Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sulphur Dyes Ltd., v. Hickson And Dadajee Limited .

Bombay High Court
Feb 20, 1992
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary: Sulphur Dyes Ltd. (formerly Hickson and Welch Ltd.) — Rectification of Register of Members

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under section 155 of the Companies Act I of 1956 was filed by Sulphur Dyes Limited (formerly Hickson and Welch Ltd.) seeking directions to Hickson and Dadajee Ltd. to delete the former name “Hickson and Welch Limited” and substitute the petitioner's present name in the respondent company's register of members in respect of 20,872 ordinary shares of Rs. 100 each (constituting 34% of the respondent's equity share capital).

The petition attaches particulars of the relevant share certificates and distinctive numbers (Exhibit 'A') and a certificate of incorporation evidencing the change of name dated 3rd July 1989 issued by the Registrar at Cardiff, U.K. (Exhibit 'G').

The respondent refused to amend its records and share certificates. The petitioner therefore sought rectification of the Register of Members under section 155 of the Companies Act I of 1956, praying for the register and certificates to show the changed name.

Additional factual matters in the record: there was an earlier agreement dated 22 December 1987 whereby Hickson and Welch Ltd. agreed to transfer its business and (by clause 2(g)) the issued share capital held in Hickson and Dadajee Ltd. to Alvin Morris Ltd.; that agreement was not acted upon with respect to the respondent company's shares, was not communicated to the respondent, and was later clarified by an agreement dated 10 October 1989 to the effect that clause 2(g) was not intended to be acted on.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on proof of a valid change of company name supported by a fresh certificate of incorporation, the respondent company is legally obliged to rectify its Register of Members to reflect the petitioner's new name in respect of the shares held by it.
  2. Whether clause 37 of the Articles of Association of Hickson and Dadajee Ltd., which governs transfer notices and the company's role as agent for sale to members, prevents or justifies refusal to record a mere change of name of an existing shareholder.
  3. Whether the petitioner is attempting to circumvent the Articles (in particular clause 37) by effecting a name change so as to transfer shares indirectly, and if so, whether that alleged circumvention should lead the Court to refuse discretionary relief under section 155 and relegation to a civil suit.
  4. Whether, if the Court is minded to allow rectification, the Court should nevertheless stay its order to enable the respondent company to pursue other remedies (e.g., a civil suit).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Sulphur Dyes Ltd.)

  • The change of name from Hickson and Welch Ltd. to Sulphur Dyes Ltd. was effected by special resolution and a fresh certificate of incorporation was issued on 3rd July 1989 (Exhibit 'G'), which under the Companies Act is conclusive evidence that statutory requirements for change of name were complied with.
  • A change of name does not affect the rights or obligations of the company; therefore the register should be rectified to reflect the petitioner's current name.
  • The case is a simple change of name of an existing shareholder and not a transfer of shares to a different party; clause 37 of the Articles applies only when the shareholder approaches the company to effect a transfer.
  • The petition is properly brought under section 155; there is no sufficient cause to refuse rectification or to compel the petitioner to litigate in a separate civil suit.

Respondent's Arguments (Hickson and Dadajee Ltd., advanced by Shri Bharucha)

  • The petitioner has resorted to a device to circumvent clause 37 of the Articles of Association and is attempting indirectly to transfer its shares to a third party without complying with the clause's mandate (i.e., the petitioner's name change is not bona fide).
  • Clause 37 becomes applicable as soon as a proposed transferor intends to effect a transfer; the 22 December 1987 agreement evidencing an intention to transfer (to Alvin Morris Ltd.) brought clause 37 into play and therefore the petitioner cannot simply change its name to bypass the procedural safeguards in the Articles.
  • The remedy under section 155 is discretionary; the Court should decline to exercise its discretion in favour of the petitioner in these facts and should instead require the petitioner to pursue a civil suit.
  • If the Court nonetheless allows the petition, the respondent asked for a stay of the order to enable it to file a civil suit.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in these principal steps:

  1. Statutory effect of change of name and certificate of incorporation:

    The Court relied on provisions of the Companies Act I of 1956 (in particular section 23 and section 35) which indicate that where a company changes its name and a fresh certificate of incorporation is issued, that certificate is conclusive evidence that the statutory requirements for the change have been complied with, and the change is complete and effective on issue of such certificate. The Court also referred to identical provisions in the English Companies Act (section 13(7) of the Companies Act 1985) and noted there were similar provisions in the 1948 Act.

  2. Nature of the present case — change of name, not transfer:

    The Court accepted the petitioner's position that this was a "plain and simple case of a mere change of name of existing shareholder duly supported by fresh certificate of incorporation." It emphasized that a change of name does not of itself affect the rights or obligations of the company or render legal proceedings defective.

  3. Application of clause 37 of the Articles:

    Clause 37 sets out the procedure for a proposing transferor to give a transfer notice specifying fair value, authorizing the company to act as agent for sale to another member, etc. The Court held clause 37 becomes applicable when a shareholder actually approaches the company with a proposal to transfer shares. An uncommunicated or unacted upon agreement (such as the 22 December 1987 agreement, which was neither acted upon with respect to these shares nor communicated to the respondent) does not confer rights on the company nor trigger clause 37 so as to affect the existing shareholder's rights.

  4. On allegations of circumvention and bona fides:

    The respondent alleged the name change was a device to circumvent clause 37 and to transfer shares indirectly. The Court examined the facts: the 22 December 1987 agreement was not acted upon in respect of these shares; it was not communicated to the respondent; the 10 October 1989 agreement clarified that clause 2(g) was not intended to be acted upon; and the name changes involved (including the petitioner's fresh certificate) supported the conclusion that Sulphur Dyes Ltd. is merely the changed name of Hickson and Welch Ltd. The Court found the respondent had not established a case of fraud or circumvention sufficient to deny relief.

  5. Discretion under section 155 and whether to compel suit:

    The respondent argued the remedy under section 155 is discretionary and that discretion should be exercised against the petitioner. The Court concluded there was no sufficient cause to refuse rectification. It further observed that courts should prevent multiplicity of litigation and should not encourage the respondent to start fresh litigation on the same subject matter. Consequently, relegating the petitioner to a suit or staying the order to permit fresh litigation was declined.

  6. Remedial directions:

    On this basis, the Court allowed the petition in the terms sought, directing rectification of the Register of Members and implementation within four weeks, awarding costs to the petitioner, and expediting the certified copy of the order.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is allowed. The Court directed Hickson and Dadajee Ltd. to rectify its Register of Members and amend the relevant records so that the shares held by the petitioner appear in the petitioner's present name, Sulphur Dyes Ltd., and ordered implementation within four weeks.

Direct consequences imposed by the order:

  • The respondent is directed to rectify its Register of Members and implement the order within four weeks from the date of the judgment.
  • Costs of Rs. 1,000 are payable by the company to the petitioner.
  • The issue of the certified copy of the order is expedited.

Implications beyond the parties: The opinion did not purport to lay down a novel legal principle; it applied statutory rules concerning change of name and the conclusiveness of a fresh certificate of incorporation, and held that uncommunicated or unacted upon agreements do not activate Article 37's transfer machinery so as to deprive an existing shareholder of rights following a bona fide change of name. The judgment did not state any broader precedent beyond the direct effect on the parties.

Order accordingly.

Show all summary ...

D.R Dhanuka, J.:— Sulphur Dyes Limited has filed this petition under section 155 of the Companies Act I of 1956 seeking an order and direction of this Court to Hickson and Dadajee Ltd., to delete the petitioner's former name “Hickson and Welch Limited” and substitute in its place the present name of the petitioner in respect of 20,872 shares held by the petitioner in the said Company.

2. It is not disputed that Hickson and Welch Ltd. is the shareholder of Hickson and Dadajee Ltd., holding 20,872 ordinary shares of Rs. 100 each constituting 34 per cent of the equity share capital of the respondent company. A statement of me distinctive numbers of the share certificates held by the said company is annexed as Exhibit ‘A’ to the petition. The particulars of these shares along with certificate number and distinctive numbers are mentioned hereinafter:

Certificate Number. No. of Shares. Distinctive Numbers. 4 612 4 615 6 816 746 14661 11 130 5002 5131 12 65 5132 5196 28 628 7197 7824 312 952 8873 9824 144 45 10249 10293 40 250 11517 11766 62 443 13180 13622 73 498 4559 15056 103 2756 15630 18385 201 6650 22651 29300 324 1739 40688 42426 382 5218 45761 50978 20872

3. The petitioner has averred in paragraph 9 of the petition that by a special resolution passed on 23rd June 1989 at an Extra-ordinary General Meeting of Hickson and Welch Limited, the name of the said company was changed to Sulphur Dyes Ltd. The petitioner relies or copy of certificate of incorporation of change of name dated 3rd July 1989 issued by the Companies Registered Office, Cardiff, U.K, certifying the change of name of Hickson and Welch Ltd. to Sulphur Dyes Ltd. A copy of the said certificate dated 3rd July 1989 is annexed to the petition as Exhibit ‘G’. The petitioner requests for rectification of register of members of the respondent company in respect of shares held by it by showing its changed name as a shareholder.

4. The respondent company refuses to effect the change in its record and amend the share certificates in respect of the shares held by the petitioner in its former name Hickson and Welch Ltd. The petitioner has therefore filed this petition under section 155 of the Companies Act I of 1956 seeking rectification of Register of Members in terms of prayers (a) and (b) of the petition.

5. Clause 37 of the Articles of Association of the Company known as Hickson and Dadajee Ltd., reads as follows:—

“37. Except where the transfer is made pursuant to Article 43 or Article 54 the person proposing to transfer any share (hereinafter called “the proposing transferor”) shall give notice in writing (hereinafter called a “transfer notice”) to the Company that be desires to transfer the same. Such notice shall specify the sum he fixes as the fair value and shall constitute the Company his agent for the sale of the share to any member of the Company approved or selected as being willing to purchase the share (hereinafter called the “purchasing member”) at the price so fixed, or at the option of the purchasing member at the fair value to be fixed by the auditors of the Company in accordance with Article 39 hereof. A transfer notice may include several shares and in such case shall operate as if it were a separate notice in respect of each. A transfer notice shall not be revocable except with the sanction of the Directors.”

6. The petitioner contends that the instant case is merely a case of change of name of the company and not a case where the existing shareholder seeking transfer of shares held by it to a different or another party. The petitioner has relied upon the relevant provisions of law contained in the Companies Act 1 of 1956. Section 23 of the said Act provides that where a company changes its name in pursuance of section 21 or section 22, the Registrar shall enter the new name on the register in place of the former name and shall issue fresh certificate of incorporation with the necessary alterations embodied therein and the change of name shall be complete and effective only on issue of such a certificate. Section 23(3) of the Act provides that the change of name shall not affect any right or obligation of the company or render defective any legal proceeding by or against it. Section 35 of the Act provides that a certificate of incorporation given by the Registrar in respect of any association shall be conclusive evidence that all the requirements of the Act have been complied with in respect of registration and matters precedent and incidental thereto and that the association is a company authorised to be registered and duly registered under the Act. Therefore, when a fresh certificate of incorporation is issued by the Registrar on a change of name of the pre-existing company, such fresh certificate of incorporation is liable to be treated as conclusive evidence of the fact that all the requirements of the Act for effecting the change of name have been complied with. Since the petitioner is a foreign company registered under the U.K Companies Act, attention of the Court is also invited to identical provisions contained is Companies Act, 1985 and in particular to section 13(7) of the said Act Section 13(7) of English Companies Act, 1985 reads as under:—

“13(7). A certificate of incorporation given in respect of an association is conclusive evidence—

(a) that the requirements of this Act in respect of registration and of matters precedent and incidental to it have been complied with, and that the association is a company authorised to the registered, and is duly registered, under this Act, and

(b) if the certificate contains a statement that the company is a public company, that the company is such a company.

7. There were identical provisions in English Companies Act, 1948 also.

8. Shri Bharucha, the learned Counsel for the company, has submitted that the petitioner has resorted to a device so as to circumvent the provisions of clause 37 of the Articles of Association of the Company. Shri Bharucha submits that the petitioner is indirectly trying to manouvre and manipulate transfer of shares to a third party without following the mandate of clause 37 of the Articles of Association of the Company. It is not possible to accept the submission of Mr. Bharucha. However it is necessary to refer to a few more facts in order to appreciate the contentions urged on behalf of the company by its teamed counsel. The relevant facts having bearing on this aspect of the matter are as under:—

(a) On 22nd December, 1987, Hickson and Welch Ltd. agreed to transfer its assets to Alvin Morris Ltd. By clause 2 of the said agreement, it was provided that Hickson and Welch Ltd. shall transfer its entire business as a going concern to Alvin Morris Ltd. By clause 2(g) of the said agreement, it was provided that such transfer of assets will include inter alia the entire issued share capital of the shares held by Hickson and Welch Ltd. in Hickson and Dadajee Ltd. Hickson and Dadajee Ltd. were not made aware of the said agreement at any point of time. Prior to 10th of October 1989, the name of Alvin Morris Ltd. was changed to Hickson and Welch Ltd. By 3rd July 1989, the name of Hickson and Welch Ltd. was changed to Sulphur Dyes Ltd. The above referred agreement dated 22nd December 1978 was never acted upon in respect of intended transfer of shares held by Hickson Welch Ltd. in the respondent company. The proposal to transfer the said shares as aforesaid was not even communicated to the respondent company. By an agreement dated 10th October 1989 arrived at between Sulphur Dyes Ltd. and Hickson Welch Ltd. it was clarified between the parties that clause 2(g) of the agreement dated 22nd December 1978 was never intended to be acted upon. In any event the said agreement dated 22nd December 1987 was abandoned in respect of proposed transfer of shares.

9. Shri Bharucha has submitted that it would be clear from the above facts that the so-called change of name of the company from Hickson and Welch Ltd. to that of Sulphur Dyes Ltd. was effected not with a bona fide intention but with an intention to circumvent clause 37 of the Articles of Association of the Company. Shri Bhaurcha has further submitted that clause 37 of the Articles of Association becomes applicable as soon as the proposed transferor intends to effect transfer of the shares held by it. Shri Bharucha submits that clause 37 of the Articles of Association of the company became applicable as soon as the above-referred agreement dated 22nd December, 1987 was entered into. Shri Bharucha has further submitted that agreement dated 10th October 1989 is not a genuine agreement. I am not persuaded to accept any of these submission surged on behalf of the company for the reasons which I would just indicate. To my mind, this case is plain and simple case of a mere change of name of existing shareholder duly supported by fresh certificate of incorporation.

10. It is true that Hickson and Welch Ltd. entered into an agreement of sale dated 22nd December 1987. Hickson and Welch Ltd. could always modify or abandon part of agreement dated 22nd December 1987. The Company cannot claim to be an agent of the petitioner for sale of the said shares. The petitioner cannot be deprived of its rights as an existing shareholder merely because it has changed its name. If the Court does not grant this petition, what would happen to exercise of rights in respect of 20,872 shares. If the petitioner is not exercise the rights of a shareholder in respect of these shares in its present name, whoelse can exercise these rights. Can it be said that no one should exercise the shareholder's right in respect of these share? Mr. Bharucha, with respect, has no real answer to these questions. Clause 37 of the Articles of Association would become applicable when the shareholders approaches the company with a proposal to transfer the shares. An uncommunicated proposal does not and cannot confer any right on the company so as to affect the rights of the existing shareholders. Alvin Morris Ltd. or Hickson Ltd. is not even the shareholder of Sulphur Dyes Ltd. Sulphur Dyes Ltd. is merely the changed name of Hickson and Welch Ltd. The provisions of the statute that the fresh certificate of incorporation is to be treated as conclusive evidence of the change of same effected must be given full effect to. The provisions of the statute to the effect that the rights of the existing shareholders are not affected merely to change of its name must also be given full effect to. I am not satisfied that a case of alleged fraud or circumvention is made out. The case is merely of change of name of the existing shareholder.

11. It is then contended that Sulphur Dyes Ltd. would perhaps dispose of its shares in future and indirectly the new shareholders of Sulphur Dyes Ltd. would become entitled to the shares of Hickson and Dadajee Ltd. I need not express any opinion on this eventuality in this petition. If Sulphur Dyes Ltd. is entitled to dispose of its shares in accordance with law, the Court cannot affect the rights of Sulphur Dyes Ltd. to act in accordance with law.

12. Mr. Bharucha has then submitted that the remedy provided under section 155 of the Companies Act I of 1956 is discretionary and discretion should not be exercised in favour of the petitioner having regard on facts and circumstances of this case. The learned Counsel has further submitted that the petitioner should be relegated to the remedy of a suit. The facts are plain and simple. The certificate of incorporation issued on change of name is conclusive. The company has no sufficient cause to refuse rectification of register. I do not see any good reason for rejecting this petition in exercise of my jurisdiction under section 155 of the Companies Act I of 1956.

13. The learned Counsel for the company has ultimately submitted that in case the Court is inclined to allow this petition, the order of this Court should be stayed for sometime in order to enable the company to file a civil suit. It is not possible to accept this submission either. The Courts must endeavour to put an end to the disputes and prevent multiplicity of litigation. I see no merit in the case of the Company. The Company cannot be encouraged to start a fresh round of litigation in respect of the same subject matter.

14. In the result, I allow the petition in terms of prayers (a), (b) and (c) of the petition. The company is directed to rectify the Register of Members and implement this order within four weeks from today.

15. Cost payable by the company to the petitioner is quantified at Rs. 1,000/-.

16. Issue of certified copy is expedited.

Order accordingly.