- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Parvatibai v. State Of Maharashtra .
Factual and Procedural Background
This revision petition challenges the judgment and order dated 2-8-95 passed by the 5th Additional Sessions Judge, Nagpur, in Criminal Appeal No. 73/93, which acquitted the non-applicants 2 and 3 and set aside the earlier order dated 30-7-93 of the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Nagpur. The case originated from a police report, and the complainant has preferred this revision against the acquittal. The State has not filed any revision or appeal against the acquittal order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the lower appellate Court rightly reappreciated the prosecution evidence and correctly acquitted the non-applicants 2 and 3.
- Whether the conviction by the Judicial Magistrate First Class was justified based on the prosecution evidence.
- The impact of non-examination of the Medical Officer, panch witness, and non-analysis of seized articles on the prosecution's case.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The Judicial Magistrate First Class correctly convicted the non-applicants 2 and 3 after proper consideration of prosecution evidence.
- The lower appellate Court erred in reappreciating evidence and wrongly acquitted the accused, failing to prove the offence beyond reasonable doubt.
- P.W.1 (Parvatibai) and P.W.2 (Kundanlal) testified that both sustained injuries, and their evidence is consistent and acceptable despite the non-examination of the Medical Officer.
- The alleged contradictions and omissions in evidence are not fatal since the Investigating Officer was not examined to prove those discrepancies.
- The lower appellate Court wrongly relied on these aspects to acquit the accused, making its order unsustainable in law.
Non-Applicants' Arguments
- The learned A.P.P and the counsel for non-applicants 2 and 3 supported the impugned order of acquittal passed by the Sessions Judge.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court observed that the revision was filed by the complainant in a case instituted on a police report, with no appeal or revision filed by the State against the acquittal. Exercising powers under Section 397 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the Court noted limited scope for interference.
It was undisputed that the prosecution did not examine the Medical Officer, the panch witness, nor sent the seized clothes and weapons for chemical analysis, resulting in lack of evidence regarding alleged blood-stains. The prosecution examined only three witnesses (P.W.1 Parvatibai, P.W.2 Kundanlal, and P.W.3 Vithhal), whose testimonies were inconsistent and contained material discrepancies.
The Court found that P.W.1 and P.W.2 were interested witnesses whose evidence did not inspire confidence due to material contradictions. The absence of medical and forensic evidence further weakened the prosecution's case. Accordingly, the Court held that the lower appellate Court rightly appreciated the evidence and correctly acquitted the accused. Therefore, the impugned judgment and order required no interference.
Holding and Implications
The Court DISMISSED the revision petition.
The direct effect is the upholding of the acquittal of non-applicants 2 and 3 by the lower appellate Court. No new legal precedent was established by this decision.
1. Heard Shri Naidu, the learned counsel for the applicant, Shri Badar, the learned A.P.P for non-applicant No. 1 and Shri Gupta, the learned counsel for the non-applicants 2 and 3.
2. The instant revision is directed against the judgment and order dated 2-8-95 passed by the 5th Addl. Sessions Judge, Nagpur in Criminal Appeal No. 73/93 where the present non-applicants 2 and 3 came to be acquitted and the order passed by the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Nagpur on 30-7-93 came to be set aside.
3. Before I proceed to consider the merits of the matter, it will be appropriate to observe at this stage itself that the present revision is preferred by the complainant in a case which is instituted on a police report. The State has not filed any revision or appeal against the order of acquittal passed by the Addl. Sessions Judge and, therefore, while exercising powers under Section 397 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, this Court has very little scope in the matter in question.
4. The learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Nagpur after taking into consideration the prosecution evidence, came to the right conclusion and rightly convicted the non-applicants 2 and 3 for the offence charged. It is further submitted that the lower appellate Court has not rightly reappreciated the evidence on record adduced by the prosecution and came to the wrong conclusion that the prosecution has failed to prove the offence charged against the non-applicants 2 and 3 and wrongly acquitted them. The learned counsel further submitted that P.W 1 — Parvatibai, the complainant and P.W 2 — Kundanlal-hus-band of the complainant, in their respective testimonies have specifically stated that both of them have sustained injury in the incident in question. The learned counsel submitted that non-examination of doctor in the circumstances of the case, is not fatal to the prosecution since the evidence of these two witnesses is consistent and acceptable to the Court. It is further contended that the question of discarding the evidence on the basis of the contradictions and omissions in the instant case does not arise since the Investigating Officer has not been examined by the prosecution in order to prove the same. The learned counsel, therefore, contended that the lower appellate Court has wrongly placed reliance in this aspect and reached the wrong con clusion by which the order of acquittal came to be passed. On the backdrop of this circumstance, it is submitted that the appreication done and the finding arrived at by the learned lower appellate Court is not just and proper and the same is not sustainable in law.
5. Shri Badar, the learned A.P.P as well as Shri Gupta, the learned counsel for non-applicants 2 and 3 have supported the impugned order passed by the Sessions Judge.
6. I have considered the argument advanced by the learned counsel and perused the impugned judgment and order passed by the lower appellate Court. It will be appropriate at this stage to consider undisputed facts. Those are; the prosecution has not examined the Medical Officer in the insant case, the prosecution has also not examined the panch witness in order to prove the seizure of clothes and weapons, the clodies and weapons were also not sent to the Chemical Analyser. Therefore, there is no evidence brought before the Court in respect of any blood-stains alleged to have been noticed on the clothes.
7. The prosecution in the instant case has examined only 3 witnesses i.e P.W 1. Parvatibai, P.W 2 Kundanlal and P.W 3 Vithhal. The evidence of these three witnesses is inconsistent and suffers from material discrepancies. P.W.I Parvatibai and P.W 2 Kundanlal are the interested witnesses and their testimonies do not inspire confidence because it suffers from material discrepancies in respect of the material particulars of the prosecution case. As stated above, in the instant case non-examination of the doctor and panch witness by the prosecution as well as not obtaining opinion of the Chemical Analyser in regard to the clothes and weapons has adversely affected the prosecution in question. The lower appellate Court, in my opinion, has rightly appreciated the evidence adduced by the prosecution in the instant case and, therefore, the impugned judgment and order requires no interference at the hands of this Court.
8. In the result, the revision is dismissed.
9. Petition dismissed.
Alert