- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rashtriya Mill Mazdoor Sangh v. S.L Mehendale And Another
Parties Involved:
Facts of the Case:
The present appeal is directed against an order issued by a learned Single Judge on January 13, 1999. This order effectively placed the matter in abeyance pending the issuance of final orders by the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (B.I.F.R.). The case was subsequently adjourned to December 20, 1999.
The B.I.F.R. had previously issued an order on December 30, 1998, which was a continuation of an earlier order dated December 12, 1997.
Issues:
1. Whether the learned Single Judge's decision to keep the matter in abeyance until the B.I.F.R. issued final orders was appropriate.
2. The implications of the adjournment of the case to December 20, 1999.
Holding:
The appeal was disposed of in light of the circumstances surrounding the case, specifically the pending final orders from the B.I.F.R. Consequently, the Notice of Motion in Appeal No. 235 of 1998 was rendered moot and also disposed of.
Conclusion:
The court's decision to dispose of the appeal reflects a procedural stance awaiting the B.I.F.R.'s final determination on the matter at hand. As such, the learned Single Judge's order to keep the case in abeyance was upheld, ensuring that all proceedings remain aligned with the B.I.F.R.'s forthcoming directives.
Disposition:
- Appeal disposed of.
- Notice of Motion in Appeal No. 235 of 1998 disposed of as it does not survive the appeal's disposition.
Further Proceedings:
The case is adjourned to December 20, 1999, pending the final orders from the B.I.F.R.
Y.K Sabharwal, C.J and S. Radhakrishnan, J.:— This Appeal is directed against the order dated 13th January 1999 passed by the learned Single Judge whereby the matter has been kept in abeyance till the final orders are passed by the B.I.F.R and the case has been adjourned to 20th December 1999. The impugned order was passed by the learned Judge in view of the order dated 30th December 1998 passed by the B.I.F.R under Section 22(3) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (the said Act.).
2. The order dated 30th December 1998 passed by the B.I.F.R is in fact in continuation of its earlier order passed on 12th December 1997.
3. We have perused both the orders i.e dated 12th December 1997 as also dated 30th December 1998.
4. We have also perused the applications filed by the National Textile Corporation on the basis of which these orders were passed. A perusal of these two orders as also the application makes it clear that what was suspended was the recovery proceedings etc., in respect of the applicant-company by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Commissioner of Employees State Insurance Corporation, Maharashtra and Central Excise authorities in Maharashtra and Goa and all or any of the rights, privileges, obligations and liabilities occurring or arising in contracts, settlements and awards in respect thereof.
5. We are unable to accept the contention that reference to these bodies was on account of typographical error. It also deserves to be noticed that annexures to the application under Section 22(3) of the Act also set out the overdue payments on account of provident fund/ESIC and the payments due to the Excise Department. There is no whisper in the application about the employees with which the Writ Petition is concerned. The use of the words ‘Standing Order’ in the two orders cannot be considered in isolation and has to be seen in the context of ESIC, Regional Provident Fund Commissioner and Central Excise authorities. The appellate authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction in its order dated 9th September 1998 has also observed that the appellant is not one of these organisations. Therefore, orders dated 12th December 1997 and 30th December 1998 are not applicable to the appellant.
6. In this view, we are unable to sustain the order dated 13th January 1999. It is accordingly set aside. The matter will be placed before the learned Single Judge for hearing. Appeal is disposed of accordingly.
7. As the Appeal is disposed of, Notice of Motion in Appeal No. 235 of 1998 does not survive and it is disposed of.
8. Appeal Disposed of.
Alert