Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ramcharan Bhudiram Gupta v. The State Of Maharashtra .

Bombay High Court
Jul 14, 1995
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Vishnu Sahai, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment disposes of two connected criminal appeals arising from a single incident. According to the prosecution, on 1-9-1986 between 12:15 and 12:45 p.m. a dacoity occurred at Flat No. 5 Usha Sadan, Woodhouse Road, Colaba, Bombay, during which jewellery and other articles belonging to Mrs. Theresa Julius Hill (P.W.1) were looted and she sustained injuries inflicted by a knife. The informant lodged an F.I.R. (C.R. No. 697 of 1986) on 1-9-1986 at 2:30 a.m. Investigation included recovery of a knife at the scene, medical examination of the informant, identification parades and subsequent recoveries made at locations pointed out by the appellants.

The appellants (Ramcharan Bhudiram Gupta and Amarsingh @ Babusingh s/o Santoshsingh Thakur) were convicted by Shri S.B. Sonar, Additional Sessions Judge, Greater Bombay (judgment and order dated 20th October, 1993) under various sections of the Indian Penal Code (including sections 394, 392 read with 34, 452 read with 34, and 392 read with 397 in respect of Amarsingh) with substantive sentences ordered to run concurrently. The appellants challenged those convictions and sentences in these connected Criminal Appeals.

Procedural highlights: the appellants were arrested on 11-11-1986 (in connection with another crime), identification parades were conducted on 12-11-1986 at police station Vakola, recoveries at the appellants' instance were made on 14-11-1986 and 15-11-1986 and were recorded; the prosecution examined 11 witnesses at trial (the informant being the only eyewitness); the trial Judge accepted the prosecution case and convicted; these convictions were then appealed to the present Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the identification proceedings (test identification parade) conducted by the police were reliable and, if not, whether convictions founded on that identification evidence could be sustained.
  2. Whether, despite acquittal on the principal criminal counts for lack of reliable identification evidence, the appellants could be convicted on the basis of property recovered at their pointing out under section 411 IPC, even though no charge under section 411 was framed at trial.
  3. If conviction under section 411 IPC is acceptable, what sentence should be imposed in view of the period already undergone by the appellants in custody?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The sole and principal submission advanced on behalf of the appellants was that the identification proceedings were a "big farce"—i.e., that the identification evidence was unreliable because the appellants may have been shown to the identifying witness prior to the formal parade and because the prescribed safeguards were not observed.
  • Counsel for the appellants conceded that he could not demolish the recoveries made at the appellants' instance.

Respondent / State's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the State's or prosecution's specific oral arguments in response; only that the State was represented by the Additional Public Prosecutor and that the Court perused the evidence and exhibits.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A.I.R. 1961 Allahabad P. 153 (Asharfi appellants v. The State) The prosecution must show that from the time of arrest until admission into jail precautions were taken to ensure the accused were not seen by any outsider; absence of such link evidence creates reasonable doubt about prior showing of suspects to witnesses. The Court relied on this authority to hold that, because no link evidence was produced and because the identifying witness and appellants were in the police station at the same time before the parade, the identification evidence could not be safely relied upon and must be discarded.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a stepwise evaluation of the evidence with emphasis on identification procedure and recoveries:

  1. Identification evidence: The Court emphasized established legal principle that identification evidence can be relied upon only if all chances of the suspects being shown to the witnesses prior to the test identification are eliminated. The burden of proving that suspects were not seen by outsiders from arrest until jail admission lies on the prosecution.
  2. Link evidence absent: The prosecution failed to produce link evidence to show that from arrest until lodging in jail the suspects' faces were veiled or that precautions were taken; consequently the prosecution did not discharge its burden and the identification evidence lost value.
  3. Circumstances at the police station: The Executive Magistrate (P.W.6) stated that when he visited the police station to conduct the parade, the appellants were confined in a lock-up and the identifying witness (Mrs. Theresa Hill) was already present in the police station. This created a reasonable possibility that the witness might have seen the appellants before the parade. The Court treated this circumstance as sufficient, by itself, to discard the identification evidence.
  4. Departure from prescribed procedure: The Court found that the identification parade violated the procedure in the High Court Criminal Manual (Bombay Appellate Side) which provides that not more than two suspects should be put at a time in one parade; here three persons (the two appellants and Medha Jagganath Dhobi) were paraded together. The Magistrate stated ignorance about the Manual's method. Further, the identification memo lacked any mention that dummies of similar appearance were mixed with the suspects; this omission undermined confidence in the parade.
  5. Conclusion on identification: For these cumulative reasons—absence of link evidence, the realistic possibility of prior exposure at the police station, breach of Criminal Manual procedure, lack of evidence regarding dummies—the Court concluded that the identification evidence "does not inspire confidence" and must be rejected.
  6. Recoveries and section 411 IPC: The Court then considered whether the appellants could nonetheless be convicted for possessing stolen property recovered at their instance. The Court held in the affirmative that the appellants could be convicted under section 411 IPC based on the recoveries, despite the fact that no specific charge under section 411 was framed at trial. The Court characterized section 411 as a minor offence relative to the offences originally charged (sections 392, 394 read with 34 etc.).
  7. Sentence: Considering the appellants had already been in custody for a substantial period (approximately one year and eight months since the impugned judgment) and that the maximum sentence under section 411 IPC is three years, the Court reduced the sentence on the section 411 conviction to the period already undergone by the appellants.
  8. Administrative directions: Because of the infirmities found in the identification procedure, the Court directed the Registrar to send a copy of the judgment to several authorities (Advocate General, Director General of Police Maharashtra, Principal Secretary Home Department Govt. of Maharashtra, Judicial Secretary, and Commissioner of Police, Greater Bombay) to highlight procedural shortcomings and encourage appropriate steps to rectify the practice of holding identification at police stations.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Appeals partly allowed.

Direct effect on parties (core orders given in the judgment):

  • The Court set aside the trial Court's judgment and order dated in the opinion (the text records setting aside the judgment and order dated 23-10-1993) and acquitted the appellants on all counts where conviction was founded primarily on identification evidence.
  • Despite the acquittals on those counts, the Court convicted both appellants under section 411 IPC for possession of stolen property recovered at their pointing out.
  • The sentence on the section 411 IPC conviction was reduced to the period already undergone by the appellants in custody; the appellants were ordered to be released forthwith unless they were wanted in some other case.
  • The Court directed that the Registrar send a copy of the judgment to specified state and police authorities to draw attention to infirmities in the manner identification proceedings are being conducted (particularly the practice of holding identification at police stations and non-observance of the Criminal Manual).

Broader implications:

  • The Court condemned the prevalent practice (as represented on the record) of holding identification parades at police stations and recommended that identification parades be held in jail where feasible, so that proper mixing with dummies and safeguards can be effected and the identification procedure will be free from suspicion.
  • The opinion directed administrative action by sending the judgment to relevant legal and police authorities, thereby seeking procedural reforms rather than purporting to lay down a new statutory rule of law in abstract form.

Final operative result stated by the Court (as recorded in the opinion): The appeals are partly allowed and partly dismissed; appellants acquitted on all counts dependent on the impugned identification evidence, convicted under section 411 IPC, sentence under section 411 reduced to the period already undergone, and ordered to be released forthwith unless wanted in another case.

Note: This summary is prepared exclusively from the text of the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond what the opinion itself records.

Show all summary ...

Vishnu Sahai, J.:— Since both these criminal appeals arise out of a common incident, we propose disposing them of by a common judgment.

2. Vide judgment and order dated 20th October, 1993 passed by Shri S.B Sonar, Additional Sessions Judge, Greater Bombay, in Sessions Case No. 426 of 1987 the appellants were convicted and sentenced in the manner stated hereinafter:

Appellant Ramcharan Bhudiram Gupta:—i) Under section 394 I.P.C to 6 years rigorous imprisonment;

ii) Under section 392 I.P.C read with 34 I.P.C to 6 years rigorous imprisonment; and

iii) Under section 452 read with 34 I.P.C to 5 years rigorous imprisonment and to pay a fine of Rs. 2000/-, in default to further under-go rigorous imprisonment for one year.

Appellant-Amarsingh @ Babusingh s/o Santoshsingh Thakur:—i) Under section 394 I.P.C to 8 years rigorous imprisonment;

ii) Under section 392 read with 34 I.P.C to 7 years rigorous imprisonment and to pay a fine of Rs. 2000/- and in default of payment of fine to further undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year,

iii) Under section 392 read with 397 I.P.C to 8 years rigorous imprisonment; and

iv) Under section 452 I.P.C to 7 years rigorous imprisonment and to pay fine of Rs. 1000/- and in default of payment of fine to further under-go 6 years rigorous imprisonment.

3. The substantive sentences of both the appellants were ordered to run concurrently. It is these convictions and sentences of the appellants which have been challenged in these two connected Criminal Appeals.

4. According to the prosecution, on 1-9-1986, between 12.15 to 12.45 hours, at Flat No. 5 Usha Sadan, Woodhouse Road, Colaba, Bombay-5, a during robbery took place, during the course of which gold ornaments, one two in-one tape recorder, and wrist watch etc. belonging to Mrs. Theresa Juliar Hill P.W 1 were looted. It is alleged that unknown miscreants participated in the robbery and one of them who was armed with a knife during the commission of robbery, inflicted grievous hurt with it on the person of Mrs. Theresa Hill. After committing the robbery, the miscreants are said to have run away.

5. The F.I.R of the incident was lodged on 1-9-1986 at 2.30 hours by Mrs. Theresa Julius Hill at police station Colaba, against three unknown persons. On the basis of the F.I.R, C.R No. 697 of 1986 was registered at police station Colaba by S.I Bhagwan Sawant P.W 4. He sent the informant who was in an injured condition for medical examination to St. Georges' Hospital.

6. The injuries of the informant were immediately examined the same day at 2.15 p.m by P.W 2 Dr. Prakash Nalte. Dr. Nalte found that she had the following injuries on her person:—

“Contusion below left eye. CLW right little finger, abrassion on the right side of the neck 1″ × 1″. Contusion on the left side of the neck and abrassion on the right fore hand ½″ × ½″.

7. Dr. Nalte stated in the trial Court that the said injuries were possible by any hard blunt weapon.

8. On 11-11-1986, the appellants were arrested in connection with Crime No. 439 of 1986 of police station, Vakola. Their interrogation revealed their complicity in the present case.

9. The investigation of the case was conducted by Madhav Manechandar in P.W 3 Special Officer at Colaba Police Station and P.I Vikram Marathe, P.W 11 of Police Station Vakola.

10. P.W 3 Madhav Machindar on 1-9-1986, visited the scene of offence and prepared the spot panchanama etc. He recovered the knife which was lying there under a panchanama.

11. On 12-11-1986, P.I Vikram Marathe requested the Special Executive Magistrate, P.W 6 Bagambal Shetty on phone to hold the test identification parade of the appellants co-accused Medha Jagganath Dhobi and Mary Miachel the same day. He also tetephonically informed the informant Mrs. Theresa Hill about this test identification. The same day. P.W 6 Bagambal Shetty, came to police station Vakola and held two parades viz. one in connection with the appellants and Medha Jagganath Dhobi and the other with that of co-accused Mary Miachel. At the test identification parade, the informant is said to have identified both the appellants as well as Medha Jagganath Dhobi and Mary Miachel.

12. On 14-11-1986, P.I Marathe interrogated the appellant Amarsingh who promised to get some of the robbed articles recovered. Consequently, P.I Marathe prepared a panchanama and along with the panchas and the appellant proceeded to Room No. 23 in Rashida Chawl. After the aforesaid room was opened, at the instance of the appellant, from a blanket, one two-in-one tape recorder, two table watches, currency coins of copper and white metal of different countries, 2 ladies purses, one copper chain having pendant, two towels and one jacket were recovered.

13. On 15-11-1986, during the course of interrogation, appellant Ramcharan Gupta offered to get some of the robbed articles recovered. Consequently, P.I Marathe prepared a panchanama. Thereafter, along with the panchas and the appellant went to Malvani at Gate No. 6. They came to room No. 354 of a Municipal Chawl, wherein one lady claiming to be the sister of the appellant namely P.W 7 Shanti Gupta, produced one calculator of casio make from a steel cupboard. Thereafter, appellant Ramcharan Gupta led them to a shop by the name of Geeta Jewellers where a person by the name of Ramprakash Soni, P.W 5 was present. At the instance of the appellant, he produced one gold piece, and purchase Bill Book of his shop, which was taken charge by drawing a panchanama. Thereafter, the appellant Ramcharan Gupta led them to another shop known by the name of M.L Jewellers. In that shop, one Laxman was present. At the instance of the appellant he is alleged to have produced one gold piece and a note book containing the entry about the said gold piece.

14. On 15-11-1986, P.I Marathe recorded the statement of P.W 5 Ramprakash Soni and P.W 7 Smt. Shanti Gupta.

15. On 23-11-1986, P.I Marathe called the informant for recording her further statement. At the police station, the informant is alleged to have identified Article No. 1 namely the tape recorder.

16. After completing the investigation, P.I Marathe filed the charge sheet against the appellants in the Court of Metropolitan Magistrate, 21st Court, Bandra, Bombay.

17. The case was committed to the Court of Sessions in the usual manner where charges under section 392, read with section 34 I.P.C, 392 read with section 397 I.P.C, 394 read with section 34 I.P.C 397 read with section 34 I.P.C and 452 read with section 34 I.P.C were framed against the appellants to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

18. The defence of the appellants was that of denial.

19. In the trial Court, apart from tendering voluminious documentary evidence, the prosecution examined as many as 11 witnesses. Out of them P.W 1 Theresa Hill is the solitary eye witness of the incident. The remaining witnesses included P.W 6 Bagambal Shetty, the Executive Magistrate, who conducted the test identification parade of the appellants and P.W 11 P.I Vikram Marathe who investigated the case.

20. In defence no witness was examined.

21. The learned trial Judge believed the evidence adduced by the prosecution and passed the impugned judgment.

22. We have heard Mr. Prakash Naik for the appellants and Mr. B.R Patil, Additional Public Prosecutor for the State of Maharashtra. We have also perused the oral evidence and the various Exhibits, including the identification memo of the appellants, produced by the prosecution. After giving our anxious consideration to the matter, we are of the opinion that these appeals deserve to be partly allowed.

23. Mr. P.D Naik learned Counsel for the appellants made a solitary submission before us namely that the identification proceedings in the instant case are a big farce, and that being so, the conviction of the appellants on the various counts cannot be sustained. We find considerable merit in the aforesaid submission of Mr. Naik.

24. It is well settled that the evidence of identification can only be relied upon if all the chances of the suspects being shown to the witnesses prior to their test identification are eliminated.

25. To ensure that firstly, the prosecution has to adduce link evidence to the effect that right from the time of arrest till being lodged in jail, the faces of suspects were kept veiled and no one had the opportunity to see them. This has not been done in the instant case. No link evidence has been adduced by the prosecution to prove this fact. Since the burden of showing that right from arrest till being lodged in jail, the faces of the suspects were throughout kept veiled was on the prosecution and as it has failed to discharge this burden the evidence of identification is rendered worthless in the instant case. We are reinforced in our view by the decision reported in A.I.R 1961 Allahabad P. 153, (Asharfi appellants v. The State Respondent)1, wherein in paragraph 35, James, J., spoke for the Division Bench, thus” it is the duty of the prosecution to show that from the time of the arrest of an accused person to the time of his admission into the jail, precautions were taken to ensure that he was not seen by any outsider.”

26. Secondly a perusal of the evidence of P.W 6 Mr. Shetty, the Executive Magistrate who conducted the identification of the appellants, shows that when on 12-11-1986, he visited police station Vakola in connection with conducting the identification parade, he found that the appellants were confined in a lock up room and that the identifying witness, who was a lady, Mrs. Theresa Hill, was already sitting in the police station. In such a situation, there was a reasonable possibility of Mrs. Theresa Hill seeing the appellants prior to the identification parade. In our view, this alone is sufficient to discard the identification evidence against the appellants. In A.I.R 1961 Allahabad page 153, Asharfi appellants v. The State respondent, supra, the Court observed in paragraph 35 that the plea of shown does not require to be affirmatively established; it is sufficient if the accused can create a reasonable doubt in the mind of the Court. “Direct evidence may not be available but he may discharge his burden by showing, for example that he and the witnesses were present in the police station, at the same time” ……In our view, the aforesaid observations are tailor made for this case.

27. We strongly deprecate the practice of conducting identification at police stations; a practice which we are informed at the Bar, is only prevalent in Greater Bombay. The sooner it is abandoned the better it is because, the probability of the suspects being shown to the witnesses prior to the test identification is always there at the police station. At any rate, on account of such a practice, there is always a lurking suspicion in the mind of the Court that the witnesses might have seen the suspects prior to the test identification.

28. In order to make identification evidence beyond reproach, it is high time that an end is put to the practice of holding of identification at police station and identification parades instead are held in jail. This practice would not only enable the police to wash the stigma of showing suspects prior to their identification; a stigma which more than often is unfounded, but has manifold other advantages. Jails have a large population these days. It would be easy there to find persons similar to the suspects sought to be put for identification. Such similar persons have to mixed with the suspects at the time of identification.

29. The identification in jail would not only actually be free from any taint or suspicion but equally importantly it would also appear to be so. It would instill a sense of confidence both in the minds of the suspects sought to be put for identification as well as the Court. There are some other infirmities too in the evidence of identification, which render it unworthy of acceptance.

30. Firstly, the procedure of holding the identification as laid down in the Criminal Manual issued by the High Court of Judicature, Appellate Side, Bombay has not been followed. The Manual provides that not more than two suspects at a time should be put for identification in one parade but, in the instant case, three persons viz., the appellants and Medha Jagganath Dhobi were put up together for identification in one parade.

31. In fact, the Executive Magistrate went to the extent of saying that “I am not aware about the High Court Criminal Manual about the method of holding the parade”. This is a shocking state of affairs. We expect that in future, it would be ensured that the Magistrate who conduct identification proceedings, are at least aware of the High Court Criminal Manual which deals with the manner in which they are to be conducted. We would like to emphasise that little value can be given to the identification held in breach of provisions contained in Criminal Manual of this Court. Secondly, in the identification memo, there is no mention of the fact that dummies mixed with the appellants bore similar physical appearance and hence, we do not think it safe to believe the Magistrate when he deposed to this effect in the trial Court. Once the Court entertains doubts about dummies bearing similar physical appearance being mixed with the appellants, at the time of their test identification, the Court has no option but, to reject the evidence of identification.

32. The fall out of the aforesaid discussion is that the identification evidence against the appellants does not inspire confidence and consequently, both the appellants have to be acquitted on all the counts.

33. However, one question which remains is as to whether the appellants can be convicted in respect of the property recovered at their pointing out. In our judgment, the answer to this question has to be in the affirmative and the appellants can be safely be convicted under section 411 I.P.C

34. Mr. P.D Naik learned Counsel for the appellants frankly conceded that he could not shatter the recovery made at the instance of the appellants.

35. It is true that in the instant case no charge under section 411 I.P.C was framed against the appellants in the trial Court. However, in our view, that would make no difference. Both the appellants were charged under sections 392 read with section 34 I.P.C and 394 read with section 34 I.P.C and the offence under section 411 I.P.C is a minor offence in relation to those offences.

36. That being so, even in the absence of a charge under section 411 I.P.C, we can convict both the appellants on that count.

37. Coming to the question of sentence under section 411 I.P.C, we are informed by Mr. Naik that the appellants are continuously in jail since the date of the impugned judgment i.e 20-10-1993. In other words, the appellants have already been in jail for nearly one year and eight months. The maximum sentence under section 411 I.P.C is 3 years. In our view, considering the circumstance, that the incident took place way back in the year 1986, it is a fit case in which the sentence of both the appellants under section 411 I.P.C be reduced, to the period already undergone by them.

38. Since in this judgment, we have pointed out some of the infirmities in the manner in which identification is being conducted, we direct the Registrar to send its copy to the Advocate General, Maharashtra, the Director General of Police, Maharashtra, the Principal Secretary, Home Department, Government of Maharashtra, the Judicial Secretary (Law and Judiciary Department) Government of Maharashtra, and the Commissioner of Police, Greater Bombay. In the result, these appeals are partly allowed and partly dismissed. Although we set aside the judgment and order dated 23-10-1993 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Greater Bombay and acquit the appellants on all the counts but, we convict them under section 411 I.P.C and reduce their sentence on that count to the period already undergone by them. The appellants are in jail. They shall be released forthwith unless wanted in some other case.

39. Before parting with this judgment, we would like to put on record our appreciation for the learned Counsel of the parties for the enormous assistance which they have rendered us.

40. Appeals partly allowed.