- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bharati N. Wadhwana And Others v. Arjun Kishandas Jaisingh And Another
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petition before the court sought quashing of criminal proceedings initiated under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The petitioners are described in the opinion as being the original accused Nos. 4, 6, 8 and 11 in the original complaint. The petitioners' counsel contended that those petitioners had resigned before or at the time the cheque was issued and therefore were not liable to be prosecuted. Respondent No. 1 disputed the fact of resignation. The hearing was conducted with Mr. Marwadi appearing for the petitioners, Mr. Desai for respondent No. 1 and learned A.P.P. Mr. Galeria for the State. The Court issued a partly favorable order: quashing prosecution in respect of one petitioner identified in the opinion as "petitioner No. 3", while leaving open relief for the other petitioners to apply before the trial court for discharge.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether criminal proceedings under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act can be quashed insofar as directors who claim to have resigned before issuance of the cheque are concerned.
- Whether, at the stage of considering a quash petition, xerox copies of resignation-related documents (not certified or signed as true copies) and a disputed assertion of resignation can be accepted, or whether the accused must prove the resignation and compliance with the Companies Act, the Articles of Association and Memorandum of Association, acceptance by the company and recording with the Registrar of Companies, before relief can be granted.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners (original accused Nos. 4, 6, 8 and 11) had resigned before or at the time the cheque was issued, and therefore they should not be liable for prosecution under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
Respondent No. 1's Arguments
- The fact of resignation was seriously disputed by the complainant; therefore the resignation could not be accepted at the quash stage.
- Unless the accused proved at trial that the resignation complied with the Companies Act and the company's Articles of Association and Memorandum of Association, that resignation was accepted by other directors or by the company, and that it was duly recorded with the Registrar of Companies, the submission of the petitioners could not be considered for quashing the proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court evaluated the competing contentions and placed emphasis on the disputed nature of the resignation evidence. The court observed that the documents filed by the accused in support of their resignation were xerox copies and were not signed as true copies or certified copies. Because the complainant disputed the genuineness of those documents, the Court held that the question of resignation could not be resolved at the quash petition stage on the basis of the uncertified photocopies.
For these reasons the Court accepted respondent No. 1's objection that the resignation-related documents required proof and confirmation by evidence at trial rather than being determinative for quashing prosecutions at this stage. Consequently, the Court declined to quash the proceedings in respect of those petitioners whose resignations remained disputed and unproven.
The Court made an exception in respect of one individual identified in the opinion as "petitioner No. 3", noting that respondent No. 1 did not seriously dispute that this petitioner had resigned before issuance of the cheque. On that basis, the Court treated the undisputed status of that petitioner's resignation as sufficient to grant relief for that petitioner.
Holding and Implications
Core ruling: The petition is partly allowed and the rule is partly made absolute.
The criminal prosecution against petitioner No. 3 in Case No. 258.S/98 pending before the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Girgaum, Mumbai is quashed. The Court granted liberty to the other petitioners to apply before the concerned Metropolitan Magistrate for their discharge.
Implications: The direct effect is the quashing of prosecution only in respect of petitioner No. 3; the remaining petitioners were not granted quashing at this stage because the resignation facts were disputed and supported only by uncertified photocopies. The opinion does not state any broader precedent or wider legal principle beyond the immediate outcome and the Court's reliance on the need for proof when documentary genuineness is disputed.
Petition partly allowed.
1. Heard Mr. Marwadi for the petitioners, Mr. Desai for respondent No. 1 and learned A.P.P Mr. Galeria for the State.
2. This petition is filed for quashing the proceedings initiated against the petitioners under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. It was contended by counsel for the petitioners Mr. Marwadi that the petitioners, who were original accused Nos. 4, 6, 8 and 11 in the original complaint, had resigned before or at the time when the cheque was issued, and therefore, they were not liable for prosecution. However, counsel for respondent No. 1 Mr. Desai has strongly contended that as the fact of resignation of these directors was seriously disputed by the complainant and unless the accused proved in their defence before the trial Court that the directors/petitioners had resigned and that resignation was as per the provision of the companies act and as per the Articles of Association and Memorandum of Association of the Company, that the resignation was accepted by other directors or by the company and that it was duly recorded by the Registrar of Company, the submission of counsel for the petitioners cannot be taken into consideration and therefore the petition is liable to be dismissed.
3. I find considerable force in the submissions made by counsel for respondent No. 1 because if the respondent-complainant is not accepting the genuineness of the document (Admittedly the documents filed with the petition in their support by the accused are the xerox copies not even signed as true copies or certified copies), then the accused are required to prove it before the trial Court by adducing evidence in that regard, and therefore, the objection raised by the respondent's advocate is upheld at this stage.
4. However, so far as petitioner No. 3 is concerned, respondent No. 1 did not seriously dispute that petitioner No. 3 had resigned as Director even before issuance of cheque, hence the petition is required to be allowed in respect of petitioner No. 3. For all the reasons I pass the following order:—
5. Petition is partly allowed.
6. Rule partly made absolute.
7. Criminal prosecution against petitioner No. 3 in Case No. 258.S/98 pending before the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Girgaum, Mumbai is quashed. Liberty to other petitioners to apply before the concerned Metropolitan Magistrate for their discharge.
Petition partly allowed.
Alert