Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajashri Rajendra Shasane v. Rajendra Babulal Shasane .

Bombay High Court
Sep 27, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion — M.L. Dudhat, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This First Appeal challenges the judgment and decree dated 19 February 1994 in M.J. Petition No. 576 of 1990 issued by the 3rd Family Court, Bombay. The Family Court had granted a decree of divorce under section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.

The parties were married on 7 December 1986. The appellant (wife) returned to her parental home in October 1987 to give birth and had a daughter, Tejasari, on 14 January 1988. The respondent-husband initiated divorce proceedings under section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act, claiming cruelty and desertion (specifically under section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b)). Although the petition before the Family Court was framed on those grounds, the Family Court converted the petition into one for divorce by mutual consent under section 13-B and granted the divorce. The Family Court also directed payment of Rs. 40,000 as permanent alimony to the appellant and ordered Rs. 600 per month as child maintenance from the date of its order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Family Court may convert and grant a decree under section 13-B (divorce by mutual consent) when the petition before it was filed under section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b) for cruelty and desertion and there was no petition under section 13-B filed by both parties.
  2. Whether a decree of divorce under section 13-B can be validly passed without compliance with the mandatory requirements of section 13-B(2) and the requirement under section 23(1)(bb) that the court satisfy itself that consent was not obtained by force, fraud or undue influence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant's petition before the Family Court was filed under section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b) (cruelty and desertion), not under section 13-B.
  • No petition for divorce by mutual consent under section 13-B was filed by both parties; therefore the Family Court had no jurisdiction to pass a decree under section 13-B.
  • The Family Court's conversion of the petition into one under section 13-B and the subsequent decree on that basis was illegal and without jurisdiction.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any arguments advanced by the respondent.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds from the admitted factual and procedural posture: the petition before the Family Court was filed by the appellant on the grounds of cruelty and desertion under section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b), and there was no petition before that Court under section 13-B for divorce by mutual consent.

The Family Court had observed (in paragraph 9 of its judgment) that the parties had been living separately for more than one year, that there was no cohabitation, that the appellant had only claimed maintenance, and that the parties had voluntarily prayed for dissolution. The appellate Court noted that those observations cannot substitute for a properly filed and plead petition under section 13-B by both parties.

The opinion emphasizes the statutory structure and mandatory procedure of section 13-B:

  • Section 13-B requires a petition for divorce by mutual consent to be filed by both parties, based on factual averments such as separation for one year or more and their mutual agreement to dissolve the marriage.
  • Sub-section (2) of section 13-B mandates a time frame and procedure: after filing, upon motion of both parties not earlier than six months and not later than eighteen months, the Court must be satisfied—after hearing the parties and making such inquiry as it thinks fit—that the marriage was solemnized and the averments of the petition are true, before passing a decree. This provision is treated as mandatory and non-discretionary.
  • Oral statements at the time of arguments that the parties have mutually agreed cannot convert an existing petition under section 13(1)(i-a)/(i-b) into a valid section 13-B petition.
  • Section 23(1)(bb) requires the court, before passing a decree under section 13-B, to satisfy itself that consent was not obtained by force, fraud or undue influence. That is an additional mandatory safeguard which must be observed by the Court before granting a mutual consent divorce.

Because there was no petition under section 13-B filed by both parties, and because the Family Court did not (and could not) comply with the mandatory preconditions of section 13-B(2) and the safeguard of section 23(1)(bb), the appellate Court concluded that the Family Court had acted without jurisdiction in passing the decree under section 13-B.

Holding and Implications

The decree passed under section 13-B is set aside and the matter is remanded to the Family Court for fresh adjudication of M.J. Petition No. 576 of 1990.

Direct consequences and directions given by the appellate Court:

  • The judgment and decree dated 19 February 1994 (M.J. Petition No. 576 of 1990) are set aside because the decree under section 13-B was passed without jurisdiction.
  • The matter is remanded to the Family Court for a fresh decision on the original petition filed on the grounds of cruelty and desertion (section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b)).
  • The Family Court is directed to decide the amount of maintenance afresh, allowing both parties to lead fresh evidence.
  • As an interim measure, until final disposal of the petition, the respondent-husband is directed to continue paying Rs. 600 per month to the appellant for the maintenance of the child.
  • The Family Court is directed to dispose of the petition expeditiously and in any case within six months from the date it receives the record from the appellate Court; the appellate Court's registry is directed to send the record forthwith and to expedite certified copies.

The opinion does not announce or rely upon any new judicial precedent; it rests on the statutory requirements and the conclusion that those statutory procedures had not been followed by the Family Court in this case.

Order accordingly.
Show all summary ...

M.L Dudhat, J.:— This First Appeal is filed against the judgment and decree dated 19th February, 1994 in M.J Petition No. 576 of 1990 passed by the learned Judge, 3rd Family Court, Bombay. By the aforesaid judgment and decree, the Family Court passed the decree of divorce under section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.

2. In this appeal, the Appellant who is the wife of the respondent got married with the respondent on 7-12-1986. Sometime in the month of October 1987, appellant returned to her parental home for delivery and gave birth to a female child named Tejasari on 14-1-1988. Respondent-husband filed the present petition under section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act for a decree of divorce against the present appellant on the grounds of cruelty and desertion i.e under section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b) of the Hindu Marriage Act. The Family Court, while delivering the judgment converted the said petition into a petition for divorce by mutual consent under section 13-B of the Act and granted divorce. The Family Court has also directed the respondent-husband to pay an amount of Rs. 40,000/- towards the permanent alimony to the present appellant and also directed the respondent-husband to pay Rs. 600/- per month towards maintenance of the child from the date of the order.

3. Mr. Kanade, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant-wife, submitted that the appellant filed the said petition for divorce before the Family Court under section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b) of the Hindu Marriage Act i.e on the grounds of cruelty and desertion. Admittedly, before the Family Court, at no point of time petition for divorce by mutual consent under section 13-B of the said Act was ever filed by the Appellant and the Respondent. In spite of that, the Family Court surprisingly passed the decree under section 13-B of the Act and granted divorce by mutual consent. The aforesaid decision, according to the learned counsel for the Appellant, is illegal and without jurisdiction.

4. It is an admitted position that the present appellant filed petition for divorce on the grounds of cruelty and desertion under section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b) of the Act. It is also admitted that there is no petition for divorce by mutual consent as contemplated under section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act. If that is so, one fails to understand as to how the Family Court could have passed the decree of divorce under section 13-B of the Act when the petition was filed by the Appellant-wife for divorce under section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b) of the Hindu Marriage Act. In para 9 of the judgment, the Family Court has observed that from the statement of the petitioner and the respondent, it is clear that they are living separately for more than one year and there is no cohabitation between the parties from the date of the said separation. Appellant has claimed only the maintenance from the respondent-husband. The Family Court further observed that the parties have voluntarily prayed for dissolution of their marriage. One fails to understand as to how the Family Court can make such observations when there is no petition whatsoever by the husband for dissolution of the marriage. On these grounds the trial Court held that parties are entitled to the decree of divorce under section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act.

5. The Family Court has completely lost sight of the fact that in the present case, the petition is filed by the Appellant-wife only for divorce under section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b) of the Act on the grounds of cruelty and desertion. In order to pass a decree of divorce by mutual consent, both the parties have to file a petition for divorce by mutual consent on the ground that they have been living separately for a period of one year or more and that they are unable to live together and that they have mutually agreed that their marriage should be dissolved. Further, under sub-section (2) of section 13-B of the Act, after the said petition is filed, on the motion of both the parties made six months thereafter and not later than eighteen months after the filing of the said petition, if the petition is not withdrawn in the meantime, the Court shall, on being satisfied, after hearing the parties and after making such inquiry as it thinks fit, that the marriage has been solemnized and that the averments in the petition are true, pass a decree of divorce declaring the marriage to be dissolved with effect from the date of the decree. Further, the provision under sub-section (2) of section 13-B is mandatory and no discretion is given to the Court to convert the petition for divorce under section 13 on the grounds of cruelty and desertion unless the said conversion is done by mutual consent of both the parties. Parties merely agreeing orally at the time of arguments that they have mutually agreed that their marriage should be dissolved, the Petition filed under section 13(1)(i-a) and (i-b) cannot be treated to have been filed under section 13-B and decree for divorce by mutual consent cannot be passed in such a situation. Further, it is also a mandatory provision under section 23(1)(bb) of the Act that before passing the decree under section 13-B, the Court has to satisfy itself that consent has not been obtained by force, fraud or under undue influence. According to our opinion, since there was no petition before the Family Court under section 13-B of the Act by both the parties mutually agreeing for a divorce by mutual consent, the decree passed by the trial Court in the present case is liable to be set aside as the same has been passed without jurisdiction and, therefore, is illegal. In view of this, the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court dated 19th February, 1994 passed in divorce petition bearing No. M.J Petition No. 576 of 1990 is set aside and the matter is remanded back to the Family Court for its fresh decision on the M.J Petition 576 of 1990 filed on the grounds of cruelty and desertion. The trial Court has also to decide the amount of maintenance by allowing both the parties to lead fresh evidence. However, as and by way of interim measure, till the final disposal of the said petition before the Family Court, respondent-husband is directed to continue to pay the amount of Rs. 600/- per month to the Appellant-wife for the maintenance of the child. In view of the fact that the petition filed by the Appellant is pending for a long time, Family Court is directed to dispose of the said petition as expeditiously as possible, in any case within six months from the date of the receipt of the record from this Court to the Family Court. Office of this Court is directed to send back the record to the Family Court forthwith. Certified copy expedited.

Order accordingly.