- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Anz Grindlays Bank Ltd. v. Anz Grindlays Bank Employees Union And Another
M.B Shah, C.J and A.Y Sakhare, J.:— Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
2. This Appeal is filed against the judgment and order passed by the learned Single Judge dismissing the writ petition filed, against the order passed by the Industrial Court on 30th June 1997.
3. The operative portion of the impugned order is as under:—
“(1) The demand of the union for regularisation of the 27 temporary workmen from Annexure ‘A’ is justified.
(2) The management is directed to regularise their services within six months from today.
(3) Fourteen workers who were already absorbed are not entitled to any reliefs as it is outside the scope of the reference.
(4) The action of the bank in terminating the service of the workmen mentioned in Annexure ‘B’ is not legal and justified.
(5) The management is directed to reinstate the workmen shown in Annexure ‘B’ in service from the date of their termination and pay back wages.
(6) The workmen shown in Exhibit ‘B’ are entitled to regularisation and the bank should do so within six months from today.
(7) The action of the bank in terminating the services of 27 workmen mentioned in the section of reference No. 26 of 1995 is not legal and justified.
(8) The management is directed to reinstate them in service from the date of their termination and pay them back wages.
(9) These workers were appointed as temporary and they are entitled to wages and bonus and no other reliefs as claimed.”
4. After considering all the contentions raised by the learned Counsel for the appellant, the learned Single Judge arrived at the conclusion that the aforesaid order cannot be faulted.
5. At the hearing of this Appeal, the learned Counsel for the appellant submitted that there was no evidence on record to establish that 27 workers have completed 240 days work and, therefore, the Industrial Court ought not to have granted reliefs.
6. As against this, it has been rightly pointed out that admittedly, the bank was having a register of employees and that register was not produced before the Court. From this conduct of the appellant, of not producing the record, the Courts below have rightly drawn an adverse inference. Further, the Tribunal, after appreciating the entire evidence led by the respondents, has arrived at the conclusion that the respondents have proved their case that the workmen have completed more than 240 days as temporary employees.
7. The learned counsel for the appellant further submits that with regard to the 9 workmen, the respondents have not examined those employees and, therefore, there is no evidence to establish that they have worked for more than 240 days. The learned Single Judge has discussed this aspect also and arrived at the conclusion that the evidence led by the union was sufficient to show that all the workers have worked for more than 240 days.
8. In this view of the matter, there is no substance in the Appeal and hence, it is dismissed.
9. Issuance of certified copy of this order is expedited.
10. Appeal Dismissed.
Alert