- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Arun Digamber Varangaonkar v. Kharpe Gruh Udyog
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The Plaintiff, Arun Digamber Varangaonkar, carrying on business as a sole proprietor in the name "Gharkul Utpadane" (based in Amravati and also residing at an address in Bombay), filed a suit in the High Court's original side seeking, inter alia, perpetual injunctions against the Defendants for alleged trade mark and copyright infringement. The Plaintiff alleged long use since 12 August 1986 of the word marks "GHARKUL" and "GHARKUL UTPADANE" and an original artistic device of a triangular house-cum-roof-top with chimney, and claimed that the Defendants marketed spices packaged in a deceptively similar get-up (including a device and colour scheme) under the label "PHUL CHHAP".
The plaint pleaded sales and distribution of the Plaintiff's goods in Maharashtra including Bombay and in several other States. The Plaintiff annexed two cash memos to support availability of the Defendants' goods in Bombay and stated that some cause of action arose in Amravati outside the local limits of the Court's jurisdiction, but that a material part had accrued in Bombay, seeking leave under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent to maintain the suit in the High Court.
On 30 September 1993 the High Court granted leave under Clause 12 (ex parte). The Defendants later filed a chamber summons seeking revocation of the ex parte leave. In their supporting affidavit the Defendants alleged that statements in the plaint about sales in Bombay were false, that they neither sold nor appointed agents or distributors in Bombay, and that the two cash memos relied upon by the Plaintiff were not genuine evidence of retail sales by the Defendants in Bombay (alleging that one alleged retailer's premises was a private residence and typewriter repair business, and that the other address was that of a person connected to the Plaintiff). The Defendants also asserted that the parties reside and carry on their businesses at Amravati and that the balance of convenience favours trial at Amravati.
The Defendants served the chamber summons on the Plaintiff (service acknowledged in court) and the Plaintiff filed no affidavit in reply. The Court considered Clause 12 of the Letters Patent and Section 62 of the Copyright Act, 1957 in determining whether the ex parte leave should be revoked.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the ex parte leave previously granted under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent to permit the Plaintiff to maintain the suit in this Court should be revoked in view of the factual matrix and the Defendants’ challenge to the asserted Bombay connection.
- Whether, and to what extent, Section 62 of the Copyright Act, 1957 (which identifies district courts for copyright suits and permits a suitor to institute proceedings in a district where he actually and voluntarily resides or carries on business) affects the High Court's jurisdiction under Clause 12 and the proper forum in this case.
- Application of the forum conveniens (balance of convenience) doctrine: whether the material facts and convenience (place of residence/business of the parties, place where transactions occurred, volume and location of evidence, expenses of trial) favour trial in Bombay or in Amravati.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Position
- The Plaintiff alleged long-standing use of the word marks "GHARKUL" and "GHARKUL UTPADANE" and a distinctive triangular house-cum-roof-top device since 12 August 1986 on his products and packaging.
- The Plaintiff claimed that the Defendants marketed spices and food preparations in a get-up, colour scheme and device deceptively similar to the Plaintiff's, thereby causing likely confusion among (particularly semi-illiterate or illiterate) consumers.
- The Plaintiff relied on two cash memos (test purchases) annexed to the plaint to show that the Defendants' disputed goods were available in Bombay, and he served a pre-suit notice on the Defendants on 28 July 1993.
- The plaint states that part of the cause of action arose in Amravati but that a material part arose in Bombay, and accordingly leave under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent was sought and granted.
Defendants' Arguments
- The Defendants asserted that the plaint contains false and incorrect statements regarding sales in Bombay: they averred they neither sold nor made their goods commercially available in Bombay, nor appointed stockists, dealers or distributors there, nor employed salesmen for Bombay.
- Concerning the two cash memos, the Defendants stated that one address (Amruta Traders at Tulsi Baug) was in fact a residence-cum-typewriter repair business and that Amruta Traders did not carry on retail business there; the other address belonged to a person related to the Plaintiff. The Defendants suggested the cash memos were not genuine evidence of their sales in Bombay and that Amruta Traders had acted as agents of the Plaintiff.
- The Defendants emphasized that both Plaintiff and Defendants reside and conduct business in Amravati, that the manufacturing of the disputed goods occurs in Amravati, and that the balance of convenience for trial is in Amravati rather than in Bombay.
- The Defendants sought revocation of the ex parte leave previously granted under Clause 12 on these bases.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by analysing the scope of Clause 12 of the Letters Patent. It observed that Clause 12 grants original jurisdiction to the High Court in cases other than suits for land where the cause of action has arisen wholly or in part within the local limits of the High Court's ordinary original jurisdiction, or if the defendant dwells or carries on business within those limits. The Court noted the present dispute was not about land or immovable property and so the ordinary non-land provisions of Clause 12 applied.
The Court then considered Section 62 of the Copyright Act, 1957, which governs the forum for suits arising under the Copyright Act. The opinion cites subsection (1) (that suits under that Chapter be instituted in a district court having jurisdiction) and subsection (2), which defines a “district Court having jurisdiction” to include a district where the person instituting the suit actually and voluntarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain.
The Court explained the interplay between Section 62 and Clause 12: subsection (2) of Section 62 enables a suitor to file a copyright suit in a district where he actually and voluntarily resides or carries on business, thereby providing an exceptional forum choice for the plaintiff. However, the Court held that Section 62 cannot oust the High Court's jurisdiction under the Letters Patent, and that the High Court must nonetheless determine whether it is appropriate to exercise its original jurisdiction in a given case. The Court emphasised that it would not entertain a suit under the Copyright Act where the whole of the cause of action has not arisen within its jurisdiction, or a material part has not arisen there, or where the balance of convenience strongly favours proceeding in another court.
In applying forum convenience, the Court set out relevant considerations (drawn from the record): parties' places of residence and business, where transactions took place, the volume of evidence and convenience or inconvenience of producing it at the forum, expenses of trial, and other relevant matters.
Turning to the facts before it, the Court noted that the plaint itself showed the Plaintiff mainly resided at Amravati and carried on business and manufacturing there; likewise the Defendants resided and carried on manufacturing at Amravati. The Court observed that, apart from two cash memos annexed to the plaint, there was no other prima facie material to show sales of the Defendants' disputed goods in Bombay or within this Court's jurisdiction. The Court found the Plaintiff's principal residence and the location of manufacturing and the likely bulk of evidence pointed to Amravati. Given these considerations, the balance of convenience favoured trial at Amravati, which would save parties unnecessary expense and allow convenient production of evidence.
On this basis the Court concluded that the ex parte leave previously granted under Clause 12 deserved revocation.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: EX PARTE LEAVE GRANTED UNDER CLAUSE 12 IS REVOKED.
Direct consequences stated in the opinion:
- The Court revoked the ex parte leave earlier granted under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent.
- The chamber summons filed by the Defendants seeking revocation of the ex parte leave was allowed.
- No costs were awarded.
Broader implications: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new principle of law; it applies existing provisions (Clause 12 of the Letters Patent and Section 62 of the Copyright Act) and the forum conveniens doctrine to the facts, and therefore the decision's effect (as expressed in the order) is limited to the revocation of the ex parte leave and allowing of the chamber summons in this case. No new precedent was declared in the text of the opinion.
Order accordingly.
This summary is strictly confined to the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add facts or conclusions beyond that text.
1. The Defendants by this chamber summons pray for revocation of leave granted ex parte under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent.
2. Arun Digamber Varangaonkar, the Plaintiff has filed the suit before this Court on original side against the Defendants praying therein that Defendants by themselves, their servants, agents, stockists and distributors be restrained by perpetual injunction from using the house-cum-trade mark being the device of a crude house-cum-roof top or any other mark which is deceptively similar to the trade mark of the Plaintiff being the device of a triangular roof top with chimney of the Plaintiff in relation to Defendants' masala product and spices preparation so as to pass off and/or likely to pass off and/or enable others to pass off the said preparation as and for the preparation of the Plaintiff bearing their trademark GHARKUL and device mark aforesaid. The Plaintiff also prays that Defendants be restrained by perpetual injunction from using the label or package being Exhibit O and P annexed to the plaint which is deceptively similar to and/or a colourable imitation of the package/carton/label of Plaintiff being Exhibit L and M annexed to the plaint so as to pass off and/or likely to pass off and/or enable to pass off Defendants preparations as advertisement for the preparation of plaintiff. The Plaintiff has also sought perpetual injunction against the Defendants from publishing, printing and causing to be printed and/or using whether in relation to goods or not the infringed piratical work as depicted in Exhibit O and P annexed to the plaint and thereby infringing or causing to be infringed the original artistic work of Plaintiff and thereby committing an infringement of the copy right of the Plaintiff's said original artistic work. A decree of Rs. 2 lacs is also prayed by the Plaintiff against the Defendants by way of damages for the use of the impugned trademark and device of the label, carton and package complained.
3. In the plaint the Plaintiff has averred that he carries business as sole proprietor in the name and style of Gharkul Utpadane at Badnera Road, Amravati. He resides at Amravati and also resides at 101-A. Garden View, Borivali (East), Bombay. The Plaintiff manufactures and markets spices, masalas and condiment powders meant for cooking purposes for both vegetarian and non-vegetarian dishes and pickles. These preparations are sold in Maharashtra including Bombay and in other States of Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Gujarat. According to Plaintiff the Defendants carry on business inter alia of manufacturing and marketing spices, masalas and condiment powders used for cooking purposes and the Defendants' said preparations are sold in Amravati and also at Bombay. The Plaintiff avers in the plaint that with effect from 12th August-86 the firm's preparations such as mutton-masala and various kinds of similar food preparations under the trade mark GHARKUL and GHARKUL UTPA-DANE were placed in the market and the words GHARKUL and GHARKUL UT-PADANE in the roman script as also the word GHARKUL in devnagri script were and are used as trademark for the said preparations of the Plaintiff. It is the case of the Plaintiff that in combination with the words Gharkul and Gharkul Utpadane uses and original artistic work which is a distinctively triangular shaped device of house-cum-roof top with chimney which original artistic work-cum trade mark has been used by the Plaintiff and his predecessor in title since 12th August-1986. The Plaintiff states in the plaint that the triangular device depicting a house top with chimney with the words Gharkul Utpadane rendered in the roman script and in the devnagri script appears on all preparations of the plaintiffs or on all packages, cartons, letterheads and visiting cards of the Plaintiff. According to Plaintiff the word mark ‘Gharkul’ and ‘Gharkul Utpadane’ and the distinctive devices are trade marks which belong to him and Plaintiff is the owner and proprietor of the said trade marks. According to him applications for registration of the various trade marks in the office of the registrar of trade marks at Bombay have been filed, details of which have been given in the plaint and the said applications are pending in the trade marks Registrar's office in Bombay. The Plaintiff claims to have acquired considerable goodwill and good reputation amongst the trade and the consumers in relation to spices, food preparations and pickles bearing the trade mark ‘Gharkul’, ‘Gharkul Utpadane’ and the distinctive device referred above. The grievance of the plaintiff is that the Defendants have introduced in the market preparations packed in packages and/or cartons being the same get-up, same colours scheme and same scheme of arrnagement as appears on the genuine cartons and packages of the Plaintiff. These packages also have the main feature of the red colour background with the device of crude house-cum proof top with chimney in yellow and white background and in place of trademark GHARKUL the word ‘PHUL CHHAP’ is rendered in Devnagri script in the same yellow colour as used by the Plaintiff. By this act of the Defendants the semi-illeterate or illeterate consumers of the Plaintiff are likely to be confused or deceived. The Plaintiff caused enquiry and found that these preparations of the Defendants were available in Bombay and caused, its purchases to be made. Two cash memos in respect of the test purchases made by the Plaintiff from Messrs. Amruta Traders have been placed on record to demonstrate the preparations being the impugned trademark and infringing copy of artistic work of the Plaintiff. Plaintiff before filing the suit served a notice to the Defendants through its advocate on 28th July-93 and they were asked to desist from using the crude house-cum-roof top and get-up, colour scheme and scheme of arrangement similar to that of Plaintiff. The Defendants through their trademark attorney replied to the notice given by the plaintiff and denied and disputed Plaintiffs' claims and contentions. In paragraph-27 of the plaint it is averred by the Plaintiff that part of the cause of action of the manufacture of the impugned preparations bearing the impugned trade mark and impugned get-up of the package complained of has arisen in Amravati outside local limit of jurisdiction of this Court, though material part of cause of action has accrued in Bombay and accordingly sought leave under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent.
4. On 30th September-93 this Court granted leave to the Plaintiff under Clause-12 of the Letters Patent.
5. In the affidavit accompanying the chamber summons the Defendants have stated that false and incorrect statements have been made in the plaint. According to the Defendants, they have been residing and carrying on business of manufacturing and sale of spices bearing the trademark complained of at Amravati and at no point of time they ever sold their spices complained in Bombay nor are their said goods commercially available for sale in Bombay. According to Defendants they have not appointed any stockist, dealer or distributor for sale of spices bearing the trademark in question in Bombay nor any retail sales of the said spices bearing the disputes trademark have been effected in Bombay. The Defendants have not employed any salesman to sell the said goods in Bombay and according to them they have no commercial dealing with any party in Bombay. Regarding the two cash memos annexed by the Plaintiff with the plaint, the Defendants state that, on visit to the premises of Amruta Traders, Tulsi Baug, 2/26, 1st Floor, Manmala Tank Road, Matunga West from where the Plaintiff alleges to have purchased the goods, it transpired that it was residence-cum-business premises of one Mr. V.P Pande and at that place business of selling, servicing and repairing of typewriters was being carried out under the name and style of Vishal Typewriter Service Centre. The visiting card of the said Mr. V.P Pande has been placed on record. According to the Defendants no firm by the Amruta Traders is carrying on business from the said place, nor had carried on business from the said place. As regards other addresses mentioned in cash-memos viz. 14A/A1, Avdhut Nagar, Chhatrapati Shivaji Road, Dahisar (East), Bombay, it is averred that the said place is residence of Mr. S.R Saraf and he is relative and connected with the Plaintiff. Amruta Traders were acting as agents of the Plaintiff and for some time promoted and/or sold and/or distributed the goods of the plaintiff in Bombay, and, the said cash memos were obtained from Amruta Traders without actually selling the Defendants' spices. In the affidavit the Defendants also stated that Plaintiff as well as Defendants Nos. 2 and 3 have been residing and carrying on business at Amravati and both of them have been manufacturing and selling spices bearing their respective trademarks in and around Amravati. The entire evidence relating to business of the Plaintiff is at Amravati and, therefore, balance of convenience for the trial of the suit is at Amravati.
6. The learned counsel appearing for the Defendants submitted that Plaintiff has been served of this chamber summons on 7-10-96 through their advocate on record. He undertakes to file a affidavit of service to that effect. Despite service of chamber summons upon the plaintiff, no affidavit in reply has been filed by the Plaintiff.
7. Clause 12 of the Letters Patent reads thus:
“12. Original jurisdiction as to suits. And we do further ordain that the said High Court of Judicature at Bombay in the exercise of its ordinary original civil jurisdiction, shall be empowered to receive, try and determine suits of every description of, in the case of suits for land or other immovable property, such land or property shall be situated or on all other cases if the cause of action shall have arisen, either wholly, or in case the leave of the Court shall have been first obtained, in part, within the local limits of the ordinary original jurisdiction of the said High Court, or if the defendant at the time of the commencement of the suit shall dwell or carry on business, or personally work for gain, within such limits; except that the said High Court shall not have such original jurisdiction in cases falling within the jurisdiction of the Small Cause Court at Bombay, in which the debt or damage or value of the property sued for, does not exceed one hundred rupees.”
8. The present suit is not suit for land or any immovable property and, therefore, provision relating thereto in Clause 12 has no application. The claim here relates to other than land or immovable property and would be entertainable and triable by this Court, under Clause 12 of Letters Patent if the whole of cause of action has arisen within the jurisdiction of this Court or by the leave of this Court obtained first if part of cause of action has arisen within the local limits of the jurisdiction of this Court.
9. In the present suit filed by the plaintiff, the claim is made in respect of the infringement of the copy right under the Copylight Act, 1957 and Sec. 62 of the Copyright Act which is relevant reads thus:
“62. (1) Every suit or other civil proceeding arising under this Chapter in respect of the infringement of copyright in any work or the infringement of any other right conferred by this Act shall be instituted in the district Court having jurisdiction.
(2) For the purpose of sub-section (1), a “district Court having jurisdiction” shall, notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, or any other law for the time being in force, include, a district Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction, at the time of the institution of the suit or other proceeding, the person instituting the suit or other proceeding or, where there are more than one such persons, any of them actually and voluntarily resides or carried on business or personally works for gain.”
10. From the perusal of the plaint itself, it transpires that plaintiff mainly resides at Amravati and he carries on business also at Amravati. The goods are also manufactured by Plaintiff at Amravati. The Defendants reside at Amravati and they also manufacture the goods concerning the disputed trade mark and the device at Amravati. Except two cash memos produced by the Plaintiff along with the plaint there is no other material prima facie showing the sale of the disputed goods manufactured by the Defendants in Bombay or within the jurisdiction of this Court. Subsection (2) of Sec. 62 of the Copyright provides that the suit in respect of the infringement of the copy right or any right conferred under the Copyright Act shall be instituted in the district Court within local limits of whose jurisdiction the person instituting the suit actually and voluntarily resides or carries business or presently works for gain. Obviously sub-section (2) of Sec. 62 enables the suitor to file the suit or initiate civil proceedings arising under Chapter XII of Copyright Act in the District Court within whose jurisdiction he actually and voluntarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain. This wholesome exceptional provision is intended to save suitor if he so desires for redressal of his grievance in respect of the infringement of copyright or any right conferred under the Copyright Act from suing at the place where defendant resides or carries on business. Section 62 of Copyright Act, of course, cannot take away the jurisdiction of this Court which it has under Letters Patent but at the same time this Court shall not entertain and try a suit under Copyright Act where whole of cause of action has not arisen within it's jurisdiction or material part of cause of action has not arisen within its jurisdiction or where through some part of cause of action has arisen within its jurisdiction but balance of convenience strongly and definately is in favour of suit being proceeded within some other Court. In applying the doctrine of forum convenience the Court may consider place of residence or business of the parties, the place where transactions took place, the volume of evidence and convenience or inconvenience of producing it at a particular forum, expenses of trial and such other relevant considerations. As already observed earlier, plaintiff in his plaint has himself come out with the case that he resides at Amravati and also at Bombay. The principal residence of the plaintiff, therefore, appears to be at Amravati. The goods are also manufactured at Amravati. The Defendants, according to Plaintiff himself reside at Amravati and carry on business at Amravati. The volume of evidence that may be led by the parties can be conveniently produced at Amravati. The trial at Amravati shall save the parties from unnecessary expenses and, therefore, balance of convenience definitely would be if the suit is tried at Amravati.
11. Taking into consideration the entire facts and circumstances of the case, I am of the view, that ex parte leave granted by this Court deserves to be revoked which I hereby do.
12. Chamber summons is accordingly allowed. No costs.
Order accordingly.
Alert