Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Hindustan Cocoa Products Ltd. v. The Union Of India And Others

Bombay High Court
Jun 8, 1994
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a manufacturer of deodorised cocoa butter, initially classified the product under Item 12 of the Tariff Schedule to the Central Excises & Salt Act, 1944, treating it as a "Vegetable non-essential oil" and claimed exemption from excise duty under Notification No. 33/63 dated 1-3-1963 for the period 4-5-1974 to 4-5-1979. Subsequently, the Superintendent of Central Excise informed the petitioner in 1979 that it was not eligible for such exemption and demanded payment of excise duty for various periods between 1974 and 1979, which the petitioner paid under protest.

In late 1983, the petitioner discovered from a letter by Cocoa Products and Beverages Ltd. and Notification No. 104/82 dated 28-2-1982 that the correct classification for deodorised cocoa butter was under Item 68 of the Tariff Schedule, which was fully exempt from duty. The petitioner filed a revised classification list in December 1983, which was approved by the Assistant Collector in September 1984, confirming the correct classification and exemption status.

The petitioner applied for refund of excise duty amounting to Rs. 1,80,301.38 for the period 4-5-1974 to 4-12-1983 and an additional Rs. 37,312.92 for the period 5-12-1983 to 17-9-1984. The latter claim was accepted and refunded, but the former was rejected by the Assistant Collector on 6-5-1985 on the ground of limitation under section 11-B of the Act. The petitioner challenged this rejection in a writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to refund of excise duty paid under a mistake of law for the period from 4-5-1974 to 4-12-1983 despite the limitation period prescribed under section 11-B of the Central Excises & Salt Act, 1944.
  2. Whether the limitation period for claiming refund under section 11-B applies to refunds arising from a mistake of law.
  3. Whether the refund claim should be restricted to payments made within three years prior to the date of discovery of the mistake or can cover the entire period within three years of the discovery of the mistake.
  4. Whether the respondents should be granted liberty to verify the use of goods in question to ensure applicability of the amended section 11-B of the Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The excise duty payments for the period 4-5-1974 to 4-12-1983 were made under a mistake of law, discovered first in November 1983 and confirmed by the Assistant Collector in September 1984.
  • The refund claim was filed within less than one year from the discovery and within one month of confirmation, thus within a reasonable period.
  • The limitation period under section 11-B of the Act does not apply to refunds arising from a mistake of law.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petitioner, being engaged in the relevant business, should have known the correct classification and thus cannot claim relief after a long delay of about ten years.
  • Even if the limitation under section 11-B does not apply, refund should be restricted to payments made within three years prior to the date of discovery of the mistake (November 1983).
  • The respondents should be allowed to verify the actual use of the goods to ensure the non-applicability of the amended section 11-B of the Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Industrial Plastic Corporation Pvt. Ltd. v. U.O.I, 1992 (57) E.L.T 390 The claim for refund of amounts paid under a mistake of law should be made within three years from the discovery or knowledge of the mistake. The court relied on this precedent to determine that the limitation period for refund claims starts from the date of discovery of the mistake, not the date of payment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court recognized that the classification of deodorised cocoa butter under Item 12 was a mistake of law, undiscovered by either party until 1983. The petitioner’s payment of excise duty under this mistaken classification was therefore also made under a mistake of law. The court held that a mistake of law does not cease to be such merely because of the passage of time, nor does the responsibility for the mistake affect the legal characterization.

Given that the payments were made under a mistake of law, the limitation period prescribed under section 11-B of the Central Excises & Salt Act, 1944, which bars claims after a certain period, does not apply to these refund claims. However, the court clarified that the refund must be claimed within three years from the date of discovery or knowledge of the mistake, in line with established legal principles and the cited precedent.

The court rejected the respondents' contention that the refund should be limited to payments made only within three years prior to the discovery, holding instead that all payments made within three years from the discovery date are eligible for refund.

The court also noted the respondents' request for liberty to verify the use of goods but did not impose any specific condition in this regard in the order.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed and the rule is made absolute.

The respondents are directed to examine the petitioner’s refund claim on merits and refund the excess excise duty paid for the period 4-5-1974 to 4-12-1983 within six months from the date of the order. There is no order as to costs. The decision clarifies that refunds for excise duty paid under a mistake of law are not barred by the limitation period under section 11-B of the Act, provided the claim is made within three years from the discovery of the mistake.

This ruling directly affects the parties by entitling the petitioner to a refund of the excise duty paid under the mistaken classification. The court did not establish a new precedent beyond confirming the application of existing principles relating to mistake of law and limitation periods.

Show all summary ...

Dr. B.P Saraf, J.:— The petitioner is aggrieved by the order of the Assistant Collector, Central Excise, Division-II, Thane dated 6th May, 1985 rejecting its claim for refund of excise duty amounting to Rs. 1,80,301.38 in respect of the period commencing from 4-5-1974 to 4-12-1983.

2. The petitioner manufactures deodorised coca butter which was classified by it for the purposes of central excise under Item 12 of the Tariff Schedule to the Central Excises & Salt Act, 1944 (“the Act”) which applied to “Vegetable non-essential oils”.

3. During the period from 4-5-1974 to 4-5-1979 the petitioner claimed full exemption of excise duty in respect of deodorised cocoa butter manufactured by it under Notification No. 33/63 dated 1-3-1963 which was duly allowed by the concerned authorities. On 4-5-1979, the petitioner was informed by the Superintendent of Central Excise that it was not eligible for exemption under Notification No. 33/63 in respect of payment of excise duty on manufacture of deodorised coca butter. The petitioner was asked to furnish clearance figures from 4-1-1978 onwards. By another notice dated 4-3-1980, the petitioner was called upon to explain why an amount of Rs. 18,660.08 should not be recovered from it for the period from 2-10-1976 to 3-1-1978. The petitioner paid the above amount on 31-3-1980 under an impression that the duty was leviable as stated by the Superintendent of Central Excise. By another notice dated 17-4-1980, the petitioner was asked to explain why a further amount of Rs. 28,535.80 should not be recovered from it in respect of the period from 4-5-1974 to 1-10-1976. The petitioner paid this amount also on 12-5-1980. The petitioner also paid a further sum of Rs. 16,682.98 in respect of the period from 4-1-1978 to 28-6-1979 on 2-7-1979.

4. Sometime in October-November, 1983 the petitioner discovered that the classification of deodorised cocoa butter manufactured by it under Item 12 of Tariff Schedule to the Act was a mistake of law. This mistake, according to the petitioner, was discovered from a letter dated 17-11-1983 from Cocoa Products and Beverages Ltd., Madras from whom the petitioner purchased come of its requirements. The said company had informed the petitioner that deodorised cocoa butter was correctly classifiable under Item 68 of the Tariff Schedule and was fully exempt from duty. Notification No. 104/82 dated 28-2-1982 was also referred in this connection. The petitioner thereupon filed a revised classification list on 3-12-1983 classifying deodorised cocoa butter manufactured by it under Item 68 and claiming exemption from levy of excise duty in respect thereof on the basis of exemption Notification No. 104 of 1982 dated 28-2-1982. However, pending approval of the revised classification list, the petitioner continued to pay the duty “under protest” at the rate chargeable on goods falling under Item No. 12 of the Tariff Schedule. The revised classification list was approved by the Assistant Collector on 12-9-1984 and the item deodorised cocoa butter was classified as item falling under Tariff Item 68.

5. There is no dispute about the fact that on approval of the classification of the said item as item falling under Item No. 68, no duty was payable thereon. The approval was given on 12-9-1984. On 15-10-1984 the petitioner applied for refund of Rs. 1,80,301.38 being the excise duty paid by it on deodorised cocoa butter under a mistake of law for the period from 4-5-1974 to 4- 12-1983. The petitioner also applied for refund of another sum of Rs. 37,312.92 being duty paid mistakenly for the period from 5-12-1983 to 17-9-1984. This was done on 15-12-1984. The claim of the petitioner for refund for the period from 5-12-1983 to 17-9-1984 for Rs. 37,312.92 was accepted by the respondents and the said amount was duly refunded to the petitioner. The claims of the petitioner for refund for the period from 4-5-1974 to 4-12-1983 was however rejected by the Assistant Collector, by his impugned order dated 6-5-1985 on the ground that the said claims were barred by limitation under section 11-B of the Act. It is this order of the Assistant Collector which is subject-matter of challenge in this writ petition.

6. We have heard Mr. S.A Divan, learned Counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Bulchandani learned Counsel for the respondents. It is submitted on behalf of the petitioner that the payment of excise duty for the period from 4-5-1974 to 4-12-1983 was made under a mistake of law which was discovered for the first time in November, 1983 from the letter of Cocoa Products and Beverages Ltd. dated 17-12-1983 and confirmed by the Assistant Collector on 12-9-1984 when the revised classification list was approved by him. The claim for refund for the above periods was made on 15-12-1984 within less than one year from the date of discovery of the mistake by the petitioner and in one month of the confirmation of the mistake by the Assistant Collector. According to the petitioner, period of limitation prescribed under section 11-B of the Act for filing of refund application does not apply to such refunds.

7. On the other hand the contention of the learned Counsel for the respondents Mr. Bulchandani is that the petitioner, being in the line of business, should have known the correct classification and in any event having acted under a mistake of law for long ten years, the petitioner is not entitled to get relief from this Court under its writ jurisdiction. Counsel submits that even if it is held by this Court that the period of limitation prescribed under section 11-B of the Act for filing of application for refunds under the Act is not applicable to the claims for refunds in question, no refund should be allowed for period beyond these years prior to the date of knowledge. In other words, the submission is that in any event the refund should be restricted to payments made within a period of three years prior to the date of discovery of mistake which in the instant case is November 1983. Mr. Bulchandani further submits that though apparently the goods in question were for the petitioner's own consumption, in the event of the writ petition being allowed, the respondents should be granted liberty to verify the user of the goods in the question to ensure beyond all doubt the non-applicability of the amended section 11-B of the Act.

8. We have carefully considered the rival submissions. There is no dispute about the fact that the classification of deodorised cocoa butter by the petitioner under Item 12 was a mistake of law which was discovered neither by the petitioner nor by the respondents till the year, 1983. It was only in November, 1983, when the petitioner having come to know of the said mistake, filed a revised classification list classifying the above item under tariff Item 68 of the Schedule and on consideration of which the respondent-Assistant Collector also approved the revised classification filed by the petitioner. The correct legal position, therefore, is that deodorised cocoa butter is classifiable under Item No. 68 of the Schedule and not under Item No. 12. The classification made earlier was a mistake of law. The respondents also, acting under the mistaken interpretation of law, issued show cause notices to the petitioner, in pursuance of which the petitioner paid the duty for periods from 4-5-1974 onwards between the year, 1978 to 1980. A mistake of law, in our opinion, does not cease to be mistake of law by lapse of time. It is also not material who was responsible for the mistake. Once it is held to be mistake of law, it has to be considered accordingly. In the instant case, it was a mistake of interpretation of a tariff item and which is a question of law and a mistake in that regard is nothing but a mistake of law. The payments were made by the petitioner under such mistake of law. The period of limitation for refund laid down in section 11-B of the Act, therefore, cannot apply to such refunds. The petitioner is entitled to refund of such amounts.

9. The only question to be considered is whether the petitioner is entitled to refund of duty paid by it during the period of three years prior to the date of discovery of the mistake or to all refund claimed within three years from the date of discovery of the mistake. We do not find much difficulty on this count. It is well settled that the claim for refund of amounts paid under a mistake of law should be made within the period of three years from the discovery or knowledge of the mistake. The date of payment is not the relevant consideration. Reference may be made in this connection to the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in (Industrial Plastic Corporation Pvt. Ltd. v. U.O.I)1, 1992 (57) E.L.T 390.

10. In view of the foregoing discussion, we allow this writ petition and make the rule absolute in the above terms. The respondents shall examine the claim of the petitioner on merits and refund the excess amount paid by the petitioner in respect of the period from 4-5-1974 to 4-12-1983 within six months from today. There shall be no order as to costs.

11. Issuance of certified copy is expedited.

12. Petition allowed.