Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Madura Coats Employe... v. Regional Provident F...

Bombay High Court
Jul 16, 1998
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion: Interpretation of Section 17(3)(b) — Employees Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition was brought by a trade union (the petitioner), registered under the Trade Unions Act, 1926, claiming to be the representative union of employees of Respondent No. 2, a company with establishments including one in Bombay/Mumbai. The Employees' Provident Fund Act (Act 19 of 1952) applied to the respondent's Mumbai establishment. Around 1986 the union and Respondent No. 2 jointly applied for exemption under Section 17(1) on the ground that the company's voluntary provident fund scheme gave employees benefits more favourable than those under the statutory scheme (notably deductions at 8.33% without any ceiling).

Exemption was granted. With effect from 31 December 1990 the employer imposed a ceiling on the salary unit for provident fund contributions (fixing the salary ceiling as it existed on that date). The union contended that after exemption was granted the employer could not, without prior leave of the Central Government, alter the scheme so as to reduce the total quantum of provident fund benefits; the union also referred to a 17 May 1989 government notification that increased contributions to 10% for certain industries, a contention which the union later did not press before this Court.

The union addressed letters to the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner (Respondent No. 1) and to Respondent No. 2 in 1991–1992; after no satisfactory response, the union filed Writ Petition No. 3365 of 1992. This Court directed Respondent No. 1 to issue a show cause notice to Respondent No. 2 under Section 7-A; Respondent No. 1 later issued orders rejecting the union's claims: (a) that the 17 May 1989 notification applied to Respondent No. 2, and (b) that imposing a ceiling breached Section 17(3)(b). Those rejections were challenged in the present writ petition under Article 226.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the correct meaning and scope of Section 17(3)(b) of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952?
  2. Whether an employer, after exemption under Section 17(1), can impose a ceiling on salary for provident fund contribution purposes in a manner that reduces the "total quantum of benefits" available to employees without obtaining the leave of the Central Government under Section 17(3)(b)?
  3. Whether the imposition of a ceiling that allegedly does not change employer contribution in absolute rupee terms nonetheless violates Section 17(3)(b) by reducing the "total quantum of benefits" (as contended by the union and contested by the employer)?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Once exemption is granted under Section 17(1), the employer cannot, without leave of the appropriate Government, reduce the total quantum of benefits to employees; the employer's imposition of a ceiling on salary after exemption had the effect of reducing the total quantum of provident fund benefits the employees previously enjoyed under the voluntary scheme (which had no ceiling).
  • The union had also asserted that a 17 May 1989 notification increased provident fund contribution to 10% for the establishment, but that contention was not pressed before this Court.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondent No. 2 contended the 17 May 1989 notification was inapplicable to their establishment (textile industry was specifically excluded from the scope of that notification) — a contention accepted by Respondent No. 1 in its order on that point.
  • Respondent No. 2 argued that imposing a ceiling did not violate Section 17(3)(b) because employees continued to receive the same quantum of contribution amounts in absolute terms (rupee amounts) even after the ceiling was imposed; therefore, there was no reduction in the "total quantum of benefits." Respondents relied on the Delhi High Court's decision in R.K. Mohta v. U.O.I. to support the proposition that "total quantum" cannot be equated to the rate of contribution.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R.K. Mohta v. Union of India, 1992 64 FLR 1158 (Delhi High Court) Held that the expression "total quantum" cannot be equated to the rate of contribution; lowering the rate did not necessarily reduce the total quantum of benefits when other elements (e.g., D.A. calculation) changed. The court explicitly disagreed with the Delhi High Court's view and declined to follow R.K. Mohta in this matter.
Consolidated Crop Production (P) Ltd. v. V. Hema Chandrarao, 1977 LIC 251 Held that an employer could not claim contribution below the former voluntary contribution rate (10% in that case); until a reduction was granted by the appropriate authority, employees could not contribute less than before. The court relied on and followed this Court's earlier decision to support the proposition that benefits available under a voluntary scheme cannot be reduced without appropriate authority.
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner v. Harihar Polyfibres, 1992 2 LLJ 761 (Karnataka High Court) Followed the view that employers could not reduce benefits below what was available under a voluntary scheme without the appropriate authority. The court noted that the Karnataka High Court followed the same approach as Consolidated Crop Production and treated it as supportive authority for disallowing unilateral reduction (here, imposition of a ceiling).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying the central statutory provision in dispute: Section 17(3)(b) of the Employees Provident Funds Act. It noted the legislative scheme: the statutory provident fund scheme applies automatically where the Act is attracted, but Section 17(1) permits the appropriate Government to exempt an establishment where a voluntary scheme affords benefits "not less favourable" than the statutory scheme.

The court read Section 17(3)(b) as a protective provision that prevents an employer, after an exemption has been granted, from reducing the "total quantum of benefits" in the nature of pension, gratuity or provident fund without the prior leave of the Central Government. The provision, the court held, presupposes that the benefits available to employees on the date of exemption (whether they be expressed in rates, structural features such as absence of a ceiling, or other benefit characteristics) cannot be diminished without permission.

Applying that interpretive approach to the facts, the court emphasized that the term "total quantum of benefits" is not restricted to the monetary amount paid in rupees at a given moment. Instead, the court construed "total quantum" to encompass the nature and structure of the benefits available under the voluntary scheme — for example, entitlement without a salary ceiling that allows contributions on full actual salaries, possibly in excess of the statutory ceiling.

The court rejected Respondent No. 2's submission that there was no breach of Section 17(3)(b) because employer contributions in rupee terms allegedly remained the same after the ceiling was imposed. The court explained that focusing solely on absolute rupee amounts ignores structural changes (the imposition of a ceiling) that reduce the scope of entitlement under the voluntary scheme; such a reduction is precisely what Section 17(3)(b) forbids absent leave of the Central Government.

The court considered the contra view expressed by the Delhi High Court in R.K. Mohta, which equated "total quantum" with actual monetary rate outcomes and thus upheld a reduction in rate without finding a prohibited diminution. The court expressly dissented from R.K. Mohta and relied instead on an earlier decision of this Court (Consolidated Crop Production v. V. Hema Chandrarao, 1977 LIC 251) and a Karnataka High Court decision (Regional Provident Fund Commissioner v. Harihar Polyfibres) that supported the proposition that benefits under a voluntary scheme cannot be diminished without appropriate authority.

The court concluded that Respondent No. 1 (the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner) had ignored the provisions of Section 17(3)(b) by rejecting the union's application and that imposition of the ceiling was impermissible where the voluntary scheme had no ceiling at the time of exemption.

The court also recorded that the petitioner's prayer based on the 17 May 1989 notification (raising the contribution rate to 10%) was not pressed before the Court and was therefore not decided.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is ALLOWED. The rule is made absolute in terms of the petitioner's prayer clause (a) insofar as it challenges the imposition of a ceiling on employees' salary for provident fund contribution purposes. No order as to costs was made.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The employer's unilateral imposition of a ceiling on salary units (where a voluntary scheme existed without a ceiling at the time of exemption) is disallowed unless prior leave of the Central Government under Section 17(3)(b) is obtained.
  • The court rejected the narrower interpretation that "total quantum of benefits" is limited to actual rupee amounts paid at a point in time and held that the statutory protection covers the structure and scope of benefits available under a voluntary scheme.
  • The court expressly disagreed with the Delhi High Court decision in R.K. Mohta and followed earlier decisions (Consolidated Crop Production and the Karnataka decision in Harihar Polyfibres) that support non-reduction of voluntarily provided benefits without appropriate authority. The petition did not press the contention based on the 17 May 1989 notification, and that question was left undecided.

End of summary based exclusively on the provided opinion.

Show all summary ...

A.P Shah, J.:— A very short question arises in this petition as to the correct meaning of Section 17(3)(b) of the Employees Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (Act 19 of 1952).

2. The petitioner is a trade union registered under the Trade Unions Act, 1926. Respondent No. 2 is a company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, having their offices all over India. Petitioner claims to be the representative union of the employees of respondent No. 2 employed in their establishment in Bombay. The Provident Fund Act became applicable sometime in the year 1952. The Act was obviously applicable to the establishment of respondent No. 2 in Mumbai. In about 1986 petitioner and respondent No. 2 had jointly applied for exemption of the provisions of the Act on the ground that the benefits being accorded by respondent No. 2 to their employees were more than what was available to the employees under the said Act.

3. It was pointed out that respondent No. 2 was effecting deductions amounting to 8.33% of the total salary of the workmen without any ceiling i.e, though the ceiling was fixed by the said Act at the salary of Rs. 2,500/-, the company was effecting the said deduction without ceiling even beyond the salary limit at the actual salaries drawn by the workmen. It was obvious that the voluntary scheme was more beneficial to the employee. Exemption was accordingly granted under Section 17(1) of the Act.

4. It appears from the record that with effect from 31st December, 1990, respondent No. 2 imposed a ceiling on the salary unit for the purpose of provident fund contribution as it existed on 31st December, 1990. The petitioner maintained that once the exemption is granted to the establishment under Section 17(1) of the Act, the concerned employer cannot alter the exemption so as to reduce the total quantum of benefits in the provident fund without taking leave of the appropriate Government. Incidentally it may be mentioned that by intimation bearing No. S-35011/9/98-SS-II published by the Government of India in the Official Gazette on 17th May 1989, the rate of provident fund contribution was increased from 8.33% to 10% for certain industries notified in the Schedule. According to the petitioner, respondent No. 2's establishment in Mumbai was covered by the said notification and therefore, the provident fund was liable to be deducted at the rate of 10%. It seems that the petitioner addressed several letters to the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner i.e, respondent No. 1 as well as respondent No. 2 during 1991 and 1992 but to no avail. Finally, the petitioner issued a notice through Advocate on 10th March, 1992 calling upon respondent No. 1 to direct respondent No. 2 to effect deductions to provident fund contribution on their current total wages and contribute equal amount without any ceiling of the salary of the employees concerned and further increase the rate of such deduction from 8.33% to 10% from the date of coming into force of the said notification. To this there was no reply from respondent No. 1.

5. The petitioner filed Writ Petition No. 3365 of 1992 before this Court and the same came to be disposed of by order dated 14th September, 1992 whereby the 1st respondent was directed to issue show cause notice under Section 7-A of the Act to respondent No. 2 to pass appropriate orders within a period of four weeks. Pursuant to the said order, respondent No. 1 issued show cause notice to respondent No. 2. Respondent No. 2 took up a defence that the notification dated 17th May, 1989 was not applicable to the establishment of respondent No. 1 since textile industry was specifically excluded from the scope of the said notification. Secondly, respondent No. 2 contended that imposing a ceiling does not violate Section 17(3)(b) of the Act in as much as the employees have continued to receive the same quantum of benefit as prior to the imposition of the ceiling on salary.

6. By order dated 17th February, 1993, respondent No. 1 rejected the claim of the petitioner regarding payment of 10% contribution both from the employer and employees' salary on the ground that the notification dated 17th May, 1989 is not applicable to the establishment of respondent No. 2. By passing a further order dated 5th April, 1993, respondent No. 1 rejected the petitioner's contention that there was breach of Section 17(3)(b) of the Act by reason of imposition of ceiling on the salary. Both these orders are challenged in this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

7. The main dispute relates to the meaning and interpretation of Section 17(3)(b) of the Act. The prayer based on the notification dated 17th May, 1989 was not pressed before this Court. However, it is contended that the employer has committed breach of Section 17(3)(b) of the Act by imposing a ceiling on salary. Before provisions of Section 17(3)(b) are construed, it may be borne in mind that every establishment which falls within the purview of the Provident Fund Act, the statutory scheme of 1952 automatically applies. Section 17(1) of the Act confers power upon the appropriate Government to exempt any establishment from all or any of the provisions of any scheme if, in the opinion of the appropriate Government, rules of its provident fund with respect to the rates of contribution are not less favourable than those specified in Section 6 and the employees are also in enjoyment of other provident fund benefits which on the whole are not less favourable to the employees than the benefits provided under the Act or under the scheme. Thus, where a voluntary scheme is in existence or later on framed by the employers appears to be more beneficial to the employee, it is permissible to the appropriate Government to grant exemption from all or any other provisions of the statutory scheme. When the provisions of the Act making statutory scheme compulsory are read along with the provisions to grant exemption from the statutory scheme under certain circumstances, the intention of the legislature appears to be clear. Where inadequate benefits were there, the legislature desired that the minimum benefit of provident fund ought to be in the form of contribution at 8% on either side. Where therefore the establishments were giving benefit of provident fund which was less than the statutory scheme envisages, the establishments were bound to follow the statutory scheme. Where, however, better managed companies and establishments were already in a position to offer better and more benefits to their employees in the form of provident fund and other schemes like gratuity and old age pension, the intention of the legislature in enacting Section 17(3)(b) was that such better and more benefits should not be taken away without the previous permission of the Central Government.

8. It is the case of the petitioner that on true interpretation of Section 17(3)(b) of the Act, the employer cannot impose a ceiling on the salary contrary to the existing scheme and thus take away from the employees substantial benefit which they were enjoying due to the fact that under the voluntary scheme there was no ceiling on the salary. Section 17(3)(b) of the Act reads as follows:—

“17. Power of exempt—

(3) Where in respect of any person or class of persons employed in an establishment an exemption is granted under this section from the operation of all or any of the provisions of any Scheme (whether such exemption has been granted to the establishment wherein such person or class of persons is employed, or to the person or class of persons as such), the employer in relation to such establishment—

(a) ……….

(b) Shall not, at any time after the exemption, without the leave of the Central Government, reduce the total quantum of benefits in the nature of pension, gratuity or provident fund to which any such person or class of persons was entitled at the time of the exemption”.

9. Under the above provisions, the employer is prohibited from reducing the total quantum of benefits in the nature of pension, gratuity or provident fund without the leave of the Central Government. This section pre-supposes that whatever benefits were available to the employee either in the nature of pension, gratuity or provident fund on the date when the exemption was granted, express or implied, this benefit is not to be reduced in any manner without the previous permission of the Central Government. Thus where any benefit is available in an establishment under the Voluntary Scheme, the total quantum available under the said scheme cannot be denied to the employee without the prior permission of the Central Government. Section 17(3)(b) uses the expression total quantum benefits. Therefore, where under the voluntary scheme the employees are entitled to contribution from both at the rate of 8.33% without any ceiling, it is not permissible for the employer to impose a ceiling so as to reduce the total quantum of benefits under the existing scheme. It was argued on behalf of Respondent No. 2 that even after the imposition of ceiling there is no reduction in the amount of contribution made by the employer and therefore, it cannot be said that there is reduction in the total quantum of benefits. It is hot possible to accept this argument for simple reason that the word “total quantum of benefits” do not and cannot mean only actual benefit in rupee, anna and pie but it means the benefits whether one or more available under the scheme. Under the voluntary scheme there was no ceiling on the salary. Thus the employees were entitled to contribute more than Rs. 2,500 which was the ceiling fixed at the relevant time under the statutory scheme. This benefit cannot be taken away by the employer without the prior permission of the Central Government. Respondent No. 1 has completely ignored the provisions of Section 17(3)(b) of the Act in rejecting the application made by the Union.

10. On behalf of the respondents reliance was placed on the decision of the Delhi High Court in R.K Mohta v. U.O.I 1992 64 FLR 1158 SC. There the High Court was considering the case of the employees of a private school. Prior to the applicability of the Act, contribution towards provident fund was being made at the rate of 8.33%, but after the introduction of the scheme, it was reduced to 6.25%, It was argued that by virtue of Section 12 of the Act, the same could not be reduced. It was submitted that the reduction of rate would amount to reduction in total quantum of benefits which was being paid to the employees. The High Court held that prior to the application of the Act, the school was contributing only on the salary and part of the D.A But thereafter the whole amount of D.A is taken into consideration for the purpose of calculating the provident fund. Even by reducing the rate of 8.33% to 6.25% there has been no reduction in the total quantum of benefit. According to the Delhi High Court expression “total quantum” cannot be equated to the rate of contribution. The petition was therefore dismissed. I am unable to agree with the view taken by the aforesaid view of the Delhi High Court. This Court has taken a contrary view in Consolidated Crop Production (P) Ltd. v. V. Hema Chandrarao. 1977 LIC 251. It was held by Deshmukh, J. that the petitioner cannot claim contribution below 10% which was the former contribution under the voluntary scheme and it would also follow that until the reduction by an appropriate authority has been granted by the Commissioner, the employees cannot also contribute less than what they were doing earlier. The view taken by this Court is followed by the Karnataka High Court in Regional Provident Fund Commissioner v. Harihar Polyfibres. 1992 2 LLJ 761 Kar. Thus it was clearly impermissible for respondent No. 2 to have imposed a ceiling when in fact there was no ceiling under the voluntary scheme. Petition is allowed. Rule is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a) only so far as imposing ceiling on the employee's salary is concerned. No order as to costs.

11. Petition Allowed.