- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shakuntala v. Kausalyabai
Structured Summary of the Opinion (R.M. Lodha, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, Smt. Shakuntala (the allottee), filed a complaint under Chapter III of the C.P. and Berar Letting of Houses and Rent Control Order, 1949 ("the Rent Control Order, 1949") before the House Allotment Officer (HAO), alleging that certain houses belonging to the late Bholanath Pande were vacant and that the landlord intended to induct new tenants at increased rent. The respondent landlady denied the allegations, stated that tenants occupied the houses, and contended that Clause 20 of the Rent Control Order, 1949 was ultra vires the Constitution.
On 30-6-1986 the HAO, without holding any inquiry, allotted house No. 495/5 to the appellant under Clause 24 of the Rent Control Order and directed delivery of possession within 15 days, failing which action under Clause 28 would be initiated. The landlady applied for review; the HAO dismissed the review application on 8-8-1986 observing there was no provision for review under Chapter III, and directed compliance within 7 days. Possession was given to the allottee on 12-8-1986.
The landlady filed Writ Petition No. 1854/1986 before this Court seeking quashing of the HAO order and restoration of possession. The Single Judge allowed the writ petition on 21-8-1989, ordering that the allottee restore possession of house No. 495/5 to the landlady (failing which the landlady could resort to proceedings under Clause 28). The allottee challenged that judgment in the present Letters Patent Appeal.
Separately, this Court (Division Bench) in Vidarbha (Rent Control) Bhadekaru Sangh Akola v. State of Maharashtra (reported 1986 Mh.L.J 882) had, by judgment dated 29-8-1986, held that provisions of Chapter III (Clauses 22 to 27) of the Rent Control Order, 1949 were ultra vires the Constitution as violative of Article 14.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellant can retain possession of the disputed premises obtained under Chapter III of the Rent Control Order, 1949, when Chapter III has been declared ultra vires the Constitution.
- Whether possession granted to the allottee prior to the Division Bench's declaration of invalidity (possession given on 12-8-1986; Chapter III struck down on 29-8-1986) can be protected or preserved.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)
- The appellant's counsel (Mr. S.C. Mehadia) argued that even though Chapter III had been struck down by this Court (29-8-1986), the possession/allotment given to the appellant on 12-8-1986 could not be disturbed.
- He submitted that the Single Judge's judgment quashing the HAO order on the ground that Chapter III had been declared ultra vires was not justified.
- He relied on observations in the Vidarbha (Rent Control) Bhadekaru Sangh, Akola decision that the decision would not affect proceedings where a decree or order of eviction had become final and the landlord had already taken possession pursuant thereto — contending an analogous protection should apply to the allottee's possession.
Landlady's Arguments (as reflected in the record)
- Before the HAO, the landlady denied the appellant's allegations, stated that tenants occupied the premises, and contended the complaint was not maintainable; she also asserted that Clause 20 of the Rent Control Order, 1949 was ultra vires the Constitution.
- Before this Court (writ petition), the landlady sought quashing of the HAO allotment order and restoration of possession of house No. 495/5.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vidarbha (Rent Control) Bhadekaru Sangh Akola v. State of Maharashtra (1986 Mh.L.J 882) | The Division Bench held that provisions of Chapter III (Clauses 22 to 27) of the C.P. and Berar Letting of Houses and Rent Control Order, 1949 were ultra vires the Constitution and violative of Article 14. | The court treated this precedent as controlling: because the allotment and possession arose under Chapter III, which had been declared unconstitutional, the allotment and possession could not be sustained. The court relied on the decision's declaration of invalidity as retroactive to the enactment's inception. |
| Prabhakar Rokde v. State of Maharashtra (1985 Mh.L.J 548) | Referenced in the opinion as a prior instance where the Court took note of expert reports and the question of rationalisation/unification of rent laws in the State. | Used in the background discussion to illustrate prior consideration of unified rent legislation and the State's commitments; referenced in urging the State to enact unified rent control legislation. |
| Ramkrishna Dalmia v. Justice S.R. Tendolkar (AIR 1958 SC 538) | Quoted for the proposition that presumably the Legislature understands and correctly appreciates the needs of its people and that its discriminations are based on adequate grounds. | Quoted in the context of leaving the matter of unification/rationalisation of rent laws to the Legislature; the court cited it while discussing expectations from the State regarding legislative action. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded from the controlling legal position established in Vidarbha (Rent Control) Bhadekaru Sangh Akola: Chapter III of the Rent Control Order, 1949 had been declared unconstitutional as violative of Article 14. The court explained the general legal principle that when a provision of law is declared unconstitutional it must be treated as if it had never been on the statute book, and that the effect of such declaration is retrospective — i.e., the provision is void from the date of enactment.
Applying that principle to the facts, the court observed that the allottee's complaint, the HAO's proceedings and the subsequent allotment/possession were all founded on Chapter III (specifically Clause 22 was relied upon in the complaint). Because Chapter III was unconstitutional, any order passed under it (including the HAO's allotment and the possession given pursuant thereto) was non est and void. Consequently, possession obtained pursuant to an order under an ultra vires provision could not be sustained merely because the possession was delivered before the Division Bench's declaration of invalidity.
The court considered and rejected the appellant's reliance on the portion of the Vidarbha decision that preserved landlords' possession taken pursuant to final decrees or orders of eviction. The court reasoned that those observations did not apply to the present case because the allottee's possession was not obtained pursuant to any final decree or order of eviction; it was obtained pursuant to an order under Chapter III, which had been declared ultra vires.
The court further held that, having set aside the HAO order as being made under an unconstitutional provision, the landlady was entitled to restoration of possession without being compelled to resort to proceedings under Clause 28; the direction to restore possession could be given directly. The court took into account that the allottee had occupied the premises for about 7–8 years by virtue of an interim order, and therefore ordered a clear and unambiguous handover of possession within a specified period (forthwith and, in any event, not later than two months).
In addition to deciding the immediate contest between the parties, the court commented on the persistent absence of unified rent legislation in Maharashtra despite repeated assurances and prior expert reports; it urged the State Government to take steps to enact uniform rent control legislation and directed that a copy of the judgment be sent to the Law Secretary and the Advocate General for appropriate action.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED.
Direct Consequence for Parties:
- The Letters Patent Appeal by the allottee was dismissed with costs.
- The appellant/allottee was directed to hand over peaceful vacant possession of house No. 495/5 to the landlady forthwith and, in any event, not later than two months from the date of the order.
Broader Implications Noted by the Court:
- The court reaffirmed the legal consequence that orders made under provisions declared unconstitutional (here, Chapter III of the Rent Control Order, 1949) cannot be sustained and are treated as if never lawfully enacted.
- The court strongly urged the State Government to pursue unified rent control legislation in Maharashtra and directed that this judgment be sent to the Law Secretary and the Advocate General for appropriate steps.
This summary is strictly limited to and derived from the content of the provided opinion; no facts or conclusions beyond the opinion have been introduced.
R.M Lodha, J.:— Whether the appellant can keep alive her possession of the disputed premises obtained under the ultra vires and dead law viz. Chapter III of the C. P and Berar Letting of Houses and Rent Control Order, 1949 is a million dollar question?
2. To appreciate this question we shall have to advert to factual canvas of the matter.
3. The appellant Smt. Shakuntala filed a complaint under Chapter III of the C.P and Berar Letting of Houses and Rent Control Order, 1949 (hereinafter referred to as “the Rent Control Order, 1949”) before the House Allotment Officer. It was inter alia stated in the said complaint that house No. 595.B-2 having three rooms situated at Loharpura Mohalla, Nagpur, owned by late Bholanath Pande was lying vacant and another house bearing No. 495/5 having three rooms in that very area belonging to late Bholanath Pande was lying vacant and the said landlord was intending to induct new tenants on an increased rent after the previous tenants have vacated the said premises. On a notice ultimately given to the respondent No. 1 (hereinafter referred to as “Landlady”), a reply came to be filed by her denying the allegations made by the appellant Shakuntala (hereinafter referred to as “Allottee”). It was submitted by the landlady that there were tenants in both the houses and occupied by Indradeo Mishra and Vikaykumar Gite and they have not vacated and handed over the possession of the tenements to the landlady. She further averred in the reply that the provisions of Clause 20 of the Rent Control Order, 1949 were ultra vires the Constitution and submitted that proceedings were liable to be dropped.
4. The House Allotment Officer, Nagpur, even if the law is valid, is required to act as a quasi-judicial authority, without holding any inquiry of any nature whatsoever and without going into the controversy raised by the landlady passed the order on 30-6-1986 that house No. 495/5 owned by Smt. Kausalyabai w/o Bholanath Pande and vacated by Shri Indradeo Mishra and Shri Vikaykumar Gite comprising both the blocks are allotted to the applicant Ku. Shakuntala d/o Dadaji Neolekar (allottee) under Clause 24 of the Rent Control Order. The House Allotment Officer further directed that the possession of the premises allotted be delivered to the allottee by the landlady within 15 days from the communication of this order failing which action under Clause 28 of the Rent Control Order will be initiated for compliance of this order.
5. Upset by the order, which according to the landlady, suffered from mistakes apparent from the face of record, moved an application for review of the order passed by the House Allotment Officer, Nagpur, on 30-6-1986. The said application for review was dismissed by the House Allotment Officer, Nagpur on 8-8-1986 observing that the application presented by the landlady for review of orders cannot be considered since there was no provision in Chapter III of the Rent Control Order for review. He further directed that the landlady should comply the order and deliver possession under Clause 28 of the Rent Control Order within 7 days and as a result thereof the allottee was put in possession of the aforesaid premises on 12-8-1986.
6. Being dissatisfied with the aforesaid order of the House Allotment Officer, Nagpur, the landlady preferred a writ petition before this Court which was registered as Writ Petition No. 1854/1986, praying therein that the order passed by the House Allotment Officer, Nagpur, impugned in the writ petition, dated 30-6-1986 be quashed and the possession of house No. 495/5 handed over to the allottee be restored.
7. The learned Single Judge after hearing the parties in the writ petition, vide his judgment dated 21-8-1989 allowed the writ petition and ordered that the allottee was bound to restore the possession of house No. 495/5 to the landlady, failing which she may resort to the proceedings under Clause 28 of the Rent Control Order for restoring back the property to her possession.
8. The judgment aforesaid passed by the learned Singe Judge on 21-8-1989 has been impugned by allottee in the present Letters Patent Appeal.
9. It may be observed that the validity of Chapter III of the Rent Control Order, 1949 containing Clauses 22 to 27 was challenged in Vidarbha (Rent Control) Bhadekaru Sangh Akola v. State of Maharashtra, before this Court. The Division Bench of this Court in its judgment delivered on 29-8-1986 held the said provisions contained in Chapter III of the Rent Control Order, 1949 ultra vires the Constitution of India, being violative of Article 14 of the Constitution and the said provisions were struck down. This Court held that the provisions of Chapter III are a piece of invidious delegated legislation which falls foul of Article 14 of the Constitution and have to be struck down.
10. The judgment of Vidarbha (Rent Control) Bhadekaru Sangh Akola v. State of Maharashtra, is reported in 1986 Mh.L.J 882.
11. Mr. S.C Mehadia, the learned Counsel for the appellant, with all vehemence at his command, submitted before this Court that even though Chapter III of the Rent Control Order, 1949 has been struck down by this Court by its judgment dated 29-8-1986 being violative of Article 1.4 of the Constitution of India, the possession/allotment which was given in favour of appellant on 12-8-1986 cannot be disturbed. Mr. Mehadia, thus, strenuously submitted before us that the judgment of the learned Single Judge quashing the order of the House Allotment Officer on the ground that the provisions of Chapter III have been declared ultra vires cannot be justified and in any case since the allottee has been handed over possession of the disputed premises prior to the striking down of the provisions contained in Chapter III of the Rent Control Order, 1949, there was no justification for direction by the learned Single Judge to restore back the possession of house No. 495/5 to the landlady.
12. We are afraid, the submissions made by the learned Counsel for the appellant have no force and merit.
13. The law is well settled that once the provisions of law have been declared unconstitutional and ultra vires, its effect would be as if the said provisions were never on the statute book. The declaration of provisions as ultra vires do not take effect from the date it is declared so but from the day of its inception. If the provision is unconstitutional and ultra vires and has been declared to be so by the Court, it was unconstitutional from the day it was enacted. In this view of the matter, the undisputed position is that the view of Division Bench of this Court in Vidarbha (Rent Control) Bhadekaru Sangh Akola (supra) still holds field that the provisions of Chapter III of the Rent Control Order, 1949 are ultra vires the Constitution of India. It is again undisputed and it cannot be disputed that the complaint was filed by the allottee under Chapter III of the Rent control Order, 1949, more particularly Clause 22 assuming the said provision to be valid and constitutional and the House Allotment Officer entertained the said application, purportedly filed under Clause 22, assuming the said provision to be valid and passed an order for allotment of the disputed house to the allottee holding that there was concealment of vacancy by the landlady. Though, even otherwise, the order of the House Allotment Officer cannot be justified, the way and the manner in which the order has been passed but since the said application itself was under the law which has been declared unconstitutional, no allotment of the disputed house and the possession of the said house consequent thereto could have been given by the House Allotment Officer to the allottee. Possession of allottee cannot be protected on plea that since the possession of the disputed house was given by the House Allotment Officer to the allottee on 12-8-1986 and the provisions contained in Chapter III of the Rent Control Order, 1949 were declared ultra vires subsequently by this Court on 29-8-1986 because any order which has been passed under the ultra vires law cannot be sustained. Moreover, the landlady had challenged that very order of allotment and delivery of possession before this Court and even before filing of the writ petition by the landlady, the judgment of this Court in Vidarbha (Rent Control) Bhadekaru Sangh, Akola (supra) was handed down.
14. Mr. Mehadia, the learned Counsel for the appellant then relied upon the observations made in Vidarbha (Rent Control) Bhadekaru Sangh, Akola (supra) by this Court wherein this Court had made it clear that the decision would not affect the validity of any proceedings in which a decree or order of eviction has become final and the landlord has already taken possession of the building or any part thereof pursuant thereto. The submission of the learned counsel for the appellant is that since this Court has saved and protected the possession taken by landlord pursuant to the decrees or order of eviction which had become final, as a necessary corollary, possession which was taken by his client, pursuant to the order passed by the House Allotment Officer should be saved. To say the least, the argument of the learned Counsel for the appellant is misplaced. The said observation made by the Division Bench of this Court has no application whatsoever in the present case because here the possession has not been taken by landlord pursuant to the decree or order of eviction which had become final. The fact remains that the allottee got possession pursuant to the order passed by the House Allotment Officer under the provisions of law which are ultra vires and, therefore, the said order of the House Allotment Officer having been quashed, the landlady was entitled to be restored the possession. The learned Single Judge in the operative portion of the order while allowing the writ petition and setting aside the impugned order held that the allottee is bound to restore the possession of house No. 495/5 to the landlady, failing which she may resort to the proceedings under Clause 28 of the Rent Control Order for restoring back the property to her possession. We feel that since the order of the House Allotment Officer was non est and void, the landlady was entitled to the restoration of the possession without compelling her to take proceedings or resorting under Clause 28 of the Rent Control Order. It is in the interest of justice that the landlady should be restored possession of the property when the order of the House Allotment Officer, has been set aside. Moreover, by an interim order the allottee has already taken an advantage of continuance of possession for about 7-8 years and it is in the fitness of the things that a clear and unambiguous direction is given to the appellant/allottee to hand over possession of house No. 495/5 to the landlady forthwith and in any case not later than 2 months from the passing of this order.
15. We cannot refrain from observing that despite the consistent commitments made by the State Counsel before this Court in various cases that there would be a unified Rent Control Legislation in the State, nothing positive has taken place. In a progressive State like Maharashtra, it is really surprising that when there is a call of Unified Rent Control Legislation throughout the country, the State has three Rent Control Legislation operating in three different areas. The Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947; Hyderabad Houses (Rent, Eviction and Lease) Control Act, 1954 and the C.P and Berar Letting of Houses and Rent Control Order, 1949 are applicable to different areas of the State. Right from 1971 this Court fervently hoped that there would be rationalisation and unification of the rent laws. In Vidarbha Bhadekaru Sangh v. State (supra) the then learned Assistant Government Pleader told the Court that the State Government has been seriously considering the question of rationalisation and unification of the rent laws in the State. Much water has flown in the Ganges since 1986 but no positive and concrete steps have been taken so far, it appears in enacting unified Rent Control Legislation in the State. What was stated on behalf of the Government in Vidarbha Bhadekaru Sangh v. State (supra) is reproduced:
“In fairness, Shri Jaiswal, the learned Assistant Government Pleader, told us that the State Government has been seriously considering the question of rationalisation and unification of the rent laws in the State. In fact, this Court took note in Prabhakar Rokde v. State of Maharashtra, 1985 Mh.L.J 548, that the two expert reports of the bodies constituted by the State itself, were under consideration. The Rent Acts Enquiry Committee popularly known as “Tambe Committee” was appointed by the Government of Maharashtra in the year 1975 (Urban Development, Public Health and Housing Department by Resolution No. BRA 2174/9011/75 E, dated 20th February, 1975 as amended by Resolution No. BRA 2174/9011-D-57, dated 6th August, 1975) and the Committee after deliberations and review of various legislations prevailing in the State had made a report in 1977 recommending certain measures and having a uniform legislation in the whole State. Maharashtra State Law Commission also gave its Twelfth Report on the unification and consolidation of the Rent restriction laws in the State as far back in July 1979 observing: “The Commission does not see any difficulty in the way of unification and consolidation of the rent restriction laws in the State.” A draft Bill also formed part of the said report. Shri Jaiswal stated that the State Government proposes to introduce a bill to amend bombay rent act in the ensuing Nagpur Session of the State Legislature and is seriously considering the question of having a unified legislation. Presumably the Legislature understands and correctly appreciates the needs of its own people, its laws are directed to problems made manifest by experience and its discriminations are based on adequate grounds, as pointed out in Ramkrishna Dalmia v. Justice S.R Tendolkar, AIR 1958 SC 538. It is best to leave the matter there, in view of the statement made on behalf of the State before us, in the hope that the legislature would see its way to do what is appropriate.”
16. The Courts have continued to strike the optimistic note that the State will become alive to the situation and beneficial legislation like Rent Control Act would be uniform in the State but the hope and rather the fervent hope of the Court has been belied. The reasons may be varied for the State Government to not to have acted on the said assurances made on behalf of Government before this Court but we feel now it is need of the time that the State Government acts swiftly and takes appropriate proceedings for uniform rent legislation in this State to curb the public inconvenience and evils. We need not say further in the matter.
17. Let the copy of this judgment be sent to the Law Secretary of the State Government and learned Advocate General of the State for appropriate steps in the direction for having uniform Rent Control Legislation in Maharashtra.
18. In the result, this Letters Patent Appeal filed by allottee has no force and is liable to be dismissed with costs. The Appellant/allottee is directed to hand over peaceful vacant possession of the disputed premises viz. house No. 495/5 to the landlady forthwith and in any case not later than 2 months from the date of the passing of this order. The appeal is dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert