- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. v. Income Tax Officer.
Factual and Procedural Background
These three appeals by the assessee challenge the applicability of s.201(1) r/w s.192(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 for the assessment years 1985-86 to 1987-88. For convenience the appeals were consolidated and decided together. The assessee is a company that filed annual returns of salaries under s.206 for employees at various Bombay units. A survey revealed incorrect application of law in calculating salary for tax deduction at source (TDS), resulting in lesser amounts being deducted. Specific items identified were:
- Reimbursement of drivers' salary to some employees treated as taxable under s.17(2)(iv).
- Ex gratia equivalent to one month's salary paid to employees drawing above Rs.1,500 per month, treated as taxable under s.17(1).
- Office set off/expenditure allowance (fixed allowances between Rs.75 to Rs.200 per month) treated as taxable under s.17(1).
Additionally, for 1986-87 and 1987-88 the ITO made an addition in respect of standard deduction for employees provided with a motor car for use otherwise than wholly and exclusively for attending office. The assessee was asked to make payment for the alleged short deduction. The assessee contended it had made an honest and bona fide estimate of tax liability, filed returns and deposited tax within the time required. The CIT(A) rejected the assessee's claim, and these appeals followed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether s.201(1) r/w s.192(1) of the IT Act, 1961 can be invoked against an employer who made an honest but incorrect estimate of employees' taxable salary which resulted in short deduction of tax at source.
- Whether the Assessing Officer (AO) has jurisdiction under s.201 to demand further tax from the employer in respect of tax short deducted where employees have been assessed separately and tax in respect of those employees has been dealt with in their assessments.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The assessee acted in accordance with s.192(1) by making an honest and bona fide estimate of employees' tax liability and filed the required returns under s.206.
- Tax as per the estimate was deposited within the time prescribed by law; therefore the Revenue was not correct in treating the matter as a short deduction attracting s.201.
- S.201(1) applies only where an employer either fails to deduct tax or, after deducting, fails to pay it as required; an incorrect estimate alone does not establish lack of honesty or fairness on the part of the employer.
- Relied on judicial decisions including: Gwalior Rayon Silk Co. Ltd. vs. CIT (1983) 140 ITR 832 (MP); CIT vs. Divisional Manager, New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (1983) 140 ITR 818 (MP); and CIT vs. Shri Synthetics Ltd. (1985) 151 ITR 634 (MP).
Revenue's Arguments
- The facts fall within the mischief of s.201(1) r/w s.192(1); the law requires the assessee to deduct tax as per the provisions and the error in calculation cannot exonerate the assessee from liability.
- The apparent "blatant error" in calculating salary income and consequent short deduction cannot be permitted to defeat the statutory obligation.
- The AO has charged only the short deduction and relied on decisions and Revenue orders to support that charge.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Gwalior Rayon Silk Co. Ltd. vs. CIT (1983) 140 ITR 832 (MP) | That if the estimate made by the employer is incorrect, this fact alone, without anything more, would not inevitably lead to the inference that the employer has not acted honestly and fairly. | The court applied this principle to conclude that an incorrect estimate does not automatically establish mala fides and, absent mala fide, the employer's estimate cannot be successfully challenged under s.201. |
| CIT vs. Divisional Manager, New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (1983) 140 ITR 818 (MP) | That where a regular assessment of an employee had been completed and the amount of tax fully paid by him, the ITO, Salary Circle (TDS) had no jurisdiction under s.201 to demand further tax from the employer in respect of the tax short deducted relating to such employee. | The court relied on this holding to support the conclusion that the AO had no jurisdiction under s.201 to demand further tax from the assessee where employees were assessed separately and tax liabilities addressed in their assessments. |
| CIT vs. Shri Synthetics Ltd. (1985) 151 ITR 634 (MP) | Relied upon by the assessee; the opinion as provided does not specify the particular rule or principle cited from this decision. | The decision was listed among those relied upon by the assessee; the opinion references it but does not elaborate its specific application beyond listing it with other supporting precedents. |
| CIT vs. Manager, Madhya Pradesh State Co-op. Development Bank Ltd. (1982) 137 ITR 230 (MP) | Referred to and followed in New India Assurance; the opinion identifies it as an authority followed by the Court in New India Assurance. | The court noted that New India Assurance followed this decision and treated it as supporting authority for the proposition that the ITO (TDS) lacked jurisdiction to demand further tax from an employer where the employee had been assessed and paid tax. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the text and effect of s.192(1) and s.201(1). It reproduced s.192(1), noting that it requires an employer to deduct income-tax at the time of payment on the estimated income of the employee for the financial year. The court reproduced s.201(1) which deems a person to be an assessee in default if he does not deduct, or after deducting fails to pay, the tax as required by the Act.
The court analysed that s.201 applies to two distinct circumstances: (i) where the employer does not deduct tax; and (ii) where, after deducting, the employer fails to pay the tax. Both are independent conditions that must be satisfied for s.201 to apply. The duty under s.192(1) to form an opinion about the employee's tax liability requires the employer to act honestly and fairly. Relying on Gwalior Rayon Silk Co. Ltd., the court held that an incorrect estimate alone, without more, does not demonstrate lack of honesty or fairness.
The court also considered the line of authority in New India Assurance (which followed the Manager, Madhya Pradesh State Co-op. Development Bank Ltd. decision) which held that where a regular assessment of the employee had been completed and tax fully paid by him, the ITO (TDS) lacked jurisdiction under s.201 to demand further tax from the employer in respect of tax short deducted relating to such employee. Applying these principles to the facts, the court found that the assessee had made an honest estimate, no mala fide was attributed, the assessee filed the annual return under s.206 and paid the deducted amount within the stipulated time, and the employees were assessed separately with any shortfall considered in their assessments. Given these findings and the precedents, the court concluded the AO had no jurisdiction under s.201 to demand further tax from the assessee.
Holding and Implications
APPEALS ALLOWED
Holding: The court allowed the assessee's appeals and held that the Assessing Officer had no jurisdiction under s.201 of the Income-tax Act to demand further tax from the assessee in respect of the alleged short deduction, on the facts that the assessee made an honest estimate, filed returns under s.206 and paid tax within the stipulated time, and the employees were assessed separately.
Implications: The direct effect is that the assessee is not liable under s.201 for the short deduction identified by the AO in these matters. The opinion grounds its decision on existing precedents and statutory interpretation; it does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond the application of those authorities to the facts of this case.
These three appeals by the assessee are directed against the applicability of s. 201(1) r/w s. 192(1) of the IT Act, 1961, and pertain to the asst. yrs. 1985-86 to 1987-88.
2. For the sake of convenience, these appeals are consolidated and disposed of by a common order.
3. Briefly, the facts :
The assessee is a company. It is filing annual returns of salaries under s. 206 in respect of salaries paid to its employees at various units in Bombay. In order to ascertain the varacity of the returns survey was conducted. It was found that while calculating salaries for TDS purposes correct prescription of law was not followed. As a result thereof, lesser amount was deducted. Attention was invited on the following :
(i) reimbursement of drivers salary to some employees taxed under s. 17(2)(iv);
(ii) ex gratia, equivalent to one month salary, paid to employees drawing salary above Rs. 1,500 per month taxed under s. 17(1);
(iii) office set off expenditure allowance paid to certain officers as a fixed allowance ranging between Rs. 75 to Rs. 200 per month taxed under s. 17(1).
Besides, in the standard deduction in respect of employees provided with motor car for use otherwise than wholly and exclusively for attending office addition was made by the ITO for 1986-87 and 1987-88. The assessee was, therefore, asked to make payment in respect of short deduction.
4. The assessee submitted that it made honest and bona fide estimate of the tax liability. Return as required under the law was duly filed. Tax as per the estimate was deposited within the time. The Revenue was, therefore, not correct in making the demand for the so-called short deduction. The CIT(A) rejected the claim of the assessee.
5. Shri B. K. Khare, learned counsel for the assessee, appeared before us. Our attention was invited on the provisions of ss. 201 and 192(1) of the IT Act, 1961. It was vehemently contended that these provisions can be invoked only if the assessee fails to deduct tax at source or after deducting fails to pay the tax as required by the Act. Sec. 192(1) contemplates the basis for such deduction. The section stipulates that an employer is to deduct and pay tax on the estimated income of an employee. The employer is expected to act honesty and fairly. The mere fact that the estimate by the employer is incorrect without anything more, would not inevitably lead to the inference that the employer has not acted honestly and fairly. Reliance was placed on the following decisions :
(i) Gwalior Rayon Silk Co. Ltd. vs. CIT (1983) 140 ITR 832 (MP);
(ii) CIT vs. Divisional Manager, New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (1983) 140 ITR 818 (MP);
(iii) CIT vs. Shri Synthetics Ltd. (1985) 151 ITR 634 (MP).
6. The learned Departmental Representative, Shri A. K. Sahay, appeared before us. It was vehemently argued that the case of the assessee comes within the mischief of s. 201(1) r/w s. 192(1) of the IT Act, 1961. It was contended that law prescribes that the assessee should deduct tax as per the provisions of this Act. The blatant error made by the assessee in calculating the salary income cannot go to exonerate it from the liability. It was stated that AO has only charged short deduction. Further, he relied on the orders of the Revenue authorities.
7. We have heard the rival submissions in the light of the materials placed before us and the precedents relied upon.
8. A perusal of s. 192 makes it clear that the liability of the employer is to deduct tax on the estimated income of the employee. We reproduce s. 192(1) hereasunder :
"192(1) Any person responsible for paying any income chargeable under the head "Salaries" shall, at the time of payment, deduct income-tax on the amount payable at the average of income-tax computed on the basis of the rates in force for the financial year in which the payment is made, on the estimated income of the assessee under this head for that financial year."
Sec. 201(1) reads as under :
"If any such person and in the cases referred to in s. 194, the principal officer and the company of which he is the principal officer does not deduct or after deducting fails to pay the tax as required by or under this Act, he or it shall without prejudice to any other consequences which he or it may incur, be deemed to be an assessee in default in respect of the tax."
9. It transpires from the perusal of s. 201 that it can be applied in the case of an employer only when that employer does not deduct or, after deducting, fails to pay the tax as required by the Act. These twin conditions are sine qua non, for invoking the section. Both the conditions are independent of each other. Therefore, if the employer does not deduct the tax he will come within the mischief of the section. Similarly, if after deducting he fails to pay the tax to the exchequer as required by the Act, he will be subject to the provisions of s. 201. Sec. 192(1) requires that the employer deduct the amount of tax on the estimated income of his employee. Therefore, duty is cast upon the employer to form an opinion about the tax liability of his employee in respect of the salary income. While forming this opinion, the employer is expected to act honestly and fairly. It is laid down in the case of Gwalior Rayon Silk Co. Ltd. (supra) that if it is found that the estimate made by the employer is incorrect, this fact alone, without anything more, would not inevitably lead to the inference that the employer has not acted honestly and fairly - unless the inference can be reasonably raised against an employer, no fault can be found with him.
9.1 In the case of New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (supra), the assessee-employer filed the annual return of salary income of its employees showing the amount of TDS under s. 192 of the Act. AO found that the tax deductible under s. 192 was not properly deducted in respect of the employees. Accordingly, he demanded under s. 201 additional tax that could have been deducted. The Court followed its decision in CIT vs. Manager, Madhya Pradesh State Co-op. Development Bank Ltd. (1982) 137 ITR 230 (MP) and rejected the claim of the Department and held :
"In view of our aforesaid decision, it must be held that the Tribunal was right in law in holding that where a regular assessment of employee had been completed and amount of tax fully paid by him, the ITO, Salary Circle (TDS) had no jurisdiction under s. 201 of the Act, to demand further tax from the employer in respect of the tax short deducted relating to such employee".
10. We have noted that the assessee discharged his duty. He made an honest estimate. No. mala fide was attributed against the assessee by the Revenue in the impugned order, nor this was contended by the learned Departmental Representative. Filing of estimate in consonance with s. 192(1) is the prerogative of the assessee. As long as there is no mala fide the AO cannot linker and tailor the estimate filed by the assessee. The assessee is required to deduct tax as per estimate. The amount so deducted must be paid to the exchequer within the time stipulated in the Act. From the facts gathered, we find that the assessee made honest estimate. No mala fide was attributed to the assessee in regard to the estimate. The assessee also filed annual return under s. 206 of the Act. He also made the payment to the exchequer within the stipulated time. Therefore, we find that the assessee discharged his duties as cast upon him as per the provisions of law. Admittedly the employees are assessed separately and shortfall, if there be any, was said to have been considered in the assessment of the employees. Having regard to the facts and considering carefully the precedents available over the point, we are of the opinion that the AO had no jurisdiction under s. 201 of the Act, to demand further tax from the assessee in respect of the tax short deducted.
11. In the result, the appeals of the assessee stand allowed.
Alert