- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nandkishor v. State Of Maharashtra
Factual and Procedural Background
The Court heard the advocate for the applicants. The matter concerns a private complaint in which offences under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 ("Atrocities Act") were alleged. A Single Bench of this Court in Criminal Revision Application No. 44 of 1995 (view dated 20th July, 1999; reported in 2000 (2) Mh. L.J 748) had earlier taken the position that where a Magistrate encounters a private complaint involving an offence under the Atrocities Act, the Magistrate should return the complaint and direct the complainant to present it before the Special Court constituted to try such offences. The present application was taken up for final hearing with the consent of both sides in order to avoid delay; the original complainant was not represented. The Court allowed the application and set aside the impugned orders passed by the lower courts, directing that a copy of the order be sent to the Magistrate concerned.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, when a Magistrate receives a private complaint that involves an offence under the Prevention of Atrocities Act, the Magistrate must return the complaint and direct the complainant to present it before the Special Court constituted to try such offences.
- How to treat a complaint that includes both offences under the Atrocities Act and offences triable by the Magistrate under the Penal Code—specifically, whether the presence of an Atrocities Act offence requires following the procedure of returning the complaint to the complainant for presentation to the Special Court.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Criminal Revision Application No. 44 of 1995 (Single Bench view dated 20th July, 1999; reported in 2000 (2) Mh. L.J 748) | The principle that when a Magistrate, in a private complaint, encounters an offence under the Atrocities Act, the Magistrate should return the complaint and direct the complainant to present it to the Special Court constituted for trying such offences. | The Court adopted this view and applied it to the present matter: it directed that the Magistrate should return the complaint to the complainant with a direction to present it before the Special Court constituted for trying offences punishable under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. The impugned orders of the lower courts were set aside. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court relied on the Single Bench view recorded in Criminal Revision Application No. 44 of 1995 (reported in 2000 (2) Mh. L.J 748) which held that when a Magistrate, in a private complaint, encounters an offence under the Atrocities Act, the Magistrate must return the complaint and direct the complainant to present it before the Special Court constituted for trying such offences. The Court noted the established distinction between a Magistrate issuing process and committal proceedings for sending a case to a Special Court, but observed that, in light of the cited view, that distinction does not operate to require a different outcome here.
The Court addressed the procedural consequence rather than engaging in an extended discussion about issuance of process versus trial venue. It acknowledged that the complaint also involved some offences triable by the Magistrate under the Penal Code, but held that if cognizance under the Atrocities Act must be taken by the Special Court, the Magistrate should follow the procedure of returning the complaint and directing the complainant to present it to that Special Court. On that basis the Court allowed the present application and set aside the impugned orders.
Holding and Implications
APPLICATION ALLOWED.
Holding: The Court allowed the application, set aside the impugned orders passed by the lower courts, and directed that the Magistrate should return the private complaint to the complainant with a direction that, if the complainant so desires, the complaint be presented before the Special Court constituted for trying offences punishable under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. A copy of the order is to be forwarded to the Magistrate concerned.
Implications: The direct effect is that the Magistrate must return the complaint to the complainant with the stated direction and the lower-court orders are vacated. The opinion applies and follows an existing Single Bench view on this procedural point; the opinion does not purport to establish a new precedent beyond applying that view to the present case.
Application allowed.
1. Heard the learned advocate appearing for the applicants. It appears that in Criminal Revision Application No. 44 of 1995, the Single Bench of this Court has taken a view on 20th July, 1999 (since reported in 2000 (2) Mh. L.J 748) that a grievance and the complaint involving an offence under the Atrocities Act when comes across by a Magistrate in a private complaint, such Magistrate is to return the complaint for being present to the Special Court constituted for the purpose of trying such offences. The settled distinction between the Magistrate issuing the process and like other committal proceedings committing the case to the Special Court, does not, in the light of the said view, seem to be available. But, the learned Magistrate is to return the complaint with a direction to the complainant that if so desired by the complainant, the complainant should present it to the Special Court constituted for trying such offences. I do not think that any different view is necessary to be taken, insofar as the involvement of offence under the Prevention of Atrocities Act in a complaint are concerned.
2. With the consent of both the sides, the matter is taken up for final hearing itself as because of this technicality it is not desirable that unnecessary time should pass and, therefore, the matter is heard finally. There is no representation on behalf of the original complainant.
3. It is not necessary to divulge into the discussion regarding a direction to issue process or such position being distinct from the trial of the offences in respect of which the process is issued. It is not merely under the Atrocities Act but some of the offences which are triable by the Magistrate were also involved under the Penal Code in that complaint. But then this aspect part. If the cognizance of the offence under the Atrocities Act is required to be taken only by the Special Court, I think that the same procedure should be followed by the learned Magistrate by calling upon the complainant to receive the complaint back and a direction to the complainant to present it before the Special Court constituted for trying the offences punishable under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. In view of the above, the present application is allowed. The impugned orders passed by both the Courts stand set aside.
4. Copy of this order be forwarded for information to the Magistrate concerned, as the complainant is not represented before this Court today.
Application allowed.
Alert