Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

B.V. Manek (Dr.) v. Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd.

Bombay High Court
Aug 19, 1995
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Comprehensive Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Leave under Rules 147 and 148 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay (O.S.) Rules, 1980 was granted to the plaintiff to take out a Notice of Motion in terms of a draft notice handed in; by consent the Notice of Motion was made returnable forthwith and placed for hearing, and the defendant waived service.

The plaintiff is a medical doctor. Pursuant to an application in December 1987, Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited (M.T.N.L.) provided a special-category telephone connection to the plaintiff bearing Telephone No. 5603314 at the plaintiff's residence (an address in Mulund, Bombay). The telephone was later shifted to the plaintiff's then-present address. It is admitted that the plaintiff paid all bills in respect of telephone No. 5603314.

The plaintiff's principal grievance is that the defendant disconnected the plaintiff's telephone without issuing any prior notice and without assigning reasons. The plaintiff alleged that this arbitrary action caused grave hardship and therefore moved the court for mandatory interim reliefs (seeking reconnection).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited (M.T.N.L.) has the power, under Rule 443 of the Indian Telegraph Rules, to disconnect the telephone of a relation (or other person) of a subscriber on account of the default of that subscriber.
  2. Whether Rule 443 authorizes disconnection of any other telephone(s) rented to the subscriber (as distinct from being limited to the particular telephone in respect of which default has been committed).

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff's telephone (No. 5603314) was disconnected without prior notice and without reasons.
  • The plaintiff has paid all bills relating to that telephone.
  • The disconnection caused grave and serious hardship.
  • The plaintiff sought mandatory interim reliefs (reconnection) by way of Notice of Motion.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant contended that the plaintiff's telephone had been placed under special disconnection with effect from April 20, 1995, under instructions reflected in a Dy. General Manager (TRA) letter dated May 11, 1994.
  • It was averred that V.N. Manek (the plaintiff's father) was a subscriber of telephone No. 5680227 and had fallen into arrears; despite oral and written requests he failed to clear the arrears, and his telephone was disconnected.
  • The defendant produced a notice dated November 8, 1994 to V.N. Manek for clearance of outstanding dues and claimed a copy of that notice had been marked to the plaintiff for information; the defendant asserted that the plaintiff's phone was being suspended because it was used by V.N. Manek and family members.
  • The defendant relied upon Rule 443 of the Indian Telegraph Rules as empowering disconnection for default in payment.
  • Ms. Shah, counsel for the defendant, relied upon S. Thangam v. Area Manager (Madras High Court, Writ Petition No. 5903 of 1987) as supporting authority (the court, however, found that decision distinguishable on the facts).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Santokh Singh v. Divisional Engineer, Telephones, Shillong (AIR 1990 Gau 47) Held that Rule 443 cannot be interpreted to vest power to disconnect any other telephone in the name of the same subscriber; power confined to the particular telephone in respect of which there is default. The court recorded this as one line of authority and contrasted it with a contrary view; the opinion notes the divergence but ultimately preferred the Gujarat High Court's approach over this view for the purposes of construing the rules.
Indravadan Pranlal Shah v. General Manager, Ahmedabad Telephones (AIR 1990 Guj 85) Held that if dues of a telephone are not paid by the subscriber, "any telephone or telephones or any telex service rented by him" can be disconnected without notice; relied on the definition of "subscriber" and applied to partners in a firm. The court expressed respectful agreement with the Gujarat High Court, describing that judgment as consistent with the scheme under the rules and accepting that the Department has power to disconnect any other telephone rented to the subscriber.
S.M. Ayua v. Union of India (Writ Appeal No. 1151 of 1987, decided 8-11-1990) (Madras High Court) The Madras High Court agreed with the Gujarat High Court's interpretation that Rule 443's words "rented by him" refer to the subscriber and that other telephones rented to the subscriber may be disconnected. The court recorded its respectful agreement with the view of the Gujarat High Court and noted the Madras High Court's concurrence; the present court observed the Madras decision while also noting differences in factual context between that case and the present facts.
Y. Pridhvi Kumar v. General Manager, Telecom District, Hyderabad (AIR 1993 Andh Pra 131) Held that disconnection of the telephone of a son (relation) would be arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. The court cited this authority to support the proposition that disconnecting a relation's independently-held telephone on account of another subscriber's default is arbitrary and impermissible.
Smt. Krishan Kumar v. Delhi Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd. (1989 Raj LR 393 (DB)) Held that "subscriber" means the person or firm who subscribed and does not include relations who have independent connections; DMT Nigam cannot demand dues or threaten disconnection from relations of a defaulter. The court cited this decision as supportive authority for the proposition that relations with independent connections cannot be penalized by disconnection for another person's dues.
S. Thangam v. Area Manager (Madras High Court, Writ Petition No. 5903 of 1987 dated August 4, 1987) In the facts before that court (a partnership firm in arrears, minors admitted to benefit of firm and represented by their mother), the telephone of the latter was held liable to be disconnected because of the firm's default. The present court found that the facts in S. Thangam were clearly distinguishable and held that the decision was inapplicable to the facts of the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying the relevant statutory scheme in the Indian Telegraph Rules (Part V), describing various rules dealing with disconnection (Rules 420, 421, 424, 439, 440, 442 and 443). The court reproduced Rule 443 in full, since that Rule specifically addresses consequences of default in payment:

“443. Default of payment.— If, on or before the due date, the rent or other charges in respect of the telephone service provided are not paid by the subscriber in accordance with these rules, or bills for charges in respect of calls (local and trunk) or phonograms or other dues from the subscriber are not duly paid by him, any telephone or telephones or any telex service rented by him may be disconnected without notice...”

The court analyzed the textual phrase "rented by him" and the statutory definition of "subscriber." It observed that a "subscriber" is a person who has subscribed for a particular telephone (which may be an individual, partnership firm or corporate body). On a plain reading, Rule 443 contemplates disconnection of a telephone of the subscriber.

The court recognized a divergence of authority on whether Rule 443 permits disconnection only of the particular telephone in respect of which default occurred or of any telephone rented to the subscriber. It summarized the contrary holdings of the Gauhati High Court (Santokh Singh) — which limited disconnection to the particular defaulting telephone — and the Gujarat High Court (Indravadan Pranlal Shah) — which permitted disconnection of any telephone(s) rented to the subscriber. The Madras High Court was noted as agreeing with the Gujarat view.

The court recorded its respectful agreement with the Gujarat High Court's interpretation that the Department has the power to disconnect any other telephone rented by the subscriber, describing that position as consistent with the scheme framed under the rules. However, the court drew a clear distinction between (a) disconnecting other telephones rented to the same subscriber and (b) disconnecting a telephone belonging to a relation who is not the subscriber.

For the latter point (disconnecting a relation's independently held telephone), the court relied upon authorities (including the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Y. Pridhvi Kumar and the Delhi High Court in Smt. Krishan Kumar) which held that disconnecting the telephone of a relation (who had an independent connection) would be arbitrary and violative of Article 14 or otherwise impermissible because such relations are not the "subscriber" within the meaning of the rules.

The court distinguished the S. Thangam decision relied upon by defendant's counsel, holding that the facts in S. Thangam (involving a partnership and minors admitted to its benefit represented by their mother) were materially different and therefore that authority was inapplicable to the present case.

Applying these legal principles to the facts — where the disputed telephone (No. 5603314) was not subscribed by V.N. Manek but was alleged to have been used by him and his family — the court concluded that the plaintiff (who had an independent connection and had paid the bills for that connection) could not be treated as the defaulting subscriber and that M.T.N.L. had no power to disconnect the plaintiff's telephone on the basis of V.N. Manek's default.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Notice of Motion succeeds and is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a).

Direct consequences ordered by the court:

  • The defendant is directed to reconnect the plaintiff's telephone connection within one week from the date of the judgment.
  • No order as to costs was made.
  • The defendant was directed to act on an ordinary copy of the judgment authenticated by the associate of the Court.

The opinion confines its relief to the facts before the court and addresses the proper interpretation of Rule 443 in relation to subscribers and non-subscribers (relations). The judgment does not purport to announce a broad new doctrine beyond the statutory interpretation and authorities discussed; its immediate effect is the reconnection directive in favor of the plaintiff.

Order

Order accordingly. (The court's operative direction: reconnection within a week; no costs.)

Show all summary ...

Leave under Rules 147 and 148 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay (O.S) Rules, 1980 is granted to the plaintiff to take out Notice of Motion in terms of the draft notice of motion handed in. By consent, Notice of Motion is made returnable forthwith and placed for hearing. The defendant waives service.

2. The plaintiff is a doctor by profession. Pursuant to the application made by the plaintiff in December 1987, the defendants Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited (“M.T.N.L” for short) provided a telephone connection to the plaintiff under special category bearing Telephone No. 5603314 at the plaintiff's residence at B-8, Mugh Malhar Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., 2nd Floor, Murar Road, Mulund (W), Bombay-400080. Thereafter, the defendant shifted the said telephone to the plaintiffs present address of Flat No. A-2, ground floor, Anubhav, R.P.X Road, Mulund (W), Bombay. There is no dispute that the plaintiff has paid all the bills sent to the plaintiff with respect to the said telephone No. 5603314. The main grievance of the plaintiff is that without issuing any prior notice and without assigning any reasons, the defendant disconnected the plaintiff's telephone. The plaintiff says that by reason of this high-handed and arbitrary action on the part of the defendant, the plaintiff is suffering grave and serious hardship. The plaintiff has, therefore, taken out this Notice of Motion for mandatory interim reliefs.

3. In contesting the Notice of Motion, the defendant contended inter alia that the plaintiffs telephone has been placed under special disconnection with effect from April 20, 1995 under the instructions contained in Dy. General Manager's (TRA) letter dated May 11, 1994. It is averred in the affidavit of P.R Tambe, filed on behalf of the defendant, that the plaintiffs father V.N Manek was a subscriber of telephone No. 5680227. The said V.N Manek fell in arrears and in spite of oral as well as written request from the Department, failed to clear the arrears, and therefore, the telephone connection of V.N Manek was disconnected. It is also averred that the defendant had issued a notice dated November 8, 1994 to V.N Manek for clearance of the outstanding failing which his son i.e, the plaintiffs telephone No. 5603314 will be disconnected. It is claimed that a copy of such notice was also marked to the plaintiff for information. The defendant says that the telephone of the plaintiff is being suspended as the same was under use by V.N Manek and his family members. The defendant says that they are empowered to disconnect the telephone of the plaintiff by recourse to R. 443 of the Indian Telegraph Rules.

4. The short question which falls for my consideration is whether the M.T.N.L has power to disconnect the telephone of a relation of the subscriber on the ground of default on the part of such subscriber. Before I deal with the decisions of the various High Courts cited at the Bar, it is necessary to make a brief reference to the relevant rules contained in the Indian Telegraph Rules. The Rules in Part V provides for disconnection under different circumstances and situations. Rule 420 deals with the disconnection when a subscriber who is adjudged as an insolvent, etc., commits breach or fails to observe the Rules after notice. Rule 421 contemplates disconnecting telephone where the Divisional Engineer is satisfied for the reason to be recorded in writing, after giving notice in writing to the subscriber and Rule 424 contemplates right of disconnection in the event of any emergency with or without notice. Rule 424 provides for disconnection in an event of the subscriber making outward local calls in excess of a certain number to be laid down by Telegraph Authority from a telephone after giving an opportunity to the subscriber in writing to rent another telephone or additional connection. Rules 439 and 440 provide as to when the charges become payable and the responsibility of the subscriber to pay the bills. Rule 442 provides for the mode of service of the bills and Rule 443 provides for the consequences of default in the payment of bills. Rule 443 reads as follows:

“443. Default of payment.— If, on or before the due date, the rent or other charges in respect of the telephone service provided are not paid by the subscriber in accordance with these rules, or bills for charges in respect of calls (local and trunk) or phonograms or other dues from the subscriber are not duly paid by him, any telephone or telephones or any telex service rented by him may be disconnected without notice. The telephone or the telex so disconnected may if the Telegraph Authority thinks fit, be restored, if the defaulting subscriber pays the outstanding dues and the reconnection fee together with the rental for such portion of the intervening period (during which the telephone or telex remains disconnected) as may be prescribed by the Telegraph Authority from time to time. The subscriber shall pay all the above charges within such period as may be prescribed by the Telegraph Authority from time to time.”

5. Now the question is whether Rule 443 empowers the Department to disconnect the telephone of a relation or an associate of the subscriber for the default of the subscriber. On a plain reading of Rule 443, it is clear that it contemplates disconnection of a telephone of a subscriber. The words “rented by him” means and refers to the subscriber. There appears to be some divergence of opinion on the question as to whether the Department's power is restricted only to the telephone in respect of which default has been committed or any other telephone rented to the subscriber. In Santokh Singh v. Divisional Engineer, Telephones, Shillong (AIR 1990 Gau 47), the Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court ruled that Rule 443 cannot be interpreted to vest with the Authority the power to disconnect any other telephone working in the name of the same subscriber either at the same premises or elsewhere on the ground of default of payment in respect of one of his telephones. In the opinion of the Gauhati High Court, this power is confined only to a particular telephone in respect of which there is default in payment and not to the other telephones. The Gujarat High Court has, however, taken a contrary view in the case of Irdravadan Pranlal Shah v. General Manager, Ahmedabad Telephones (AIR 1990 Guj 85). The Division Bench of Gujarat High Court has held that if the dues of telephone are not paid by the subscriber, any telephone or telephones or any telex service rented by him can be disconnected without notice. The Gujarat High Court has mainly relied upon Rule 2(pp), which defines “subscriber” to mean a person to whom a telephone service has been provided by means of installation under the rules or under an agreement. It was held that in case the subscriber consists of a partnership firm, since it is not a legal person, the partners are the subscribers. Therefore, when such partner/subscriber is in default in payment of telephone dues because the partnership firm has failed to pay those bills, Rule 443 is attracted and any telephone rented to such subscriber partner even in his individual capacity is liable to disconnection. The High Court of Madras in S.M Ayua v. Union of India (Writ Appeal No. 1151 of 1987 decided on 8-11-1990) has agreed with the view taken by the Gujarat High Court. Although the issue involved in the present suit is slightly different, I wish to record my respectful agreement with the view taken by the Gujarat High Court in Indravadan's case (supra). The judgment of Gujarat High Court, in my opinion, is consistent with the scheme framed under the rules. Thus it cannot be disputed that the Department has got power to disconnect any other telephone rented by the subscriber. However, the question is whether the Department has got power to disconnect the telephone of a relation of the subscriber on account of the default committed by such subscriber.

6. On a plain reading of the definition of “subscriber”, it is seen that a subscriber is a person, who has subscribed for a particular telephone whether it be an individual or a partnership firm or a corporate body. In the present case, the telephone's dues are in respect of telephone No. 5603314, which was admittedly subscribed by V.N Manek, the petitioner cannot be described to be the subscriber of the said telephone and the said telephone alone can be disconnected in the event of the subscriber not having paid the dues to the Department. Even the Madras High Court in S.M Ayua's case (supra) observed that the words “rented by him” in Rule 443 refers to the subscriber only. In a similar situation, the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Y. Pridhvi Kumar v. General Manager, Telecom District, Hyderabad (AIR 1993 Andh Pra 131) held that disconnection of telephone of son would be arbitrary and unreasonable and violative of Art. 14 of the (Constitution. Similarly, the Delhi High Court in Smt. Krishan Kumar v. Delhi Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd. (1989 Raj LR 393 (DB)) held that the term “subscriber” means a person or firm, who have subscribed and it would not include the relations, who have independent connections and whose phone the defaulter may be using and, therefore, DMT Nigam cannot demand dues (or give threat of disconnection) to relations of defaulter.

7. Before I conclude, I may mention that Ms. Shah, learned counsel for the defendant, relied upon a judgment of Madras High Court in S. Thangam v. Area Manager, Madras in Writ Petition No. 5903 of 1987 dated August 4, 1987. In my opinion, the facts before the Madras High Court are clearly distinguishable. In that case, the partnership firm had fallen in arrears of telephone dues to the extent of Rs. 1,67,000/-. Some minors were admitted to the benefit of the partnership firm, and their mother was representing the interests of the minors in the firm. Under these circumstances, it was held that the failure of the partnership firm in having cleared the arrears and the dues of the telephone department, the telephone connection of the latter was held liable to be disconnected. The said judgment is clearly inapplicable to the facts of the present case.

8. In view of the foregoing discussion, the Notice of Motion succeeds and is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a). The defendant is directed to reconnect the plaintiff's telephone connection within a week from today. No order as to costs.

The defendant to act on an ordinary copy of this judgment duly authenticated by the associate of this Court.

Order accordingly.