- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India v. Supreme Construction .
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition under Section 30 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 was filed by the Petitioners challenging the arbitral Award dated 29 December 1995 of the sole Arbitrator Shri S.K. Ahuja (copy at Exhibit‑A). The parties entered into contract No. 14.PT (B‑V)/1981‑1982 dated 26 November 1981 for construction of a telephone exchange building at Ulhasnagar with an 18‑month completion period. Work commenced on 11 December 1981 and was completed on 31 December 1983. The respondents (contractors) applied for and received extensions under Condition No. 5. Final bill was prepared and partly paid; respondents received payment under protest.
Disputes were referred to arbitration. Four successive arbitrators resigned (Shri Surendranath; Shri Chakravarthy; Shri J. Pal) before Shri S.K. Ahuja was appointed, entered upon reference on 17 January 1994, and issued the Award on 29 December 1995 (served on petitioners on 5 January 1996). The respondents' original statement of claim (filed 29 June 1987) contained 18 claims totaling Rs. 11,84,677.54; the Award allowed Rs. 3,09,261.46 in aggregate.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the award of the Arbitrator in respect of specific claims (Nos. 1, 9, 11, 15 and 18) is vitiated by any error apparent on the face of the record, breach of the contract terms (including conditions 10‑C and 12), or misconduct warranting interference under Section 30 of the Arbitration Act, 1940.
- Whether the Arbitrator could properly award escalation/compensation for increased labour and material costs in view of clause 10‑C (requiring books of account and limiting certain increases) and the documentary evidence produced.
- Whether the court should reappraise evidence or interfere with factual findings of the Arbitrator beyond the narrow grounds permissible under the Arbitration Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioner's counsel restricted the challenge to Awards on claims Nos. 1, 9, 11, 15 and 18.
- With respect to claim No. 1, implied challenge was raised but the petitioner contested the quantum (award Rs. 938.57 against claim of Rs. 91,015.51).
- For claim No. 9, reliance was placed on clause 10‑C of the contract: the petitioner argued that escalation/compensation awarded by the Arbitrator was contrary to clause 10‑C and that the respondents failed to produce the required books of account and documents; therefore no amount should have been awarded.
- For claim No. 11, it was submitted that the respondents failed to submit the detailed analysis of rates as required under clause 12 of the conditions of contract.
- For claim No. 15, petitioner argued there was no evidence before the Arbitrator to justify the award and challenged the basis for the figure of Rs. 10,000 awarded as losses.
- For claim No. 18, petitioner argued against the interest granted as unreasonable or unconscionable.
Respondents' Arguments / Factual Position as Found by the Arbitrator
- The respondents claimed compensation for delay‑related escalation (claim No. 9) alleging the work was prolonged from 10 June 1983 to 31 December 1983 and claiming Rs. 3,00,000 towards increased prices of materials and labour.
- The respondents relied on Government notifications dated 26 August 1982 and October 1983 to establish increase in fair wages and claimed escalation as permitted under clause 10‑C.
- Respondents had requested release of payment by letter dated 28 January 1983 (Exhibit R‑108) and then were directed to produce books of accounts (Exhibit R‑111); the respondents produced books of account and detailed calculations (including Annexure CA‑15) to substantiate their claims.
- Respondents contended there were no labour complaints during contract performance and that 10% of wage increase was absorbed by them; their net calculations supported the claimed escalation figure.
- For claims involving analysis of rates (claim No. 11) and losses for rejected material (claim No. 15), respondents provided item‑wise analyses and evidence on which the Arbitrator relied.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court conducted a focused review of the Award and confined the legal scrutiny to whether any error apparent on the face of the record or other limited statutory grounds under the Arbitration Act justified setting aside the Award.
Key steps in the court's analysis:
- Scope of challenge: The court recognized the petitioner's restriction of challenge to claims Nos. 1, 9, 11, 15 and 18 and examined the Award's treatment of each challenged claim rather than reappraising the entire factual matrix.
- Claim No. 1: The Arbitrator allowed Rs. 938.57 against a larger claim. The court reviewed the Award's discussion showing the Arbitrator heard both parties and made a reasoned partial allowance and concluded no error apparent on the face of the record was shown to set aside this part of the Award.
-
Claim No. 9 (principal challenge): The petitioner relied on clause 10‑C (which governs escalation for increases in wages or material costs caused by new statutory orders and requires contractors to keep and produce books of account). The court examined whether the respondents complied with clause 10‑C and whether the Arbitrator's award contravened that clause.
- The court noted the Arbitrator found increase in fair wages established by Government notifications (26‑8‑1982 and Oct. 1983), the respondents had requested payment (letter dated 28‑1‑1983), and were directed and did produce books of account (Exhibits R‑108, R‑111 and subsequent filings).
- The Arbitrator also found no labour complaints about underpayment and that respondents absorbed 10% of wage increase; the net escalation calculations (Annexure CA‑15) supported the awarded sum of Rs.1,40,352.
- The court quoted the Arbitrator's explicit findings that books of accounts were produced and the claim for Rs.1,40,352 was "found fully justified and accordingly the same is allowed in favour of claimant." On this basis, the court found no apparent error in the Arbitrator's application of clause 10‑C.
- Claim No. 11: The court observed the Arbitrator divided the claim into subheadings (i) to (vii), discussed each item and relied on the respondents' analysis of rates. The court concluded these findings did not go to the root of the Award and did not reveal an apparent error warranting interference.
- Claim No. 15: The petitioner argued lack of evidence for the Arbitrator's figure of Rs. 10,000. The court noted the Arbitrator relied upon admitted facts that the area for thermocole was restricted by the petitioner and material brought by respondents was not accepted for other work. The court accepted that the Arbitrator must have based the figure on evidence and found no error apparent on the face of the record.
- Claim No. 18: The court examined the interest granted and found it "neither unreasonable nor unconscionable."
- Overarching legal principle applied: The court reiterated the settled principle that courts should not reappraise evidence or substitute their own view of facts in ordinary arbitration challenges. Interference is limited to cases where an error of law or fact is patent and demonstrable without close weighing of competing views, or where the Arbitrator has misconducted himself or acted contrary to the contract. The court concluded that only very limited grounds exist to set aside an award and that the petitioner had not made out any such ground.
Holding and Implications
Core Holding: The petition is dismissed. The Court found no merit in the challenge to the Award and no error apparent on the face of the record sufficient to set aside the Arbitrator's determinations on the challenged claims.
Direct consequences and orders:
- The petition is dismissed with no order as to costs.
- The court directed entry of decree in terms of the Award with further interest from the date of decree till payment at the rate of 15% per annum.
- Certified copy of the judgment was expedited and the final line of the opinion records: "Petition dismissed."
Broader implications: The opinion reiterates the established, narrow scope for judicial interference with arbitral awards (no wholesale reappraisal of evidence). The judgment does not announce or rely upon any new legal precedent; it applies established principles to the facts of this case.
Petition dismissed.
1. This petition under Section 30 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 has been filed by the Petitioners challenging the Award dated 29th December, 1995 of the sole Arbitrator Shir S.K Ahuja, Chief Engineer, copy of the Award has been attached to the petition at Exhibit-A. A contract was entered into between the respondents and the petitioner for the construction of telephone exchange building at Ulhasnagar. As per agreement No. 14.PT (B-V)/1981-1982 dated 26th November, 1981 entered into between the parties, the respondents were required to complete the construction work within 18 months. The work commenced on 11th December, 1981 and was actually completed on 31st December, 1983. The respondents applied for extension of time and the same were granted under Condition No. 5 of the general conditions of contract forming part of the contract. The final bill was prepared as per the terms and conditions of the contract and an amount of the final bill was paid to the respondents. According to the petitioners, no further amount remained due and payable. The respondents received the payment under the final Bill under protest. Disputes arose between the parties and the matter was referred to the Arbitration. Initially sole Arbitrator Shri Surendranath, Superintending Engineer was appointed by letter dated 1st Jan. 1989. Shri Surendranath resigned from the arbitration by letter dated 22nd March, 1991. Thereafter one shri Chakravarthy, Chief Engineer was appointed as sole Arbitrator by letter dated 10th April, 1991. This Arbitrator vacated his office and resigned from the arbitration on 10th October, 1991. Thereafter one Shri J. Pal, Engineer (Arbitration) was appointed as sole Arbitrator by letter dated 22-1-1992. He also resigned on 10th December, 1993. In his place the present Arbitrator Shri S.K Ahuja was appointed as a sole Arbitrator. The Arbitrator entered upon reference on 17th January, 1994 and parties filed their pleadings. The respondents had filed a statement of claim on 29th June, 1987. As many as 18 claims were made for a total amount of Rs. 11,84,677.54 ps. In reply to the statement of claim, the petitioners filed their counter statement denying the claims. The parties were heard by the Arbitrator. The Award was given on 29th December, 1995. It was served on the petitioners on 5-1-1996. In the Award the claim of the Respondent has been allowed to the extent of Rs. 3,09,261.46 out of the total claim of Rs. 11,84,577.54.
2. I have heard the Counsel for the parties and perused the Award with the aid of the Counsel. Counsel for the petitioner has restricted the challenge to the Award with regard to claims Nos. 1, 9, 11, 15 and 18. With regard to claim No. 1, it is to be noticed that the amount awarded is Rs. 938.57 against the claim of Rs. 91,015.51. A perusal of the Award shows that the claim has been partly allowed after hearing arguments advanced by the parties. After discussing the various points raised, the Arbitrator has found it fit to award only an amount of Rs. 938.57 ps. This Court is unable to see any error apparent on the face of the record for setting aside the Award with regard to Claim No. 1.
3. The main challenge in the petition is with regard to claim No. 9. This claim as set out in the statement of claim is as under:
“We submit that the work was awarded to us on 26-11-1981 with the date of commencement to be reckoned as 11-12-1981 and specifying a period of 18 months for its completion. Accordingly the stipulated date of completion of the work was 10-6-1983. We submit that due to the various delays, hindrances and breaches of contract on the part of the respondents from time to time, the work could not be completed by the stipulated date of completion of 10-6-1983. The work prolonged beyond that date and was ultimately completed by us on or about 31-12-1983. We submit that during the prolonged period of construction 10-6-1983 to 31-12-1983 or period of 2/3 months, the prices of materials and labour had gone up considerably higher than those prevalent at the time of our tender and/than what we had contemplated while working out our tendered rates. We had to incur considerable extra expenditure in the prolonged period of contract due to increase in prices of materials and labour which we need not have incurred if the work was allowed to be completed by the originally stipulated date of completion of 10-6-1983. We submit that as well had to incur this extra expendiutre due to the delays, hindrances and breaches of contract on the part of the respondents from time to time, we are entitled to be compenstated for the same by the Respondents. We claim an amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- as compensation on this account from the Respondents and pray that the learned Arbitrator may be pleased to award the same to be paid us by the Respondent.
A perusal of the above shows that the claim is with regard to the delay in completion of the contract due to the hindrances and breaches of contract committed by the petitioner from time to time. It is claimed that the said work could not be completed on 10th June, 1983 and was in fact completed on 31st December, 1983. During this period of 6 months the prices of material and labour charges had gone up considerably higher than those prevailing at the time of the tender. Thus the respondents had claimed compensation in the sum of Rs. 3 lakhs. After considering the evidence placed on the record by the parties and after hearing the parties, the Arbitrator his granted only a sum of Rs. 1,40,352 against claim No. 9. According to the Counsel for the petitioner, these findings arrived at by the Arbitrator are beyond the compensation permitted under the contract. Counsel has relied upon clause 10(c) of the conditions of contract which were applicable with regard to rate, tender and contract for works in the Post and Telegraph Department, Civil Engineering Wing. This document sets out the conditions under which the contracts have to be awarded in the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. A perusal of this clause shows that if during the progress of the work, the price of any materials incorporated in the works or wages of labour increases as a direct result of coming into force of any fresh law or statutory rule or order, then the amount of contract is to be accordingly varied, provided, the increase payable is not attributable to delay in the execution of the contract within the control of the contractor. Any such increase in wages as a result of coming into force any fresh law is not to exceed 10 per cent of the wages previling at the time of the tender. Counsel for the petitioner does not claim any infringement of the above provision. He, however, submits that the Award has been given totally contrary to what is provided as under in clause 10C.
“The Contractor shall, for the purpose of this conditions keep such books of account and other documents as are necessary to show the amount of any increase claimed or reduction available and shall allow inspection of the same by a duly authorised representative of Government and further shall, at the request of the Engineer-in-Charge furnish verified in such a manner as the Engineer in charge may require any documents so kept and such other informations as the Engineer in charge may require.”
Relying on this clause, Learned Counsel Mr. Shah has submitted that the Respondents had failed to submit any accounts as required under this sub-clause. It is submitted in the absence of such accounts it was not permissible for the Arbitrator to award any amount to the Respondents. A perusal of the Award would, however, show that increase in fair wages has been proved before the Arbitrator on the basis of the Government notification dated 26th August, 1982 and October, 1983. The Respondents had also requested for the release of payment by their letter dated 28-1-1983. This fact was acknowledged by the respondents vide letter at Exhibit R-108. Thereafter the Respondent was directed to produce the books of accounts vide another letter which is exhibited at R-111 of the Award proceedings. This was duly filed by the Respondents. This was also acknowledged by the Respondents. Thereafter the Respondents were directed to produce books of account which were also duly produced. No complaints about the labour were received during the performance of the contract. It is observed that the Respondents have filed detailed calculations towards the claim wherein 10 per cent of the increase of the labour wages was absorbed by them. The net amount of escalation, therefore, works out to the amount awarded. It is categorically observed in the Award as under:
“In view of the above, it is quite evident that there was increase in the fair wages of labour due to Government notification during performance of the contract and the escalation was demanded by the claimant during execution of the work as provided under clause 10-C. The books of accounts were also produced by the Claimant for verification of the Respondent and also as per records, there was no labour complaint during this period in respect of payment of wages less than the fair wages as such the claimant was found fully entitled for escalation towards increase in the labour wages.
After going through the calculations filed by the claimant through his Annexure CA-15 the claim for Rs. 1,40,352.00 is found fully justified and accordingly the same is allowed in favour of claimant.”
A perusal of the extract of the Award above would clearly shown that the Arbitrator has not committed any error which can be said to be apparent on the face of the record. Counsel thereafter has highlighted the findings in the Award with regard to claim No. 11. It is stated that in this particular claim the Respondents have failed to submit the detailed analysis of rates as required under clause 12 of the conditions of contract. A perusal of the reasons given by the Arbitrator with regard to claim No. 11 shows that the claim has been divided into various subheadings from claim (i) to (vii). A perusal of the reasons shows that the Arbitrator has relied on the analysis of rates adopted by the respondents. Each and every item has been discussed in detail. In my view, it cannot be said that the findings given against claim No. 11 are such which go to the root of the Award. With regard to claim No. 15 it is submitted that there was no evidence whatsoever before the Arbitrator to come to the conclusion. A perusal of the reasons given by the Arbitrator, however, shows that the facts were admitted to the effect that the area where thermocole required to be used was restricted by the petitioner and the material brought by the Respondent was not accepted by the petitioner for use on any other work. Thus obviously the Arbitrator has come to the conclusion that the respondent was entitled to claim losses. Mr. Shah submitted that from the Award it is not apparent as to how the Arbitrator has arrived at the figure of Rs. 10,000/- as the losses sustained by the respondents. The Arbitrator has obviously arrived at the said figure on the basis of some evidence and reasons. This Court finds no error apparent on the face of award. With regard to claim No. 18, a perusal of the award shows that the interest granted in neither unreasonable nor unconscionable.
4. It is a settled proposition of law that the Court should not reappraise the evidence intrinsically or embark upon a close scrutiny of the same for arriving at the conclusion that the findings given by the Arbitrator are erroneous. Such exercise of power which can be exercised by the Appellate Court with power to reverse the findings of fact is alien to the scope and ambit of challenge of an Award under the Arbitration Act. It is only where the error of law or finding of fact is patent and is easily demonstrable without the necessity of carefully weighing the various possible views for it that the Courts can interfere with the Award. Only very limited grounds are permissible on which the Award can be set aside. The reasonableness of the reasons given by the Arbitrator are not to be adjudicated upon in the Arbitration proceedings. The scope of the Court in interfering with the Awards given by the Arbitrator has been settled by a catena of judgments of the Supreme Court and various High Courts. The Award made by an Arbitrator is conclusive as a judgment between the parties and the Court is entitled to set it aside only if the Arbitrator has misconducted himself in the proceeding or when the Award has been made contrary to the provisions of the contract. An Award being a decision of the Arbitrator chosen by the parties to decide the dispute submitted to him is ordinarily not liable to challenge on the ground that it is erroneous. It is ordinarily final and conclusive. Having examined the Award from all angles, this Court is of the view that no meaningful challenge has been made out in the petition. I find no merit in the petition. The same is hereby dismissed with no order as to costs.
5. Decree in terms of the Award with further interest from the date of decree till the date of payment at the rate of 15 per cent per annum.
Certified copy expedited.
Petition dismissed.
Alert