- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Abdul Fakirsaheb Mamtule v. State Of Maharashtra, Through Police Sub-Inspector, Dapoli .
Structured Summary of the Opinion (A.S. Bagga, J.) — Criminal Appeal No. 946 of 1986
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant was convicted by the Sessions Judge, Ratnagiri, by judgment and order dated 17 November 1986 in Sessions Case No. 33 of 1986 for offences under sections 489-B, 489-C and 420 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for seven years each for offences under sections 489-B and 489-C and three years for the offence under section 420 IPC.
Brief factual narrative as recorded in the opinion: On 20 February 1986 Manisha Mohan (P.W.3) went to the Ratnagiri District Central Co-operative Bank, Dabhol Branch, to deposit Rs. 4,000 in her husband Mohan Jagannath's (P.W.4) account. Bank employees Krishnakant Gadekar (P.W.2) and Suhas Narkar (P.W.1) suspected some notes; 13 notes were isolated and found to be forged/counterfeit by the bank staff. Both Manisha and other persons (Ganesh Kardekar, P.W.5; Vijay Kudalkar, P.W.6) stated that the suspect notes had been given to them by the appellant. Police seized in all 59 forged currency notes, obtained an expert opinion from the Currency Notes Press, Nashik Road (Exhibit 22) confirming forgery, and filed a charge-sheet. The appellant alone was tried (his brother was absconding). In his section 313 Cr.P.C. examination the appellant explained receipt of Rs.30,000 from his brother and denied knowledge that the notes were counterfeit. The trial court convicted and sentenced him as above. This appeal challenges the conviction and sentence; the present judgment was delivered on 29 March 2001.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the prosecution discharged the burden of proving that the appellant had knowledge of, or reason to believe, that the currency notes in his possession or used by him were forged/counterfeit (i.e., whether the essential mental ingredient under sections 489-B and 489-C IPC was established).
- Whether the evidence (including oral testimony and the expert opinion) sufficed to sustain convictions for trafficking/using and possessing forged currency notes and for the offence under section 420 IPC.
- Whether, in view of delay in final disposal of the appeal and the appellant's age and medical/physical condition, the sentence should be modified despite upholding conviction on merits.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- Mere possession of forged currency notes is not an offence; the prosecution must prove that the accused knew the notes were forged at the time of possession.
- The burden was on the prosecution to show circumstances that clearly and irresistibly lead to the inference of guilty knowledge or intention (relying on Bur Singh and other authorities).
- Reliance on M. Mammuti v. State of Karnataka: the expert's opinion did not show that forged notes were distinguishable at a glance from genuine notes; therefore the prosecution should have shown the forged notes to the appellant in evidence or otherwise demonstrated that he must have known.
- Defence in section 313 Cr.P.C.: appellant said he received Rs.30,000 from his absconding brother and had been spending that money in connection with construction; he denied knowledge that any notes were counterfeit.
Prosecution/State's Position (as reflected in the opinion)
- The prosecution relied on bank employees' testimony (P.W.1 and P.W.2), witnesses who received money from the appellant (P.W.3–P.W.6), the investigating officers (P.W.8–P.W.9), and the expert opinion (Exhibit 22) from the Currency Notes Press, Nashik Road, establishing that the 59 sent notes were forged.
- The prosecution contended that collateral circumstances—bulk of forged notes, mixture of forged and genuine notes, multiple persons being paid on the same date and the appellant's familiarity with currency—irresistibly point to the appellant having reason to believe the notes were forged and that he was trafficking in them.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bur Singh v. Emperor (1931 Criminal Law Journal 32) | Onus lies on prosecution to prove circumstances that lead "clearly, indubitably and irresistibly" to the inference that accused intended to foist forged notes on the public; such intention to be proved by collateral circumstances (e.g., prior palming off, possession of similar notes in large numbers). | The court cited this authority to state the standard for inferring intention or guilty knowledge from collateral circumstances and applied that standard in assessing whether the facts here warranted an inference that the appellant had reason to believe the notes were forged. |
| Hamid Ali v. State (A.I.R. 1961 Tripura 46) | Under sections 489-B and 489-C IPC, guilt is fastened on 'knowledge' or 'reason to believe'; 'believe' is stronger than 'suspect' and requires circumstances that would convince a reasonable person that the note was forged. | The court relied on this principle to emphasise that the prosecution must establish knowledge or strong reason to believe; it used this test in evaluating evidence of circumstances surrounding the appellant's possession and use of notes. |
| M. Mammuti v. State of Karnataka, (1979) 4 SCC 723 : A.I.R. 1979 SC 1705 | Importance of whether forged notes were distinguishable at a bare glance from genuine notes and whether the accused was shown those notes in evidence; where forging is not obvious, prosecution must take steps to show accused would have observed forgery. | The appellant relied on this case to argue the prosecution should have shown the forged notes to him; the court acknowledged the point but held that in the present case collateral circumstances (bulk, mixture with genuine notes, appellant's familiarity with currency, and rapid palming-off) sufficed to infer reason to believe. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in several discrete steps, strictly based on the record as summarised in the opinion:
- Expert Opinion: The court noted that 59 currency notes were sent for expert examination (Exhibit 21) and Exhibit 22 (expert opinion) concluded the notes were forged—printing quality poor, paper manipulated and pasted, numbering crude—so the 59 notes were established as forged. The court treated the expert opinion as conclusive on forgery.
- Chain and Sources of the Notes: The court detailed how the 59 notes reached police custody: 13 from Manisha (P.W.3), 6 from Ganesh Kardekar (P.W.5), 5 each from Manisha and her husband Mohan Jagannath (P.W.4) (note: text mentions 5 seized each from Manisha and Mohan), 3 recovered at arrest from the appellant, 8 from his suitcase, and 17 that Vijay Kudalkar (P.W.6) had (attached later). The court accepted the witness testimonies as consistent and corroborative.
- Witness Credibility and Factual Findings: The court found the testimony of bank employees (P.W.1 and P.W.2), the recipients of payments (P.W.3–P.W.6), and the investigating officers to be natural and unshaken in cross-examination, and therefore reliable. It accepted that forged notes were mixed with genuine notes in the payments made by the appellant on about 19 February 1986.
- Legal Standard—Knowledge or Reason to Believe: The court recited the legal requirement under sections 489-B and 489-C that the prosecution must prove knowledge or reason to believe the notes were forged. It referred to cited authorities (Bur Singh; Hamid Ali) to frame this standard: 'reason to believe' requires such convincing circumstances that a reasonable person would be satisfied the notes were forged.
- Application of Standard to Collateral Circumstances: The court examined the totality of circumstances: large number of forged notes linked to the appellant's disbursements on the same date to multiple persons; forged notes found mixed with genuine notes; forged and genuine notes seized from appellant's possession (kept separately); appellant's own admission of handling Rs.30,000 for his absconding brother and managing construction-related payments; and the appellant not being a person unfamiliar with Rs.100 notes. The court concluded these collateral facts "clearly and irresistibly" led to the inference that the appellant had reason to believe the notes were forged.
- Addressing M. Mammuti Point: The court acknowledged the argument that the prosecution did not show the forged notes to the appellant or prove forgery was obvious on bare look. However, it held that even absent that specific showing, the collateral circumstances were sufficient to satisfy the requirement of 'reason to believe'.
- Conclusion on Convictions: On this basis the court found no error in the trial judge's conclusion that the appellant trafficked in, used as genuine, and possessed forged currency notes and upheld the convictions under sections 489-B and 489-C and 420 IPC.
- Sentence and Mercy Considerations: While upholding convictions on merits, the court considered mitigating factors: the lapse of more than 14 years since conviction, appellant's advanced age at conviction (about 60 then) and estimated advanced age at present (about 73), diabetes and recent accident impairing mobility. These factors persuaded the court to reduce the severity of sentences though not interfering with the convictions themselves.
- Sentence Modification Specifics: The court modified the sentence: the seven-year rigorous imprisonment sentences under sections 489-B and 489-C were reduced to three years' simple imprisonment each; the three-year sentence under section 420 was left substantively unchanged but converted from rigorous to simple imprisonment; all sentences to run concurrently; period already spent in custody to be set off; appellant to surrender to bail to serve remaining sentence.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The court upheld the convictions under sections 489-B, 489-C and 420 IPC, and modified the sentences as specified below.
Direct consequences for the parties (as ordered in this judgment of 29-3-2001):
- The convictions recorded by the trial court are affirmed.
- Sentencing modifications: the sentence of seven years' rigorous imprisonment each under sections 489-B and 489-C IPC was reduced to three years' simple imprisonment each; the sentence under section 420 IPC (three years) was left unchanged in duration but converted from rigorous to simple imprisonment.
- All sentences are ordered to run concurrently.
- The period already undergone in custody (either as undertrial or after conviction) shall be set off against the sentence.
- The appellant shall surrender to his bail forthwith to serve the remaining sentence.
- The court directed that an ordinary authenticated copy of the judgment be acted upon and that a certified copy be expedited.
Broader legal implications: The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal precedent; it applies established principles (as cited) to the facts and confirms that where collateral circumstances are collectively strong, a court may infer "reason to believe" forgery even if forged notes were not shown to the accused in evidence. The court expressly relied on existing authorities and did not state the laying down of any novel legal proposition.
A.S Bagga, J.:— This appeal has been filed against the judgment and order dated 17th November, 1986 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Ratnagiri, in Sessions Case No. 33 of 1986, thereby convicting the appellant (original accused) for the offences punishable under sections 489-B and 489-C and 420 of the Indian Penal Code and sentencing the appellant to undergo rigorous imprisonment for seven years each for the offences punishable under sections 489-B and 489-C and three years for the offence punishable under section 420 of the Indian Penal Code.
2. The facts leading to the filing of this appeal, briefly stated, are as follows: On 20-2-1986 one Manisha Mohan (P.W No. 3) had gone to Ratnagiri District Central Co-operative Bank (hereinafter, for short, referred to as the bank) at its Dabhol Branch for deposing a sum of Rs. 4000/- in the account of her husband Mohan Gagannath (P.W No. 4). Krishnakant Gadekar, Accountant of the bank, examined as P.W No. 2, while counting the notes, suspected genuineness of some of the currency notes. He took out those currency notes numbering 13 from the bundle and showed those currency notes to Suhas Narkar (P.W No. 1) the Sub-Accountant and Incharge Manager of the said bank. Suhas Narkar (P.W No. 1) alongwith Krishanakant Gadekar (P.W No. 2) examined those currency notes closely and found that they were forged/counterfeit currency notes. The reasons for becoming suspicious were that printing of the currency notes was not proper and that same number, namely AB/3-952610 was found on two currency notes. Both the officers of the Bank questioned Manisha Mohan (P.W No. 3) as to how she got those notes. Manisha stated that those notes were given to her husband by his employer, the present appellant (original accused). At about the sametime, one Ganesh Kardekar also visited the bank. He tendered a sum of Rs. 1742.50 to the Cashier Krishnakant Gadekar. From the money tendered by the said Ganesh Kardekar (examined as P.W No. 5), six currency notes were also looked face/forged. Those notes were also of Rs. 100/- denomination. Ganesh Kardekar, on being questioned, also stated that he got those notes from the appellant Abdul Fakirsaheb Mamtule. Subsequently, one Vijay Kudalkar (P.W No. 6) himself came in the bank by about 5.00 p.m He brought 37 notes of Rs. 100/- denomination, out of which 17 notes were suspected to be forged. He also informed the Bank officials that those notes were given to him by the appellant. These 17 notes though not handed over to Bank officials, were attached later on police. After having collected the aforesaid notes, the Sub-Accountant, R.D.C.C Bank, who was holding charge as Manager, namely, Suhas Narkar lodged report at the Police Station at Exhibit 7. At the time of lodging the report, 13 currency notes which were found in the bundle handed over by Manisha Mohan, and 6 currency notes which were found from the money tendered by Ganesh Kardekar, were handed over the police, P.S.I Vijay Jagtap (P.W 8), who was attached to Dapoli Police Station, received the report and reduced it into writing at Exhibit 7. The accused was arrested by him vide arrest panchanama (Exhibit 40). From the possession of the accused 5, notes of Rs. 100/- denomination were also seized. Thereafter, P.S.I Vijay Jagtap seized 8 currency notes of Rs. 100/- denomination from the upper portion of the suitcase in the house of the appellant. There were currency notes worth Rs. 20,000/- of Rs. 100/- denomination, which were, however, not seized, since they were not forged currency notes, according to the prosecution. The 17 currency notes, which were received from Vijay Kudalkar, were attached under panchanama Exhibit 8. Those currency notes were also shown to the bank officials. Thus, in all, 59 forged currency notes were seized by the police. These currency notes were sent by P.S.I Shankar Thakur (P.W No. 9) to the Currency Notes Press, Jail Road, Nashik Road, Maharashtra State, for an expert's opinion vide letter at Exhibit 21. Subsequently, expert's opinion was received vide Exhibit 22. Thus, on the basis of the investigation and the expert's opinion on forged notes, charge-sheet came to be filed against the accused/appellant and the absconding accused, the brother of the present accused/appellant.
3. Since the offences punishable under sections 489-B and 489-C of the Indian Penal Code were and are exclusively triable by the Court of Sessions, the case came to be committed to the Sessions Judge, Ratnagiri, Only the appellant was tried, as his brother, the absconding accused, was not traceable. When the charge was read over and explained to the appellant, he pleaded not guilty to the charges. The defence of the appellant/accused in his examination under section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure was that his brother Abdul Rehiman Mamtule, i.e the absconding accused, served in Quait; that his brother was interested in constructing his own house; that his brother had handed over a sum of Rs. 30,000/- to the appellant for construction of his brother's house. The appellant finally stated in his examination under section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure that he had been spending money from the amount given to him by his brother, and paid the amount to different persons, and that he had no knowledge that the currency notes were fake/counterfeit notes.
4. On the basis of oral evidence of the witnesses to whom the currency notes of Rs. 100/- denominations were paid by the appellant and taking into account the oral evidence of the accountant and the cashier of the bank and the expert opinion from the Currency Notes Press, Jail Road, Nashik Road, the learned Judge, before whom the appellant was tried, reached the conclusion that the appellant was found trafficking in forged/counterfeit currency notes, having reasons to believed the same to be forged or counterfeit. The learned Judge, therefore, proceeded to convict the appellant for the offences punishable under sections 489-B, 489-C and 420 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced the appellant/accused, as stated above, by the impugned judgment and order.
5. I have heard Shri Ranjit Bhosale, learned Counsel for the appellant and R.Y Mirza and K.V Saste, learned APPs for the State. With the assistance of the learned Counsel, the evidence recorded in this case and record and proceeding of this case have been examined. The judgment of the learned trial Judge has also been scrutinised.
6. First of all, it would be seen that 59 currency notes were sent by P.S.I Shankar Thakur (P.W No. 9) to currency notes press, Nashik, for expert opinion on the alleged forged notes along with the letter at Exhibit 21 and the numbers of these notes were mentioned in the said letter. The expert opinion is on record at Exhibit 22. It states that the entire print of the paper of the forged note was executed on too thin pieces of papers separately and ultimately pasted together after initiating water marked security threat, etc. to form a complete note; that the quality of printing was not upto the mark; and the style of prefixing number was crude and not matching with the style used for genuine numbering. Thus, the currency notes number 59 which sent to the Currency Notes Press, Nashik Road, have been duly proved to be forged notes. There remains no doubt in this record.
7. The description of the 59 notes which were sent for expert opinion has been given in the letter (Exhibit 21) sent by P.S.I Shankar Thakur. Out of these 59 currency notes, 13 notes were handed over to the police by Suhas Narkar (P.W No. 1), who happened to the sub-accountant in the R.D.C.C Bank, and was holding the charge of Manager; 6 notes were alleged to have been produced before the police by Ganesh Kardekar (P.W No. 5); 5 notes were seized each from Sou. Manisha (P.W No. 3) and her husband Mohan Jagannath (P.W No. 4); 3 notes were recovered from the appellant at the time of his arrest and finally remaining 8 currency notes were allegedly recovered from the appellant from his suitcase, 17 notes were with Vijay Kudalkar (P.W No. 6), who himself suspected the genuineness of the notes and approached Ganesh Kardekar (P.W No. 5).
8. Manisha (P.W No. 3) in her evidence deposed at Exhibit 9 that her husband was a carpenter and that he worked for the appellant, who paid him Rs. 5,000/- in one-hundred rupee denomination as his wages. She further stated that out of the said amount, Rs. 500/- were kept by him and another sum of Rs. 500/- was retained by her husband. She came to the bank to deposit the sum of Rs. 4,000/- and while counting the notes, Cashier Krishnakant Gadekar (P.W 2) found that 13 currency notes were different and, therefore, he took out those notes and approached the Incharge Manager of the bank, viz. Suhas Narkar (P.W No. 6). The Cashier of the bank Krishnakant Gadekar (P.W No. 2) corroborates the evidence of Manisha (P.W No. 3) in all material particulars. Mohan Jagannath (P.W No. 4) is the husband of Manisha (P.W No. 3), who also deposed to have paid a sum of Rs. 4,000/- to his wife Manisha, who, in turn, went to the bank. Suhas Narkar, Incharge Manager of the bank, has also been examined as P.W No. 1. His narration also corroborates whatever has been stated by the Cashier Krishnakant Gadekar (P.W No. 2), Manisha (P.W No. 3) and her husband Mohan Jagannath (P.W No. 4), Ganesh Kardekar (P.W No. 5), who works as Clerk with Parkar Saw Mill at Dabhol, has deposed that the appellant-accused had visited their Saw Mill on 19th February, 1986 and that accused paid them a sum of Rs. 742.50 towards the cutting charges of the timber which the accused had brought to their Saw Mill. This witness further deposed to have gone to the bank to pay electricity bill of Rs. 1742.50 It has also come in his evidence that those currency notes were taken out from the amount paid by the appellant/accused and given to the cashier. So the currency notes were taken out from Manisha (P.W No. 3) and Ganesh Kardekar (P.W No. 5) by the Cashier Krishnakant Gadekar (P.W No. 2) and the Bank Incharge Manager Suhas Narkar (P.W No. 1) and finally the report at Exhibit 7 came to be filed with the police on 20-2-1986. A sum of Rs. 500/- came to be recovered each from Manisha (P.W No. 3) and her husband Mohan Jagannath (P.W No. 4). There is evidence of the Investigating Officer Vijay Jagtap (P.W No. 8) that five currency notes of Rs. 100/- denomination were attached from the possession of the appellant at the time of his arrest vide panchanama at Exhibit No. 14. Subsequently, the amount subsequently 8 currency notes of Rs. 100/- denomination were seized from the upper portion of the suitcase in the house of the appellant-accused. It is also stated that currency notes worth Rs. 20,000/- which were not forged currency notes were also found with the appellant (accused). But they were not seized.
9. The evidence of the witnesses, who have been examined, is natural and there is nothing in the cross-examination to discredit the testimony of the witnesses examined in this case. There is no doubt that the forged currency notes were received by witness Mohan Jagannath (P.W No. 4) a carpenter by profession, who worked for the appellant and that the appellant paid him Rs. 5000/- in one-hundred rupees denomination as his wages. Similarly, Vijay Kudalkar (P.W No. 6) and Ganesh Kardekar (P.W No. 5) also were given different amounts by the appellant. The appellant also admitted that he paid different sums of money to different people in connection with construction of the house of his brother, the absconding accused. The defence, as stated earlier, as taken under section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, as also the contentions raised during arguments, is that the appellant had no knowledge that the currency notes with him were fake or counterfeit/forged currency notes.
10. It was rightly contended by Shri Ranjit Bhosale, learned Counsel for the appellant, that mere possession of a forged currency note is not an offence punishable under the Indian Penal Code. It was also argued that the burden is on the prosecution to prove that at the time when the accused was possessing the currency notes, he knew that they were forged notes, and mere possession of them by him, does not foist the burden on him to account for its possession and to prove innocent possession thereof. No authority for this proposition of law need be cited. It is rightly contended that the burden is on the prosecution to establish that the accused, at the time of possession by him of currency notes knew that they were forged currency notes.
11. On perusal of section 489-B and section 489-C of the Indian Penal Code, it would be seen that section 489-B seeks to punish the trafficking or using of the forged currency notes as genuine currency notes, while section 489-C seeks to punish mere possession of forged currency notes. The ingredient which is common to both the sections, however, is that it must be established/proved that the accused had either knowledge or that he had reason to believe that the currency notes were forged currency notes. As has been observed in the case between (Bur Singh v. Emperor)1, reported in 1931 Criminal Law Journal 32, cited by Shri Ranjit Bhosale, learned Counsel for the appellant that “the onus lies on the prosecution to prove the circumstances which lead clearly, indubitably and irresistibly to the inference that the accused had the intention to foist the notes on the public and such intention, relating as it does to a future conduct, could only be proved by collateral circumstances such as that the accused had palmed off such notes before, or that he was in possession of such and similar notes in such large numbers that his possession for any other purpose is inexplicable.”
12. In (Hamid Ali v. State)2, reported in A.I.R 1961 Tripura 46, a ruling, again cited by Shri Ranjit Bhosale, learned Counsel for the appellant, it has been observed that “under sections 489-B and 489-C, guilt is fastened on the ground of ‘knowledge’ or ‘reason to believe’. The two are more or less ejusdem generis, though knowledge will be on a slightly higher plane than reason to believe. It is further observed that ‘the word ‘believe’ is very much stronger word than ‘suspect’ and it involves the necessity of showing that the circumstances were such that a reasonable man must have felt convinced in his mind that the currency note with which he was dealing was a forged one, and it was not sufficient to show that the accused was careless or he had reason to suspect or that he did not make sufficient enquiry to ascertain the fact”.
13. In the light of the aforesaid propositions, let me examine whether, in the present case, there are circumstances brought on record justifying the conclusion that the appellant (accused) had ‘reason to believe’ that the currency notes admittedly in his possession were fake/forged currency notes.
14. The appellant (accused) in his examination under section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, stated that he was paid a sum of Rs. 30,000/- by his brother, the absconding accused. It has been brought on record that different sums of money were paid by the appellant to the witnesses examined in the case, including Mohan Jagannath (P.W No. 4), Ganesh Kardekar (P.W No. 5) and Vijay Kudalkar (P.W No. 6). The amount of Rs. 5,000/-, which was paid by the appellant to Mohan Jagannath (P.W No. 4) and which was brought to the bank by Manisha (P.W No. 3) contained 13 currency notes which were suspected to be forged. Similarly, out of the amount of Rs. 1742.50, which was brought by Ganesh Kardekar (P.W No. 5) to the bank for paying the electricity bill, 6 notes in the said amount consisted of Rs. 100/- denomination, which were suspected to be forged notes. Vijay Kudalkar (P.W No. 6) also stated that a sum of Rs. 3700/- was paid by the appellant to his brother Mr. Palkar, who deals in cement business, and that out of the said amount of Rs. 3700/-, 17 currency notes of Rs. 3,00/- denomination were found to be counterfeit/forged. In all these incidents the forged currency notes were found mixed with the genuine currency notes. All these amounts were paid on or about 19-2-1986. From the possession of the appellant also forged currency notes were found and he was found in possession of genuine currency notes also which were kept separately. The appellant, who had the amount of Rs. 30,000/- given to him by his brother, the absconding accused, as per his own statement under section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, was looking after the construction work in respect of a house desired to be built by his brother. The appellant cannot be said to be a layman and not used to see the currency notes of Rs. 100/- denomination. All these circumstances, in the opinion of this Court, clearly and irresistibly lead to an inference that the appellant (accused) had reason to believe that the currency notes in his possession were fake and counterfeit currency notes. It was for this reason that the appellant had been trafficking in these currency notes along with genuine notes.
15. Relying on the case between (M. Mammuti v. State of Karnataka)3, reported in (1979) 4 SCC 723 : A.I.R 1979 Supreme Court 1705, Shri Bhosale, learned Counsel for the appellant, pointed out that it was not shown in the expert's opinion on the forged notes (Exhibit 22) that the forged currency notes were distinguishable at a bare look from the genuine currency notes and, therefore, it was necessary for the prosecution to have put a question to the appellant (accused) by showing these forged currency notes. This, obviously, has not been done by the learned trial Judge. According to learned Counsel, under these circumstances, it cannot be concluded that the appellant had no knowledge about the currency notes with him that they were forged currency notes. The argument advanced is appreciable. The problem, however, is that, as indicated earlier, the prosecution would succeed not only when the evidence is placed on record to show that the accused had knowledge about the currency notes being forged or counterfeit notes, but it will also succeed if circumstances are brought on record, irresistibly and clearly leading to an inference that the accused had reason to believe that the currency notes found in his possession were forged or fake. The collateral circumstances, such as, the bulk of the fake currency notes, the mixture of fake currency notes with the genuine currency notes, the palming off such notes quickly and the fact that the accused, by no stretch of imagination, could be said to be a layman or an uneducated man, are sufficient to infer that the accused had reason to believe that the currency notes with him were fake or counterfeit. There remains no doubt in my mind that the prosecution has established the case against the appellant (accused) that the appellant (accused) used as genuine the forged or counterfeit currency notes and that the appellant was found in possession of the forged or counterfeit currency notes, and that he had reason to believe that those were fake/counterfait currency notes.
16. The convictions recorded by the learned trial Judge cannot be faulted with. The convictions are required to be upheld and they are upheld.
17. The learned trial Judge has sentenced the appellant (accused) to suffer rigorous imprisonment for seven years, each for the offence punishable under section 489-B and section 489-C of the Indian Penal Code, and both the sentences have been made to run concurrently.
18. The offences of counterfeiting currency notes for using them as genuine, or trafficking in them, or possessing them, are all grave offences, and cannot be lightly viewed. Such offences vitiate the economy of the country and are matters of serious concern. They are rarely detected and they are perhaps a tip of an iceberg. The offence under section 489-B of the Indian Penal Code prescribe imprisonment for life as the maximum punishment, which itself shows the seriousness with which the legislature has viewed the offence. The award of 7 years imprisonment, in the present case, cannot be said to be on a higher side. The appellant (accused), however, was convicted by the judgment and order dated 17-11-1986 i.e about more than 14 years ago. The age of the appellant, at the time of his conviction by the learned trial Judge, was about 60 years. Now, the appellant must be an old man of about 73 years. The passage of long time during which the appeal has been pending in this Court and the old age of the appellant, weigh with this Court for reducing the sentence, though on merits, there is no reason why the punishment awarded should have been reduced. It has been stated across the bar by Shri Ranjit Bhosale learned Counsel for the appellant, that the appellant has grown old and also suffers from diabetes and that recently, on account of his having met with an accident, he is unable to walk without support. In view of these circumstances, this Court, allows that appeal partly only to the extent of modifying the sentence. The punishment which is awarded by the learned trial Judge shall be modified. The appellant is sentenced to simple imprisonment for three years each for the offence punishable under section 489-B and section 489-C of the Indian Penal Code. The period of sentence awarded under section 420 of the Indian Penal Code is left unchanged. The sentence of imprisonment awarded under section 420 of the Indian Penal Code, however, is converted from rigorous imprisonment to simple imprisonment. All these sentences shall run concurrently. Needless to say that the period during which the appellant (accused) was in jail, either as under trial prisoner or after conviction, shall be set off against the sentence awarded herein. The appellant (accused) shall surrender to his bail forthwith to serve out of the remaining sentence.
19. All concerned parties and authorities to act on an ordinary copy of this judgment and order dated 29-3-2001 passed in Criminal Appeal No. 946 of 1986 duly authenticated by the Sheristedar of this Court. Certified copy expedited.
Alert