Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sonia Senroy v. Amit Senroy

Bombay High Court
Apr 22, 1998
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, Mrs. Sonia Senroy, filed a suit against her husband (the defendant) seeking permanent maintenance of Rs. 27,000 per month for herself and Rs. 7,000 per month for their minor son Johann (born 17 June 1987). The plaint includes Annexures Q and R that set out proposed expense heads for the plaintiff and the child respectively. The defendant has not filed a written statement but submitted an affidavit-in-reply to a Chamber Summons.

In August 1997 the plaintiff took out a Chamber Summons seeking: (a) an order directing the defendant to produce and permit inspection of documents listed in Schedule A and supply copies, and (b) an order directing the defendant to answer on oath the interrogatories in Schedule B.

The plaintiff's factual assertions include that she was forced to leave her job after marriage, that the defendant maintained an extramarital relationship with one Nikita Reddy who allegedly bore the defendant an illegitimate child, that physical abuse and marital breakdown occurred, and that the defendant has significant income from employment with Lufthansa and from interior decoration and trading businesses. The Chamber Summons seeks financial and documentary disclosure to determine the proper quantum of maintenance.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendant should be directed to produce and permit inspection of the documents specified in Schedule A and furnish copies to the plaintiff at this stage of the proceedings.
  2. Whether the defendant should be directed to answer on oath the interrogatories set out in Schedule B at this (interim) stage, prior to filing a written statement.
  3. Whether the Chamber Summons is a permissible procedure here or amounts to a premature or "fishing" enquiry.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The documents in Schedule A and the interrogatories in Schedule B are relevant and vital to establish the defendant's true earnings and financial position for fixing maintenance quantum for the plaintiff and their minor son.
  • The materials sought (income-tax returns 1990–1997, salary certificate from Lufthansa, deeds/agreements concerning properties, passbook entries of specified bank accounts, passport, and the birth certificate of the alleged illegitimate child) are within the defendant's exclusive control and therefore appropriate to inspect.
  • The interrogatories and document inspection are necessary to obtain admissions and evidence to prove the plaintiff's case on maintenance.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant's affidavit-in-reply contends that the documents relied upon by the plaintiff are not relevant to the suit and that the Chamber Summons is premature because no written statement has been filed by the defendant.
  • It was argued that interrogatories of the kind sought should be administered only at the time of final hearing, not at an interim stage.
  • The defendant characterized the Chamber Summons as fishing enquiries and submitted that it should be dismissed with costs.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jamaitrai v. Motilal Chamaria, AIR 1960 Cal. 536 That the administering of interrogatories is to be encouraged because they can bring actions to an earlier end; interrogatories should be confined to obtaining admissions of facts necessary for the party interrogating to prove his case. The court relied on this authority to support a liberal approach to allowing interrogatories and to conclude that the plaintiff's interrogatories and document inspection were properly confined to matters relevant to proving her maintenance claim and thus should be allowed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the Chamber Summons, the plaint, the schedules annexed to the Chamber Summons, the affidavit-in-support and the defendant's affidavit-in-reply. The analysis proceeded through the following steps, as reflected in the opinion:

  1. Identification of the relevance of the requested material: The court noted that Schedule A sought inspection of income-tax returns (1990–1997), a salary certificate from Lufthansa, deeds/agreements for properties, specified bank passbook entries, the defendant's passport, and the birth certificate of the alleged illegitimate child. Schedule B interrogatories concerned sources of income, clients and income from the defendant's interior designing business, and related financial matters.
  2. Assessment of the defendant's objections: The defendant argued the requests were irrelevant, premature because no written statement had been filed, and amounted to fishing enquiries. The court considered each objection.
  3. Statutory support for pre-written-statement interrogatories: The court cited Order XI, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code to hold that the plaintiff may deliver relevant interrogatories to the defendant even before the filing of a written statement and contrasted this with the general rule that a defendant cannot deliver interrogatories to the plaintiff prior to filing his written statement.
  4. Established principle on interrogatories: The court adopted the settled legal position that interrogatories are generally to be allowed whenever answers would either maintain the case of the party administering them or destroy the adversary's case, and that the power to serve interrogatories should be used liberally to shorten litigation and serve justice.
  5. Application to the present facts: The court found the defendant's contention about fishing enquiries and prematurity to be untenable. Given that the plaintiff must prove her claim for maintenance and that the quantum depends on the defendant's overall financial position, the court held that the documents and interrogatories sought were "extremely relevant" to the core issue of maintenance quantum.
  6. Outcome of the analysis: On this basis, the court concluded that the Chamber Summons must be allowed and that the defendant should be directed to comply with the inspection and interrogatory requirements within a specified period.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Chamber Summons was made absolute in terms of the plaintiff's prayer clauses (a) and (b). Specifically, the court ordered that:

  • The defendant is directed to give inspection of the documents in Schedule A and furnish copies thereof to the plaintiff within three weeks from the date of the order.
  • The defendant is directed to answer on oath the interrogatories set out in Schedule B within three weeks from the date of the order.
  • Chamber Summons disposed of; no costs were awarded.

Implications: The direct effect is that the defendant must comply with the disclosure and interrogatory directions within the three-week time frame. The opinion applied existing procedural law (Order XI, Rule 1 CPC) and an established case authority to allow pre-written-statement interrogatories and document inspection; the court did not state or establish any new legal precedent beyond applying settled principles to the facts. No broader implications or novel legal doctrines were discussed beyond the immediate orders made in this case.

Show all summary ...

1. This Chamber Summons is taken out by the plaintiff Mrs. Sonia Senroy, praying that the defendant be directed to produce and give Inspection of the documents incorporated in Schedule A annexed to the Chamber Summons and furnish copies thereof to the plaintiff. It is also prayed that defendant be directed to answer on oath the interrogatories set out at Schedule B of the Chamber Summons taken out by the Plaintiff.

2. The plaintiff, who is the wife of the defendant, has filed this Suit against the defendant husband praying that the defendant be directed to pay to the plaintiff a sum of Rs. 27,000/- per month by way of permanent maintenance for herself as set out in Exhibit Q annexed to the Plaint. It is also prayed that the defendant husband be directed to pay to the plaintiff for the minor child Johann, a sum of Rs. 7,000/- per month by way of permanent maintenance as set out at Annexure R to the plaint. In Annexure Q, the plaintiff has specified the expenses and has given a breakup under various heads like transportation, household expenses, servant's salary, telephone bill, society outgoing, electricity bill and miscellaneous/personal expenses. In the Annexure R, the plaintiff has specified the expenses incurred for the minor child Johann under various heads like education expenses, living expenses and clothes and medical expenses. The defendant has not so for filed his written statement.

3. Plaintiff and defendant are admittedly husband and wife. They also admittedly have a minor son called Johann born out of the said wedlock on 17th June, 1987, who is at present staying along with his mother/plaintiff.

4. The plaintiff's case is that before her marriage with the defendant, she was working for Cathay Pacific Airlines at the Sahar International Airport, but the defendant, after their marriage forced the plaintiff to leave her job. The defendant, prior to their marriage, was working at Panam Airlines at Sahar International Airport, and since 1983 onwards, he is working with the Lufthansa Airlines and continues to be in the employment there. The plaintiff and the defendant met sometime in the year 1982, fell in love and got married on 21st February, 1984 at Bombay in accordance with the Hindu Vedic Rites. Thereafter, they started residing at Bandra. Initially, the couple was residing along with the defendant's parents. It is the case of the plaintiff that right from the beginning, she was being harassed by her mother-in-law, and when the situation became intolerable, the plaintiff and defendant shifted to another house sometime in June, 1985 at Vakola. Thereafter, it appears that the relationship between the plaintiff and the defendant soared and the marriage was on the rocks. It is the case of the plaintiff that often the defendant would not return home even though he was not on night duty. She also found packets of Condom in defendant's trouser's pocket. On being confronted with the same, the defendant tried to give some excuse. This was again repeated when the defendant came back from one of his foreign trips. The plaintiff found out that defendant was having adulterous relationship with one Nikita Reddy, with whom he also entered into a marriage. The plaintiff also came to know that the said Nikita Reddy had given birth to illegitimate child of the defendant on 15th May, 1996. According to the plaintiff, the defendant's philandering continued and in fact, he contacted sexually transmitted fungal infection. Their marital relationship had completely broken down. There used to be continuous fights between them and defendant used to hit her on several occasions. It was around this time, the plaintiff learnt about the illegitimate child born to Nikita Reddy at Dr. Vasa's Hospital, Kandivli. Their relationship had hit a rock bottom. The defendant himself is living luxuriously while the plaintiff has to look after herself and her minor son Johann. Therefore, the plaintiff has filed this suit for maintenance for herself and the minor child Johann.

5. It is the case of the plaintiff that apart from the lucrative job which the defendant has, he also has a business of interior decoration which is paying him handsome dividends. Defendant is an extremely wealthy person and has huge amounts of accounted and unaccounted income. It is her estimate that the defendant's earning are approximately Rs. 1,00,000/- per month from various sources. According to her, defendant earns about Rs. 40,000/- from his business of bringing imported electronic goods and selling them in the Indian market. He also earns according to her, about Rs. 50,000/- per month from its assignments of interior decoration. He also earns Rs. 19,000/- plus allowances per month from his employment with Lufthansa Airlines. It is also her case that the defendant has inherited from his father and has earned Rs. 10,00,000/-. He owns a Chauffeur driven Maruti Van with an Air Conditioner: He also has modern amenities like colour TV., V.C.R, Microwave Oven, Music System, Air-Conditioners and other expensive items of furniture and fixtures and other immovable properties. He has also rented a lavish apartment at Green Meadows, Akurli Road, Lokhandwala Complex, Kandivli (East), and spends most of his non-working time along with Nikita and his illegitimate child. According to the plaintiff's case, the rent of that premises is Rs. 4,000/- per month.

6. The Chamber Summons was taken out by the plaintiff in August, 1997, praying that defendant be directed to produce and give inspection of various documents mentioned in Schedule A and that, he be directed to answer on oath the interrogatories set out at Schedule B annexed to the Chamber Summons. It is the case of the plaintiff that unless this information is furnished by the defendant, it will be difficult for her to prove her case about the earnings of the defendant, and this information is extremely relevant and vital for fixing the amount of maintenance for herself and for her minor son Johann as claimed by her.

7. The defendant has not filed any Written Statement, but he has filed affidavit-in-reply to the Chamber Summons taken out by the plaintiff for the above mentioned prayers.

8. It is submitted by the defendant in his affidavit-in-reply that he has not relied upon these documents mentioned by the plaintiff in the Annexures to the Chamber Summons, nor are they relevant for the purpose of the suit. According to the defendant, this Chamber Summons is premature and they can be administered only at the time of hearing and final disposal of the suit itself, and not at the interim stage. It is also submitted that since Written Statement is not so far filed by him, such an interrogatory cannot be administered by the plaintiff at this stage. According to the defendant, the present Chamber Summons is taken out only by way of making fishing enquiries, and hence, the Chamber Summons is liable to be dismissed with costs.

9. I have heard Mr. Grover appearing for the plaintiff and Ms. Rajani Iyer appearing for the defendant at length. I have also perused the plaint, Chamber Summons, affidavit-in-support, and the Schedules A and B annexed to the Chamber Summons, so also, the affidavit-in-reply of the defendant.

10. What is sought in Schedule A is the inspection of documents like certified copies of defendant's income-tax returns from the year 1990 to 1997, defendant's salary certificate in Lufthansa Airlines, and Deeds/Agreements with respect to three flats and one garage, which according to the plaintiff, the defendant has purchased. What the plaintiff wants is the inspection of these documents which are within the control and in the possession of only defendant. She also wants to have inspection of the Pass Book entries from 1990 till date of the defendant's bank about No. 3502 in the Shyamrao Vithal Co-operative Bank and his another Pass Book in the Jammu Kashmir Bank and in the State Bank of Mysore, Andheri (East) Branch. She also wants to have inspection of defendant's passport and birth certificate of defendant's illegitimate child.

11. In Schedule B, interrogatories are administered with respect to sources of income of the defendant, list of clients and income from Interior Designing business of the defendant, etc. It is the case of the plaintiff that in order to determine the defendant's true financial status, it is important that the defendant be asked to disclose the sources of funds and details of bank payments. In fact, in the affidavit-in-support of the Chamber Summons, in each paragraph, the plaintiff has explained as to why she needs inspection of these documents and why the interrogatories are administered which are mentioned in Annexure B. In the affidavit-in-reply, however, the defendant has parried all these submissions. The only stock answer of the defendant seems to be that these enquiries are in the nature of fishing enquiries and are not relevant. I totally disagree with these submissions. The contents of Annexures A and B are extremely relevant for the issue which is to be decided in the suit. The plaintiff has asked for permanent maintenance for herself and for her minor child Johann. Unless the overall picture of the defendant's financial status emerges clearly before the Court, the Court cannot determine whether plaintiff is justified in asking the quantum which she has asked by way of the maintenance for herself and for her child Johann.

12. The defendant's excuse that since he has not filed Written Statement, the plaintiff's Chamber Summons is premature, also is not tenable. The plaintiff under Order XI, Rule 1 of Civil Procedure Code can deliver relevant interrogatories to the defendant even before the filing of the Written Statement. In fact, the defendant, as a rule, is not allowed to deliver interrogatories to the plaintiff before he has filed Written Statement. It is not the other way round.

13. It is also a settled legal position that as a general rule, interrogatories are to be allowed, whenever the answer to them will serve either to maintain the case of the party administering them or to destroy the case of the adversary. The power to serve interrogatories is not meant to be confined within narrow technical limits. It should be used liberally, whenever it can shorten litigation and serve the interest of justice.

14. In the present case at hand, since the defendant has not filed any Written Statement, the question of destroying defendant's case does not arise. However, the plaintiff has to prove her case and has to be obtain admissions from the defendant to facilitate the proof of her own case.

15. Mr. Grover appearing for the plaintiff relied upon AIR 1960 Cal. 536, Jamaitrai v. Motilal Chamaria, wherein, it is observed by the learned Judge of the Calcutta High Court that, “Administering of interrogatories is to be encouraged because they not infrequently bring an action to an end at an earlier stage to the advantage of all parties concerned…….. Interrogatories should be confined to obtaining from the party interrogated admissions of facts which it is necessary for the party interrogating to prove in order to establish his case.”

16. I am in agreement with the submissions made by Mr. Grover, appearing for the plaintiff. The inspection of documents sought for by the plaintiff and the interrogatories delivered by the plaintiff to the defendant are absolutely relevant for deciding the question of quantum of maintenance prayed for by the plaintiff for herself and for her minor child. This in fact is the precise issue in the suit, and therefore, the plaintiff's Chamber Summons has to be allowed. Hence, the following order:

Chamber Summons is made absolute in terms of prayer clauses (a) and (b). Defendant is directed to give inspection of the documents in Schedule A annexed to the Chamber Summons and furnish copies thereof to the plaintiff within three weeks from today. He is also directed to answer on oath the interrogatories set out at Schedule B, annexed to the Chamber Summons within three weeks from today.

With these directions, Chamber Summons is disposed of. No costs.

Order accordingly.