- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sangeeta v. Presiding Officer/Tahsildar
Summary of Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner was the Sarpanch of the village Suki, taluka Puma, district Parbhani. She challenged a No Confidence Motion passed on 19th August, 1998 against her under section 35 of the Bombay Village Panchayats Act. It was not disputed that the motion was passed by the requisite majority. The petitioner challenged the validity of the motion before the Collector and later before the Commissioner on two grounds: (1) that the notice of the meeting was not a proper notice within the meaning of Rule 5(2) of the Bombay Village Panchayat (Meetings) Rules, 1959; and (2) that the meeting did not take place in the office of the village panchayat as required by sub-section (2) of section 35 of the Act but at some other place. The opinion records that Mr. S.R. Barlinge appeared for the petitioner. The petition was ultimately dismissed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the notice for the Special Meeting convened to consider the No Confidence Motion complied with Rule 5(2) of the Bombay Village Panchayat (Meetings) Rules, 1959 (in particular, whether the requirement of "at least one clear day" was satisfied).
- Whether holding the Special Meeting in a room adjoining the Village Panchayat office (in the same building) complied with the requirement in sub-section (2) of section 35 of the Bombay Village Panchayats Act that the meeting be held "at the Office of the Panchayat."
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Counsel for the petitioner submitted that the notice was served on 18-8-1997 and the meeting took place on 19th August, 1998, i.e., on the next day; on this basis the notice did not amount to the legally required notice period.
- Relying on the definition of "Clear Day" in Clause "A" of Rule 2 of the Meetings Rules and the absence of clear provisions in the No Confidence Motion Rules, it was argued that the Bombay Village Panchayat (Meetings) Rules, 1959 must be read to require notice to be served at least one clear day in advance, excluding both the day of issuance and the day of the meeting.
- It was also contended that sub-section (2) of section 35 required the meeting to take place in the Village Panchayat office and that holding it elsewhere invalidated the meeting.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any opposing party's separate arguments or submissions.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook a textual and purposive reading of the provisions in issue:
- On Rule 5(2) (sub-rule 2 of Rule 5): The court quoted the provision — "The Secretary, shall at least one clear day, before the date fixed for a Special Meeting, send or caused to be sent to all the members intimation of the date, time and place of such Special Meeting and of all the business to be transacted thereat." — and emphasised that the rule prescribes the time at which the notice is to be sent or caused to be sent by the Secretary. The court concluded that the rule refers to despatch/sending of the notice rather than to actual service on each member. Because the notices were sent by the Tahsildar on 18-8-1998, the court found that they were sent at least one clear day before the meeting and thus there was sufficient compliance with the rule.
- On sub-section (2) of section 35: The court quoted the provision — "The Tahsildar shall invite a Special Meeting of the Panchayat for considering Motion of No confidence at the Office of the Panchayat at time to be appointed by him." — and held that this requirement must be read reasonably. The court explained that the purpose of stating the office is to provide a known gathering place for members. In the present facts the Village Panchayat office was unavailable because construction material was stored there; the meeting was held in an adjoining room in the same building (one room being used as a school). The court reasoned that holding the meeting in the adjoining room in the same building did not contravene any mandatory provision because members would reasonably know where to gather. Consequently, there was sufficient compliance with the statutory requirement.
- Based on these analyses the court found both contentions pressed by the petitioner to be without merit.
Holding and Implications
Petition dismissed.
Implications:
- The court held that (a) sending or despatching the notice at least one clear day before the meeting (as occurred when the Tahsildar sent the notices on 18-8-1998 for the 19th August meeting) satisfied Rule 5(2), and (b) holding the meeting in an adjoining room in the same building where the Panchayat office is situated, because the office itself was unavailable, did not violate sub-section (2) of section 35.
- The immediate effect is that the No Confidence Motion stood as valid and the petition challenging it was rejected summarily. The opinion does not indicate any broader precedent being established beyond the decision's application to these facts.
End of summary based exclusively on the provided opinion.
N.P Chapalgaonker, J.:— The petitioner who was the Sarpanch of the village Suki, tq. Puma, dist. Parbhani challenges a No Confidence Motion which was passed on 19th August, 1998 against her under section 35 of the Bombay Village Panchayats Act. There is no dispute that the motion was passed by requisite majority. Validity of the motion is challenged in this petition. The validity was challenged before Collector and then before the Commissioner on two grounds viz. (1) that the notice of the said meeting was a proper notice within the meaning of Rule 5(2) of the Bombay Village Panchayat (Meetings) Rules, 1959 and (2) that the meeting did not take place in the office of the village panchayat, as provided under sub-section (2) of section 35 of the Act and it took place at place other than the office.
2. Mr. S.R Barlinge, learned counsel for petitioner, submitted that admittedly the notice was served on 18-8-1997 and the meeting took place on 19th August, 1998 i.e on the next day, therefore, it will not be a notice in the eye of law.
3. Mr. Barlinge, rightly submits that in the absence of any clear provisions in the Bombay Village Sarpanch and Upsarpanch (No Confidence Motion) Rules, 1975, the Bombay Village Panchayat (Meetings) Rules, 1959 will have to be read. Relying on this rule, Mr. Barlinge, submits that a notice will have to be served at least one clear day in advance on all the members of the panchayat. He invited our attention to the definition of “Clear Day” defined in Clause “A” of Rule 2 submitted that day of issuance of the Notice and the day on which the meeting took place both will have to be excluded.
4. Sub-rule 2 of Rule 5 of the Act, which reads as under:
“The Secretary, shall at least one clear day, before the date fixed for a Special Meeting, send or caused to be sent to all the members intimation of the date, time and place of such Special Meeting and of all the business to be transacted thereat.”
5. What is provided by the rule is time at which the notice is to be sent or caused to be sent by the Secretary.
6. The sub-rule 2, as quoted above, does not require that a notice should be served on member at least one clear day in advance. It speaks about the despatch or sending of the notice. Admittedly, the notices were sent by the Tahsildar on 18-8-1998 and therefore, it was sent at least one clear day before the date fixed for the Special Meeting. In this view of the matter, there was a sufficient compliance of the Rules.
7. Another objection raised by Mr. Barlinge is based on sub-section (2) of section 35 which reads as under:
“The Tahsildar shall invite a Special Meeting of the Panchayat for considering Motion of No confidence at the Office of the Panchayat at time to be appointed by him.”
8. The provision will have to be read reasonably. A meeting is to take place in the office of the Panchayat so that everybody should know this place at which they have to gather. In the present case, construction material including sand and centering plates was stored in the office of the panchayat. One room adjacent to the office of the Panchayat, in the same building, houses a school. Therefore, since the room which is called to be office of the Panchayat was not available and therefore, the meeting took place in the adjoining room. We do not think that there is any contravention of any mandatory provisions. If the room in which the Village Panchayat Office is situated, is not available for one or the other reason and just adjacent to it, in the same building, the meeting takes place, we are sure that every member, who intends to attend the meeting, would know that the meeting is taking place in the adjoining room. Therefore, even on this count we find that there was sufficient compliance.
9. Both the contentions of the petitioner pressed in service for challenging the Motion fail and petition stands rejected summarily.
Petition dismissed.
Alert