- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Felix Menino Jesus Serrao v. State Of Goa And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The opinion concerns two writ petitions relating to constructions on a property situated near the High Tide Line (HTL) in Colva village. In Writ Petition No. 76/95, the petitioner seeks directions to respondent No. 3 to demolish a compound wall and building allegedly constructed illegally by respondent No. 4. In Writ Petition No. 237/99, respondent No. 4 in the first petition (now petitioner) seeks quashing of an order dated 2-2-99 and directions for regularisation of constructions on Survey Nos. 54/4 and 51/2. Both petitions revolve around the same property and were heard together. The controversy involves whether constructions were made without permission, whether they fall within 200 metres of the HTL, and whether these constructions are liable to be regularised or demolished under applicable regulations.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the constructions by respondent No. 4 (petitioner in W.P. No. 237/99) on the property fall within 200 metres of the High Tide Line and are therefore subject to Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) restrictions.
- Whether the constructions were made without requisite permissions or licences from competent authorities, including the Ministry of Environment and Forests.
- Whether the order dated 20-10-95 by the Goa State Coastal Committee of Environment (GSCCE) was properly communicated and whether principles of natural justice were violated.
- Whether the constructions in question are liable to be regularised under the Goa, Daman and Diu Village Panchayat (Regulation of Buildings) Rules, 1985, or are illegal and liable to demolition.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner in Writ Petition No. 76/95 (Felix Serrao)
- The property is within less than 200 metres from the HTL.
- Respondent No. 4 constructed compound wall, well, and building without permission or licence.
- Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 rejected construction plans and issued demolition notices, but no action was taken.
- Construction involved excavation of sand dunes, which is impermissible under CRZ Regulations.
Respondent No. 4 / Petitioner in Writ Petition No. 237/99 (Piedade Gonsalves)
- There was an existing structure (laterite pillars with thatched roof) used partly as storage and partly as summer residence.
- The construction is beyond 200 metres from the HTL.
- Construction started on 13-7-94 and completed on 17-8-94; no sand dunes were excavated.
- Application for regularisation of construction was filed but not disposed of.
- GSCCE is not a statutory body and is no longer in existence.
- Claims entitlement to regularisation under amended Rule 3 of the Goa, Daman and Diu Village Panchayat (Regulation of Buildings) Rules, 1985.
- Alleges violation of principles of natural justice as no opportunity was given before GSCCE’s decision.
Respondent No. 3 (Authority)
- Construction is illegal and without permission or licence from authorities and Panchayat.
- Structure is within 200 metres from HTL and on sand dunes.
- Notices for demolition have been issued.
- Order dated 20-10-95 by GSCCE was communicated by letter dated 8-12-95, against which no reaction was received.
- Petitioner attempted to mislead to obtain fresh copy of GSCCE decision.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the affidavits, photographs, and submissions to determine the legality of the constructions. It noted that the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves admitted the property mainly consisted of sand dunes, but failed to specify which parts. The photographs showed cutting and leveling of sand dunes, indicating total reconstruction rather than mere repairs. The court found that the constructions were within 200 metres of the HTL, a zone classified as a 'No Development Zone' under CRZ III regulations, with sand dunes classified as CRZ I, where construction is prohibited without prior approval. The petitioner did not demonstrate that the constructions were beyond 500 metres from the HTL or that prior approval from the Ministry of Environment and Forests was obtained. The petitioner’s changing stand regarding the timeline of construction further undermined her case. The GSCCE had inspected the site and decided the construction was illegal and on sand dunes, and this decision was communicated to the petitioner, who did not respond timely. The court found no sufficient material to regularise the constructions and held them illegal and liable to demolition under the applicable rules and CRZ regulations.
Holding and Implications
Writ Petition No. 76/95 is allowed: The compound wall, well, and building in Survey Nos. 51/1, 51/2, and 54/4 are ordered to be demolished. Respondent No. 3 is directed to take necessary action. The interim order is vacated. Respondent No. 4 shall bear the costs.
Writ Petition No. 237/99 is dismissed with costs.
The decision directly affects the parties by mandating demolition of illegal constructions and denying regularisation. The court did not set any new precedent but applied existing CRZ regulations and local building rules strictly to uphold environmental and regulatory compliance.
Batta, J.:— The petitioner in Writ Petition No. 76/95 seeks directions to respondent No. 3 to act in pursuance of Notices dated 24th February, 1994 and 16th February, 1995 to demolish the compound wall and the building illegally constructed by the respondent No. 4. In Writ Petition No. 237/99 the petitioner (who is respondent No. 4 in Writ Petition No. 76/95) seeks quashing and setting aside of Order dated 2-2-99 passed by respondent No. 3 therein and for directions to respondent No. 2 to consider the regularisation of the petitioner's structures in Survey No. 54/4 and 51/2. The controversy in the two petitions centres around the same property and, as such, the petitions were taken up together. Learned Advocate for the petitioner in W.P No. 237/99 had requested on 27-9-99 to take up this petition along with W.P No. 76/95 and, as such, arguments on merits in respect of both the petitions were heard.
2. In Writ Petition No. 76/95 the petitioner contends that the property of respondent No. 4 under survey 54/4 is situated within less than 200 metres from the High Tide Line and that respondent No. 4 has made construction of compound wall, dug a well and constructed a building in the said property without obtaining any permission or licence and that respondent Nos. 2 and 3 have already rejected the plans for construction of compound wall and the well. It is further the case of the petitioner that in spite of the fact that respondent No. 3 has issued notices for demolition of compound wall and the building, the respondent No. 3 is not taking any action to demolish the same. According to the petitioner, the respondent No. 4 had escavated sand dunes for the purpose of the said construction.
3. Respondent No. 4 filed affidavit dated 23rd June, 1995 in which it was contended that the property in question had already a construction consisting of laterite pillars covered by palm leaves and thatched roof used partly to store coconuts and partly for residence during summer for sea bathers. It was further urged by respondent No. 4 that in front of petitioner's plot that is between the petitioner's plot and the sea beach, there are residential houses and also a hotel. Respondent No. 4 admitted in this reply that the property in question which is purchased by her consists mainly of sand dunes. According to respondent No. 4 she wanted to convert the existing hut into residential rooms and she was told that since the structure was existing, it was not necessary to apply for conversion and not to take any permission or licence for the said purpose. Subsequently by application dated 19th November, 1994, the respondent No. 4 applied for regularisation of the constructions and for necessary licence. But no order on the same has been passed by the authorities. According to respondent No. 4 the construction done by her is required to be regularised. Subsequently, respondent No. 4 filed additional affidavit on the ground that certain subsequent developments had taken place and certain additional facts were required to be placed on record. Accordingly, in this affidavit, it was stated that the respondent No. 4 had not excavated any sand dunes in the suit property. It was specifically stated in this reply that the construction put up by respondent No. 4 is beyond 200 metres of HTL and that the Order dated 20-10-95 by the Goa State Coastal Committee of Environment had never been communicated and it is only on 2-2-99 that the said Order was communicated which is sought to be challenged by filing Writ Petition No. 237/99. In this affidavit, it was also stated that the construction in Survey No. 54/4 was started on 13-7-94 and completed on 17-8-94.
4. In Writ Petition No. 237/99 the challenge to Order dated 2-2-79 passed by respondent No. 3 therein is that the said Order has been passed in violation of the principles of natural justice; that there always existed a structure of thatched roof of laterite stones pillars which was used by sun bathers and visitors, that the construction of the building in place of the said structure was started on 13-7-94 and completed on 17-8-94 and that the said structure of the petitioner is 200 metres away from HTL. It was also urged in this petition that the application for regularisation has not been disposed of.
5. Respondent No. 3 has filed affidavit in this petition stating that the representation dated 17-5-95 and 11-7-95 of the petitioner was discussed in the 8th GSCCE meeting held on 20th July, 1995 and on the said day the Sub-Committee decided to inspect the site and after inspection of the site, decision was taken in the matter on 20-10-95 which was communicated to the petitioner, by letter dated 8-12-95 against which the petitioner never reacted. It is specifically urged by respondent No. 3 that in order to create a cause of action, the petitioner has maliciously misled the respondent to give her a fresh copy of the decision taken by GSCCE at the 9th meeting held on 20-10-95. According to respondent No. 3 the construction is completely illegal inasmuch as no permission or licence has been secured from the respondents nor from the Colva Village Panchayat. It was also stated that the structure is on sand dunes and it is within 200 metres from HTL.
6. In rejoinder, the petitioner has affirmed that Order dated 20-10-95 was never communicated to the petitioner and respondent No. 3 has produced xerox copy of the outward register wherein the said letter dated 8-12-95 is shown to have been despatched to the petitioner.
7. We have heard learned Advocates, appearing in the matter. Learned Advocate Shri S.S Kantak has taken us through the facts of the case and has submitted that the constructions made by the petitioner are without any licence and without obtaining permission from the authorities concerned and that the constructions are within 200 metres of the HTL and that the constructions have been made on the sand dunes which is not permissible as per CRZ Regulations. He also pointed out that the change of stand by Respondent No. 4 in Writ Petition No. 76/95 and in this connection has drawn our attention to the two affidavits filed by the respondent No. 4. After drawing our attention to the said affidavits, it is urged that though the respondent No. 4 had admitted in the first affidavit that the construction had been stopped after the notice dated 26-11-94 was received, but in the second affidavit the respondent No. 4 has stated that the construction had already been completed by 17-8-94. Shri Kantak also drew our attention to CRZ Regulations and pointed out that Colva has been classified as CRZ III, except sand dunes which are classified as CRZ I and that in CRZ III there are restrictions on the constructions to which our attention has been drawn by him. He therefore contends that the constructions in question are liable to be demolished.
8. Learned Addl. Government Advocate Ms. W. Coutinho, pointed out before us that the demolition notices have already been issued. She further urged that the decision taken by GSCCE on 20-10-95 was communicated to the petitioner by letter dated 8-12-95 against which respondent No. 4 never reacted and belatedly sought to challenge the said order on the ground that the same was not received.
9. Learned Advocate Shri Lobo, appearing for respondent No. 3 stated that notices for demolition have already been issued.
10. Learned Advocate Shri V.A Lawande, appearing on behalf of respondent No. 4 in Writ Petition No. 76/95 and for the petitioner in Writ Petition No. 237/99 strenuously urged before us that the construction in question does not fall within 200 metres of HTL; that HTL, has still not been demarcated; that the structure existed in the property in question and the petitioner in Writ Petition No. 237/99 had merely repaired the said structure, that the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves is entitled to regularisation of this construction in question in view of amended Rule 3 of the Goa, Daman and Diu Village Panchayat (Regulation of Buildings) Rules, 1985 and that the application for regularisation has not been disposed of by the authorities so far. He, therefore, contends that the decision taken by GSCCE is required to be set aside. Besides this, it is pointed out that the said GSCCE is neither a statutory body nor it is in existence now.
11. We had given liberty to the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves to place before us material in order to substantiate her contention that the construction in question is liable to be regularised in accordance with Rules and Regulations. This opportunity was given since the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves had alleged that no opportunity was given by the GSCCE before decision was taken by them to the effect that the construction in question could not be regularised and that the principles of natural justice have been violated.
12. The central question which is required to be dealt with in these petitions is whether the constructions put up by Piedade Gonsalves are in accordance with the Rules and Regulations. The said Piedade Gonsalves had in categorical terms admitted in affidavit dated 23rd June, 1995 that the suit property consists mainly of sand dunes. It was nowhere specified in the said reply or the reply filed thereafter or any other document placed for the purpose of regularisation as to which part of the property consisted of sand dunes. This was absolutely essential since Piedade Gonsalves had herself admitted that the property in question consisted mainly of sand dunes. It is also to be noted at this stage that the construction of the compound wall, the well and the construction of the building in survey No. 54/4 does not have any permission nor any licence from any authority. According to Piedade Gonsalves there already existed a structure in the suit property and the said petitioner had merely repaired the same. The details of the said structure, the location of the said structure, the extent of the said structure was nowhere specified by the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves. Besides this, a bare look at the photographs produced by the petitioner Felix Serrao which are at page 23 clearly show that it is not a case of repairs, but it is a case of total reconstruction. The photographs at page 22 of the petition show the existence of sand dunes, cutting and levelling of the sand dunes. The photos have not been disputed though it is stated in para 2 of affidavit dated 25-6-99 filed in W.P No. 76/95 that photos are clicked at a particular angle so as to create an impression that the structure is on sand dunes which have been cut. The photos speak for themselves.
13. Besides this, the case of the authorities as well as the petitioner Felix Serrao is that the construction is within 200 metres of HTL. This was disputed by Piedade Gonsalves and her case is that the property in question as well as the structures are beyond 200 metres away from the HTL. Here again it is not disclosed by Piedade Gonsalves as to how far away is the suit property from the HTL, except for saying that it is beyond 200 metres of HTL. At this stage, it is relevant to note that as per CRZ Regulations, the village of Colva has been classified as CRZ III, except sand dunes which are classified as CRZ I. In CRZ III, the area upto 200 metres of HTL has been earmarked as ‘No Development Zone’ and no construction is permitted except for repairs of existing authorised structures not exceeding existing FSI, existing plinth area and existing density and for permissible activities under the notification including facilities essential for such activities. Development of vacant plots between 200 and 500 metres of High Tide Line in designated areas of CRZ-III with prior approval of Ministry of Environment and Forests (MEF) is permitted for construction of hotels/beach resorts for temporary occupation of tourists/visitors subject to the conditions as stipulated in the guidelines at Annexure-II. The guidelines impose further restrictions on development of vacant plots between 200 and 500 metres of HTL. Though the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves has stated that her construction is beyond 200 metres of HTL, yet she has nowhere disclosed that the structures are beyond 500 metres of HTL. Therefore the restrictions in respect of the vacant plots would be directly applicable to the suit property in question and no construction in such area can be carried out without prior approval of the Ministry of Environment. No such approval has been obtained by the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves from the Ministry of Environment and Forests.
14. It is also pertinent to note that the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves has been changing her stand in the matter from time to time. In the affidavit dated 23rd June, 1995, it was categorically stated in para 13 that the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves had stoped the work of construction on the receipt of notice dated 26-11-94 which means that the construction had not been completed till then. However, in spite of the said stand, petitioner Piedade in subsequent affidavit dated 25th June, 1999 changed her stand and stated that the construction in survey No. 54/4 had been started on 13-7-94 and had been completed on 17-8-94. This stand is totally contrary to the material on record.
15. The petitioner Piedade Gonsalves had filed applications dated 17th May, 1975 and 11th July, 1995 for the purpose of approval of the construction in question, the GSCCE which was the competent body at that time had in the 8th Meeting held on 20th July, 1995 had decided that the subcommittee shall inspect the site. The site was duly inspected and it was found that the construction in question falls within 200 mertres of the HTL and the construction had been carried out on existing sand dunes. In view of the said site inspection report, a decision was taken by the GSCCE in its meeting on 20th October, 1995 to the following effect:—
“Item No. 45:— Proposed construction and regularisation of existing building in Sy. No. 54/4 at
Colva village by Smt. Piedade F.
Gonsalves (DJ/6030)
This case was placed in the last 8th G.S.C.C.E Adjourned meeting held on 20-7-95. The Committee had decided to inspect the sit. Accordingly the site has been seen by the G.S.C.C.E Sub-Committee on 12-9-95 and it was observed that:
(1) The applicant has proposed for regularisation of building newly constructed sand dunes.
(2) The applicant has already constructed partly i.e 9 rooms are constructed which are also not as per the site conditions.
(3) The portion to be constructed i.e common room and rooms with 4 toilets with porch is to be done on the existing sand dunes. The said dunes partly have been already cut and flattened by the applicant.
(4) The site plan submitted does not tally as per the site condition. The applicant already carried out partly construction of compound wall. The existing building which is constructed does not have required side set back. The completed building provided flat terrace.
(5) The entire existing and proposed construction falls under Cultivable land as per the Regional Plan and within the 200 mts. from H.T.L
The G.S.C.C.E agreed to the above observations of the sub-committee.”
16. This decision is said to have been conveyed to the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves vide letter dated 8-10-95, but the fact that it was conveyed is disputed by the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves and respondent no. 3 has placed before us the outward register by which this letter was despatched to the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves. Thus, in effect the request of the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves for approval as well as for regularisation of the construction in question, has been duly considered by the competent committee. Besides this, the petitioner Piedade Gonsalves has not been able to satisfy us that the constructions in question are liable to be regularised. As we have already pointed out, the constructions have been done without obtaining any permission or licence or prior approval of the Ministry of Environment and Forests, as required under the CRZ Regulations. The constructions in question are totally illegal and, as such, are liable to be demolished.
17. For the aforesaid reasons, the writ petition No. 76/95 is allowed and the compound wall, well and the building falling in Survey Nos. 51/1, 51/2 and 54/4 are ordered to be demolished. Respondent No. 3 shall therefore take necessary action in that regard. Rule is accordingly made absolute in the aforesaid writ petition. The interim order dated 24-7-95 is hereby vacated. In the facts and circumstances, the costs shall be borne by respondent No. 4 in Writ Petition No. 76/95.
18. Writ Petition No. 237/99 is dismissed with costs.
Petition dismissed.
Alert