuine attempts on the part of the company to pay the redemption value of the debentures is apparent from the petition itself. The respondent-company paid 50 per cent, of the redemption amount of the first series debentures in the year 1997. Under a letter dated August 25, 1997, certain instalments were fixed and between August and December, 1998, an amount to Rs. 25 lakhs was paid. Further instalments of Rs. 24.29 lakhs, Rs. 10 lakhs and Rs. 49.31 lakhs were paid in 1999.

5. It has been contended on behalf of the respondent-company that the company is a solvent going concern. The annual turnover of the company for the year 1998-99 was Rs. 2,838.62 lakhs and for the year 1997-98 was Rs. 3,874.47 lakhs. The amounts paid by way of revenue to the treasury during the year 1998-99 was Rs. 22,698 lakhs as per the last audited balance-sheet. The company was paying dividend for 37 years up to the financial year 1996-97. Further, the petitioners as debenture holders are secured under a debenture trust deed executed in favour of the debenture trustees being the ICICI. The petitioners hold a second charge on the properties of the company as set out in the trust deed. The company has around 3,000 workmen employed. The monthly wage bill is Rs. 5 crores. As per an agreement with the workmen, the company is paying Rs. 1.25 crores per month to the workmen towards arrears of wages. The gross value of the fixed assets as on June 30, 1999, is Rs. 22,698 lakhs. The nonpayment of the amounts, it is asserted, is due to a temporary cash crunch which is nothing but a result of the market conditions and the general slack in the economy. It is contended that this is not a fit case where a winding up petition ought to be admitted and that the winding of the company or even an order of admission of the company petition would result in serious repercussions and may bring the entire company to a grinding halt.

6. Learned counsel for the company has relied upon the following decisions in support of his contention that in these circumstances, a company petition deserves to be dismissed.

(i) Rishi Enterprises, In re, [1992] 73 Comp Cas 271, 272 (Guj):

“The section itself confers judicial discretion upon the courts. In the present case, it seems that the intention of the petitioners in insisting on admission of these matters is only to coerce the company and extract from it immediately by any means the amount which is payable to the petitioners. There is no such law that a company which is a running company employing about 500 employees who are paid their wages regularly and which is having a business of crores of rupees every year should be brought to a grinding halt by admitting these petitions merely because it is in some financial difficulty at the moment. On the contrary even in those cases where the company is closed, it has been laid down that it is the duty of the court to welcome revival rather than affirm the death of the company. It has been also held that it would not be right to say that creditors can insist, on winding up of the company by the court as a matter of right if the position of the company is such that it would be unable to pay its debts to them even if the company can be resurrected. The petitioning creditor cannot be permitted to insist on his pound of flesh from the company which may be a death blow to the company only on the ground that for a temporary period a running company is not in a position to pay the debt. This would be clear from the following decision of this court.”

(ii) New Swadeshi Mills of Ahmedabad Ltd. v. Dye-chem Corporation, [1986] 59 Comp Cas 183, 186 (Guj):

“It is the case of the creditors that the company is unable to pay its debts and that it is just and equitable that the company should be wound up. The circumstances call for no proof of inability on the part of the company to pay its debts as such inability is self evident on the admitted facts. There are huge debts, secured as well as unsecured, which, as matters stand, are far beyond the means of the company to meet. Even so, a court will exercise a sound discretion in deciding whether to wind up a company or not and in doing so consider many relevant factors. It may be that despite the inability to pay its debts, a company has still prospects of coming back to life and if the court is told of any specific proposal, which in the opinion of the court is likely to materialise, the court will be inclined to give a chance to resurrect the company. It should be the policy of the court to attempt to revive though at the moment the company may not be solvent and may not be able to meet its obligations to its creditors. But this should be only if it is shown that there is reasonable prospect for resurrection and survival. It may be easy for a court when once it is shown that the company is unable to pay its debts to bury it deep, and distribute whatever is available as distributable surplus. But it is the duty of the court to welcome revival rather than affirm the death of the company and for that purpose the court is called upon to make a discreet exercise.”

(iii) American Express Bank Ltd. v. Core Health Care Ltd., [1999] 96 Comp Cas 841 (Guj) (headnote):

“A claim to an order of winding up is not a matter of right but is in the discretion of the court on one or more of the grounds having been established as mentioned in section 433 of the Companies Act, 1956. However, there is no warrant to assume that the stage for exercise of such discretion arises only after the petition is admitted and that the court cannot exercise that discretion even if on considering the totality of the materials as are made available on record by the petitioner it is satisfied that no order of winding up be made at the time of considering admission of the petition…

7. The word ‘may’ used in sections 433 and 443 is indicative of the fact that even if one or more of the grounds mentioned in section 433 is made out, and the company is unable to pay its debt, it is still not mandatory, but rests in the discretion of the court whether to make an order of winding up, The court must in each case exercise its discretion in deciding whether in the circumstances of the case, it would be in the interest of justice to wind up the company.”

8. In light of the rival contentions, it is crystal clear that the respondent-company is a going concern doing substantial business having a huge turnover. The respondent-company is paying huge amounts' as revenue and also has a substantial asset bases. The respondent-company has also from time to time paid to the petitioners substantial amounts including an amount of Rs. 10 lakhs on July 16, 2001, and July 31, 2001, as assured before this court. The ICICI is the trustee of the petitioner as debenture holders and charge has been created on the properties of the company in favour of the trustees. From the information furnished, the assets of the company are much more than their liabilities. The company is engaging 3,000 workmen who are dependent on the company being functional and operative. All these facts are relevant and have to be taken into account before an order of winding up a company or even admission of the petition is passed. The company is not commercially insolvent. It will not be in the interest of any one or even the society at large to admit the present petition or to advertise the same at this stage. In my opinion, the same would seriously prejudice the functioning of the company which is operational and striving to get over the financial crunch. The same may result in the commercial death of the company.

9. However, at the same time, the interest of the debenture holders ought to be protected. The company has expressed its readiness and willingness to pay the amounts to the petitioners provided sufficient time is given to the company.

10. In the aforesaid circumstances both learned counsel have invited this court to pass an appropriate order in the interest of justice. I therefore, pass the following order:

(1) The respondent shall make payment of the amounts set out in the third column of the schedule hereto annexed by their respective due dates set out in the first column of the schedule, each such payment to be made strictly on or before the relevant due date. On respondent paying to the petitioners the amounts on the dates as set out in the schedule annexed hereto, the petition shall stand dismissed.

(2) In the event of respondent committing any two defaults in payment of the amounts as set out in the schedule annexed hereto, the petition shall stand admitted and shall be advertised one week after written intimation to the respondent in that behalf.

(3) Learned counsel on behalf of. the petitioners makes a statement on instructions from its clients that the petitioners shall grant their no objection to the release of their charge. on the assets of solvent dyes business of the company having book value not exceeding Rs. 10 crores as on July 31, 2001, within two weeks of indentification of the assets by the respondents and written intimation in that behalf to the petitioners. However, existing charge on the balance assets of the company shall continue till the entire dues are paid by the respondent-company as per the schedule hereto annexed. On payment of the entire amount as per clause 1 above, the charge on the balance assets shall also stand released.

(4) Default for the purpose of clause 2 shall be construed to be a failure on the part of the respondents to pay to the full amount of any instalment as set out in the schedule annexed hereto within seven days of the date on which such instalment is payable by the respondent.

(5) On full payment being made as per the schedule hereto annexed in accordance with clause 1 above, the petitioners shall be deemed to have accepted the same in full and final settlement of their claims against the respondent, but not otherwise.

11. The petition stands dismissed with no order as to costs. Certified copy expedited.

12. All concerned to act on a copy of this order duly authenticated by the company Registrar.