Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Canfin Homes Ltd. v. Lloyds Steel Industries Ltd.

Bombay High Court
Mar 30, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

By a letter dated 24 February 1992 the petitioner sanctioned a term loan of Rs. 5.52 crores to the respondent company, Lloyds Steel Industries Ltd., for construction of employee dwelling units at Wardha. The respondent executed, among other documents, a Demand Promissory Note dated 21 August 1992 promising repayment of Rs. 5.52 crores with interest at 22% per annum, a loan agreement and a supplementary loan agreement dated 17 August 1992, and guarantee agreements executed on 27 August 1992 by the Chairman and a Director.

The sanction letter and loan agreement specified interest rules (including reference to National Housing Bank guidelines and a 2% service charge and penal interest at 2% over and above the loan rate for defaults). The loan was repayable in 120 monthly installments.

Disbursements totalling Rs. 5.52 crores were made on several dates between 21 August 1992 and 7 January 1994. The Company acknowledged outstanding sums by letters dated 1 April 1995 and 1 April 1998, the latter acknowledging liability of Rs. 4,42,15,834/-. On 27 August 1999 the petitioner served a demand notice claiming Rs. 5,72,18,397/- plus further interest and indicating it as a statutory notice prior to winding up proceedings. The Company's reply of 21 September 1999 stated that it offered additional security over other properties but received no favourable response.

The Company Petition for winding up was filed on 27 September 1999, alleging principal outstanding of Rs. 4,11,66,156/- and total dues including interest and other charges of Rs. 6,10,15,192/-. The Company created an equitable mortgage over immovable property at Wardha (25.15 hectares) referenced in a memorandum dated 17 August 1992.

An affidavit in reply was filed on behalf of the respondent company setting out defences and contentions (described below). After hearing, the Court admitted the Company Petition, made it returnable on 4 July 2001, directed publication of the petition (with a short delay on advertisement), required deposit of Rs. 2,000 with the Prothonotary & Senior Master, and ordered that a certified copy be expedited.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a secured creditor (the petitioner) is entitled to present and maintain a petition for the winding up of a company without first relinquishing its security.
  2. Whether the pendency of a civil suit instituted by the petitioner (seeking recovery and enforcement of security) after the presentation of the Company Petition precludes the Court from entertaining the winding up petition.
  3. Whether the petition should be rejected at the admission stage on the ground that the petitioning creditor is secured and that the petition does not state whether the security is sufficient to meet the creditor's dues.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments (as set out in the affidavit in reply)

  • By November 1997 the Company had paid Rs. 4.52 crores toward repayment; these payments are not reflected in the Company Petition or its particulars of claim.
  • Under section 434(1)(a) of the Companies Act, 1956, a company is deemed unable to pay if it fails to pay or to secure the debt within the stipulated period; the petitioner already has valuable security (the equitable mortgage), so the Company cannot be said to have failed to secure the debt.
  • A secured creditor must, in the first instance, relinquish its security if it seeks to be part of winding up proceedings; absent relinquishment (or an express statement in the petition), the winding up petition is not maintainable. The petition does not disclose sufficiency or insufficiency of the security.
  • The petitioner instituted a civil suit (Suit No. 237 of 2000) after the Company Petition was filed; having taken that remedy, the Company Petition should not be entertained.

Petitioner's Position (as recorded in the opinion)

  • The petitioner relied on documentary admissions (including the Company's acknowledgement dated 1 April 1998 of outstanding dues of Rs. 4.42 crores) and later payments made under the Court's ad interim order.
  • The petitioner manifested an intention to enforce its security by filing a civil suit for recovery and enforcement of securities; that indicates it seeks to realize security rather than surrender it at the admission stage.
  • The Company's offer of additional security suggests that the existing security was inadequate to meet the petitioner's dues.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bharat Overseas Bank Ltd. v. Shree Arcee Steels P. Ltd. (1985) 58 Com. Cases 174 Held that rejection of a winding up petition at the stage of admission on the ground that the petitioner was a secured creditor was not justified; sufficiency of security to be considered later after admission and advertisement. The Court relied on this Division Bench ruling to support the proposition that a secured creditor may present a petition and that the court should not dismiss at admission simply because the creditor is secured.
Karnatak Vegetable Oils and Refineries Ltd. v. Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. (1954) 24 Comp. Cas 249 (Mad) Madras High Court decision considered in support of the view that secured creditors may apply for winding up. Cited as one of the earlier authorities forming a consistent strand of jurisprudence permitting secured creditors to petition for winding up.
India Electric Works Ltd., In re, AIR 1970 Cal 398 A Learned Single Judge of the Calcutta High Court held that a petition for winding up could not be maintained at the instance of a secured creditor. The opinion notes this decision as part of earlier conflicting authorities that were considered and distinguished by later Division Bench authorities.
Calcutta Safe Deposit Co. Ltd. v. Ranjit Mathuradas Sampat (1971) 41 Comp. Cas 1063 (Cal) A Learned Single Judge decision referenced among earlier authorities on secured creditors and winding up. Referred to as part of the judicial history; the Division Bench authority that followed declined the single judge's restrictive approach.
Techno Metal India (P) Ltd. v. Prem Nath Anand (1973) 43 Company Cases 556 (Cal) Division Bench held that secured creditors can successfully prosecute an application for winding up; section 439(2) of the Companies Act supports inclusion of secured creditors among petitioning creditors. Used to reinforce the Court's conclusion that the statutory scheme recognises secured creditors as entitled to present petitions for winding up without prior abandonment of security.
M.K. Ranganathan v. Government of Madras, AIR 1955 SC 604 Supreme Court discussion of the position of a secured creditor in winding up; quoted Lord Wrenbury (Food Controller v. Cork) on the phrase "outside the winding up". The Court relied on this Supreme Court authority to explain the legal concept that secured creditors are ordinarily "outside" winding up but may enter if they choose.
Food Controller v. Cork, 1923 AC 647 (Lord Wrenbury dictum) Explains that a secured creditor (e.g., a mortgagee) may remain outside the winding up and enforce rights separately, or may choose to prove as a creditor and thereby come into the winding up. Quoted (through M.K. Ranganathan) to elucidate the distinction between secured creditors who remain outside and those who elect to come into winding up.
Ram Chand v. Bank of Upper India Ltd., ILR 1922 Lah 59 Explains that in liquidation a secured creditor may realise security and prove for any balance; secured creditor's realization reduces the estate in insolvency. Cited as an early judgment exemplifying the settled position that secured creditors may realize security and, if necessary, prove for the balance.
Sharfuzzaman v. H. Hunter, AIR 1930 Oudh 20 Held that a secured creditor may remain outside proceedings, realize security, and, if realization is less than the debt, prove for the balance in the liquidation. Referred to by the Court as supportive precedent for the rule that secured creditors can either remain outside or come into winding up for the balance.
Canara Bank v. Official Liquidator (1991 Vol. 70 Company Cases 295) Referred to approvingly for the position of secured creditors in liquidation and their options under insolvency rules. Used to show consistency of the principle in subsequent case law.
Allahabad Bank v. Canara Bank, (2000) 4 SCC 406 : AIR 2000 S.C. 1535 Supreme Court explained two categories of secured creditors: those who come before the Company Court (by relinquishing security and proving debt) and those who stand outside and realize security; clarified consequences under section 529 and related provisions. The Court relied on this Supreme Court judgment to explain statutory and practical consequences of a secured creditor electing to come into winding up or to stand outside it, reinforcing the conclusion that a secured creditor may petition without having first relinquished security.
Harinagar Sugar Mills v. M.W. Pradhan, 67 B.L.R 294 Division Bench articulation that the object of a petition for winding up is to realize the company's property for distribution to creditors. Cited to support the proposition that the fundamental purpose of winding up is asset realization for creditors and that a secured creditor's options must be understood against that background.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court identified the principal question as whether a secured creditor may maintain a petition for winding up without relinquishing its security. It undertook a statutory and precedential analysis, summarised in these steps:

  1. Statutory starting point: The Court observed that section 439 of the Companies Act, 1956 expressly contemplates that a petition for winding up may be presented by a secured creditor. Clause (b) of s.439(1) and sub-section (2) were read to include secured creditors within the class of persons entitled to present petitions.
  2. Precedent and comparative authority: The Court reviewed decisions of Division Benches and Single Judges (including Bharat Overseas Bank, Techno Metal, and earlier Madras and Calcutta authorities). It recorded that the Division Bench in Bharat Overseas had held that dismissal at admission on the sole ground of the petitioner being a secured creditor was unjustified and that the court should admit and advertise the petition and then consider sufficiency of security.
  3. Scheme of winding up provisions: The Court outlined the statutory scheme (sections 433, 434, 439, 441, 444, 446, 447, 528, 529 and related provisions), explaining the sequence: presentation of petition, winding up order (which commences the winding up), proof of debts after winding up, and application of insolvency rules to the proof and ranking of secured and unsecured claims.
  4. Role of insolvency rules: By reference to s.529 and the incorporated insolvency rules, the Court explained the options available to secured creditors (realize security and prove balance; surrender security and prove whole debt; estimate value and prove for balance; rely on security and not prove). The Court emphasised that these options operate at the stage of proving claims in winding up, which comes after an order of winding up.
  5. Meaning of "outside the winding up": Drawing from M.K. Ranganathan (and Lord Wrenbury's dictum), the Court reiterated that being "outside" does not prevent a secured creditor from entering winding up if it so chooses; the law does not mandate that a secured creditor must be outside.
  6. Timing of relinquishment: The Court concluded that it would be inappropriate to require a secured creditor to relinquish its security at the stage of filing a winding up petition, because the occasion to elect and to prove debt arises after a winding up order when proofs are called for. Thus, asking for relinquishment at the admission stage is misplaced.
  7. Application to facts: The Court noted documentary admissions by the Company (including the 1 April 1998 acknowledgement of Rs. 4.42 crores) and the petitioner's conduct (instituting a civil suit to enforce security and obtaining ad interim payments). The offer by the Company to furnish additional security was treated as an indicator that existing security might be inadequate. On that basis the Court found that substantial dues were owed and that the petition should be admitted.
  8. Procedural disposition: Having concluded there was no merit in the respondent's submissions that the petition was barred on account of the petitioner being secured or having filed a civil suit, the Court admitted the Company Petition and gave administrative directions (return date, advertisement, deposit, waiver of service by respondent, and expedited certified copy).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court ADMITTED the Company Petition for winding up and made it returnable on 4 July 2001. The respondent waived service. The Court ordered publication of the petition (with an agreed short delay), required the petitioner to deposit Rs. 2,000 with the Prothonotary & Senior Master within four weeks, and directed expedition of a certified copy.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petition proceeds in the Company Court; the petitioner is permitted to maintain the winding up petition despite being a secured creditor and despite having instituted a civil suit to enforce its security. Procedural steps ordered (advertisement, deposit, returnable date) will follow.
  • Legal consequence as applied here: The Court reaffirmed the established rule (as reflected in the cited authorities and statutory provisions) that a secured creditor may present a winding up petition and that relinquishment of security is not required at the petition/admission stage — the option to surrender or realize and to prove the balance arises later when debts are to be proved.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion applies existing statutory provisions and prior authorities to the facts; it does not purport to lay down a novel principle beyond the authorities cited. The Court relied on settled statutory interpretation and precedent to reject the respondent's contention that the petition was not maintainable solely because the petitioner was a secured creditor.

Order accordingly.

Show all summary ...

1. By a letter dated 24th February, 1992, the petitioner agreed to grant to the respondent-Company in the present case, Lloyds Steel Industries Ltd., a term loan of Rs. 5.52 crores for the purpose of enabling the respondent to construct dwelling units for its employees at Wardha. The respondent executed various documents in favour of the petitioner, including a Demand Promissory Note dated 21st August, 1992, promising to pay to the petitioner an amount of Rs. 5.52 crores with interest at the rate of 22% per annum for value received. A loan agreement dated 17th August, 1992 and a supplementary loan agreement also of the same date were executed by the Company. On 27th August, 1992, the Chairman of the Company and one of its Directors executed Guarantee Agreements by which they guaranteed the due repayment of the amount disbursed by the petitioner.

2. A letter dated 24th February, 1992 issued by the petitioner sanctioning the term loan, inter alia, stipulated that the rate of interest would be as per the guidelines of the National Housing Bank for NHB refinanceable loans and that there would be a service charge of 2%. The letter, inter alia, provided that penal interest at 2% over and above the interest charged on the loan would be payable in the event of the repayment schedule not being adhered to. The loan agreement which was executed on 17th August, 1992, provided that the applicable rate of interest would be 22% or as prescribed by the NHB on the applicable portion of the loan. The loan was repayable in 120 equal monthly installments over a period of 10 years.

3. On the basis of the documents which were executed by the respondent, the petitioner disbursed to the respondent an amount of Rs. 5.52 crores - Rs. 1 crore on 21st August, 1992, Rs. 1.85 crores on 18th August, 1993, Rs. 1.15 crores on 10th September, 1993, Rs. 1 crore on 19th October, 1993 and Rs. 52 lakhs on 7th January, 1994. By its letters dated 1st April, 1995 and 1st April, 1998, the Company has acknowledged the outstandings which are due and payable to the petitioner. In the second of those letters, the Company has acknowledged its liability of Rs. 4,42,15,834/- as being amount due and payable to the petitioner. On 27th August, 1999, a demand notice came to be addressed on behalf of the petitioner by its Advocate to the respondent claiming repayment of an amount of Rs. 5,72,18,397/- together with further interest and it was also stated that the said notice was a statutory notice prior to the institution of winding up proceedings. In a reply dated 21st September, 1999 it was inter alia stated on behalf of the Company that the Company had made an offer to furnish additional security in favour of the petitioner in respect of the properties of the Company situated at Wadala, Shivaji Park, Mahalaxmi and Sion but, that there was no favourable response from the petitioner.

4. The Company has created an equitable mortgage of its immovable property admeasuring 25.15 Hectares situate at Wardha and the reference thereto is contained in a Memorandum entered into on 17th August, 1992, a copy whereof is annexed at Exh. H to the Company Petition.

5. The Company Petition has been instituted on the basis that, as on 27th September, 1999 when the Petition was filed, an amount of Rs. 4,11,66,156/- was due and outstanding on account of the principal and that together with the interest and other charges, a total amount of Rs. 6,10,15,192/- is due to the petitioner.

6. An affidavit in reply has been filed to the Company Petition on behalf of the respondent. In setting out the defence of the Company to the Petition, the following submissions were urged on behalf of the respondent:

(i) By November 1997, the Company had paid to the petitioner an amount of Rs. 4.52 crores towards the repayment of the loan. This fact has not been adverted to in the Company Petition, nor is there any reference in the particulars of the claim to the payments which have been made by the respondent to the petitioner from time to time;

(ii) Under the provisions of section 434(1)(a) of the Companies Act, 1956, the Company would be deemed to have been unable to pay the debt if within the stipulated period of the receipt of a notice of winding up, it had failed either to pay or to secure the debt due and outstanding to the petitioner. In the present case the petitioner has available to it valuable security in the form of an equitable mortgage of immovable property of the Company. Consequently, it cannot be stated that the Company has failed to secure the petitioner;

(iii) A secured creditor must, in the first instance, relinquish its security if it wants to be a part of the process of winding up of the Company from whom a debt is due and payable. Unless the security is relinquished in the first instance, the petition for winding up cannot be maintained. In any event, the Petition does not contain any disclosure of whether the security is or is not sufficient to meet the dues of the petitioner; and

(iv) The petitioner has instituted a suit being Suit No. 237 of 2000 in this Court after the Company Petition was filed. The petitioner having taken recourse to its remedies by filing a Civil Suit, the Company Petition ought not to be entertained.

7. 6A. The principal point on which the arguments were addressed to the Court was on the question as to whether the petitioner as a secured creditor is entitled to maintain the Petition for winding up without relinquishing the security held by it as a secured creditor. The submission on the part of the respondent Company, which has already been noted earlier, is that unless the petitioner were to relinquish the security prior to the institution of or in any event by an express statement in the petition for winding up, the petition itself would not be maintainable. Having given my anxious consideration to the submissions urged on behalf of the respondent, I am of the view that there is no merit in the submissions.

8. At the outset, it must be noticed that section 439 of the Companies Act, 1956 itself postulates that the petition for winding up of a Company may be presented by a secured creditor. Under clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 439 a petition for winding up of a Company can be presented by any creditor or creditors including any contingent or prospective creditor or creditors. Sub-section (2) of section 439 provides that a secured creditor, the holder of any debentures including debenture stock, whether or not any trustee or trustees have been appointed in respect of such and other like debentures and the trustee for the holder of debentures shall be deemed to be creditors within the meaning of clause (b) of sub-section (1). Consequently, as a matter of first principle, there can be no doubt about the proposition that it is open to a secured creditor, as indeed it is open to any creditor, to petition the Company Court for the winding up of a Company.

9. The issue indeed is not res integra since a Division Bench of this Court in Bharat Overseas Bank Ltd. v. Shree Arcee Steels P. Ltd., (1985) 58 Com. Cases 174, had occasion to consider this question. The Division Bench considered the Judgment of the Madras High Court in Karnatak Vegetable Oils and Refineries Ltd. v. Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd., (1954) 24 Comp. Cas 249 (Mad) and two Judgments of Learned Single Judges of the Calcutta High Court in India Electric Works Ltd., In re, AIR 1970 Cal 398 and Calcutta Safe Deposit Co. Ltd. v. Ranjit Mathuradas Sampat, (1971) 41 Comp. Cas 1063 (Cal). The Learned Single Judge exercising Company jurisdiction had come to the conclusion that the petition for winding up could not be maintained at the instance of the Bharat Overseas Bank which was a secured creditor. Allowing an appeal of the Bank and setting aside the dismissal of the petition for winding up, the Division Bench held that the Company Court was not justified in dismissing the petition for winding up at the stage of admission on the ground that the petitioner was a secured creditor. While allowing the appeal, the Division Bench has held as follows:

“We are of the opinion that bearing in mind the clear provisions of the companies act and the principles which have been discussed in detail in the Madras High Court and the Calcutta High Court judgments above cited, the rejection of the petition in this case at the stage of admission was not at all justified. The petition was required to be admitted and advertised and it is at that stage that the court could go into the question as to whether the security is sufficient or not and exercise its discretion to accept the petitioning creditor's claims and request for winding up or to reject the same on judicial consideration.”

(emphasis supplied).

10. A similar view, it may be noted, has been taken by a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court in Techno Metal India (P) Ltd. v. Prem Nath Anand, (1973) 43 Company Cases 556. The Court held thus:

“It is now too late to argue that a secured creditor cannot successfully prosecute an application for winding up, especially in view of Sub-section (2) of section 439 of the Companies Act, 1956, a provision which was lacking in the Indian Companies Act of 1913. Apart from the fact that for the purpose of winding up, the term “creditor” includes a secured creditor, there are judicial precedents established in cases decided under the earlier Act where it was held that a secured creditor is fully competent to make such an application. In this connection, reference may be made to the case of Karnatak Vegetable Oils and Refineries Ltd. v. Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. Reference may also be made to two decisions of learned single judges of our court in the matter of India Electric Works Ltd. and Calcutta Safe Deposit Co. Ltd. v. Ranjit Mathuradas Sampat. These were cases decided under the Act of 1956. The precedents as well as the provisions of section 439(2) of the Companies Act, 1956, are against the contention of Mr. Sen and we cannot accept the proposition that the respondent being a secured creditor is not entitled to apply for winding up unless he abandons his security or satisfied the court as to its inadequacy.”

(emphasis supplied).

11. As a matter of first principle, having regard to the scheme which emerges from the various provisions contained in the Companies Act, 1956 for winding up, there is no reason to exclude a secured creditor from the purview of petitioning creditors who can move a Company Petition for winding up. Section 433 of the Companies Act is a part of Chapter II of Part VII which deals with winding up by the Court. Section 433 furnishes a list of circumstances in which a company may be wound up by the Court. Section 434 provides a deeming definition of when a company is deemed to be unable to pay its debts. Section 439 which has already been adverted to earlier expressly contemplates that the petition for winding up can be presented by a secured creditor. Under section 441, the winding up of a company is deemed to commence at the time of presentation of the petition for winding up. Where the Court makes an order of winding up of a company, section 444 mandates that intimation thereof shall be sent to the Official Liquidator and the Registrar of Companies. Under sub-section (1) of section 446 when a winding up order has been made or the Official Liquidator has been appointed as provisional liquidator, no suit or other legal proceeding shall be commenced or if pending at the date of the winding up order, shall be proceeded with, against the company, except by leave of the Court. Under section 447 an order for winding up of a company operates in favour of all the creditors and of all the contributories of the company as if it had been made on the joint petition of a creditor and of a contributory. The provisions in regard to the Official Liquidator are made in the group of sections commencing with section 448. Under section 466(1), the Court is empowered to stay the proceedings for winding up. Section 467 deals with the settlement of a list of contributories and application of the assets of the Company. Sub-section (1) provides that as soon as may be after making a winding up order, the Court shall settle a list of contributories, with power to rectify the register of members in all cases where rectification is required and shall cause the assets of the Company to be collected and applied in discharge of its liabilities. Chapter III of Part VII makes provisions in regard to voluntary winding up and Chapter IV, in respect of winding up subject to supervision of Court. Chapter V of the Act prescribes provisions which are applicable to every mode of winding up. Section 528 provides as follows:

“S. 528. Debts of all descriptions to be admitted to proof.— In every winding up (subject, in the case of insolvent companies, to the application in accordance with the provisions of this Act of the law of insolvency), all debts payable on a contingency and all claims against the company, present or future, certain or contingent, ascertained or sounding only in damages, shall be admissible to proof against the company, a just estimate being made, so far as possible, of the value of such debts or claims as may be subject to any contingency, or may sound only in damages, or for some other reason may not bear a certain value.”

12. Section 529 deals with the application of insolvency rules in the winding up of insolvent Companies. Sub-sections (1) and (2) of section 529 provides as follows:

S. 529. Application of insolvency rules in winding up of insolvent companies.— (1) In the winding up of an insolvent company, the same rules shall prevail and be observed with regard to—

(a) debts provable;

(b) the valuation of annuities and future and contingent liabilities; and

(c) the respective rights of secured and unsecured creditors; as are in force for the time being under the law of insolvency with respect to the estates of persons adjudged insolvent;

Provided that the security of every secured creditor shall be deemed to be subject to a pari passu charge in favour of the workmen to the extent of the workmen's portion therein, and, where a secured creditor, instead of relinquishing his security and proving his debt, opts to realise his security,—

(a) the liquidator shall be entitled to represent the workmen and enforce such charge;

(b) any amount realized by the liquidator by way of enforcement of such charge shall be applied rateably for the discharge of workmen's dues; and

(c) so much of the debt due to such secured creditor as could not be realized by him by virtue of the foregoing provisions of this proviso or the amount of the workmen's portion in his security, whichever is less, shall rank pari passu with the workmen's dues for the purposes of section 529A.

(2) All persons who in any such case would be entitled to prove for and receive dividends out of the assets of the company, may come in under the winding up, and make such claims against the company as they respectively are entitled to make by virtue of this section;

Provided that if a secured creditor instead of relinquishing his security and proving for his debt proceeds to realise his security, he shall be liable to pay his portion of the expenses incurred by the liquidator including a provisional liquidator, if any for the preservation of the security before its realization by the secured creditor.

Explanation— For the purposes of this proviso, the portion of expenses incurred by the liquidator for the preservation of a security which the secured creditor shall be liable to pay shall be the whole of the expenses less an amount which bears to such expenses the same proportion as the workmen's portion in relation to the security bears to the value of the security.”

13. The scheme of the provisions relating to winding up, particularly those of sections 528 and 529 of the Act, is that the stage of proving of a claim on debt arises after an order of winding up is passed. A secured creditor, as a matter of general rule, is outside winding up, unless he expressly abandons his security. The Supreme Court in a judgment in M.K Ranganathan v. Govt. of Madras, AIR 1955 SC 604, considered the position of a secured creditor in the winding up of a Company and referred to the dictum of Lord Wrenbury in Food Controller v. Cork, 1923 AC 647(A). In para 15 of its judgment the Supreme Court held thus:

(15) The position of a secured creditor in the winding up of a company has been thus stated by Lord Wrenbury in — Food Controller v. Cork 1923 AC 647(A);

“The phrase outside the winding up is an intelligible phrase if used, as if often is, with reference to a secured creditor, say a mortgagee. The mortgagee of a company in liquidation is in a position to say “the mortgaged property is to the extent of the mortgage my property. It is immaterial to me whether my mortgage is in winding up or not. I remain outside the winding up and shall enforce mu rights as mortgagee.” This is to be contrasted with the case in which such a creditor prefers to assert his right, not as a mortgagee, but as a creditor. He may say I will prove in respect of my debt. If so, he comes into the winding up.”

14. A secured creditor is thus as contemplated by these settled legal principles, outside the proceedings for the winding up of a company. He is outside winding up in the sense that unlike an unsecured creditor, the law does not mandate that he must, to use a colloquial expression, “stand in line” with the general body of the creditors, who must prove their claims in winding up and receive prorata to the extent of the surplus available for distribution. The secured creditor is entitled to realise his security and does not stand amidst the general body of creditors who share in the available surplus. Though a secured creditor is outside the scope of winding up proceedings, the law equally does not mandate that he shall not enter the proceedings for winding up. Should be choose to become a part of the proceedings for winding up, the law permits him to do so. The options then available to the secured creditor in such a case have been summarized in a passage in Pennington's Company Law (Fourth edition, page 762) thus:

“Secured creditors:

A creditor who has a mortgage, charge or lien on the property of the company as security for his debt may either;

(a) sell the property subject to his security and prove in the winding up for the balance of his debt after deducting the amount realized, or

(b) surrender his security to the liquidator and prove for the whole of his debt as unsecured creditor; or

(c) estimate the value of the property subject to his security, and prove for the balance of his debt after deducting the estimated value; or

(d) rely on his security and not prove in the winding up.”

15. The same position would exist, in any event at least broadly speaking, in our law. By the provisions of section 529 of the Companies Act, 1956, the insolvency rules are attracted in regard to the proof of claims of creditors in the proceedings for winding up. These rules are contained in Part III of the Presidency Towns Insolvency Act, 1909. Section 48 of the Act provides that with respect to the mode of proving debts, the right or proof by secured and other creditors, the admission and rejection of proofs, and the other matters referred to in the Second Schedule, the rules in that Schedule shall be observed. Rule 9 of the Second Schedule enunciates that if a secured creditor realises his security, he may prove for the balance due to him, after deducting the net amount which has been realised. Rule 10 provides that if a secured creditor surrenders his security to the official assignee for the general benefit of the creditors, he may prove for his whole debt. Rule 11 provides that if a secured creditor does not either realise or surrender his security he shall, before ranking for dividend, state in his proof the particulars of his security, the date when it was given and the value at which he assesses it, and shall be entitled to receive a dividend only in respect of the balance due to him after deducting the value so assessed. Similar provisions are contained in section 47 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920.

16. In its Judgment in Allahabad Bank v. Canara Bank, (2000) 4 SCC 406 : AIR 2000 S.C 1535, the Supreme Court while considering the interface between the provisions of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 on the Companies Act, 1956, noted that secured creditors fall in two categories: Those who desire to go before the Company Court and those who like to stand outside the winding up. In so far as the first category was concerned, the Supreme Court held thus:

“62. The first category of secured creditors mentioned above are those who go before the Company Court for dividend by relinquishing their security in accordance with the insolvency rules mentioned in section 529. The insolvency rules are those contained in sections 45 to 50 of the Provincial Insolvency Act. Section 47(2) of that Act states that a secured creditor who wishes to come before the official liquidator has to prove his debt and he can prove his debt only if he relinquishes his security for the benefit of the general body of creditors. In that event, he will rank with the unsecured creditors and has to take his dividend as provided in section 529(2).”

(emphasis supplied).

17. Insofar as the second category of secured creditors consisting of those who stand outside winding up is concerned, the position of this category of secured creditors was explained as follows in para 63 of the Judgment of the Supreme Court:

“63. The second class of secured creditors referred to above are those who come under S. 529-A(1)(b) read with proviso (c) to section 529(1). These are those who opt to stand outside the winding up to realise their security. Inasmuch as section 19(19) permits distribution to secured creditors only in accordance with section 529-A, the said category is the one consisting of creditors who stand outside the winding up. These secured creditors in certain circumstances can come before the Company Court (here the Tribunal) and claim priority over all other creditors for release of amounts out of the other monies lying in the Company Court (here, the Tribunal). This limited priority is declared in section 529A(1) but it is restricted only to the extent specified in clause (b) of section 529-A(1).”

18. The position of the secured creditor has, in this regard, been considered by three early judgments and these may be adverted to at this stage since they express a consistent strand of thought which has been followed since. In Ram Chand v. Bank of Upper India Ltd., Delhi, ILR 1922 Lah 59, the position of the secured creditor was elucidated in the following words:

“As far as possible the rules of bankruptcy are applicable to liquidation matters. When a company goes into liquidation, a secured creditor may realise his security and prove for any balance there may be outstanding. The remaining assets of the company would in that case only be liable for such principal and interest as was due on the date of the winding up order. A secured creditor in the case of a liquidation is on the same footing as in that of insolvency proceedings. The property hypothecated is thus liable for the whole claim, principal and interest up to the date of realisation, and it is only the liability of the remaining assets that could be affected by the winding up order.”

19. The same view was taken in Sharfuzzaman v. H. Hunter, AIR 1930 Oudh 20, which is thus:

“A secured creditor who has advantages of security may remain outside the Act. He can realise upon his security. The extent to which he realises on his security will reduce the estate in insolvency. But he obtains at first no part in the dividend and is unaffected by the proceedings. Should, however, the amount of realization be less than the amount due to him he is given the special privilege of proving for the balance. This balance is the difference between the decretal amount and the amount realised. When he has proved he will not obtain any more than his proportionate share in the estate. He will be out then on the footing of an unsecured creditor.”

20. These Judgments have been referred to with approval in a Judgment of a Learned Single Judge of the Madras High Court in Canara Bank v. Official Liquidator, reported in 1991 Vol. 70 Company Cases 295.

21. The secured creditor who seeks to prove the whole of his debt in the course of the proceedings of winding up must before he can prove his debt relinquish his security for the benefit of the general body of the Creditors. If he surrenders his security for the benefit of the general body of creditors, he may prove the whole of his debt. If the secured creditor has realised his security, he may prove for the balance due to him after deducting the net amount that has been realised. The stage for relinquishing security arises when a secured creditor seeks to prove the whole of his debt in the course of winding up. If he elects to prove in the course of winding up the whole of the debt due and owing to him, he has to necessarily surrender his security for the benefit of the general body creditors. Therefore, in my view, it would be wholly inappropriate and inapposite to require the secured creditor at the stage when he files Company Petition for winding up to exercise the option of relinquishing his security since that stage does not arise until the debt is to be proved.

22. In the present case, the petitioner has evinced a clear intention to enforce the security by filing a suit in this Court for the recovery of its dues and the enforcement of its securities. There can be no doubt about the proposition that the object of a petition for winding up is to realise the property of the Company for distribution to all the creditors in accordance with the applicable rules. This has been laid down by a Division Bench of this Court in Harinagar Sugar Mills v. M.W Pradhan, 67 B.L.R 294. A secured creditor who seeks to prove the whole of his debt in the course of the winding up proceedings is necessarily required to relinquish the security. That however, cannot be construed to mean that when he files a petition for winding up, a secured creditor must relinquish has security. In the present case, the petitioner has filed a suit in this Court and made it clear, therefore, that he seeks to enforce the security. When the stage for the proving its of debt does arise, the petitioner would necessarily have to prove for the balance of the debt which is due and owing to it after the security in respect of which the petitioner is a secured creditor is realised.

23. There is no merit in the other contentions which have been urged. The Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner stated that the last payment which was made by the respondent Company was in 1997 after which on 1st April, 1998 it has acknowledged that there are outstanding dues of Rs. 4.42 crores to the petitioner. Thereafter, various amounts have been paid by the Company in pursuance of the adinterim order which was passed by this Court. The fact that the Company has offered additional security to the petitioner is one indicator of the fact that the security which has been made available to the petitioner is inadequate to meet the dues. This question, however, need not detain the Court any further since in my view the acknowledgement of the liability in the present case shows that there are substantial dues owing to the petitioner at least to the extent of Rs. 4.42 crores as on 1st April, 1998. In these circumstances, the Company Petition is required to be admitted.

24. The Company Petition is accordingly admitted and made returnable on 4th July, 2001. Respondent waives service.

25. The petition to be advertised in Free Press Journal, Navshakti and Maharashtra Government Gazette. The petitioner to deposit a sum of Rs. 2,000/- with the Prothonotary & Senior Master within a period of four weeks from today. On the request of the Learned Counsel for the respondents, Advertisement not to be issued for a period of three weeks from today.

26. Certified copy expedited.

Order accordingly.